18 ms·
Netflix CEO may have missed the real reason why US subscriber numbers plunged
- drenvuk 7y agoSounds like they just need to take a page from Spotify's playbook and start just shoving fully autoplayed best matching shows down people's throats. They'll be happier being force fed with no options. weird but plausible.
- DeonPenny 7y agoThat would be great
- jdsully 7y agoWorked wonders for broadcast and cable TV.
- drenvuk 7y agoI don't see why Netflix can't provide the best of both worlds. edit: btw I'm a huge fan of your work with keydb.
- jdsully 7y agoThey are getting there with their auto-play functionality. The missing piece is themed “channels”. P.s. Thanks for your kind words. I’m always open to feedback/suggestions for KeyDB. Feel free to open a GitHub issue at any time.
- penagwin 7y agoYou're comment feels like it has a negative ton (shoving down throats) but if the content recommendation is really good and isn't gamed it works really well IMO. My experience has been spotify is great at recommending songs I like, even unpopular songs - I've quickly fallen into the rabbit hole of making a playlist - checking out the playlist recommendations, seeing their artist's other tracks, etc.
- m0zg 7y agoOr it could just be that their catalog is 99% unwatchable garbage and they keep raising the prices every year anyway.
- DeonPenny 7y agoIts actually really good and their orginals are usually better than everything else they have.
- PenguinCoder 7y agoThat's part of the problem. People aren't getting Netflix to watch their original programming.
- throwaway082729 7y agoThat's a really low bar for them to beat.
- ziddoap 7y agoWell this is a tad hyperbolic and quite subjective, isn't it? Regarding pricing, yeah rising prices suck but do you really expect prices to remain stable indefinitely?
- m0zg 7y agoGiven that there's hardly anything to watch and customers are leaving because of it, I expect the prices to go down. They need to focus, produce at least something GoT/Breaking Bad-grade, and sustain it for a few years.
- ziddoap 7y ago>Given that there's hardly anything to watch Subjective, I find lots of things to watch and enjoy. >produce at least something GoT/Breaking Bad-grade Again, subjective. I enjoyed Breaking Bad, but did not enjoy GoT. Other people liked the vice-versa. Other people liked neither. It sounds like you want Netflix to cater specifically to your tastes. I imagine pricing restructure might happen if the exodus is extreme, but it doesn't seem like it is very extreme. After all, they gained subscribers didn't they? Just not as many as they had thought. >second-quarter earnings report Wednesday revealed fewer _new_ subscribers than expected >The company said it _added_ 2.7 million subscribers across the globe in the second quarter
- heymijo 7y ago> If video streaming subscribers don’t know what they want to watch, they’re almost twice as likely to tune into their favorite broadcast television channel (58%) rather than browse through the menus of their streaming services (33%), according to the research from Nielsen. > Research by behavioral psychologists has shown that too many choices can overwhelm consumers, create the unpleasant feeling known as “decision fatigue” and sometimes leading them to shut down and walk away from a potential purchase. > Television viewers also need to choose what channel to watch. Yet part of the allure might be how television just beams whatever’s on the channel instead presenting viewers with even more options on what to watch. Maybe Netflix hasn't missed this at all. Maybe this is the functionality they're after with the auto-start/preview of any show you hover over.
- gnicholas 7y agoDoes this 58% statistic come from a sample of people who actually have broadcast TV access and streaming access? I, for one, have never had broadcast TV access as an adult, and the most recent "TV" I purchased was actually a 48" Vizio display that has no coax input. I was surprised by this number and assume they were only looking at people who actually have access to both. If that's the case, what is the number among the total universe of streaming video users?
- droithomme 7y ago> according to the research from Nielsen Nielsen drops families who don't watch any broadcast TV. Which is now most households. Their stats are useless.
- hyencomper 7y agoI think Netflix has lost touch with their consumer base, with most changes such as removal of the rating system being universally criticized. I cancelled my subscription recently as I realized that while Netflix has a lot of shows, there is a dearth of quality content and the search function is not useful. With shows like Friends and Office leaving, there is not much to draw people who like leaving it on in the background. Also, the auto-playing of trailers at full volume is super-annoying.
- mrexroad 7y agoThe auto playing of trailers has been enough to curtail my casual browsing of their app.
- protomyth 7y agoYeah, I go to Netflix if I know what I want to watch not to browse. It is very much like a DVD that won't let you skip the trailers.
- smolder 7y agoI just made a quick greasemonkey script that disables the autoplay at the top but leaves up the jpg splash. If anyone's interested I can share it.
- brighter2morrow 7y ago>If anyone's interested I can share it. No thanks, I don't use Netflix.
- fpalmans 7y agoI'm interested...
- smolder 7y agoI posted it here: https://paste.ee/p/8xg54 https://paste.ee/p/8xg54
- ziddoap 7y agoClassic paradox of choice problem, and I'm keen to see how Netflix decides to tackle it.
- m463 7y agoIf this is the actual reason subscriptions are dropping, then the obvious solution would be to ACTUALLY allow searching and filtering of the catalog, along with nuanced rating of shows and accurate prediction. I remember that netflix sponsored a contest to accurately predict what people wanted to watch, then ignored the winning algorithm.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoIf people are always engaged in videos like TV and movies, they are generally less engaged in their own life - which is generally pretty unhealthy. I think people have come to realize that they don't need to watch stuff streaming all the time. They can read a book, or go outside, and even interact with real people. Several online offerings offer zilch in the way of true health benefits.
- darepublic 7y agoAgree with you that constant screen time doesn't make for a healthy lifestyle. Seems pretty speculative and prob too optimistic to assume people are coming to this realization and acting on it.
- snr 7y agoThis.
- gen3 7y agoI wouldn't be surprised if Netflix comes out with a "TV Mode" soon, that allows you to pick from personal channels similar to how music streaming services have weekly mixes.
- keanebean86 7y agoActually a random play actually sounds interesting to me. They know what I like already. I don't want it on by default. Just a link to play a random show/movie and let me skip/hide if it sucks.
- aantix 7y agoImagine flipping through the Netflix "channels", Die Hard is playing, and it's playing right at the scene where Bruce Willis is jumping out of the window of the building. And there's an option in the right corner to "play from the beginning". Flip to the next movie, and it's positioned right at its most popular scene.
- InitialLastName 7y agoI've been pondering a feature like this for a while to replicate my youthful viewing habits. When I was younger, I would get home from school and watch a few hours of TV. The channel I watched would syndicate sitcoms in blocks, same show at a given time, played in episode order (but a few different shows over the afternoon). What I'd love from netflix is to be able to put together a list of shows I'm watching right now and have it run a playlist in random order by show, but with the episodes in the correct order per show.
- gen3 7y agoand it would all be ad free! It would be all the good parts of TV, but even better.
- xemdetia 7y agoTo me there is a reason why twitch is popular and I believe it is exactly this feeling. I remember watching some more dodgy streaming services that just effectively were streamed playlists of shows, but you didn't have any control over the playlist. You watched (or watched part of) a series start to finish and then a new series would start and you'd watch that instead. It was a small enough total catalog that you often could pick up where you left off a week or two later and watch another chunk, and that was it. The pendulum has seemingly reached the limits of self-programmed content and has started to swing the other way, and people are starting to realize the value of having a content producer putting on a good show across several programs. Netflix also feels (by the way they are developing their internal IP) that they are becoming a niche (in genre) service rather than a generic appeal service and losing subscribers feels like an outcome of the catalog they have tried to pursue. The subscribers they retain are likely going to have a higher level of permanence compared to people who are a more general audience.
- throwaway082729 7y agoThere's nothing worth watching in Netflix now. I find myself spending more time on Prime Video where I can find richer content through Prime movies and subscription channels like HBO, Starz and PBS (for British murder mystery shows). Moreover, Netflix is getting its recommendations for me completely wrong. Without user reviews, I've no idea if the content is good. I'm not going to waste my time watching some random show if I find that it's crappy 2 episodes in. Prime on the other hand shows me IMDB ratings (which are good enough) along with user ratings.
- jhallenworld 7y agoAmazon has the interesting idea of making it as easy as possible to buy a subscription (to Starz, HBO) and then cancel it later when you are no longer interested. I think this is very important in the future, where every content producer wants to have their own Netflix. The advantage that Amazon offers, is that you only have to learn how to cancel a channel on Amazon, and not on 10 different websites..
- penagwin 7y agoWhat you're describing is a "streaming service aggregator" which would be great but I doubt many streaming services will want to be apart of (Talking netflix, hulu, etc).
- ryanianian 7y agoYou may consider a meta-streaming service like ReelGood (not affiliated just a happy user). You tell it which streaming services you have, what shows you've liked, etc and it gives you recommendations from across all your services. I go through cycles of using it and not but every time I'm feeling too much choice-fatigue I pull up my reelgood recs and pick something from there.
- sho 7y ago> Netflix is getting its recommendations for me completely wrong As far as I can tell Netflix has no "recommendation engine". I have never noticed any correlation between the kind of show/movie I like and what it displays; it seems completely random, well, with a bias towards self-made content which presumably costs them less in licensing - almost all of which is made-for-TV level garbage of no interest to me in any format. I genuinely think I could write a better recommendation engine. I think sorting by basically anything - budget, popularity in my demographic, most watched until completion, would be better than whatever they have now. Basically my only use for Netflix now is the occasional standup comedy special (which I have to search for by name), the rare occasion I suddenly think of a movie I want to watch and is actually there (also search by name), or to put other people in front of. I'd try HBO Go but for some idiotic reason it's not available in my area. Frankly, if they can actually execute, I think Disney is going to clean Netflix's clock.
- throwaway_009 7y agoThey started going downhill with every original show losing logical consistency after the 1st or 2nd season, political pandering instead of offering good quality entertainment. And the removal of the user reviews was a degrade, as they want to push bad shows to users and waste their time, instead of letting them make an informed choice. I hope they get disrupted because of their arrogance.
- happytoexplain 7y ago>political pandering instead of offering good quality entertainment This, unfortunately, is the ultimate double-edged sword. It would be a very safe and content-less world indeed if fictional media did not in some what appear to address or include something political in nature. Usually when we feel like what we're watching is not political, it's actually because it's simply political in ways that we identify with or do not find offensive.
- throwaway_009 7y agoIt just bothers me that they try to include a few tropes in every movie or show without it fitting in the story properly. As I said, if they maintain the logical consistency and in the context of a good story I don't mind some political push. But if it is in every show/movie, it just becomes repulsive.
- colemickens 7y agoI'm curious to understand what you're describing. Can you give an example of a Netflix show, the season and political trope, and how it detracted from the show's quality? And I'm definitely curious what you're imagining as you write out "repulsive".
- pok1poekpo12 7y agoGood Example: Black Mirror episode where man has sex with his friend in Mortal Kombat. Is this really an interesting addition to the Black Mirror world? Accept gay people, alright, whatever; I still don't want to watch 2 people having VR chat sex.
- _bxg1 7y agoUhh... yeah... I would never consider cable networks "trusted sources". I do experience decision fatigue sometimes when streaming, but my solution is just to have a couple of comfort-sitcoms always on-hand, not to subject myself to an endless pipeline of advertisements and low-budget reality TV.
- sundayedition 7y agoThere is a lot of what I'd consider "noise" popping up on Netflix that they won't let me filter out. I don't care for most dubbed shows, and I haven't had any luck with any of the foreign imports. No way to filter them out that I'm aware of, so half of the "New shows" don't appeal to me I wouldn't give up Netflix for cable, it's more likely to be Prime only, or something with quality content that I wouldn't watch as often because they don't have as much variety (HBO, Showtime, AMC, CBS) Stranger things was released and we watched that but I haven't been on Netflix in weeks since; another price hike and the values no longer likely there for me.
- crooked-v 7y agoSignal-noise ratio is how I'd put it, too. There's a lot of stuff it recommends to me over and over that I have no interest in watching, like generic mockbusters and Korean soap operas.
- dkarl 7y agoIt could really use a YouTube-style "not interested" button. It's so stubborn that it feels like it's trying to force shows on me instead of helping me find what I want to watch.
- cpuguy83 7y agoIt used to have this. The recommendation engine used to actually be good.
- ALittleLight 7y agoOne thing that frustrates me about Netflix is how I'll watch an item X but after a few minutes decide I don't like it and watch something else. My home screen will be clouded for quite some time with recommendations based on X. How are they missing such an obvious signal that I didn't like X?
- ryanianian 7y agoNetflix is blatantly user-hostile. The UX is designed to get you to spend more time with Netflix, not to make you like it more. Many of the shows it suggests to me are not in english, yet the UX rarely discloses this in the description or (infuriatingly auto-playing) preview. Some people don't mind reading subtitles but I detest it - they could at least tell me the show is in German before wasting my time.
- zadkey 7y agoI think Netflix needs to invest in quality over quantity. I agree, its hard to find something I want to watch. There is definitely choice fatigue. If they had 1/3 as many shows but those shows were 3 times better. I am sure I would have no problem.
- MegaButts 7y agoIt sounds like you want something more akin to HBO. Ironically, HBO is trying to become like Netflix and Netflix is trying to become like HBO. https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2018/07/att-changing-hbo/564635/ https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2018/07/at... Surprisingly, I find myself using Hulu more than all the others combined, including Prime. Hulu's app is so horrendously bad though I consider cancelling as more than 50% of the time it won't load on the first try, and probably 20% of the time it won't load at all on my TV.
- qznc 7y agoI'm back to a send-CD service like Netflix started with. I love this mode: I maintain a list of movies I'd like to watch. I have two of them available to watch in the evening. No Ads. No continue seduction.
- habosa 7y agoFor sure. I recently started watching HBO Go more and I realized that 90%+ of the shows on that service are excellent. On Netflix it's like 20% tops.
- jupiter90000 7y agoThere is something to be said about the Nielsen hypothesis given -- finding something to watch takes effort, and starts taking more time the more one has already seen. My wife and I can spend upwards of 30+ minutes trying to find something we want to see and haven't already watched. Especially for just some casual 'background' watching, just putting on a channel on TV with some acceptable type of programming focus is alot easier than digging for it. Btw, for Netflix I usually just do a trial when a new Stranger Things season comes out, watch it all and maybe a few of their new movies, then cancel.
- tsieling 7y agoNo punishment is enough for auto-play previews.
- pixelbath 7y agoI just don't feel like Netflix is made to make my video viewing experience better anymore. They don't take customer feedback seriously, they're removing features that people obviously love, and becoming victims of the ever-growing race to "increase engagement." 1. Autoplaying trailers: Netflix straight-up says that's not going away (https://twitter.com/Netflixhelps/status/947587245086859265 https://twitter.com/Netflixhelps/status/947587245086859265), and I haven't met a single person who actually likes it. When stopping to talk about a show, my wife just mutes the television on the main screen, and I navigate to the Search screen, which is the only one that doesn't autoplay something. It's almost hostile amount of "HERE LOOK AT THIS SHOW" going on, and I despise it. 2. Removing reviews: If you've been on Netflix long enough, chances are you remember the pages-long reviews left by extremely passionate users on all kinds of films. Netflix just decided one day to throw all that away, probably because negative reviews decreased engagement or some other silly reason. The users added value to your service, and you actively threw it out. This also had the side-effect of tossing aside the count of films I've watched or rated, which I found to be an interesting bit of data. 3. Shuffling algorithms: Maybe I'm doing it wrong, but I have a difficult time navigating to anything that's not a specific title. Genres, their weird made-up categories ("Comic Book Superhero Movies" or "Classic Sci-Fi and Fantasy"), or even foreign films. There's no way to browse this stuff unless the category happens to pop-up on screen. In addition, the "Continue Watching" category moves around randomly. Sometimes it's right at the top, sometimes 3 pages down. Similarly, why is "My List" not always at the top? It used to be a top-level navigation element. 4. Already seen: There's no way to hide anything in the UI. Not things I watched, not things I'm uninterested in, and certainly not things I dislike. I used to be able to signal disinterest in shows; now I can't. I could go on at length despite having already done so, but I think there's more at play here than Netflix's catalog. They're showing that all they're chasing is more money and bigger deals, and damn what the users think. Maybe I'm wrong; maybe it really is their "content slate drove less growth in paid net adds" this quarter, but I'm willing to bet that (at least in part) it's because even Hulu, owned by a bunch of traditional television media corporations, gives more consideration to its users.
- programmertote 7y agoI share the same thoughts. That's why I even wonder how data scientists and UX/UI folks, who work at Netflix, feel like when their recommendations to the management are not heeded by the latter. Maybe Netflix data scientists have a hard time finding useful insights out of the trove of data they have.
- archey1 7y agoNetflix is just getting more expensive and less interesting to me. With all of the content I like being taken off to be hosted on network exclusive streaming platforms that I refuse to pay for - I'll probably eventually just cancel Netflix as well going back to the tried and true method of just buying bluray box-sets of the content I want to watch. Or piracy. I think the critical mistake that all these megacorps are making is that people don't actually want to pay for a bazillion streaming services. That's the reason we cut the cord in the first place. People hated being locked into packages and this is basically the same thing - you need the "NBC" package for The Office or the "CBS" package for Star Trek. I can't be bothered to spend all that money. Netflix was worth it because it made accessing so much content easier than piracy, but with everything getting pushed into a walled garden "package" approach again...piracy will be easier again. I get HD over the air with less than a dozen chanels, and that's often enough to keep me distracted if I'm not feeling up to playing a videogame or watching a movie.
- JTbane 7y ago>People hated being locked into packages and this is basically the same thing - you need the "NBC" package for The Office or the "CBS" package for Star Trek. I can't be bothered to spend all that money. At this point it is very tempting to go back to good, old-fashioned torrents of TV shows.
- quicklyfrozen 7y agoIt's certainly a hell of a lot easier to not have to think about where to find your favorites. And once it's downloaded there are (almost) never any playback issues.
- bamboozled 7y agoIt’s laughable to me that after all the years of investment and business development in these steaming services it’s still much, much, much easier to use p2p networks to get content you want. I wonder if there would just be more profit in injecting advertisements in tv shows and distributing them openly using BitTorrent? Think of the size of the audience, yeah people will cut the ads out but a lot of people couldn’t be bothered.
- isbjorn16 7y agoMy problem with Netflix isn't the slate of shows and movies it has in its catalog. It's definitely not as nice as it used to be, but there are a jillion and a half shows and movies out there. My problem is that Netflix has taken note that we watch anime a few times a week, which doubtless means we want every single band/carousel/whatever to be about anime. New Anime, Critically Acclaimed Anime, Popular Anime, Watch it Again Anime, Anime Where Characters Wear Hats, Anime Where Characters Float in Hats, and Anime About Hat Making. For the love of all let me get some other options in the fucking list before I lose my mind. I like comedies, action movies, sci-fi, documentaries, and historical dramatizations or historical fictions too, you know. Not everything has to have a talking cat in it.
- randrews 7y agoI have this problem with ML and recommendation systems in general. I hope this fad goes away soon and people go back to making simple, understandable, show-me-the-newest-stuff feeds.
- isbjorn16 7y agoRight - I just feel like it takes things entirely too far. Not every signal deserves a boost that takes a certain genre of suggestions up to 11. These recommendation systems need to be a bit less zealous; I like black pepper, too, but that doesn't mean I want a huge bowl of black peppercorns in cream sauce for dinner.
- SanchoPanda 7y agoThey may be doing the math on extremes in categories where relative quality is good given their current catalogue.
- ryacko 7y agoPeople tend to look up movies not by theme, but by actor or director. Could Netflix be okay with categories that don’t fill up entire screens?
- pteredactyl 7y agoThey need a 'Non-Netflix Content' filter.
- residentfoam 7y agoI find myself browsing Netflix but not finding anything interesting. Old movies and low-quality content. I am deleting the subscription.
- krisroadruck 7y agoIs it that people don't know what they want to watch? Or is it that what they want to watch isn't in the netflix catalog. 9/10 times I have a specific movie or show in mind that I want to watch and I search for it on netflix it tells me it is only available to be shipped via DVD or bluray and its not available in their online catalog. Maybe if they spent less money on trying to develop their own content and more money licensing the best content to come out over the past 30 years then there would be more engagement. The percentage of the top 1000 or so movies as rated on IMDB or Rotten tomatoes that is NOT on netflix is staggering. When we all bought into the concept of netflix a decade or so back it was on the premise of all-you-can-eat on demand access to the largest/most inclusive catalog of movies and shows anywhere. They long ago ditched that model and they are suffering as a result. It's not even that you can't get the latest blockbusters, its that you can't get most highly rated movies from ANY of the last 3-4 decades. But movies rated 5/10 or lower? Seems like they've managed to license just about every one of those. Bleh.
- sfink 7y agoI suspect that isn't netflix's decision to make. Everyone is trying to get into the streaming market these days, and the only way to capture subscribers is to offer up content that other services don't have, which means they're willing to burn huge piles of investor money to lock up exclusive rights. Yes, it defeats the whole point of streaming subscriptions. Yes, it'll drive a large segment of the subscriber base back to piracy. But it's a classic prisoner's dilemma. As long as I'm speculating about shit i know nothing about, I'll follow up by predicting that the next wave - after things get bad enough - is cross-licensing deals between the bigger surviving players. That'll improve the value proposition to subscribers (great for us!) and also raise barriers to entry, so next will be the price gouging. Oh, and somewhere in there will be the contracts that prevent content creators/distributors from licensing new stuff to anyone else (unless they are one of the surviving streaming services.)
- pok1poekpo12 7y agoAnecdotally, I don't think it is choice fatigue that is causing a subscriber drop. I think it reflects a drop in the quality of their original content. Compare early black mirror to what it is now. It's become far less of a "thinking" show, and much more of a "You should accept this, you shouldn't accept this" show.
- rubyn00bie 7y agoI used to like Netflix content because it felt like they were telling me a story which they had thought through and I would get to see to its end... or I'd even finally get an ending to some shows other networks/services killed too soon. To me, Netflix content strategy was saying "storytelling is what is important," and "we want to make sure we find and tell the best stories." New ones, old ones, great stories just the same... Anymore, I do not believe this to be true, and feel sort of silly for thinking it ever was true. It's become quite obvious their strategy is create new shows to lure people in, and then cancel them (because they'd have to pay the stars more), rinse repeat, hoping more people stay than leave. They do not care about finishing the stories they're telling, or the stories at all, they don't care about content, they care about growth. Honestly, anymore, I don't even want to watch Netflix shows because they'll probably get canceled before they end. Edit: small grammar fix
- musha68k 7y agoNetflix to me is not much more than a pretty bland version of Huxley's "Feelies". Actually most modern TV show stories would fit nicely into one or two well edited movies. I find all of this very comparable to the food in our super markets - lots of nutritionally empty calories and cheap canola oil. Time badly wasted and truly dystopian - all this zombie-like "binging" is way worse than "bread and games".
- chadcmulligan 7y agoYes, this is what I'm finding with many Netflix shows, they are extended movies. The problem is that each episode isn't really an episode, it has no "arc". Like when you watch NCIS for example, there's resolution after an hour or so. There's sometimes a bigger plot line if you watch all the episodes in a series but you don't have to. ..and because its better for them once they've hooked you to keep you there, the series usually provides a cliff hanger, but many times the series isn't renewed so the risk/investment in time is high. If it is renewed then they really have no new idea so they just rehash the first series and do it again (e.g. the OA, I guess, I stopped after the beginning of the second series). So you never get the closure you get from watching an old school tv series or movie, there's no high's or low's of a good story, there's just time used up.
- ineedasername 7y agoWe seem to be reaching peak streaming, the point at which the addition of more streaming services may result in a net loss of streaming consumption because the interesting content is too spread out and it's too expensive or inconvenient to subscribe to them all. It's rather like each streaming service is turning into its own version of a TV channel. It's almost the vision of a'la cart cable pricing, only each channel is too expensive and the UX too cumbersome to subscribe to more than a small handful. Perhaps in a few years, streaming aggregators will appear and bundle a bunch of services together, and the internet will have reinvented Cable TV.
- someexgamedev 7y agoCable subscriptions are a single subscription that gives you access to everyone's content. Netflix's digital innovation is that they did it at a tenth the price. Now that all the content creators have realized the digital value of their content, it doesn't matter for Netflix whether those networks splinter it out into 20 different subscriptions or hide it behind 1 expensive cable subscription again. Netflix doesn't have that content so they lose either way. Their only way forward is to become just another content network, OR a cable provider with the same elevated subscription cost. Whichever way they lean, the stock will tumble until they're in line with all their competitors. The gap has been closed.
- duxup 7y agoI just find discovery really hard on Netflix. If it isn't a Netflix original I feel like I'm scrounging around / fighting Netflix to find something...it feels like there is little to offer.
- teilo 7y agoNetflix is becoming more and more of a frustrating experience. First they removed all user reviews. Then they removed ratings. (or vice versa. Whatever.) They constantly shift things around in their UI. Even things like "My List" and "Continue Watching" will spontaneously move. They hide categories, and sub-categories, making browsing and discovery a pain. They constantly throw crap at me that I don't care about and will never care about. They auto-play previews, with audio, and there is no damn way to turn it off. Thumbs up/down seems to have no effect on this either. I thumbs down what I don't want to see, and it keeps coming back anyway. It's almost as if there is a concerted effort at Netflix to force specific content down your throat. They don't want you going beyond what's visible on their idiotic horizontal scrollers, and they don't want you to know what people actually think about the content they are forcing on you.
- SkyPuncher 7y agoHaving listened to podcasts with several important Netflix people as guests, I have picked up that they are unintentionally user hostile. They're so focused on data that it seems they completely forget about the intangible side of enjoying the user experience. Seems like they can't see the forest for the trees.
- vl 7y agoThe problem is that optimizing for long-term satisfaction metrics is extremely tricky and hard. Such metrics lead to the better user retention, potentially even with less watch time. Paradoxically higher watch time may lead to lower user satisfaction (and decreased retention). In ML world these metrics require combining DNNs with methods like Q-learning. YouTube learned these lessons and now probably has the most advanced ML among competition in its’ recommendation system.
- goalieca 7y agoWatch time is bullshit. Focus on making a quality product that people enjoy. My goal in life is not to spend any more time in front of the tv than 1-2 hours per day. Usually it’s just before bed when I relax.
- low_key 7y agoFirst, I'll admit that I'm still a subscriber. For me, the biggest problem with Netflix is the user interface. The auto-playing audio and video at every corner is extremely annoying. The used car dealership feel of it is stressful, which is exactly the opposite of what I want when I'm ready to watch a show or movie. They have some content that I like and I'll watch it when I know exactly what I want to see before I open the app. If not, then I don't go to Netflix anymore, it is just too hostile.
- tedsanders 7y agoThere's something I don't understand, but I'd like to. Most of the criticisms of Netflix I see fall into two buckets: One common criticism is that Netflix is worse than regular TV, because having to actively choose a Netflix show is more stressful than regular TV, where you can just turn it on, sit back, and relax. The second common criticism I read is that Netflix is annoying, because as soon as you turn it on, it starts autoplaying videos at you in obnoxious attempt to grab your interest and attention. Like, aren't these two criticisms completely opposite? Regular TV always autoplays at full volume. What nuance would help me understand why autoplaying is annoying on Netflix but not annoying on regular TV? (Disclosure: I work at Netflix, am speaking purely in a personal capacity, but would love to make things better for people to the extent that I can.)
- ryanthemadone 7y agoTrying to find something to watch on Netflix is definitely a chore, having stuff autoplay isn't facilitating that search - the feature often 'gets in the way' painfully and makes me mute my TV. I don't have a regular TV service anymore, but I suspect it's quite easy to flip it on, jump to the guide (which probably isn't blaring loud stuff at you) and scan the currently airing shows for something you're familiar with and you like. So no contradiction as far as I can tell. My Netflix experience is one where I often have 2-3 shows that I'm currently watching. I want those shows front and center when I log in, perhaps with recommendations for similar shows alongside. It would be even cooler if two shows I was watching had recommendations that crossed over both of them. I should also be able to "close" a series I've started watching, but decided I don't want to watch anymore. When I don't have active shows that I'm watching I kind of want Netflix to help me find stuff based on my viewing history, right now I have IMDb and other apps open on my phone so that I can check community scores and reviews of content I don't know about, whatever dumb business strategy decision prohibited that data being in the Netflix app should be rescinded immediately. Heck I should be able to pull up all sci-fi, filter for stuff I haven't seen, filter for TV series, movie or whatever, order by rotten tomatoes score and then filter for stuff that isn't space based or something. You get the gist, there's so much Netflix could be doing to enable discoverability.
- mplanchard 7y ago
- magicalhippo 7y agoPersonally I often don't want to invest too much into starting a new series, and I don't have time for an entire movie. I also often want to learn new things, or see something interesting. So I turn to YouTube, with all the creative folks uploading interesting and engaging videos about all sorts. I think Netflix is missing something by focusing entirely on TV series and movies. Give me something interesting I can watch for 15, 30, 45 minutes that doesn't require the kind of mental investment a TV series does.
- iscrewyou 7y agoThey raised the prices and then the news came out that they are removing two of their most popular shows. I was ok with the price increase. But now they removed stuff I watch, this new price on my monthly subscriptions has me asking “what am I paying for?” They are double dipping to increase production of Netflix shows. More power to them. But don’t remove the things people are actually watching the most.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rossdavidh 7y agoSo, I am reminded of a point in the "early" (that is, early as a consumer venue) internet, when there was a lot of great content, but no good search engines. It did not send people back to pre-internet sources, nor do I think the current situation will send people back to their network broadcast channel. But I think there is a real problem, which is that there are more and more good shows, and no more hours in the day. It feels...a bit like too many companies chasing any finite-sized market. It feels like just before the crash. It's hard for the world to ever admit it, especially the U.S., but maybe we don't actually need to have this many shows?
- habosa 7y agoI signed up for Netflix because the original (maybe too good to be true) premise was that I'd be able to stream basically everything in one place. The key is that I came to stream shows that I already watched but which had no home on the internet. Now Netflix is a place to watch shows and movies made by Netflix. So it's like HBO, but more quantity and less quality. My favorite "comfort food" shows like The Office, It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, etc are slowly leaving the service. So I find my Netflix account collecting digital dust most of the time. More and more I find myself liking YouTube TV. It gives me mindless channel flipping, live sports, and the cloud DVR gives me a pseudo-netflix where I have every episode of all my favorite shows ready at a click (I just need to fast-forward recorded commercials).
- geodel 7y agoWell Netflix is now big enough where what their CEO want and what middle management chose to implement will be different things. On tech side despite all their tech wizardry I get this feeling that this company is overwhelmed with Java design pattern types. On business side it's full of too clever by half folks who would think every user hostile feature is great if it improves some bullshit metrics.
- jimbob45 7y agoThey lost all their content because everyone else wanted to hoard it for their own services. That's fine, I'm a faithful consumer and I'll do my part against shady practices. Then they put out substandard SJW shows like Bright and Jessica Jones. That's still okay, not every show is targeted to me and they still weren't conducting shady business practices so they were still a good company in my eyes. Then they put out 13 Reasons Why. All my goodwill toward them was lost and my subscription was canceled within the month.
- IanDrake 7y agoAt some point Netflix got woke and for me that killed it. Most Netflix originals prioritized a political message first and entertainment a distant second. I don't need to get my values from entertainers, of all people.
- jl2718 7y agoWhether you agree with the message or not, it’s the opposite of entertainment when you know that everything is going to conform to a trope. I wonder whether they’d consider that maybe people are just bored and don’t want to pay for the content.
- nkozyra 7y agoIs the final result individuals or studios having a distributed platform to sell access to just their show (s) for a reasonable fee? This is what people want and have been saying so for decades. Don't make me pay for a service I use 2% of. This is the whole anti ala carte thing cable companies have done forever.
- droithomme 7y agoThere's multiple reasons. Not all these reasons are being discussed. Valid reasons discussed get censored. Netflix had great technology and business plan and management executed it well for many years. I reluctantly dumped it all in late May. I'd been watching it carefully after in December they hired an activist executive from ABC who cares more for political correctness than profitability. Dumping at the end of May proved smart and I'm pretty happy with my half million in locked in gains. Netflix is now going to descend to $190 or so. Maybe it comes back from that. Maybe. Only if they make changes. After it hits rock bottom, if it then comes back up to $300 I'll reinvest. Those of you who didn't dump your stock yet, fasten your seatbelts and good luck to you. Hopefully I'm just a crank.
- sjg007 7y agoYeah I suffer from decision fatigue with both Netflix and Prime, even from just the Apple TV movies...
- taivare 7y agoDecision fatigue = JavaScript Frameworks
- chrisallick 7y agoSpelled ‘know’ wrong in the subtitle... eye roll
- miguelmota 7y agoIt seems like Netflix is focusing on quantity rather than quality. They crank out a ton of Netflix Originals but they're all pretty uninteresting and almost seems tailored to high schoolers. I get that they're trying to capture young audiences but the content has sucked for a while and their lack of inventory of non-Netflix Original movies is what caused me to cancel my subscription last year. Would think that most people don't sign up for Netflix for their Netflix Original content and those that do end up disappointed after realizing that Netflix doesn't offer recent or classic movies. I remember when I could stream on multiple devices and watch classic TV shows which was awesome but now it's more expensive with all the different subscription tiers and they've removed some of my favorite shows. Spotify subscribers get offered a Hulu subscription for free (comes with ads though). Hulu has the good classic shows that Netflix no longer has.
- elamje 7y agoThe difficulty with Netflix and the like moving to a platform with a recommendation engine, is that no matter how good the machine learning is, it will have a strong incentive(minimization function) to show cheap content. Netflix has awesome blockbusters, but you will see the Netflix label and smaller budget movies higher in your recommendations because it cuts Netflix’s cost. In other words Netflix has to pay a lot more $ per view of blockbusters from big Hollywood studios than it does for private label movies and shows. If Netflix can have 10x the amount of private label hits like House of Cards and Black Mirror, they will do fine.
- rajacombinator 7y agoI was happy paying for Netflix when they made 2-3 A list shows per year and 1-2 B list shows. Now they make 50 F list shows per quarter by the people who were so bad that Hollywood wouldn’t hire them. (Amy Schumer, etc.) Couldn’t be happier to not pay!
- noisy_boy 7y agoThings I dislike about Netflix: 1. Auto-playing trailers 2. Stop showing me stuff I have already seen (I can search it if I want to). Atleast add a "don't show this again" button 3. Auto-playing stuff I have already seen to rub it in 4. No system of reviews/ratings - I have to manually check IMDB or Rotten Tomatoes 5. "More like this" doesn't really show things that are more like "this". Also, if I like a comedian's special and click "more like this" for their other works, I rarely get more than one or two I am seriously contemplating to unsubscribe - hardly use it anyway due to lack of quality content.
- zizee 7y agoI'd really like Netflix to add a feature of "hide this shitty show from me forever because I will never watch it", it would be an obvious win from a user's perspective. Why don't Netflix provide this? Because people would quickly realize how little in their catalog is worth watching.
- gtirloni 7y agoThat's great news it's true. Netflix just have to invest in curating content and an always-on channel(s) to fix that problem. Much cheaper.
- hartator 7y agoThe thing is almost all Netflix produced content is really not that good. If it was HBO quality, no one would consider leaving.
- leftyted 7y agoI don't understand why Netflix doesn't open up the website to everyone, build out the search tools (they suck), and let people pay per episode, per season, or per movie. I bet they'd make more money. I also wonder if Netflix missed an opportunity by not thinking of their product as a streaming platform a couple years ago.
- Pfhreak 7y agoI suspect Netflix has, in fact, considered exactly this model and decided against it because: a) It would make them less money b) They don't have rights agreements that would permit it
- rahulsom 7y agoNielsen's unable to offer value to streaming services. Their technology and service only work with traditional broadcast television. They would like to see streaming services to send them their data so they can sell it back to them. Streaming services don't benefit from such an agreement. Netflix has been in the streaming business for 10+ years, as has Hulu. For Nielsen to say they can tell these services how streaming customers behave is a bit too presumptuous. Keep in mind, some of these new customers have never subscribed to broadcast television. There's possibly even a generational gap in their behavior.
- noitsnot 7y agoNielsen claimed to be able to track Netflix efficiently two years ago.
- homerhomer 7y agoIt's a quality vs quantity issue. Netflix removed the ratings from their hosted content and I feel that I've TRIED to watch to many shows that were not worth my time. Eveytime I go to Netflix I can't find anything that seems good. I know there's good show and they claim so many thousands of shows but why I'am I seeing the same 100 shows everywhere I turn? Ugh
- jillesvangurp 7y agoThey raised their prices and shut down several popular series early. I cancelled my subscription last week because I was finding it hard to find something good to watch that I hadn't seen yet. I'm now catching up on a few things on Amazon Prime like the Expanse season 3, American Gods, Good Omens and a few other things. I will probably switch back in a few months when Netflix has added a few things that I might want to see. They do have a few series that they haven't killed yet that I would want to see. Apparently, they keep your profile and settings for 10 months. This suggests that I'm not the only one shopping around.
- mixmastamyk 7y agoNetflix is finally facing some decent competition, and in response, they've been raising prices. :-/ I understand they need their own content, but they've already got more than I can watch. I'd prefer more quality and sticking with shows over quantity and higher prices.
- tbabb 7y agoThis analysis suggests a trivial solution, if it's accurate: Make a "shuffle" channel on Netflix which just starts playing a random show/movie which the algorithm has confidence you'll like. "Skipping" would be just like changing the channel on TV. That could probably do a better job of satiating the viewer than broadcast channels, which don't know your taste.
- egberts1 7y agoPlus their latest made for Netflix-specific movies have taken on some political issues as a dig. I’m more into politic-Free dialog.
- codeisawesome 7y agoI unsubscribed from Netflix because in Singapore too many of my searches for well known movies come up empty, and TV shows also catch up super late :(
- allthecybers 7y agoI'm interested to see how this plays out. Netflix will either figure it out and survive or they'll continue to shed subscribers and get acquired by Apple to augment AppleTV. I say that partly in jest. My Netflix was cancelled about 6 months ago. It felt like it was another version of Facebook... great for mindless scrolling but nothing that made me want to stop scrolling and watch. Part of it was the loss of several favorite shows making the service not worth the price plus the price of other subscriptions. I would say the same about Prime Video if it wasn't free with Amazon Prime.
- kyriakos 7y agoIs it me or the article grammar is off? Missing words etc
- b3b0p 7y agoI feel like I might be in the minority opinion on this, but I don't enjoy any of the Netflix originals they keep pumping out. At least not enough to spend time on them. I don't like the Marvel shows, Stranger Things was okay I guess maybe, but I don't enjoy them enough like for example Game of Thrones or The Fabulous Miss Maisel or some of the others from HBO, Showtime or surprisingly Amazon. Most if not all the Netflix original content is B quality to me at best. Low production, not interesting, bad dialogue, bad stories, etc... I have limited time. I try to spend it wisely. I'd rather use my wasted time on something far more enjoyable, like playing my NES or reading a book or movie, or even watch something of higher quality and production value (HBO is pretty reliable for that or a movie on my backlog). Or even just get out and go somewhere to see and meet people. Right now my only subscription service is Funimation ($5/month). I like watching dubbed anime late at night too chill out before bed. Currently (re)watching Black Lagoon (it's so great!) and the Mix Simuldub. With a side of computer science books on my backlog with some related videos or courses as well as a good book which right now is Snow Crash (embarrassingly I have not read this yet).
- WalterBright 7y agoThe obvious solution for Netflix is to create a handful of "channels". Something people can just switch to anytime and just veg.
- t0mbstone 7y agoMy biggest complaint with Netflix is that they seem to be churning out tons of mediocre shows. The plot and theme of each of these shows are always extremely shallow, and seem to be generated almost via a trope randomizer designed to hit cliche target markets. - rich moms having babies - black family reunion - asian family with convenience store - older gay couples living together - superhero franchise season 7! - football players with one last chance to go to college - people in jail!
- ryanmcbride 7y agoNetflix was so great when their streaming service started, and even back when they only did DVDs by mail. It was so cool that I had access to so many movies and shows in once place. Now that every broadcast company has their own streaming service with their own fees, streaming is almost as bad as network TV. (at least with streaming you don't have to watch reruns unless you want) I've gone full into Plex now. That seems to be the only way to have a watchable selection of stuff in one place now.
- kara_jade 7y agoWell, I can tell the Netflix CEO why they have lost me as a subscriber: - Their original content is not terribly appealing to me. - They lack much of the content I want to watch (and in Germany the selection of content is much, much smaller to begin with). - They have a horrendous user interface. Perhaps I’m in the minority, but I like lists. And even one big list with all the content Netflix offers would be far superior to their interface. I’m not interested in their recommendation algorithms or their peculiar categorization, I want to sift through their metadata on my own terms. Give me a big, filterable list. (That is something that bugs me about every streaming service: you are heavily restricted when it comes to searching and filtering.) I have found that my local library has actually a very good selection of DVDs and Blu-rays. So they have become a reliable source of content. Other than that I occasionally buy used or new media cheaply. And for special interests (Anime) I have the net.
- raylangivens 7y agoI am based out of the Asian sub-continent. I cut the cord on my Netflix subscription 5 months ago. I only have a Prime Video subscription and a Hotstar subscription (for Live football, tennis etc). Netflix started becoming a place which would have content that I absoultely didn't want to watch and there were gazillion such titles. I felt that a reduced set of options that Hotstar (which has license to HBO-content) and Prime Video was good enough for me. I felt I had too many options on Netflix and didn't want the overhead to select one. As for some of the content on Netflix that I do like for e.g. Narcos & Mindhunter, Piracy FTW.
- drawkbox 7y agoThe article viewpoints are probably right, Netflix and Amazon need a few more hits that people trust. The Office was a big fallback show and Netflix needs a few of those of their own. Stranger Things probably fits that. The Witcher might change things for quality on Netflix. Netflix shows have high production quality in terms of cinematography, lighting, sound, color, sets, on location etc. Writing and big draw actors aren't there just yet, though they have a bunch of that going and started that way with House of Cards. Stranger Things was new actors except a couple like Winona Ryder, the writing was better and it was successful. Maniac and Sabrina are also pretty good in this area. Bojack Horseman has a cult following. Dark is amazing. Black Mirror was a great acquisition. I Am Mother was pretty good and premiering Annihilation was a steal. Russian Doll was excellent. Animation like Death, Love & Robots, Voltron, Castlevania and more are solid. Those are all the model to go for. What is missing in most shows is writing and casting/actors draw to make a staple series that becomes a fallback like the article mentions. > Consumers turn to a trusted source when they don’t know what to watch on their streaming service > Subscriptions like Netflix and Amazon Prime offer plenty of critically-acclaimed, award-winning content. But the thing is, viewers have to pick which movies and series they’ll watch, and observers say many are getting burned out from all that decision-making. Now with The Witcher the writing is based on a really solid book series, they have a big name actor Henry Cavill that has read the series and it looks great. It could be their Game of Thrones. Amazon is also trying this with Lord of the Rings and Wheel of Time. These shows if they are done right, will get rewatched for a long time and draws in the mega fans that are influencers. Netflix is doing pretty good with stand up comedy, maybe even the leader now. They paid Dave Chappelle and will forever be thanked for that by comedy content consumers. Netflix and Amazon need some big hits like the coming epics, and they need some good staple shows like the Office, Parks and Recreation, Brooklyn 99 (Netflix should have bought this), Always Sunny in Philadelphia, Friends, Seinfeld, Curb Your Enthusiasm and more. When they have that they equal the content competition that has that trusted good quality. They need a few more of these always watchable fallbacks. They are both still chasing HBO, HBO is still the top in consistently good content and shows. Personally I love the competition, some real funding and creator freedom is being unleashed, some are big hits, some are average and some not so good, but I like the amount of content and like the vibe of where Netflix is headed. Their new intro splash where the N goes into color bands is even great, matches their really colorful catalog.
- jv22222 7y ago> Netflix was worth it because it made accessing so much content easier than piracy Amazon can solve that problem. They makes it easy to bring all those disparate channels into a single UI. For example, we have HBO, Boomerang, CBS all in the one Amazon Prime browsing experience. IE You don't need any other apps other than Amazon Prime. Makes it super easy, but yeah, all the $10/month start to add up.
- subpixel 7y agoThe lack of reviews and ratings on Netflix means I don’t watch anything at all without googling for reviews and ratings. A significant number of times this leads to me reading, watching, or doing something else.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Sojuwa 7y agoBlacked Mirror has been more than enough reason to keep me subscribing.
- dkersten 7y agoI used Netflix because it was convenient. I don't watch much, so when there were fewer things that I was interested in, there was no point in keeping my subscriptions. I never signed up for any of the other streaming services because they didn't fulfill my requirements of convenient since I'd have to manage multiple accounts. I just watch even less now and spend my time on other, more rewarding, things. No big loss.
- robtherobber 7y agoThis very much reads like this article since 2018 (and probably others): https://medium.com/@gholemserge/netflix-poor-ui-40e94f56fc0e https://medium.com/@gholemserge/netflix-poor-ui-40e94f56fc0e
- magwa101 7y agoNetflix is so hard to use. They constantly recommend their latest releases when I have no interest at all. My behavior shows what I want to watch. I have a "My List" filled out. I've been on it for 20 years. Their motivations are obviously not aligned. Youtube recommendations are an example of a working system. Netflix is toast.
- alam2000 7y agoThe US subscribers plunged could be due to infighting with those users behind VPN servers. Many non-US users are using VPN servers to view Netflix, once detected and blocked, it caused the number of users in US dropped.