21 ms·
Amazon workers launch protests on Prime Day
- kome 7y agoway to go! as consumers, we can help by boycotting amazon.
- jonknee 7y agoYea so that way they'll have no jobs at all!
- deogeo 7y agoOr they will have jobs at other retailers, that will step in to take Amazon's market.
- Mehvix 7y agoWhat makes you think other retailers will treat the employees better than Amazon is right now?
- jonknee 7y agoThey'll be in for a rude awakening when they find out other fulfillment center jobs are just as hard and pay equal or less.
- icelancer 7y agoYeah... I am wondering what most outraged people think other warehouse jobs pay and how they treat their employees.
- deogeo 7y agoOther jobs are just as vulnerable to protests, strikes, and boycotts, so I don't see why they couldn't all be pressured to treat workers better. By your logic, workers should never fight abuse, as they'll "just get another job that's just as hard". But the history of labor shows this to be false, and that collective action can achieve improvements.
- chc 7y agoHow is this not a generalized objection to any strike or boycott? That isn't the goal here, and historically, similar tactics have been effective.
- mkane848 7y agoDid that sound clever in your head?
- dang 7y agoPlease don't respond to a bad comment with a worse one. Maybe you don't owe the other commenter better, but you do owe the community better if you're posting here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mkane848 7y agoYou're right, I just get really annoyed when people take flippant attitudes in situations that you'd think would elicit some empathy.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rstupek 7y agoCue Amazon putting in more robots!
- throwaway2048 7y agoThe amount of smug proclamations about how all these workers are going to be replaced by robots in these threads is really gross. Nearly everyone that posts on HN is in a situation where their employer holds vastly more power than themselves in their employer/employee relationship, statistically are you likely being screwed, and you aren't going to be Jeff Bezos one day either.
- nerdjon 7y agoI mean... it's happening. So either we continue to deny it isn't or we actually start those conversations now and figure out how we live in that world. And there is a correlation between actions like this and the desire to have a more automated workforce. Not saying that as blame because there are many other reasons and you can look at the reasons their jobs are so bad right now anyways. But we can't ignore it.
- ngold 7y agoWhen this was science fiction it was assumed we could all work less, not fewer people working more for less pay.
- tathougies 7y agoThat would require everyone to own a robot, but most people do not have the foresight to purchase one or involve their money in such a thing.
- throwaway2048 7y agoOr you know, millions of dollars.
- SmileyRedBall 7y agoWhat would it effect Bezos Net Worth to double the warehouse operatives hourly rate to $22?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SmileyRedBall 7y ago> Not more much than his divorce. Haaaa..aaaar :]
- honopu 7y agonot relevant, free market, they decide to work there, or not.
- SmileyRedBall 7y ago> not relevant, free market, they decide to work there, or not .. Yea they can decide to move to the next low-pay job, zero-hour contract, no benefits, wages barely pays the rent, on food stamps ..
- switch007 7y agoExactly. The implicit argument is that there is always some magical high-paying job with awesome benefits just round the corner if they just simply make the simple decision of switching jobs and/or pulling themselves up by their bootstraps. Right...
- bduerst 7y agoRising tides lift all boats. The largest employers changing their hiring practices forces other employers to change as well, to remain somewhat competitive.
- bancars 7y agoThat’s an awfully easy position to take when you don’t have to work at an Amazon warehouse. How many times have you been fired for using the bathroom?
- Animats 7y agoYes. Don't be a scab and cross the picket line. Don't buy from Amazon today.
- Wohlf 7y agoScabs are workers who cross the picket line, not customers. If you think boycotts are a good idea, ask the auto unions how well customers not buying cars worked out for their members.
- fucking_tragedy 7y agoCustomers boycotted Stop & Shop when workers went on strike earlier this year, and it worked out pretty well for the workers[1]. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/22/us/stop-shop-strike.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/22/us/stop-shop-strike.html
- thecount122195 7y agoNot the first time New Englanders have boycotted a supermarket chain either. When Market Basket ousted their president and voted to give the shareholders dividends rather than reinvesting in the company[1]. Though these workers wern't on strike they were protesting what they felt like was the first step of the company getting gutted and sold. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_Basket_protests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_Basket_protests
- astura 7y ago>Scabs are workers who cross the picket line, not customers. That's not the way unions themselves use the word. https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/24904995/boston-union-calls-yankees-scabs-crossing-hotel-picket-line https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/24904995/boston-union-ca... "Boston union calls Yankees 'scabs' for crossing hotel picket line"
- mc32 7y agoOnly because it's a way to use and coöpt language for your cause, not because it's the way the public understands it. It's like AOC insunuating Pelosi racist. It's used for effect. Or, imagine a nurses' strike, but I as a patient don't honor their strike, am I a scab?
- oneepic 7y agoJust a little reminder that many workers in fact do not get treated well just because their company thinks they do.
- luxuryballs 7y agoI think it should also be noted that the best way to show an employer that they need to do better is supply and demand, quitting entirely and working for someone else is not only more effective than simply demonstrating or slacking off, it’s also many magnitudes more professional and better for your career.
- vageli 7y ago> I think it should also be noted that the best way to show an employer that they need to do better is supply and demand, quitting entirely and working for someone else is not only more effective than simply demonstrating or slacking off, it’s also many magnitudes more professional and better for your career. If the goal is to get the employer to notice the issue, leaving and hope they get the idea, when the pool of applicants is essentially unlimited seems like a poor way of articulating a position. Amazon is a captive audience in this protest and by not just outright leaving, the employees are forcing Amazon to consider their situation, rather than write it off and bring in a new batch.
- lucasmullens 7y agoSome people have mouths to feed and bills to pay. You can't just tell people to quit if they don't like it. There aren't many other $15/hour jobs available for most of those workers.
- Tade0 7y agoquitting entirely and working for someone else Doesn't work if every other employer is also like that.
- enlyth 7y agoI agree with the worker in the video, they should be treated as human beings. One of the issues is doing a simple, monotonous task every 8 seconds, 10 hours a day, 5 days a week, without creating anything of value, is going to be dehumanizing and unfulfilling regardless. Robots carrying out this work would probably be for the best for everyone involved, although Amazon should do right by the workers carrying them over this difficult transition period where they're still required for part of the menial manual labour tasks. The compensation should reflect the mental and physical stress they put people through.
- vorpalhex 7y agoSo the fix to this is Amazon laying off all their workers?
- Someone1234 7y agoAs automation keeps on improving and productivity gets more centralized will there be a shortage of jobs? The above poster makes a fair point that this is work well suited to automation. In the broader sense with retail closing and Amazon taking market share, centralizing productivity (i.e. reducing retail jobs to fewer picker jobs), and then automating those fewer jobs away entirely, are we going to have a hole in society where those jobs once existed? I genuinely have no idea how society would work if you simply eliminated 20% of jobs tomorrow. Mass poverty? Artificially created jobs? A larger rich/poor divide?
- beatgammit 7y agoIt's highly unlikely that 20% will disappear overnight. Every other case where we've seen automation/innovation eliminating jobs has been a gradual process, so I see no reason for this not to continue. Amazon has been testing cashierless grocery stores, yet they haven't completely eliminated their competition where they're available. I'm sure they'll become popular, but they'll likely roll out relatively slowly. We already have self checkout, yet some people prefer to checkout with a human, and I doubt that will change. Manufacturing jobs have been using more and more automation, yet manufacturing jobs are still available, just different. Many jobs that used to be minimum wage jobs have been replaced by higher paying jobs with specialists; there are fewer of them, sure, but they pay better. As labor jobs get replaced by automation, we'll invent new jobs to take advantage of the increased labor pool. That's just the way innovation goes.
- dhruvrrp 7y ago> He says he has to pick an item about every eight seconds, or 332 per hour, for a 10 hour day. Ignoring the math, it’s hard to imagine that pace. Are they forced to continually be moving? Or is the person counting picking up, say 15 usb chargers as 15 separate things?
- pardavis 7y agoPick workers at robotized FCs stand in one place at the nexus point of conveyors and robots. Robots bring them shelving units of products. Conveyor belts bring them empty containers. The human selects products from the robot and puts it in the container.
- pwinnski 7y agoIf they're going to do that much automation, they might as well have the robot put the product in the container. Which they do. Amazon has both human and robot pickers.
- pardavis 7y agohttps://www.aboutamazon.com/amazon-fulfillment-center-tours/ https://www.aboutamazon.com/amazon-fulfillment-center-tours/
- Eric_WVGG 7y agoYes. I read an article last week about a guy who got fired for "unnecessary motion." (will update this comment with a link if I can dig it up.) Here's a story about a patent on a wristband that enables this kind of tracking: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jan/31/amazon-warehouse-wristband-tracking https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jan/31/amazon-wa... It is humanly possible. As a teenager, I worked at UPS, where I was expected to stack boxes real-life-Tetris-style into a van at a rate of 45 per minute. They could get as heavy as 30 lbs. I actually got to enjoy it after a while (biceps!), but I could never get the hang of memorizing the zip codes (every truck has a list of 1-30 that we were expected to memorize instantly).
- xtracto 7y agoBetween this and the Mechanical Turk article I read earlier today, I am left thinking about these type of jobs. There is this "chasm" of things that machines still cannot but that are repetitive and boring for humans, for which the value to human-effort ratio is small. I foresee that in the following 10 years, we will be seeing more and more of these types of works. Now, the interesting thing about some of these jobs is that they cannot be moved to places where the payment to cost of living ratio can be improved. Some Mechanical Turk tasks could (if the language allowed it) but the Amazon warehouse jobs would be impossible to move. Unless, Amazon opens a chain of warehouses in Mexico's cities that border the US (Tijuana, Tecate, Mexicali, Sonoyta, Nogales, Cd Juarez, among all the others) and then dispatches the goods from there. That however would need to include a very good import/export deal.
- tachyonbeam 7y ago> I foresee that in the following 10 years, we will be seeing more and more of these types of works. On the other hand, people are hard at work trying to automate these jobs. Amazon would love nothing more than to have a completely robotic warehouse and a fleet of delivery robots that run 24/7.
- WengerPen 7y agoWell, in theory a company like these can create robots that are operated from anywhere in the world. In that case, the operator job may be outsourced as it may be cheaper and less of a hassle than to have a person in X country getting paid more, complaining and going on strike.
- alexgmcm 7y agoIs the North of Mexico that much poorer though? I mean Mexico is quite wealthy compared to the rest of Latin America and the North of Mexico includes many of the wealthier areas. It's not the same building a warehouse in Nuevo Leon as in Chiapas.
- topspin 7y agoOff topic: I've been seeing Prime Day ad notifications in Brave. Thought that was interesting; about the most 'mainstream' ad I've ever seen in Brave.
- _zachs 7y ago"I have to pick an item every eight seconds, or 332 per hour, for a 10-hour day" No, no you dont
- lonelappde 7y agoIt's not a paradox as stated, since "or" has ambiguous meaning, but it does look suspicious, since 3600sec/8sec is 450, and 3600sec/332 is about 10.8sec.
- jeanl 7y agoI've been boycotting amazon for a long time. Waiting for "democracy" to solve the problems of unabated exploitative capitalism is a cop out. I put my money where my mouth is. I pay more, wait longer, but shop at places where I know people are treated at least decently.
- Havoc 7y agoHonestly it's been underwhelming anyway. The vast majority of the deals are re-runs of ones in past 6 months...just all at same time. I buy a lot of amazon stuff, but this barely shifted my day to day pattern. I did find out that you get wifi power plugs that are controllable and measure electricity usage. That's pretty cool...just not sale related.
- wingworks 7y agoDo you have a link/name of the wifi power plugs? Sounds intriguing.
- Havoc 7y agoTP link one ...also saw some random github-y thing while googleing the model number which hints at some level of hackable/api-able interfacing which made me click the buy button. That's sketchy info though https://smile.amazon.co.uk/dp/B07GWWRK1C https://smile.amazon.co.uk/dp/B07GWWRK1C [Please bookmark & make use of smile.amazon.com/co.uk thing...it's amazon's corporate charity thing - free 0.5% donation]
- wingworks 7y agohmmmm, thanks! Will need to find the NZ/Aus version. And yes, I already use Amazon Smile on the US version, great idea.
- capkutay 7y agoSlightly unrelated but there is something weirdly consistent about how Amazon treats their workers and people who have to work with them. I remember just exhibiting an AWS conference was the most time-intensive grueling event I've ever worked in the tech industry. Obviously not as hard as a factory-working job, but they hold the only event in the industry that has you working from 7 am to 7 pm w/ no break if you want to exhibit.
- icelancer 7y ago...aren't most exhibits/conferences like this? All my trade shows events are at least this grueling, and I no longer work in major IT.
- capkutay 7y agoI mean they practically can become that if you include the networking events and dinners but the listed hours in the exhibition hall usually are closer to 8 hours.
- misterprime 7y agoEw, no. That's horrible. The company I work for does a lot of shows. I generally do about 22/year. A common range is 9am to 5pm, but 10am to 4pm is not unheard of. 8am to 6pm happens from time to time and feels really bad. I think out of 60ish shows that I've done only one was 7am to 7pm.
- capkutay 7y agoYeah the best ones are 11 to 7. No one wants to network at 8 am before a bunch of keynotes and presentations. Lunch and after event mixers are the best. 7 am to 7 pm was terrible. everyone was sleepy in the morning (pre caffeine) and completely worn out by the happy hour/closing time.
- 40acres 7y agoMarx predicted this with his theory on Entfremdung (alienation), in a system of highly optimized division of labor those laborers are going to be for a lack of a better word: bored.
- thundergolfer 7y agoAlso knew that capital is indifferent to the lived experience of labourers.
- f00zz 7y agoI'll get downvoted to hell for saying this, but $15/hr is upper middle class pay here. I made less than that for much of my software development career...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- orhmeh09 7y agoYour post would be considerably more useful with date and location information.
- Tade0 7y agoSo did I, but where I come from $1k/month of take-home-pay is enough to rent a two bedroom apartment and live comfortably. The US is, all things considered, expensive.
- thundergolfer 7y agoYou’ll be getting downvoted because what you make “here” and it being upper-middle class pay is not relevant at all to these workers, unless you want to make a disingenuous suggestion that they move countries to “here”.
- f00zz 7y agoOf course I understand that. I just find it very hard to sympathize with the plight of someone making $15/hour. It seems high, even taking differences in cost of living into account.
- thundergolfer 7y ago> It seems high Senior FAANG engineers make ~$200/hr. How does $15 seem at all high?
- beecat 7y agoIf I think about it, I feel pretty dehumanized myself each time I click through a clumsy AWS GUI for a set of shoddy services that my company pays 60k a month for the privilege of running our operations and storing our business intelligence on the computers of the one entity that has not only the financial muscle but also the lack of moral scrupples to use that intelligence to enter our market and outcompete us. Jussayin'
- friendlybus 7y agoGlad someone finally said it. What's stopping these data collecting companies from cornering a huge amount of markets?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- WengerPen 7y agoWhen you reach that size, you are not looking for investments in the millions, you are looking for the billions.
- BurningFrog 7y agoSince Amazon easily hires and retains people at these wages, there very likely isn't anything wrong with these jobs. At least not compared to similar jobs for the same segment of the work force. What I think is really going on here is that Amazon has a PR vulnerability that can be exploited. With enough videos and testimony produced contrasting the plight of the poor oppressed workers with their boss, The World's Richest Man, Amazon will need to do something to make this go away. Or at least that's what this campaign hopes.
- cyphar 7y ago> Since Amazon easily hires and retains people at these wages, there very likely isn't anything wrong with these jobs. At least not compared to similar jobs for the same segment of the work force. I agree that there are almost certainly many other examples of inhumane treatment of low-wage workers. We should fix those too. If low-wage workers had unions then you would be able to have those kinds of cross-industry group actions. But no, the work conditions at Amazon are not acceptable. And to pretend that this a free market transaction -- and not a case of people who are desperate (and probably being forced to work several jobs and depend on government programs due to inhumanely low wages) being exploited.
- dymk 7y ago$15/hour is “inhumanly low”? Since when? Amazon has been a leader in paying unskilled workers a good salary at huge scale.
- andrepd 7y agoIt's not just the salary, it's the working conditions.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cyphar 7y agoThey only just started paying $15/hour recently, after the whole STOP-BEZOS Act back-and-forth with Bernie Sanders[1]. You appear to be implying they paid a $15/hour minimum wage before October of last year (you can't be a leader in something if you only started doing it 9 months ago because of overwhelming public pressure by politicians) -- they didn't. My point is that low-wage workers are usually not in a position to quit one of their multiple jobs because they might become homeless or lose their health insurance. In fact, Amazon having higher wages means that low-wage workers are more likely to continue working there despite the conditions, because they have nowhere else they could go. But instead of discussing the point I was making, you are cherry-picking one particular phrase I used -- which applies to almost all other low-wage jobs but no longer (as of Oct 2018) applies to Amazon. But also, the working conditions are the thing that most people have issue with (now that Amazon finally pays its workers a minimum wage that is reasonable). Not being able to take bathroom breaks without risking the loss of your job is not a humane way to treat people, even if you're paid $15/hour. [1]: https://www.businessinsider.nl/bernie-sanders-amazon-fight-minimum-wage-raise-stop-bezos-act-win-2018-10/?international=true&r=US https://www.businessinsider.nl/bernie-sanders-amazon-fight-m...
- 15engineer 7y agoReading through these comments I find myself rather dazed at all of the complaints regarding $15 an hour salaries, I'm a software engineer with 6 years of experience in a first world country and I make less than that before taxes.
- thundergolfer 7y agoWhich first world country is this? I made $30AUD as a waiter in 2015. An Australian software engineer with that much experience getting paid almost half that ($15 is USD yeah?) in 2019 would be absurd.
- 15engineer 7y agoHong Kong and yes USD.
- alexgmcm 7y agoIt depends on the cost of living though. I earn around that in Western Europe but it's still a pretty good job for Spain and I have no doubt I live in better conditions than the Americans working for $15 an hour, which is really what matters.
- 15engineer 7y agoYou're right it does depend on cost of living, but I live in a city/country (Hong Kong) with one of the highest costs of living in the world[1]. [1] https://www.expatistan.com/cost-of-living/country/ranking https://www.expatistan.com/cost-of-living/country/ranking
- povertyworld 7y agoOh, it's so nice to see all these rich tech guys are concerned about the plight of Amazon workers. Suppose if one of these Amazon workers applied to be a programmer at your company even though they didn't go to a top twenty school or have 5-7 years experience with the trendiest stack, but merely did a bootcamp, and published some apps on their own, would you hire them and spend your money (as opposed to Jeff Bezo's money) to better their lot in life? Or would you hit delete the second their pathetic resume touched your inbox? At least Jeff Bezos is making it possible for people to pay their rent and not end up yet another homeless guy on the San Francisco sidewalk.
- noicebrewery 7y ago"At least" is right; he is doing the very least he can. If they are working for the wealthiest man on the planet he could afford to pay them a decent wage.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoI haven't seen any one in this debate saying anything like that.
- dingo_bat 7y agoITT: everyone decides how Amazon should spend their rightfully earned money. Makes me kind of sick.
- codeforces 7y ago996.icu did not only happen in China, it is happening everywhere on this planet.
- eatonphil 7y agoD and
- eatonphil 7y agoThaneks
- eatonphil 7y agos