7 ms·
I think it's possible that the Max will never fly again. Its entire design was based on the assumption that it is possible to "undo" the effects of moving the
by lisper 7y ago
I think it's possible that the Max will never fly again. Its entire design was based on the assumption that it is possible to "undo" the effects of moving the engines with a "minor" software tweak and end up with an airframe that flies the same as a regular 737. That may not actually be possible. Boeing may have been aiming for a point in the design space that does not actually exist. But the business model for the 737 depends on its existence. So when the new software comes out, there will be two possibilities:
1. They got it right this time
2. They didn't get it right (because it's not possible to get it right), but they are going to insist that they did because admitting that they were chasing a chimera all along would be the end of the company
The problem is that it will be very hard for anyone without very deep knowledge to determine which of these is the case. I don't see any way to tell a convincing story [1] about how the Max can be flown safely that does not involve re-training pilots to fly the plane "raw", i.e. where a human pilot is capable of flying the plane when the automation has failed, without any software covering up its native handling characteristics. That will require a new type certificate and re-training. That can make the plane safe to fly, but it will utterly destroy its economic model, so that is an unacceptable solution.
Boeing has already destroyed all of the credibility it once had. It insisted that the Max was safe to fly when it manifestly wasn't. They will again insist that the Max is safe to fly whether or not it actually is because their survival as a company depends on it. The problem is not that the plane may be unsafe. The problem is that, under the circumstances, there will be no way to know whether or not it is until the next one crashes.
- wolf550e 7y agoThe US government can save it, if it's possible to save it. The government hires an independent contractor organization (I guess The Aerospace Corporation and NASA people and former-FAA people from the time the FAA had technical people, etc.) to do a blue ribbon commission style full analysis of the plane, at a huge cost in time and budget, and publishes the whole thing, scathing as it is to Boeing. Some people might get fired, in both Boeing and the FAA, but that doesn't matter. The independent contractor organization gets carte blanche to declare any issues as "preventing certification", and to suggest any fixes, and oversee Boeing implement the fixes and the tests (what the FAA should have done). When they sign off that the plane is safe, the FAA signs off (as a formality, because we don't trust the FAA) and airlines based in the US start using the plane where jurisdiction allows (maybe only in US, maybe in friendly countries). After a while of no crashes, other jurisdictions will allow it and other airlines will buy/unground it. Boeing pays the government for the work of the independent contractor organization, in equity I guess. The government holds the stock until the stock price rises after the fixed plane succeeds in the market, and then sells. Note I know nothing about anything, so the above is fan fiction.
- PaulHoule 7y agoI think they can save it, but they are not going to be able to keep the common type rating with the old 737 and Boeing should quit trying to do so. They need to put pilots through simulator training of both kinds of MCAS failure: (1) MCAS goes nuts and needs to be turned off, and (2) MCAS is not there to save you when you need it. So long as Boeing refuses to capitulate, the grounding is going to go on, and the longer the grounding goes on, the more problems are going to be discovered, the more orders get canceled, etc.
- a3n 7y ago> The government hires an independent contractor organization (I guess The Aerospace Corporation and NASA people and former-FAA people from the time the FAA had technical people, etc.) to do a blue ribbon commission style full analysis of the plane, Great idea, but I think Feynman died awhile back.
- ulfw 7y agoIt's not that simple. The 737max is the way it is because a ton of stuff is not certifiable today anymore but is grandfathered in since the 60s.
- mantap 7y agoForces are forces and any upwards force from the engines can be counteracted by the control surfaces as long as they have enough authority. Boeing's entire problem is trying to do all this with only two flimsy sensors, and compounded by them inexplicably ignoring one of the sensors. The original design was stupid as hell but there's nothing wrong with the general idea of what they are trying to achieve as long as it is implemented competently.
- PaulHoule 7y agoThe A320 has "flight envelope protection" which does something much like MCAS except it is much more comprehensive because it is integrated with the fly-by-wire system and can use all control surfaces. FBW on the A320 has many benefits such as better passenger comfort because it can use the control surfaces to take the edge off turbulence. You can get away with smaller control surfaces which then lowers weight, improves range, etc. Airbus went through a lot of work to validate the safety of the FBW/Flight Envelope Protection -- if sensors fail, it goes into one of several degraded modes. Pilots are trained to recognize these modes and fly them. Boeing has applied this technology to their large jets, but it's just sad that the most common Boeing jet by far, the 737, is a technological backwater. Boeing is talking about making a "New Midsize Aircraft" which has a questionable market, but so far as I can tell, their business plan is to be building a starship for NASA in 2070 but still be selling 737s.
- dehrmann 7y agoIs it fair to say Airbus is better at FBW because they have more experience with it?
- orwin 7y agoAnd they have an history with FBW-caused accidents. Especially AF296 killed 3 people when they try to demonstrate the anti-stall capacity of the FBW during an airshow. Airbus modified the way the fbw control reclamation worked after this. After the Rio-Paris accident (forgot the flight name, it was AF too), they changed the way the degradation worked wehn sensor fails (i think now 3 different mode exists, and information is more visible). Those incident killed people, and there is a chance that the first one was actually caused only by the manufacturer (the second one was 99% the pilot though, the remaining 1% was: better information, better sims and better gradation so that even new, tired pilot can't make this kind of mistake).
- nolok 7y ago> I think it's possible that the Max will never fly again. Call me cynical, but I believe this is not possible. It may be upgraded, rebranded, recertified, and they may retrain everyone who may come anywhere near its cockpit, but they can't just drop the plane for three reasons: 1. They already sold too many. Those customers will want a refund, and will have a major loss of faith into Boeing. Unless there is a replacement plane to give but ... 2. They don't have any replacement. They don't have anything to put in that slot. And it's already a plane they had to rush because a) it's the main seller, and b) the competition (A320 Neo) is a very good plane in that slot. 3. Like said above, it's the major seller. It has how many thousands of orders and how many years of wait to get your planes already ? And nobody cancelled to move to airbus because they're just as backlogged. So neither Boeing, nor the airlines, nor the US government want it / can afford for it to disappear, they want it fixed, anyway possible. Don't get me wrong, I believe in a perfect world it should be grouded forever and be remembered as a huge warning lesson, but this will never happen. The real question is, why aren't Airbus and Boeing massively increasing their production capacity for those lines ? Feels like they've been been backlogged since forever, and it's only getting worse. I get that you can't create a new set of factory and their trained workers overnight, but we're talking decade here.
- raverbashing 7y agoOh they can make it so they can sell the existing ones, the big question is if they'll be certified as a 737 or something else.
- yummypaint 7y agoAlot of these problems seem to ultimately trace back to overconsolidation of these manufacturers. The possibility that passengers will be subjected to unsafe aircraft because Boeing is too big to fail is unacceptable. If they are unable to move fast enough to cope with the changing market, pethaps they should be split up. Ultimately we may be moving toward a taxpayer bailout of Boeing. Instead of doing that why not take that money any fund grants to help rediversify the market?
- mrep 7y ago
- bronco21016 7y agoI’m not sure where the idea comes from that a new type certificate or even simulator training would destroy the program. If the MAX is found to be too different from the current 737 type rating and requires a trip to the sim for pilots then airlines are going to do it. Boeing will likely end up footing a good chunk of the bill but there is no way the 350+ airframes that are already built are simply going to be scrapped. To put it in perspective, in North America, American Airlines and United Airlines have each ordered at least 100 of the airframes. These airlines each operate several different fleet types of similar sizes that each require putting pilots through extensive training to move them back and forth. The economics of operating the MAX would be changed but I would imagine it’s still going to come out as cost effective when considering how much more efficient the aircraft is vs the older aircraft they’ll be replacing. I certainly appreciate the skepticism of getting the product back out there without extensive training. I think even after its all said and done the pilots and pilots’ unions will heavily advocate for additional training to ensure these things are being operated safely.
- LeifCarrotson 7y agoRequiring simulator training and a new type cert may have meant that the 373 Max was less financially competitive with the Airbus A320. But if Boeing can get out of this disaster with a few more AoA sensors on each airframe, some safety-critical software, some simulators, and some free training for the airlines to send their pilots to...they'd be fools not to do that. A fleet sitting on the ground for months is worth a lot more than some simulator time.
- msbarnett 7y ago> Requiring simulator training and a new type cert may have meant that the 373 Max was less financially competitive with the Airbus A320. Yeah, but at this point that’s just going to mean Boeing ends up selling these things for less of a profit. There’s years of backlog of 737 MAX orders, and years of backlog of A320 Neo orders. Airlines with orders in for dozens of MAXes in 2021 aren’t going to be able to switch those orders to Neos without incurring years and years of delays on delivery.
- deleted 7y ago
- rossdavidh 7y ago1) I mostly agree with your analysis 2) I don't think that admitting they were "chasing a chimera" would mean the end of the company, but... 3) I do think it would be the end of the current management's tenure, and that functionally means they will behave as if it would be the end of the company
- WalterBright 7y ago> because it's not possible to get it right Of course it is. All jet airliners already have active augmentation to make them fly as if they do not have stability problems that can lead to crashes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yaw_damper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yaw_damper
- salawat 7y agoDutch roll isn't a stability problem in the same way the problem that MCAS corrects for is a problem. All aircraft experience Dutch roll. It's an inevitability. Control stick force inversion on approach to stall is absolutely not an inevitable consequence of large aircraft design. Yaw dampers are specifically required as a labor saving device on civil transport aircraft with swept wings; but all pilot's are aware of Dutch Roll. None were made aware of the failing behavior that MCAS corrects.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Dutch roll isn't a stability problem in the same way the problem that MCAS corrects for is a problem. It's still a stability issue that has led to fatal crashes because some pilots were unable to correct for dutch roll. Successfully countering dutch roll is an ongoing process, and a pilot may know all about it in his head and still be unable to correctly counter it with properly coordinated stick & rudder movements. Dutch roll is no joke and the yaw damper is required and is critical equipment. On the other hand, dealing with runaway MCAS is literally just turning a switch off on the console.
- salawat 7y agoAgain, every pilot knows about Dutch Roll; it may have caused problems before, but everyone knows about it, and as far as I'm aware, no one ever hid it's existence from pilot's for the sake of certification and sales. No one was told about MCAS or the force inversions it was meant to correct ahead of time, or shared enough technical detail to ensure pilots know what to be prepared for. Major difference there. >On the other hand, dealing with runaway MCAS is literally just turning a switch off on the console. Which instantly decertifies your aircraft to be carrying passengers. Look, I get it. That's paperwork talk! The thing still flies! But we have to hold ourselves accountable to the silly whims of paperwork talk, lest we fall victim to Normalization of Deviance, who is a cold-hearted, stone-faced bitch.
- ulfw 7y agoIf the 737 were properly certified (without all it's grandfathered stuff from the 60s which wouldn't be certifiable today anymore) then I'd agree - the max would never fly again. But at the end of the day, the FAA will let it fly again because it not flying might break Boeing's back and Boeing is essential as a defense company.
- droithomme 7y ago> I think it's possible that the Max will never fly again. I maintain that it will fly again, there will be a third high fatality crash related to MCAS, and then it will never fly as a passenger plane again. The existing planes will be repurposed as cargo planes. You heard it here first. And a massive federal bailout of Boeing because it is critical to national security is well beyond inevitable at this point.
- lysp 7y agoI don't think it'll never fly again. At worse, they'll have to have a separate type-rating and require pilots to go through further training to fly it. The whole idea behind the plane was to skip full training and be qualified with a short hour long tablet training session. That cost saving measure has now passed, so rather than scrapping the Max all together, pilots will just need the further training.
- NikkiA 7y agoBoeing are already getting ready to rebrand it the 737-8200, so no, it'll fly again, there's too much money at stake.