5 ms·
Indeed, I think the support for insects feeling pain probably extends to saying cars with accident avoidance feel pain. That is to say, I'm not convinced: pain
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
Indeed, I think the support for insects feeling pain probably extends to saying cars with accident avoidance feel pain.
That is to say, I'm not convinced: pain is a perceptual result.
- Retric 7y agoCars with accident avoidance don’t learn to avoid things after experiencing them. For entities that do, pain seems like an obvious term.
- derangedHorse 7y agoWhat people on this thread are trying to say is that things like cars and robots are created and seemingly understood by us humans. We took inanimate objects and pieced them together using principals we've learned from observation of these inanimate objects. Insects on the other hand are what we've scientifically classified as biological things. Creatures that share some of the same biological qualities we have. Unfortunately, humans don't understand all parts of their own biology to even recognize how similar another living thing is. What I'm saying is that if pain is a perceptual result, we have no way of saying insects cannot perceive it the same way we do. All we know is that they have brains, like most other biological creatures, and that the base assumption should be that they do have pain. Take any other creature like a dog. Why would a dog feel pain? Their brain's may be more complex than something like an ant, but who's to say the rise in brain complexity has brought about the emergence of pain? Humans know too little about the world but a lot of people insist on taking the opinion most convenient to them. If they don't have to think about the fact that they inflict pain on insects, they can keep killing them in a variety of ways without any moral apprehension in the slightest.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoI don't understand what you mean by "perceptual result". Animals avoid dangerous behaviours because they cause them pain. Robots, including self-driving cars avoid dangerous behaviours, because they are programmed to do so. Why is the existence of robots programmed to avoid dangerous behaviour indicative of whether animals feel pain?
- hackinthebochs 7y ago>Animals avoid dangerous behaviours because they cause them pain. Robots, including self-driving cars avoid dangerous behaviours, because they are programmed to do so. We don't know a priori whether these are in fact two distinct sets or just two descriptions of the same set. That is, nature may have "programmed" the insect to avoid dangerous stimuli without any conscious awareness of it, similar to how my hand starts to move from a hot stove before I consciously feel the pain. Or, our programming of accident avoidance might in fact endow a conscious experience of pain for all we know.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoIf I understand correctly, you're suggesting that animals could react to stimuli that we would consider painful by following the same behaviours that they would if they felt pain, not because they feel pain but because they have been programmed to follow those behaviours in response to those stimuli? I find this unlikely. The set of stimulus-response behaviours necessary to avoid every possible danger that might arise in an animal's environment would be immense. It seems much more economical to "program" behavious that avoid any painful stimulus (e.g. by setting some "pain threshold" and programming the animal to avoid anything that causes a sensation of pain above that threshold). This is particularly so for insects that have a limited number of neurons in which to store their stimulus-specific programs.
- hackinthebochs 7y ago>by following the same behaviours that they would if they felt pain This is taking the claim I made too far. My point was that reacting to noxious stimuli does not a priori require the conscious experience of pain (which includes a suffering component). When it comes to analyzing sets of possible behaviors, that provides more evidence with which to decide between nociception and pain. I do think that most "animals" (excluding insects) probably experience pain due to, as you said, the varieties of possible behaviors being too large to be merely reflex based. But it's not obvious to me that this holds for insects.
- pessimizer 7y agoI think it extends to saying that people who aren't me feel pain. another thing I have no evidence of. Being a black American, at points there has actually been a scientific consensus that I myself don't feel pain. Just because I react similarly to you when you feel pain doesn't mean that you're not anthropomorphizing.