8 ms·
The duality of modern Microsoft is absolutely astounding. How they can simultaneously do incredible things for Github, and open source Windows components, while
by jchw 7y ago
The duality of modern Microsoft is absolutely astounding. How they can simultaneously do incredible things for Github, and open source Windows components, while continuing to not fix the most user hostile Windows ever produced, is completely bonkers.
My litmus test for whether Windows is finally fixed is whether of not it’s possible to install it without Candy Crush, but unfortunately without killing the network and applying a registry patch as far as I know it can’t be done.
- jimbob45 7y agoSeems to me that DirectX is the last remaining barrier to finally getting the majority of the Windows user base to migrate to Linux. That and driver support.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoYou are ludicrously incorrect, just as everyone for the past 2 decades has been when they have predicted the year of the Linux Desktop. This trend will continue until Linux Desktop people stop underestimating what users actually do with computers.
- jenscow 7y agoNothing. They moved to mobile instead
- freehunter 7y agoThis is the correct answer. Even Ubuntu's famous bug #1 (Microsoft has a majority marketshare) was closed many years ago [1] as PC operating systems have declined in importance. Steve Jobs's comment about PCs being "trucks" has also come true. Almost all leisure computing has moved either to mobile devices (phones and tablets) and/or to the web (which overlaps mobile devices), making the OS less and less important. Gaming is about the only leisure activity left where desktop OS matters, but that's a relatively small marketshare comparatively. [1] https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/1/comments/1834 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+bug/1/comments/1834
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoAnd yet, Linux Desktop still is not dominant, even only counting desktop computers. Hmm...
- snazz 7y agoAs people use desktops less and less, they care less and less about what runs on them.
- belltaco 7y agoThat narrative of the post-PC world collapsed when the sales of tablets like iPads collapsed.
- freehunter 7y agoCouple of things: 1) Tablets aren't the only "post-PC" platform. Most of the leisure computing is done on smartphones when it would have been done on a laptop or desktop 5-10 years ago. 2) If we're considering tablets to be PC replacements, we should expect their sales trends to be along the lines of PC sales. People keep PCs a lot longer than smartphones, so we should expect people to keep their iPads a lot longer than their phones too. 3) Tablet sales have absolutely not collapsed [1] [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/272595/global-shipments-forecast-for-tablets-laptops-and-desktop-pcs/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/272595/global-shipments-...
- Razengan 7y agoFrom what I could tell, iPads are the only tablets still going strong and getting even better. It’s Google who threw in the towel on tablets. See the recently revealed iPadOS: https://www.apple.com/ipados/ipados-preview/ https://www.apple.com/ipados/ipados-preview/
- LarryDarrell 7y agoPlay XBill and write manifestos with LaTeX?
- iforgotpassword 7y ago> This trend will continue until Linux Desktop people stop underestimating what users actually do with computers. Nothing. They use apps on their Linux phones, or happily use any OS that runs a browser since everything is web based today. Oh and for gaming there is consoles of course, which crushes the PC gaming market in pretty much any discipline. The only people remaining dependent on desktops (or laptops) will be office workers, and I'm pretty sure they don't care about DirectX so much, so replacing those with Linux seems very doable, it's just the question if companies care enough. Last I checked, even office 365 worked on Linux.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> They use apps on their Linux phones Somehow I doubt Android is what Linux Desktop evangelists imagined. At best this is moving the goal posts significantly. > or happily use any OS that runs a browser since everything is web based today. Apparently that doesn't include Linux, despite it being free, not having invasive telemetry, and not having ads in the application launcher. > Oh and for gaming there is consoles of course, which crushes the PC gaming market in pretty much any discipline. And yet Steam is a ridiculously huge money maker and people are buying more PC games than ever. > The only people remaining dependent on desktops (or laptops) will be office workers Incorrect, but let's entertain your fantasies anyway. > I'm pretty sure they don't care about DirectX so much, so replacing those with Linux seems very doable Then why hasn't it happened? You think companies like paying licensing fees to Microsoft? Consider that there are good reasons people do not use Linux Desktop instead of just assuming they're all idiots.
- iforgotpassword 7y ago> Somehow I doubt Android is what Linux Desktop evangelists imagined. You must be confusing Android with a desktop OS. It's mobile so they don't fall into the desktop category at all. Which was exactly my point: they simply don't need a desktop OS anymore. > Apparently that doesn't include Linux That reads like you're looking at some statistics that show that 0% of desktop users run Linux. Care pointing to it? > And yet Steam is a ridiculously huge money maker and people are buying more PC games than ever. So? It's completely overshadowed by the console market, not even including mobile games here. > Then why hasn't it happened? You think companies like paying licensing fees to Microsoft? You're asking why it hasn't happened yet in reply to me using future tense. But let's put aside that pretty much everything you said was deliberately besides the point. Why it hasn't happened yet is pretty simple. Companies weigh the cost of switching vs. The cost of just keep paying for Windows (so no changes, no initial setup cost, no training, ...). That's gonna be cheaper for quite some time but eventually everything will be in the cloud so there is less and less reason to keep up a huge and complicated windows domain network with software rollout and other brain damage. You might keep a basic AD in place for user management that the web services talk to but that's it. Funnily enough my current and previous employer is still on win 7 because of the frequent messups you read about regarding 10, and how even in a corporate environment it's near impossible to disable all telemetry. I'm curious what they'll do at 7's EOL. As for the average home desktop user, you're not seriously expecting your mom to go ahead and download and install Ubuntu are you? As long as most OEMs still exclusively sell machines with Windows preinstalled, there really shouldn't be anything surprising about the fact that most people use Windows. We already see some of the larger ones offering machines with Linux though, and with the desktop keeping to lose relevance and everything moving to the web I wouldn't be surprised to see this getting more prevalent over the next decade if Microsoft doesn't get their act together regarding Windows. It currently looks like they're cutting costs in that department, normal users seem to get the beta versions now so they could cut down their QA.
- bediger4000 7y ago> people stop underestimating what users actually do with computers Oddly, this is the factor that underlies most of my personal beefs with both Microsoft and Apple. What's wrong with my wifi? At least I can look in journalctl on linux. My laptop doesn't have enough screenspace - I can use i3wm on linux. I want double-click to include '*' and '/' and ':' in a "word", hey I can change xterm config. I want left-mouse-button to start a selection, and right to continue it, and middle-mouse-button to paste, and I want F2 to paste, X11 can do that. I don't want the focused window to pop to the top? Can do on Linux. There's so many things that Windows and MacOS make the decisions for you and make it very, very hard to do otherwise that really cramp your style on a basic level.
- zamalek 7y agoMost people don't do these things on their computers: > journalctl, i3wm, xterm config, non-standard mouse configurations The versatility of Linux is frequently touted as its best feature, a feature that 99% of humans don't care about, and would confuse that same 99% of people. People are used to what Microsoft and Apple imposed on them. For better, or for worse, they honestly couldn't give a damn about being able to do stuff like that. Their style is the Apple style, or the Microsoft style and, most importantly, the no-terminal style. Linux is the perfect desktop for developers. It hits all the wrong checkboxes for end-users.
- bediger4000 7y agoAgreed, most people don't do much more than open "Edge" and "Outlook", some people Use "Word", a few people use "Excel" because "Word" doesn't do tables very well. The point being two-fold: 1. The argument that a Linux desktop won't fly because people do so damn many things that a Linux desktop just can't do is false. 2. Windows and Mac really push you hard into a single style of interacting with your computer.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> a feature that 99% of humans don't care about, and would confuse that same 99% of people. This is precisely the kind of condescending bullshit I'm talking about. > People are used to what Microsoft and Apple imposed on them. A convenient fantasy for Linux Desktop evangelists to soothe their egos.
- jchw 7y agoAlong with everything else that could be said about this, I don’t think that is even a major problem. Everything I’ve tried to run on Steam Proton runs at 60 FPS with highest settings. My guess is that Vulkan has enabled much better Direct3D emulation. (Of course, I don’t play much and I didn’t bother to benchmark. It probably is still worse than native in many cases. But hey, glitch free and fast enough for me. Was very surprised to see games with Denuvo running great.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- api 7y agoIt mirrors the new structure of the industry: developers are a totally separate market from users and generally get paid to work on software whose purpose is to exploit and "farm" users through surveillance capitalism and AI/ML powered soft mind control. In other words developers (and their employers) are customers while users are a product or resource to be exploited.
- umvi 7y ago> The duality of modern Microsoft is absolutely astounding. See: http://bonkersworld.net/organizational-charts http://bonkersworld.net/organizational-charts I don't work there, but I've heard Microsoft is more like a federation of organizations than one giant consistent, cohesive team.
- agumonkey 7y agoSo are most big corps methinks. Here about Nokia death caused by internal tension between depts ? Sony sub-units more or less completely independent (selling cd and cd-burners).
- panpanna 7y agoSony is NOT like that. For example their phones have extremely complicated DRM that makes everything slower (and reserves tons of memory and even affects things like camera) because of their movie and music business.
- aNoob7000 7y agoOh man, I couldn't stop giggling looking at the Microsoft and Oracle org charts. Those two pictures capture those two organizations completely.
- jchw 7y agoBecause its buried far down and I can’t edit my post, I want to hijack this post to point out that it turns out in newer builds MS has actually removed the Candy Crush auto installation. https://mspoweruser.com/rejoice-windows-users-candy-crush-is-finally-gone/ https://mspoweruser.com/rejoice-windows-users-candy-crush-is... I didn’t notice because my Windows 10 image is out of date, presumably getting the latest ISO would fix the problem.
- withinrafael 7y agoNope. This feature bootstraps from the web and it's still in the latest update post-fresh install. This article is incorrect.
- zarathustraa 7y ago> My litmus test for whether Windows is finally fixed is whether of not it’s possible to install it without Candy Crush https://mspoweruser.com/rejoice-windows-users-candy-crush-is-finally-gone/ https://mspoweruser.com/rejoice-windows-users-candy-crush-is... What's you new litmus test?
- criley2 7y agoFunny that you're being downvoted for presenting evidence contradicting the OP. The groupthink in this thread is overwhelming.
- Apaec 7y agoIt's still an stupid mistake MS made that could be once back. That's enough for me for staying away from the MS tax for life.
- jchw 7y agoThank you. I installed Windows as early as last month (in a VM) and still got Candy Crush. This is probably because my ISO image was not fully up to date. I was not aware of this change but it is greatly appreciated. I can no longer modify the parent comment but if dang or anyone else with permission wants to please feel free. No need for a new litmus test, though solving the problem of Edge opening MSN ads after updating would probably buy some goodwill.
- jchw 7y agoCorrection: It still happens with a completely fresh install, just like withinrafael claims. https://i.imgur.com/zDWo4Hb.png https://i.imgur.com/zDWo4Hb.png Very sad.
- fortran77 7y agoI just checked my Windows 10 machine that I use every day for 8 hours to get real work done. There's no "Candy Crush" on it.
- fortran77 7y agoMac OSX comes with chess. What's the difference?
- freehunter 7y agoHonest question and I am absolutely not starting an argument, but what have they done for Github? All I'm aware of is making private repos free, but I haven't seen anything beyond that. I must be out of the loop.
- cjaybo 7y agoThe latest development that I'm aware of is the package registry they are launching: https://github.com/features/package-registry https://github.com/features/package-registry
- jchw 7y agoI have no idea how much they had to do with Github’s recent developments, but: - Github Sponsors with donation matching for some limited time period - Github Pro which based on browsing user profiles a surprising amount of folks have bought into - Github Package Repositories. - Github Pipelines. Generally I have been waiting for Github to start sucking but it has only gotten better imo. I have been a pretty big Gitlab fanboy for a while so it’s weird to harp on Github’s progress but they’ve done a good job flipping the script.
- joeblubaugh 7y agoTheir PR UIs have recently gotten some much-needed improvements too.
- kzrdude 7y agoWe finally got a dual sided "more context" button for diffs, that was so annoying when that was missing (and a declined feature request when I asked).
- paavohtl 7y ago> - Github Pro which based on browsing user profiles a surprising amount of folks have bought into Not a statement either way, but AFAIK everyone who has the Student Pack[1] gets the PRO badge. I have it and I haven't spent a penny on GitHub (though my employer has). [1] https://education.github.com/pack https://education.github.com/pack
- marcosdumay 7y ago> How they can simultaneously do incredible things for Github, and open source Windows components, while continuing to not fix the most user hostile Windows ever produced, is completely bonkers. Developers, developers, developers. When they stopped singing that, they nearly failed. Now they are back. It doesn't include being nice to end-users.
- kitchenkarma 7y agoI don't think Microsoft is doing incredible things. They are baiting the developers and just use the strategy of locking people into their constellation of spying services. Acquiring GitHub they got access to all private repositiories and insight to what other companies are doing. This is despicable.
- urda 7y ago> Acquiring GitHub they got access to all private repositiories and insight to what other companies are doing. This is despicable. Spreading disinformation in 2019 is despicable itself. - Microsoft already handles data from competitors in other portions of their corporation. If it was discovered that Microsoft and / or GitHub actors were acting in bad faith with private repositories, that would immediately erode the trust of their Azure platform. - Most projects are more than just the code. It's often build toolchains, pipelines, and other specific knowledge around said code.
- oblio 7y agoYou're not looking at the big picture. Microsoft already has - and has had for 30 years! - the most valuable data in the world flowing through Excel and Word. Code is cool, but they could already know everything every company in the world is doing. I don't think they're abusing the trust put into them, we'd know by now. They'd also probably be blown to smithereens by governments and other corporations, through lawsuits.
- duhballs 7y agothis past weekend my windows 10 host installed candy crush (and other stuff) without asking me. I honestly thought I had been hacked. My other favorite thing is bing in the start menu. They changed the gpo/registry setting to disable it like twice, and didn't even have safe search enabled on it!