11 ms·
Bankrupt Maker Faire revives, reduced to Make Community
- brianpgordon 7y agoIt seems kind of strange to me that he's running it as a for-profit private company but is asking for the support of the community to fund it. There's got to be a better structure for this kind of enterprise, right? And the explanation for why nonprofit doesn't work (“The one thing i don’t like about non-profit is that you end up working for the source you got the money from. You dance to their tune to get their funding”) doesn't really make sense. If he's taking someone else's money then yeah there's going to be some amount of dancing, but that applies to funding for-profits as well. Unless, I guess, you can convince a community to give your for-profit company funding in exchange for nothing with no strings attached, which seems - again - strange...
- erikpukinskis 7y agoYeah. I don’t understand why they can’t just run as a conference company. That seems like the obvious business model. Send the magazine for free to last years attendees, which gives you free advertising for next years conference. If you have to “dance to the beat of someone’s drum” why not make it the people who are huge fans of the experience you produce?
- TylerE 7y agoBecause, if you read the article posted here a month ago, they were losing their arse doing exactly that.
- michaelt 7y agoThe impression I took away from that article was they had 22 full-time employees all year round, to produce one weekend in New York; one weekend in San Mateo; a print magazine; and licensing the brand to affiliated events. The two weekend events presumably only occupied a small fraction of them, except in the immediate ramp-up to the events.
- syshum 7y ago>>The two weekend events presumably only occupied a small fraction of them, Clearly you have never organized a large event before
- maccard 7y agoI'm part of a large scale events team (albeit as a programmer). 22 full time staff for two weekend events is pretty insane.
- glenneroo 7y agoThey also published a magazine 6 times a year, many tutorial books (I have acquired a few over the years) and publishing lots of DIY project guides online.
- hadlock 7y agoI worked briefly with a team that did 16 events a year nationwide + put out a (print edition) weekly periodical, the team was only about 14. Most of the staff worked on the periodical. 22 seems really high.
- CPLX 7y agoI'm the founder and CEO of a national conference/events business, producing a dozen events a year and significant editorial content. What's being described is way too many people, unless they're all heavily ROI-positive sales people, in which case this problem doesn't exist.
- gamblor956 7y agoThis sort of dismissiveness is the same sort of cluelessness that leads most people to think software should only take a week to code. Complex things take skill, time, and effort. If it's not your domain it's very likely you are severely underestimating the work involved.
- jshaqaw 7y agoI am the co-founder of an annual weekend even infinitesimally smaller than the NY Maker Faire. It takes our staff a huge amount of work just to pull it off every year. You can’t wing an event - all the parts need to come together like clockwork or you Fyre Festival. You are coordinating all of these vendors, third party participants, venues, etc... which is like herding cats. 22 sounds like a really lean staff to pull off such vast events.
- Zenst 7y agoCarboot sales model would be the closest one that would work out well for all.
- wpietri 7y ago> dance to their tune to get their funding”) doesn't really make sense It makes perfect sense to me, having worked for a couple of non-profits. A regular business gets money by selling products to people. A nonprofit gets money by selling good feelings to rich people. Often, one of those good feelings a rich person buys is a sense of control. They don't just give you money and say go; they give you money for a very specific purpose. Often, to get that money you have to apply for grants, meaning that you must conform to their desires up front, write a big project plan, and the follow that plan closely to receive the money. It's very much a waterfall approach to things, which can cause a lot of waste, and can be very distracting for people who want to focus on the non-profit mission. You also of course need a whole apparatus to find and flatter those rich people, which isn't free. Basically non-profits sound like a better vehicle in theory than they are in practice for many purposes. And they don't guarantee fiscal probity from the community's perspective. A non-profit exec can still pay themselves millions of dollars [1]. For what it's worth, I am happy to help out community-oriented for-profit businesses. E.g., San Francisco's Borderlands Books, which is community-sponsored [1]. I give them $100/year just because I want them to keep existing, and bookstores in SF aren't really viable businesses anymore. [1] https://www.erieri.com/blog/post/top-10-highest-paid-ceos-at-nonprofits https://www.erieri.com/blog/post/top-10-highest-paid-ceos-at... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/borderlands-books-san-francisco-sponsorships-crowdfunding https://www.theguardian.com/books/2015/feb/25/borderlands-bo...
- benj111 7y agoYou seem to be describing a (for profit) relationship between a small to medium size IT vendor and a large blue chip, and the internal decision making process of a blue chip as well.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoNo, it's more like the relationship between a small store that adds value to a community in ways that don't appear in GAAP calculations, and a corporation that extracts value from communities in ways that ditto. It's going to take a while for it to become clear if this new venture is the first or the second type. Obviously everyone is hoping for the former.
- syshum 7y agoThere is a middle ground between Non-Profit and Traditional For Profit... Public Benefit Corporations I do agree however is " You dance to their tune to get their funding" do not make alot of sense, you do that if you are non-profit or for-profit... You have to dance to the tune of customers if your for-profit, or donors if your non-profit... His lack of ability to under stand that is likely one reason the company when bankrupt.... If you do not deliver a product consumer what to buy you go out of business....
- crankylinuxuser 7y agoI'd be looking more at a Benefit Corp. It's a for-profit, with no monetary reasons for the corporate charter. https://benefitcorp.net/ https://benefitcorp.net/
- KirinDave 7y agoTheir CEO was the same guy who felt it was appropriate to get his company involved with a community dispute over if Naomi Wu was a "real" maker or secretly propped up by her boyfriend. I don't get the impression he is a very good steward of the brand. It's too bad, too. Maker Fair is one of the most important events in the penninusla. It's hugely important to educational efforts and a major focus for local makers who otherwise won't turn a profit outside of efforts like Bizarre Bazaar, which are quite expensive to attend.
- wrycoder 7y agoExcept many of the big sponsors weren't convinced this year.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- colechristensen 7y agoWhere did all the money go? It's a niche market but 80,000 subscribers and 100,000 attendees in San Mateo alone should be able to keep the lights on.
- mdorazio 7y agoIf I remember correctly, they had a stupidly large permanent staff for what they do, taking California-level salaries.
- dougmwne 7y agoI interviewed there. Very cool office near the SF waterfront. Lots of staff. Even 5 years ago, clearly unprofitable and relying on funding. I recall thinking at the time that their executives smelled the blood in the water. I sure did.
- tonystubblebine 7y agoPretty sure salaries for editors and writers are still pretty low, even in California.
- IshKebab 7y ago22 employees cost a lot of money!
- _hardwaregeek 7y agoWhy isn't Make attached to a store that actually sells DIY kits and parts? Seems like a clear business model to me. Or at the very least, better than print publishing. Now, they probably don't have the capital or wherewithal to start selling electronics now, but a company like Adafruit or Sparkfun should take over the Make mantle and just use it to put out good guides and drive kit sales.
- roberte3 7y agoThey have had a very solid store business at one point selling electronic kits. (Pi's, Arduino, etc). A few years ago the kits were even in every Barnes and Nobel ni the country at Christmas. (And sadly most of them were in the clearance bin in January...)
- bjt 7y agoYeah, the commitment to print publishing is the part I don't get. He's tying himself to the mast of a sinking ship.
- colechristensen 7y agoHackaday is doing this with Tindie, they seem to be doing pretty well.
- mr_crankypants 7y agoThere was https://www.makershed.com https://www.makershed.com, which is currently out of business. It mostly only sold kits, drones, 3D printers, stuff like that. Very little in the way of individual parts and tools. Which always struck me as a bit of a problem -- it more-or-less sold a strict subset of the actual DIY stuff that you could get at competing retailers. So maybe they'd sell someone their very first Arduino starter kit, but it must have been really hard to retain repeat customers. Having bought that Arudino kit and completed all the introductory projects, when the time comes to start getting more creative, you're going to have to go somewhere else to buy, say, an LCD display or a fistful of capacitors. And you'd presumably stay there, since there were so few things you could get at Makershed that you couldn't also get somewhere that sells the other stuff you need. In short, it was kind of a lot like what Radio Shack had become in the end, only even more so.
- deboflo 7y agoThe first time I saw the Tesla Model S was at Maker Faire in May 2009. It changed my life.
- mlurp 7y agoI went to the maker faire in NYC a few years ago. There was lots of cool stuff, but unfortunately about 60% of it were various slight mods/etc of 3d printers. Lots weren't even special, just a brand promoting itself.
- Killes 7y agoI think there is some definite educational and inspirational value to Maker Fair and magazine. I guess that's more domain of non profits, but maybe some philanthropic education funds could lend a hand for the more educational aspects. Of interest an exceptional example of educational community around "maker stuff" funded by a great shop is https://www.adafruit.com/about https://www.adafruit.com/about , a lot of excellent work there!
- Animats 7y agoThe maker movement appears to be dead. At least in the SF peninsula. TechShop went bankrupt. Its successor, "TheShop.build", closed their SF location, and briefly, the San Jose location had an eviction notice on the door. The noprofit, Maker Nexus, has pivoted to being mostly an educational operation for middle and high schoolers. HumanMade opens in SF Saturday, but that's more of a job training center. Nobody seems to be able to make the "gym model" maker space go here. Demand is down, too. Steampunk is dead. Etsy now allows outsourcing production. There's too much Burning Man stuff already built. Google, Facebook, and Stanford all have in-house maker spaces now.
- codesushi42 7y agoThe failure of IoT and consumer 3D printers also helped kill the Maker movement. Along with Pebble and countless other failed Kickstarter projects. Hardware is hard. Best to stick with software based businesses.
- mr_crankypants 7y agoY'know, it was the arrival of IoT and consumer 3D printers (and drones, etc.) that really killed the maker movement for me. After Make Magazine started devoting every other issue to consumer products that cost $500 and up, I finally conceded that the Maker movement had become a firmly upper middle class pastime, and canceled my subscription.
- Xunxi 7y agoI disagree with the "upper middle class” gripe. Instructables is still resourceful if you don't like consumer product reviews. There are also tons of hacks on YouTube and build logs on forums. I think a the maker inertia is killed by dwindling creativity, access to equipment and fear of losing out to Chinese competition if you intend on bringing your product to market. *I could be wrong
- mr_crankypants 7y ago
- deng 7y agoAt least in Germany, the Maker Faires still seem to be doing fine. They are done by Maker Media GmbH, which is part of Heise Publishing Group (they do the c't and iX magazines). They don't publish numbers on how specifically Maker Media is doing, but at least the Maker Faires seem to be doing OK since they pretty much have record visitor numbers every year and are expanding (the one I go to in Hannover will expand from 2 to 3 halls this year). I guess the trick is to find the sweet spot in the exhibitors. You need to have plenty of "real Makers", otherwise the Faire loses its spirit, but you also need commercial exhibitors from which you can get "real" money. I remember from last year in Hannover, the big commercial exhibitors were Nintendo (who showcased their Labo stuff), Volkswagen, and Conrad Electronics (big reseller here in Germany). Also, lots of food trucks outside. But all in all, it was still acceptable in my book, and my kid loved it. So I think this can well be done with profit, but I guess that being part of a big technical publishing group also creates lots of synergy which saves cost.
- zaarn 7y agoI think heise did publish a statement that Maker Media GmbH is doing fine and that the Maker Faires will continue in the forseeable future. Atleast in my parts, Conrad is a big sponsor of Maker stuff (they profit of the parts, after all, especially makers that don't want to handle customs), so they're fine in my book. From what I know from german makers on youtube and IRL, the fair is pretty decent and well staffed with actual makers.
- deng 7y ago> From what I know from german makers on youtube and IRL, the fair is pretty decent and well staffed with actual makers. I can confirm. It has definitely gotten more commercial over the years, and I also wish they would get rid of some stuff that plain weirds me out (don't get me started on the BattleBot arena... also, some of the cosplayers...), but as I said: all in all, it's still OK.
- zaarn 7y agoMaker Cosplay? Do they dress up as MOSFETs?
- squarefoot 7y agoSadly it's not the 70/80s anymore, most people don't give a damn about building stuff when they wake up in the morning, you need special sfx or something really spectacular to attract people, especially kids, who will shot selfies and videos near the giant sized robot|working jet backpack|150Km/h electric skate| etc. to climb their online social ladder. If you're smart you can slip some cool device, development system, analog electronics kits etc. under the radar and get a few of them to learn something when they get back home, but you have to provide motivation; curiosity alone works only for a small subset among us. So, why not partnering with schools and institutes? Wouldn't be nice if they rent a lab to a school for technical lessons, then assign tasks to teams and have say every 3 months the winning project published on the magazine? That would create competition encouraging more users/schools to join while boosting sales. The gist is: you don't sell many Van de Graaf Generators (the device, not the band:^) kits until you show what happens to the girl's hair when she touches the electrode.
- ineedasername 7y agoI was an early subscriber, but it seemed like the magic of the early issues really faded after the first two years or so. I hope they can recapture a bit of that.
- KirinDave 7y agoTo some extent, I think this is good. While the Maker Faire is iconic and I'd like to preserve that at all cost, the actual org behind it is poorly managed and inexplicably for-profit. It makes me think that there is room for new non-profits focusing on what people actually wanna do in the various venues as opposed to be a generalist system. I hope someone will compete in this fashion.
- musicale 7y agoMake: magazine seems like it should be as viable as any magazine (which means: maybe or maybe not?) Maker Faire will probably be better if it's primarily run by volunteers and has fewer corporate sponsors.