11 ms·
Instagram influencer engagement hovers near all-time lows
- AliaksandrH 7y agoit's clear that influencers make a lot of money on IG but IG doesn't get a cut
- ekuzyakov 7y agoAgreed, it's just a matter of time before the FB going to tweak the algorithm to address the issue
- teej 7y agoI actually don’t think it’s clear at all that IG influencers make money at all. I imagine that it’s similar to Twitch or Youtube - you have a very small 0.1% minority at the top making most of the income and everyone else scrapes by.
- rococode 7y agoI think a lot of the lower-tier influencers look at influencing as a source of freebies rather than an actual job. They don't make much of an income, but they're perfectly happy just with the free things they're given to promote.
- ghaff 7y agoNot Instagram, but I know someone who is a food scene/restaurant blogger on the side. She likes going it (and does a good job). She gets some trips and probably money/benefits here and there but it's definitely more of a hobby with some perks than what a lot of people here think of as a side-gig much less a significant employment stream. I know someone else who does hiking equipment reviews who I expect is in a somewhat similar boat.
- anbop 7y agoSomehow I feel like Instagram is going to be financially OK.
- gberger 7y agoInfluences drive up time spent on IG, which drives up ad revenue
- Simulacra 7y agoDo influencers really...influence? It seems like a lot of money is thrown at some of these folks but it's not clear that is directly leading to sales.
- css 7y agoSurprisingly, people follow attractive people because they want to see photos of attractive people and not because they wonder what tea they drink
- bobthepanda 7y agoAnecdotally, influencing can work in certain product categories (clothes, makeup) where you would want some authoritative source to demonstrate that something looks as good as advertised.
- winternett 7y agoI try to follow attractive people at times on there, but I quickly end up unfollowing them once I find that the misleading fame has gone to their head... Most of these "influencers" only post selfies or product promos and it gets really boring after 3-4 images. :(
- appleiigs 7y agoI watch the Super Bowl for the (american) football, but the TV commercials are still effective. Much of advertising is just reminder that the product exists. Effective not because I buy what Tom Brady buys. "Influencers" are just "content providers" to get the views.
- richk449 7y ago> Effective not because I buy what Tom Brady buys Meaning ceramic underwear?
- _bxg1 7y agoThe economics wouldn't shake out if it didn't work. Just because they don't work on you personally doesn't mean they don't work.
- sschueller 7y agoWell Instagram let the boat sale away. Where was the ability to directly link a product you are promoting in your post? How many times have you seen people say, link is in my profile? They could be facilitating the sale of promoted products directly and offer brands and individuals services to make it easy to go from click to sale. Additionally make sure people stay on the correct side of the law and disclosing that they are being paid. Maybe even require such payments to go via Instagram.
- alephnan 7y agoThey have product listings directly on Instagram now.
- the_watcher 7y agoThis exists. Product tagging is available to influencers, and Shopping rolled out earlier this year (and you can pay via IG).
- AznHisoka 7y agoAs with any data study, it always helps to read the fine print. This is how they measure engagement rate: "The firm measures engagement with a like follower ratio or the average number of likes on each Instagram post compared to the number of followers." Thus engagement rate could be decreasing, but that doesn't say anything about the total average engagement of Instagram posts, which might be increasing. Possible reasons engagement rate is decreasing (but overall engagement rising): 1) The people who followed your brand in the early stages are your most enthusiastic fans and most likely to engage with your posts. Followers that hop on the bandwagon are less likely to engage, thus lowering your engagement rate. In effect, over time, your follower count will increase, but new followers will increase the denominator (number of followers) but won't increase the numerator (engagement). 2) Perhaps, there's been a rise in automated followers. Thus, your follower count has been increasing but most of it are bots, thus your engagement rate is decreasing. 3) Perhaps Instagram might be pushing more people to follow brands they don't want to engage with. Whether it's through algorithmic recommendations, or more ads that tell you to follow a brand.
- shostack 7y agoI think #3 is really interesting. As an advertiser with a lot of hands-on experience in ad platforms, FB from the start has tried to make the experience as simplistic as possible to manage. This has the side-effect of also getting less-savvy advertisers to spend lots of money on things that may be less effective for them, but may help FB's bottom line in terms of total advertiser spend and RPM's on their inventory by giving them greater control of where and to whom they fill a given impression in the auction. Depending on how things are working behind the scenes, I could see your third scenario being related to what I've observed. To be fair to them it's a tough Product situation. The majority of their advertisers are not savvy technical marketers who know the ins and outs of Ad Manager, have attribution solutions, etc. So in a sense, they need to overly simplify. But when you oversimplify things, require less technical setup of things like conversion tracking, etc., you tend to move further upstream from revenue-driving activity in the funnel, which can get very wasteful very quickly.
- ummonk 7y agoThe longer I am on a platform the more I tend to follow (because I don’t unfollow much) but my engagement remains the same. I imagine most people are the same.
- the_watcher 7y agoKey: > The engagement rate for Instagram influencers with at least 10,000 followers is steady at about 3.6% worldwide. Influencers with 5,000 to 10,000 followers have an engagement rate of 6.3% and those with a following of 1,000 to 5,000 have the highest rate at 8.8%, per InfluencerDB. This makes it pretty obvious that the growth of influencers is concentrated in the long tail, where engagement is lower and sponsored posts less valuable.
- alephnan 7y agoPersonal plug, I'm exploring a "microinfluencer" (1k-1000k followers) management platform, initially focused on the fashion industry in NYC. This article is somewhat encouraging, actually. Per HN's policy of commenting substantively, I will say these influencer deals are amateurish and lacking paperwork. Currently an engineer at Big4, and exploring the seed/angel investment landscape. I'd love to get in touch to get advice and pick your brain on how to do further market research.
- catacombs 7y ago> I'm exploring a "microinfluencer" (1k-1000k followers) management platform, initially focused on the fashion industry in NYC. So a management company that recruits hopeful influencers and skims the top of their take-home pay? No, thanks. I'm sure plenty will be fine on their own.
- alephnan 7y agoYes, it would skin the top off their take-home Venmo payments that is currently lacking in legal paperwork. In addition, they wouldn’t have to orchestrate these deals over direct message and email exchanges. This criticism is akin to saying Stripe or Visa or any broker platform not adding value. It’s a fallacy of smaller pie slice in a larger pie. These are economic activities not being pursued because of barriers to entry for brands, and the overhead of orchestrating many smaller influencers versus 1 legitimate big contract with a more established influencer. And yes, they would get 30% less, because they have to pay taxes now.
- seattle_spring 7y agoExactly what legal paperwork does some tool who does stupid yoga poses with a free t-shirt need?
- alephnan 7y agoI lived in Seattle for half my life, and I see where this question stems from. It’s unbelievable to people in the Northwest that people in NYC, London, and other fashion hubs spend $1K on an article of clothing. This is the norm, not the exception here. Brands like Supreme barely want to sell their $600 t-shirt to paying customers, much less give them away. Point being, it’s a strawman to compare the target demographic of free tech swag to up-and-coming models getting free designer clothing. Still, it seems the fashion industry is adverse to paperwork and the formality. They’d love it if they didn’t have to deal with paperwork, and can get a tax incentive to give out more (which can potentially be abused, but that’s a separate discussion).
- alkonaut 7y agoWhat is "engagement" here? Is it something that is coupled to actual sales, or just likes/reposts?
- tomc1985 7y agoGood. Anything to destroy the navel-gazing ego-stroking that has come to characterize online life
- buboard 7y agotangentially i can't stomach that word, "Influencer"
- izzydata 7y agoI feel that it is more than just the terminology. It is also their ideology. It doesn't matter what they are called it will still elicit a negative reaction from me.
- bseidensticker 7y agoI am interested in this phenomenon of hating influencers. Do you feel the same way about this same phenomenon with athletes / other celebrities? Wheaties has been doing influencer marketing since 1934 [1]. Does the fact that pretty much every successful athlete makes most of their money from influencer marketing illicit a negative reaction from you as well? If so, then you can stop reading. If not, do you mind explaining why it's different? Also, what do you mean by "their ideology"? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_athletes_on_Wheaties_boxes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_athletes_on_Wheaties_b...
- buboard 7y agoguys, the word is elicit To your point, i think there is no comparison. Famous athletes/artists have earned the public's trust due to being very talented and working hard. I don't think most social media promoters have earned the same kind of recognition and thus trust, especially when it is obvious from the get-go that they are going after monetization ASAP, they are not in it for the fun of it. It's not equally inspiring
- bseidensticker 7y agoIt still comes down to an influencer is someone who makes content, shows it to an audience, and sells access to that audience. Some content is cheaper and more engaging than other types, thus leading to some people with a large amount of influence proportional to how hard they have worked. You might be surprised at how hard these people are working though. The field is pretty crowded, everyone successful has likely worked extremely hard to get where they are.
- Hoasi 7y agoDoes this surprise anyone? Traffic doesn't not equal conversion, it never did. If you need to call yourself an influencer, you are unlikely one. Instagram's policies to market itself don't change facts. Marketers used to pride themselves being hidden persuaders.
- unreal37 7y agoThe marketers using influencers are still hidden. An influencer is just an extremely cheap actor. Tom Cruise costs $20 million to get for this commercial, and 1,000 influencers costs only $1 million.
- ForrestN 7y agoI operate a larger instagram account (125k followers), and while I would rather die than apply the word "influencer" to it, I can confirm that it's very unlikely that this has to do with the content of the feeds. We have extremely regular content: 2 posts per day of artworks currently on view around the world. Sometimes we add thousands of followers a week, and our posts rack up tons of likes. Sometimes it takes weeks to add a thousand followers. There's no change in the number of people mentioning us, no outside source for the influxes. It really feels like we hit some threshold in the algorithm and then everything changes for a while. We've been pinned at 125k for a few weeks now after a period of fast growth. Nothing about our content or our natural audience has changed.
- seanwalker08 7y agoI've got a smaller account(33k) and have noticed similar issues lately. It makes no sense as to why visibility fluctuates when my behavior hasn't changed. I have a feeling it's Instagram trying to push us to use their ad system.
- bigdubs 7y agoMy sense is at some point Instagram is going to suppress engagement unless you pay them, they may be testing out how that will play out.
- ForrestN 7y agoThis is my fear too. Instagram’s addictive neuroengineering has crowded out attention to our website, so it’s a platform where we need to be in order to reach our constituency. But we are a tiny non-profit and can’t afford to pay to play.
- sizzle 7y agoSounds like something out of the Yelp playbook I've experienced personally w.r.t. their shady sponsored advertising services and their review filtering and business search sorting algorithms.
- martin_a 7y ago
- dmix 7y ago> The engagement rate for sponsored posts fell to 2.4% in Q1 2019 from 4% three years earlier, while the rate for non-sponsored posts slid to 1.9% from 4.5% for the comparable periods. So their sponsored posts get more engagement than non-sponsored posts? Does that mean people basically follow them for their product placements?
- unreal37 7y agoMore like the sponsored posts are better, more engaging content.
- ryanmarsh 7y agoThis article doesn’t address the power law of influencers. Audiences are engaging with a smaller number of super mega influencers such as the Bucket List Family (1.8M followers).
- worthlesss 7y agoThat's because they are all worthless people. I say again: They are all worthless people
- davidmurdoch 7y agoMy wife has about 10k followers and over the past month or so total engagement (number of likes and follows) has dropped considerably, and most of the time her photos don't show up in any hashtags. Her "impressioned" engagement rate (percentage of people that saw the post that then liked or commented) hasn't really changed noticeably. Instagram just shows her photos to fewer people (and often never shows them to anyone but existing followers - no considerable Explore or Hashtag views). I've clicked around many "influencers" photos recently and followed their hashtags and often their photos don't show there. Fun anecdote: the less clothes the person (man or woman) is wearing the less likely the photo is to appear in the hashtag feed. My conspiracy theory: Instagram is favoring personal relationship and smaller accounts, or maybe trying to encourage small accounts to become "addicted to engagement" in order to pull more wannabe influencers into the platform. None of my findings are by any means thoroughly researched or done in a scientific manner. Just casual and curious browsing. I'm curious if anyone else has seen any odd hashtag behavior lately. It's possible Instagram just tailors my version of a hashtag's "Recent" feed to me.
- macspoofing 7y agoI don't think you need any conspiracy theory to explain anything. The 'influencer market is becoming saturated. With low barriers of entry, you have millions of people joining and trying to squeeze out every penny of value. This is the end result of 'perfect competition' or 'long tail' - depending on what your dance is.
- Darkphibre 7y agoHow would that explain not showing up in search results for keywords in the post?
- errantmind 7y agoIf you aren't seeing your posts show up in the hashtag's 'recent' section then you are likely shadow-banned from that hashtag due to a lack of engagement / relevance
- 7y ago
- keyle 7y agoI've ran this joke before but it's true... Watch TV, get 5 ads every 5 minutes. Watch Instagram, get 1 ad every 15 seconds...
- miguelmota 7y agoIf you want to know how the influencer culture works and how they portray a photoshopped lifestyle, watch the Fyre Festival documentary.
- klingonopera 7y agoThere are quite a number of documentaries made by YT'ers, too, IMHO, the one with the most "lulz" is definitely this one by the "Internet Historian": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBPg5ftCMv8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UBPg5ftCMv8
- miguelmota 7y agoThat was gold, thanks for sharing
- klingonopera 7y agoSorry for stalking, but so was your very first submission! It's probably standard reading here on YCombinator, but it was my first of Paul Graham's essay on "Why Nerds are Unpopular", and it just speaks to me on so many levels... Considering the main topic is about influencers, and that their "currency" is popularity, it's not even that off-topic to repost it here: http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html
- ChrisRR 7y agoCan someone ELI5 what an influencer is? I've seen the term used quite often but never looked into it. Is it basically an instagram user with lots of followers that posts sponsored pictures or is there more to it than that?
- dbuder 7y agoInstagram could have become some interesting things if it had sold to FB. The world's biggest modelling agency for one.