19 ms·
The problem is not the general economics, the problem is the vested interests. Most upsides are qualitatively important and improve ordinary life but the profit
by ggm 7y ago
The problem is not the general economics, the problem is the vested interests. Most upsides are qualitatively important and improve ordinary life but the profit is diffuse. Most abatement cost is huge incumbents like oil and coal and car industry and tax income. Their costs are being resisted and they outspend everyone else.
- emckay 7y agoThis is a big part of the problem, but there is some hope! Shareholders of the big oil and gas companies have started to recognize the long-term threat of climate change. There were 87[0] shareholder proposals last year that asked firms to adopt emission reduction targets, disclose lobbying expenses, or take other action that would result in lower emissions. Most of these failed, largely because the big institutional investors voted against them. Shameless plug: I'm trying to solve this problem by creating a governance-first index fund [1]. [0] https://voting.greengovernance.org https://voting.greengovernance.org [1] https://greengovernance.org https://greengovernance.org
- Bantros 7y agoThe long-term threat is that they are finite
- bryanlarsen 7y agoThere is far more oil, coal and natural gas in the ground than there is capacity in the atmosphere to absorb the resulting CO2.
- Bantros 7y agoIs that a fact?
- adrianN 7y agoYes. We have more than twenty years of fossil fuel reserves. We need to be carbon neutral in less than twenty years if we want to stay below 2° of warming.
- Robotbeat 7y agoYes. Oil and gas and coal proven reserves of burned would produce about 4.5 trillion tons of CO2. About half of that would remain in the atmosphere. There’s currently about 2 trillion tons of CO2 in the atmosphere today at 400ppm. So in proven reserves alone, we have enough to more than double the current CO2 levels, or triple/quadruple them from pre-industrial levels (when they were ~280ppm). ...but the real kicker is that proven reserves are just a small fraction of total likely recoverable reserves long-term. Proven reserves basically assumes no tech improvement and no exploration, two things we’re continually doing. So proven reserves have actual GROWN over time and likely will. There are truly vast amounts of fossil fuels available that could be tapped if we had to tap them. For instance, there’s over a trillion barrels of kerogen/oilshale oil (which is expensive to extract, like Canada’s oil sands) in JUST the Green River formation in Colorado/Wyoming, more than all the world’s proven oil reserves combined. But it sits untapped because oil prices are so low. And practically all of northern Alaska has coal underneath it if you drill to the right depth, 5 trillion tons (~18 trillion tons of CO2), more than four times all the world’s coal proven reserves combined. Source: https://pubs.usgs.gov/dds/dds-077/ https://pubs.usgs.gov/dds/dds-077/ America alone has enough fossil fuels in the ground to single-handedly double or triple or sextuple the CO2 level. Add in similar fossil fuel amounts in much of Africa, South America, Russia, Canada, Antarctica, Australia, and the world’s oceans, and the planet would be unrecognizable. There’s enough fossil fuels (if we tried hard enough) to get the CO2 levels in the 10,000 ppm range where there are serious long term health effects from just breathing the stuff. And psychological effects start becoming apparent at just 500-1000ppm, which we will see by the end of the century or so. So yeah, we’ll run out of atmosphere to dump the CO2 into before we run out of fossil fuels.
- Bantros 7y agoThanks for the information
- AlanSE 7y agoThe atmosphere can absorb it, but many ecosystems (the important ones for people) cannot survive the resulting changes in climate.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoOf course. I tried adding a similar caveat to my message, but my feeble attempts muddied my simple message. Even your caveat is slightly over-simplified because there's a significant time component: most ecosystems would probably be OK if the oil was burned over a few million years rather than a few decades.
- alistairSH 7y agoYou mean the same oil/gas companies that have known about these issues for decades and covered it up?[0] I trust them to do the right thing about as far as I can throw them. If they are making any changes now, it's simply because it's economically sensible, not because they want to save the planet. 0 - https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/exxon-knew-about-climate-change-almost-40-years-ago/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/exxon-knew-about-...
- DownGoat 7y agoThey knew about it long before that even. That carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas, and questions about our use of fuels that produce it were raised in the late 1800 hundreds. Climate change is a problem that has been ignored for over 120 years. they had some better excuses for ignoring it in the past, but this is not a new problem. It should have been solved in the past, and not solving it now will lead to disaster.
- cubano 7y agoDon't plants require carbon dioxide to grow? I am not sure it was immediately obvious to people 120 years ago (the Mariner 2 spacecraft, which flew past Venus in 1962, was the first to take detailed pictures showing its heat-trapping clouds) that CO2 was such a "dangerous" thing. I have recently been made aware of relatively inexpensive massive high density tree planting projects as a way to potentially solve the CO2 "problem"[0] I personally find ideas such as these are far better for world's ultra-poor then raising the price of energy thru carbon taxes, as pretty much the only way people can move into a significantly better living situation is thru the use of energy. [0] https://www.oregonlive.com/environment/2019/07/massive-tree-planting-effort-could-save-planet-climate-change-research-finds-but-its-too-early-to-take-it-as-gospel.html https://www.oregonlive.com/environment/2019/07/massive-tree-...
- Retric 7y agoNot all energy sources generate significant CO2 or even cost more than those that do. It’s vastly more efficient to make the least economically expensive changes early than to wait and be forced to use more drastic approaches. Long term carbon sequestration via forests is extremely expensive as you can’t then use the land for anything else. Not extracting carbon is by far the cheapest option for long term sequestration. PS: Sequestration of biomass underground is a viable long term option, but it’s again expensive.
- Dumblydorr 7y agoThey won't allow their core profit centers to br disrupted.
- some_random 7y agoOf course, which is why it's in their best interests to do something now to avoid massive disruption later from potentially disastrous (for them) regulation.
- asdff 7y agoThey will pen their own regulation like they've always done.
- Paul-ish 7y agoJust a heads up, the sign up for your newsletter has a really irritating reCAPTCHA. I have gone through at multiple grids to no avail. I have given up at this point. The newsletter is not worth it.
- emckay 7y agoReally sorry about that :( I'm using TinyLetter by MailChimp, and I don't have any control over that page. I'll look into other providers in the future.
- mushufasa 7y agoI created a web app for shareowners to take action. It's free to use, we're not selling investments. www.yourstake.org We're actively trying to improve the site. There should be a movement of shareholders. Please reach out with feedback! I'd like to talk to you.
- trentnix 7y agoOn the contrary, most changes proposed reduce the quality of life, reduce choices, and require rationing and rationed distribution of some sort. It is consistently pointed out that the first world quality of life is a problem and a growing population (which is almost entirely the product of people living longer, considering first-world birth rates are abysmal) is a problem. And it is rarely acknowledged that developing nations contribute greatly to pollution and curbing that would almost certainly handicap their growth (and likely result in various forms of protest, violence, and war). To simply assign resistance to how humanity uses and consumes energy to oil and coal and car industry and tax income is absurd. General economics is the only surefire way to get the changes we are told are necessary entrenched in society and our way of life. And that means it's technology, not government control and regulation, that is the solution that should be pursued. Carrots might work. Sticks won't.
- gameswithgo 7y agothe history of nations avoiding or failing to avoid various environmental collapse shows that often it has been central government control that provided the solution. sticks have worked. empirically.
- trentnix 7y agoSticks get results. There's no doubt about that. But that road runs both ways.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoDisagree vociferously. 1) A carbon tax is perhaps the most common proposed solution to the climate change problem. It would increase quality of life, not reduce choice nor induce rationing. Currently, burning carbon imposes externalities that are not paid by the emitter. This means that some of the carbon emitted is emitted even though it provides more costs than benefits. A carbon tax and dividend INCREASES economic efficiency by ensuring that CO2 is generated only when benefits exceed costs. 2) oil & gas are extremely useful for a lot of different things, and there's still a lot of it left in the ground. Technology improvements will only shift usage; it will still be used for something. Only a "stick" such as a carbon tax can ensure that such usage is efficient.
- raxxorrax 7y agoWe are still locked into unsustainable growth. Developed nations crave more people to stabilize their economies. Completely crazy... Growth should just be a byproduct of increased productivity and that would allow for population increases. But our current resources just aren't enough, especially for people in first world nations.
- nabla9 7y agoThere would be cost to ordinary people in developed countries as well. The rapid change needed will probably reduce living standards for a generation with several percentages. Overall there may be net positive effects for all generations, never in the history of the humanity have masses sacrificed for the whole of the humanity.
- mises 7y agoThis is why people are not going along with the far-left proposals. I personally will not reduce my living standard for the sake of some "green dream". How about we wait for a generation and invent the requisite technology? Then, it will be more cost-effective and will out-compete the old stuff.
- egil 7y agoWe still need an incentive to invent today to gain the necessary technology for tomorrow.
- makerofspoons 7y agoWe don't have that kind of time. James Anderson, a leading atmospheric scientist who is famous for his research on ozone depletion by CFCs, says we have as little as five years: https://www.sciencetimes.com/articles/23104/20190703/only-5-years-to-save-the-world-from-climate-change-warns-harvard-scientist.htm https://www.sciencetimes.com/articles/23104/20190703/only-5-...
- nabla9 7y agoWe don't have time to wait.
- hanniabu 7y ago> I personally will not reduce my living standard for the sake of some "green dream". (1) It's not a dream, it's the physical world around you. If you like the way it is then action needs to be taken now. (2) If you will not not willingly reduce your standard of living for a green world, then you will forcibly have your standard of living reduced by a shittier planet. Massive specie die-offs, expensive food, droughts, more frequent bad weather, heat and violence that comes with hotter temperatures, countries panicking and fighting for resources, people panicking and fighting for resources, etc.
- roenxi 7y ago> Most abatement cost is huge incumbents ... The costs have to be high enough to change people's behaviors, and will probably fall on the people who are currently consuming the fossil fuels. Financial games can do all sorts of things as we work out who is going to be formally treated as responsible for the write-down of lots of assets. However there is no escaping the physical costs of climate abatement; where things that could be done easily with fossil fuels get a little bit harder to achieve. There are entrenched interests that don't like climate change, but if the alternatives are even in the same ballpark from a financial perspective there would be a stampede of bankers investing for the reduced political risks.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- greggeter 7y agoYes, this is true. O&G companies have so much time, money, and engineering invested, it'd be like asking Google, Twitter, and Facebook to give up their monopolies. It may take time, but scrappy upstarts, better batteries, and Gen4 nuclear will eventually unseat them. Let's be kind to O&G industries that employ and support the livelihood of billions and have helped advance civilization more than any other industry. Their time is coming for disruption - the timeframe is at least a generation.
- londons_explore 7y ago> the problem is the vested interests. There is also vested interest at the nation state level. No nation wants to be the only nation to do something serious about climate change. If they were, they would take all the downside, and get none of the benefit. Some countries are already seeing this. The UK is leading on some emissions control measures, and it's already contributed to bankruptcy of large chunks of it's steel industry.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoOne solution to this problem is Nordhaus' climate club proposal: https://issues.org/climate-clubs-to-overcome-free-riding/ https://issues.org/climate-clubs-to-overcome-free-riding/
- londons_explore 7y agoThe idea is good, but I think it's conclusions might be based on false assumptions. The modelling assumes that every country has two choices - "be part of climate club, and restrict carbon emissions", or "don't be part of the club, do whatever with carbon, but pay to export goods to club members". That isn't the case. There is a third option: "Attempt to set up a different club with different rules". When you model that, the smart move is to be a member of a club which is both big and inexpensive (ie. not many carbon restrictions). Over time, the stable position in this model is no action on anyone's part.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoThe stablest option of all is "no club". It will take a HUGE amount of interest and pressure and votes and money to create the first carbon club. Any set of countries attempting to create a competing "pollution club" will have to do it in opposition to that pressure. If that pressure isn't sufficient to prevent creation of the "pollution club" it probably wasn't sufficient to create the first "carbon club" in the first place.
- bko 7y agoThe problem is that people say they care but they don't want to bare the cost. Politicians aren't stupid, they know this and choose not to do anything about it > The survey results also suggest that the amount that people are willing to pay monthly varies. Fifty-seven percent are willing to pay at least $1 per month. The share declines with the monthly cost: 23 percent would pay at least $40 monthly, and 16 percent would pay at least $100 each month. However, the fact that 43 percent are unwilling to pay anything underscores the polarization about climate change. Party identification and acceptance of climate change are the main correlates of whether people are willing to pay, with Democrats being consistently more inclined to pay a fee. http://www.apnorc.org/projects/Documents/EPIC_press_release.pdf http://www.apnorc.org/projects/Documents/EPIC_press_release....
- ihm 7y agoPoliticians are also in the pocket of the Koch brothers who spend about as much on politics as the Dema and the Republicans[0]. People’s beliefs aren’t an immutable fact that exists in isolation, they’re a product of the propaganda-soaked media environment, which is also part of the problem and has to be changed. [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/27/us/politics/kochs-plan-to-spend-900-million-on-2016-campaign.html https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/27/us/politics/kochs-plan-to...
- learnstats2 7y agoShouldn't democratic governments, i.e. of the people, have a vested interest which outweighs the others? Unilaterally installing public infrastructure for renewable energy would remove all of the other concerns - forcing the 'vested interests' above to get in line. Effective governments are already doing this.
- astazangasta 7y agoThe problem is that people routinely underestimate the scale of vested interest. Bill McKibben famously quantified the problem as the amount of actual capital (as in, can be used as collateral) in the ground for some companies - trillions of dollars worth. But the problem actually goes far beyond this. The real vested interest is Washington, DC - what is being confronted here is not a few oil companies and their lobbying power; that could easily be overcome, there is a ton of public interest and pressure in fighting climate change. The real barrier is that Washington's imperial power is tied to fossil fuels. Starting as early as the 1920s there was the recognition that US oil supplies were dwindling (they peaked in 1969 and have been falling ever since), and that the bulk of remaining oil was in the Middle East. This remains the case, although Venezuela is an important new source in the era of not-so-cheap oil. Since that moment, Washington has used control over the Middle East not as a way to get oil, but as a way to exercise imperial control over world affairs. This is why our foreign policy includes a close, bizarre, and to most Americans anathema, alliance with the repressive, dictatorial, feudal monarchy in Saudi Arabia; one of Obama's signal achievements was selling this regime $115 billion in weaponry. All of this effort, along with the effort of the Iraq War, the Afghanistan war, and the 70-year long campaign to control Iran, was organized to ensure the continuation of American power by maintaining dominance over the global oil supply. None of this power is possible without this concentration of oil resources. If the world, instead, moves to a decentralized system based on cheap, accessible technologies, the result would be an instant loss of control for Washington. All of the military power arrayed to dominate the Middle East would become irrelevant. This is intolerable. It is THIS vested interest that we must overcome to fight climate change. Few activists appreciate this; little of our rhetoric around climate change is organized around the war machine. It continues to be along the lines of, "This is just good sense, why can't we have a technology transition, screw the oil companies?" Without confronting the war machine, without aiming at the real organized power that stands behind our use of fossil fuels, we're unlikely to win.
- mariushn 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_We_Fight_(2005_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Why_We_Fight_(2005_film)