3 ms·
I've got school aged kids in the UK, and I've never seen anything other than phonics as the way to teach reading. Seems to work just fine, never came across a
by lordnacho 7y ago
I've got school aged kids in the UK, and I've never seen anything other than phonics as the way to teach reading.
Seems to work just fine, never came across a kid who couldn't read quite soon after they started being taught.
But of course that may just be my particular environment.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoI think phonics is a slight mismatch with English, which might produce poor spelling ability? The "buh-aye-buh-ee" comment elsewhere here also seems somewhat on the nose. UK schools have been all-in with phonics for some time though.
- m-i-l 7y agoYes, only ever seen phonics taught in the UK - wasn't aware there were alternative approaches, let alone any controversy on the topic. It might not be clear from the original article, but it isn't just single letters, there are also digraphs (i.e. two letters that make one sound, e.g. bee is read b-ee), split digraphs (i.e. where a digraph is split by a consonant, e.g. a-e for cake), and later on things like the magic e and suffixes with a-y for baby. There's some resources at https://www.gov.uk/education/phonics https://www.gov.uk/education/phonics , and you can look on iPlayer or YouTube for https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alphablocks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alphablocks .
- timthorn 7y agoAlphablocks is excellent and is also now accompanied by Numberblocks, which was developed in conjunction with the National Centre for Excellence in Teaching Mathematics. There was a big push by the Conservative government as soon as they got into power to get all primary schools to teach synthetic phonics. Before then, whole word teaching was quite common.
- tomatocracy 7y agoI do too (albeit they are in the private system not the state system). While mine are/were taught phonics, reading is taught separately to that, and we're lucky enough to have teachers who recognised that they learned better with whole words. As others have said, it's about going with what works for the individual child, not one size fits all.