6 ms·
“But the last 50 years have been terrible for people with lower skills. Adjusted for inflation, the average earnings of a man who didn’t go to college is lower
by sokoloff 7y ago
“But the last 50 years have been terrible for people with lower skills. Adjusted for inflation, the average earnings of a man who didn’t go to college is lower now than it was 50 years ago. That’s unheard of.”
How much of this effect is the vastly higher percentage of people who now go to college? If you line up 100 people by vague estimation of their likely earning potential in 1970 and do the same today, but now 2.5 times as many people attend college, the population remaining with "no college" in 2020 isn't really the same population as it was in 1970.
- kazen44 7y agoAlso, how much of this effect is basically the rest of the world playing catch up in terms of economic production? China and the rest of Asia are magnitudes more competitive compared to 50 years ago. And prior to that US industry was unmatched thanks to the massive effects world war 2 had on the other, western industrialized nations.
- deogeo 7y ago> Also, how much of this effect is basically the rest of the world playing catch up in terms of economic production? If the rest of the world becoming more productive results in US workers being worse off, then something is severely wrong with US trade policy. For one, it contradicts the dogma that more trade is strictly beneficial.
- bilbo0s 7y agoI think that dogma though was meant to address the situation in a global context. ie - More trade is strictly beneficial for the global population in aggregate. But yeah, it's still trade, so there will be lows and highs, and ebbs and flows.
- asark 7y ago> For one, it contradicts the dogma that more trade is strictly beneficial. Ricardo's original idea was applicable with a narrow set of assumptions/conditions and didn't have much to say about who'd end up with the greater net wealth. I'm not sure how/why it was turned into a magical improve-any-economy law of nature.
- astazangasta 7y agoRicardo's mistake is not thinking about development; comparative advantage is optimal now, but a society that just makes coffee beans is going to lose in the end to the one that makes microchips because of the difference in how the economy and society develop over time.
- 0815test 7y agoThis may have been a mistake by Ricardo, but not one that points towards less trade as optimal. Indeed, export-led development (implying more trade openness) is the one reliable way we know about of going from the "coffee beans" to the "microchips" stage of development.
- astazangasta 7y agoFalse, I recommend Ha-Joon Chang's writing on this subject. The US did not develop in a climate of trade openness, it used tariffs to protect its development. In fact no developed economy developed this way, all of them protected their industry until it was mature and ready to compete, had their governments invest in research and infrastructure and so on. If you have an example of a country that successfully developed through export led development and trade openness I would love to hear it.
- cycrutchfield 7y ago>For one, it contradicts the dogma that more trade is strictly beneficial. It is strictly beneficial, in aggregate. But in any situation, there are winners and there are losers. There are no decisions you can make where everybody wins. If you live in a first world country and your skill set is worse than somebody in the developing world, you’re going to have a bad time.
- deogeo 7y ago> But in any situation, there are winners and there are losers. The usually trotted-out theory of comparative advantage claims there are only winners.
- cycrutchfield 7y agoI don’t think you fully understand comparative advantage then.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoagain, only in the aggregate/ entity of measurement level. I would argue anyone who says otherwise is either being disingenuous or doesn't actually understand economics. That is not to say that is not trotted out frequently. Also, to be fair, during my economics education they had this whole focus on modeling policies and finding optimizations where no one is worse off. Of course, in the real world, that practically never happens... and there is an argument that the focus on efficient/competitive markets/ equilibria/rational agents is also a bit "wouldn't it be nice if the world was actually like this...", whereas in the real world only the most trivial goods/markets can vaguely be described as such...
- FooHentai 7y ago>If you live in a first world country and your skill set is worse than somebody in the developing world, you’re going to have a bad time. Even if your skill set is greater, your cost of living is higher. So you'd have to be more than marginally better. Also, the logical conclusion of where this seems to be headed is that if you're a low-skill person living in a first-world county, voting for protectionist, isolationist policies/politicians is a rational choice.
- maxxxxx 7y agoThat doesn't explain why inequality within the US keeps growing. As a whole the country is doing well but somehow the benefits go a small number of people while everybody else is stagnating.
- zebrafish 7y agoSure it does. US consumer demand rises after WWII because of GI bill & repurposing of capital -> competition drives prices down -> Securities & Exchanges Act essentially mandates firms optimize for returns to capital as a fiduciary duty to shareholders -> producers look to countries where standards of living demand lower wages to maintain market positions -> US jobs decline but shareholder value grows -> wealth concentrates in the hands of those who have the opportunity to be a shareholders
- moorhosj 7y agoYou kind of hand-waved 70 years of economic history/decisions. How does “US jobs decline” match with an historically low unemployment rate?
- AndrewKemendo 7y agoIt's explained somewhat in the article: We’ve also had a combination of tax and regulatory policy that has encouraged capital formation and increasing returns to capital, so labor’s share of returns has decreased. To add to that, capital is exponentially more portable than labor. With globalization, capital in the form of investments can move wherever it needs to to grow, it's borderless. Labor however, in order to grow wealth has to physically move. Remote jobs for basic labor doesn't exist - that's almost exclusively knowledge work. So if you're a coal miner, your ability to create wealth is extremely limited to certain physical places. If you're a remote Java dev, you can code from anywhere and grow wealth much easier, but there is a serious time cost to switching work. If you're an investor and just need to drop money into an account, not only can you do it from anywhere, you can move things around more or less immediately with little (relative) cost. It's about portability of the thing that is growing the wealth. Labor = slow, Capital = fast.
- bilbo0s 7y agoYep. And even the people with college will necessarily compare less favorably with that older cohort over time. In a world where everyone has a college degree, well, some people with college degrees will have to be the ditch diggers so to speak. I don't know how you solve that problem? It's just math.
- chillwaves 7y agoUse your educated populace to design robots to dig ditches. It's not "math" that humans have to engage in undesirable labor, under brutal conditions. We have thousands of years of developing tools that are contrary to that statement. It is a collective social decision to say that an hour of someone's time is worth less than building a robot. That's the only reason why cashiers still exist.
- bilbo0s 7y agoIt's still math. If you go that route, then the people who build and program the robots will necessarily be paid less. Today that is likely a top 10% job. (More likely a top 5% job if we're being honest.) In a world where everyone has a college degree and there are 30 times the number of people who can program those things because the tools have gotten just that easy... well, you do the math. At the extreme, you can't just pay 100% of the labor market more money because they have a college degree. It just doesn't work like that. Put in more base terms, there is only room for 1% of the people, in the top 1%. You may be able to, through the magic of increased production, decrease the price of everything in your economy. So that the other 99% of people can afford access to everything to which people in the top 1% have access. But even that is difficult in the extreme. It'd just be easier, over time, than is paying everyone in your economy more over time.
- jayd16 7y agoThis is a real misunderstanding of economics. If you increase productivity through technology, it's possible for everyone to earn more real dollars (as a product of cost of living). It's not a zero sum game. Imagine it this way. Everyone today is making more than hunt from a cave money. Why is that? Because a single human can produce more than the bare minimum for survival.
- shados 7y agoIt's like playing an MMORPG-style videogame where the developers keep raising the level cap. The higher the cap, the worse off people who are just starting are (and why in those games developers keep having to provide a "catch up mechanics", like a scroll to rush you to level cap, or making stuff easier to obtain. In the real world that's a lot harder to do though). Probably made worse by the vastly higher amount of dual income household, so someone with just 1 income is proportionally worse off. A single unskilled worker vs a couple of high skill workers, competing for supply & demand against each other...yeah, the former's not gonna have fun.
- luckydata 7y agoIn the real world those are called "redistributive policies" and work quite well, especially for the economy as a whole. http://www.levyinstitute.org/publications/can-redistribution-help-build-a-more-stable-economy http://www.levyinstitute.org/publications/can-redistribution...
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThey work well... until they don't. Anyone from Eastern Europe over the age of about 40 can tell you about it. Like anything else redistribution falls on it's face if you go too crazy with it.
- jdietrich 7y agoThere is a world of difference between redistribution and central planning.
- FranzFerdiNaN 7y agoA lot of people over 40 in Eastern Europe would rather go back to the Soviet Union than stay in their new capitalist dreamworld. Things weren't great, but at least they had a job, a roof, food and healthcare.
- nec4b 7y ago
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoThis suggests that everyone going to college is doing well. That isn't the case. There are people who have master's degrees, but are earning $15/hour. I agree with your point that populations can change over time. Fifty years ago, many people didn't get degrees and made good money. Today, people without degrees (and some with) don't make good money. So instead of trying to segment in groups (the college educated vs. everyone else), let's just look at everyone. This removes the concern of our shifting populations. One metric to look at is median income. Adjusted for inflation, it hasn't budged much in decades. In the past 42 years, it's increased about 32 percent. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N
- sokoloff 7y agoIn a consumer driven economy, with a savings rate of around 7%, most people are spending the vast majority of their income on consumption [competing with other consumers for some scarce goods], why would we think that median real income should increase significantly faster than inflation?
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoBecause of the huge productivity gains over the past 42 years. The profits from those gains all collect at the top.
- sokoloff 7y agoThat seems to be a reason to think that the median (real) income will not increase.
- imtringued 7y agoIt's basic supply and demand. Globalization puts high downward pressure on wages because people in Asia can live on far less money than Americans. If you have to raise prices because of higher cost of living then your customers simply buy from somewhere else. Then there are certain degrees with too many graduates which flood the market which results in lower wages. Others have a shortage of graduates which means the companies have to hire from a labor pool where everyone is employed and therefore have to outbid their competitor to hire anyone at all. Add double income households which compete for rivalrous (if I have it, you don't have it) goods like housing and the end result is the US economy.
- rayiner 7y agoIncome inequality comparisons are full of problems like this. Reflecting your intuition, I’d imagine most people would conceive of increasing income inequality to mean increasing gaps between people in the same station in life across two time periods. But demographics have changed dramatically since 1970. For example, immigrants make up almost 3x as large a fraction of the population (from 5% to almost 15%) than in 1970. Obviously, if you add a large number of (typically) economically disadvantaged people to the population, income inequality is going to go up, even if there is no change in incomes for everyone else: https://www.migrationpolicy.org/sites/default/files/source_images/FRS-SPT-2019_Figure_1_UPDATED.png https://www.migrationpolicy.org/sites/default/files/source_i.... Likewise, peoples’ incomes increase with age. The population overall has grayed significantly. Again, even if wealth inequality wasn’t increasing for people of any given age, changing the age distribution of the population will affect income inequality. Finally, a larger fraction of the population now comprises historically disadvantaged minorities. While the income gap between races in the US is a huge problem, it’s a different problem than “income inequality” genetically, deserving more targeted solutions. (And even that income gap is hard to analyze, because the ages of people of different races in the US differ quite dramatically). The median age of non-Hispanic whites is 42. The median age of Hispanic people is 28. The median age of African Americans is 33: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/07/07/biggest-share-of-whites-in-u-s-are-boomers-but-for-minority-groups-its-millennials-or-younger/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/07/07/biggest-sha...). Income inequality probably is going up. But I’ve never seen a study that actually holds demographic changes constant so the result reflects peoples’ perception of what income inequality means.
- sokoloff 7y agoI also suspect that some of these "oversights" aren't mistakes at all, but rather intentional obfuscation of facts. Take note of how often you hear/read something like "incomes haven't risen in 30 years, but prices have gone up over 50% over that period". [Almost?] Inevitably, the income will be real income [inflation adjusted] and the prices nominal prices.
- frankbreetz 7y ago
- tolstoshev 7y agoCollege is just a proxy for IQ. Shoving more people into college isn't going to make them smarter, if they don't have the mental horsepower. Basically you've got two levers, genetics and environment, and practically you can only change the latter by early intervention. Nutrition, enriching environment, and good education.