10 ms·
The “backfire effect” is mostly a myth, a broad look at the research suggests
- supergauntlet 7y agoThis link isn't terribly blogspammy or anything, but the original article has more information: https://fullfact.org/blog/2019/mar/does-backfire-effect-exist/ https://fullfact.org/blog/2019/mar/does-backfire-effect-exis... And the original paper: https://fullfact.org/media/uploads/backfire_report_fullfact.pdf https://fullfact.org/media/uploads/backfire_report_fullfact....
- gpvos 7y agoIt's more readable, better organized, and shorter, too.
- dr_dshiv 7y ago"I didn't think the backfire effect was real, but now I'm not so sure." Is there a catchy name to describe the effect of disbelieving social science research?
- rosser 7y ago"Skepticism"?
- spamizbad 7y agoNot sure, but social science research is currently in the midst of a replication crisis. And not necessarily due to anyone acting in bad faith: you can run an experiment twice a few months apart and get opposite results. No idea on how to fix, but probably needs to invest in more robust experiment design, larger samples, and perhaps more advanced statistical methods. Sadly all of those demands cut against the "publish or perish" mentality in academia which often favors quantity over quality. A shame, since most social science researches want to do the best work possible but are constrained by $$$ and the broader culture of expectations in academic research.
- germanlee 7y agoIt's in a replication crisis because pretty much none of it is science ( no replicable testing possible - hypothesis, experiment, theory ). It's why Richard Feynmann associated social science with pseudoscience. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tWr39Q9vBgo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tWr39Q9vBgo Because real science destroyed the credibility of religion and religion in much of the world is no longer a credible social control tool, the elites needed a new form of religion to control society. That new religion is social "science". Whereas religion controlled everything from economics, schooling, family, culture, society, law, etc, now they all fall under the pseudoscience/religion called social "science". --------------------------------------------- Reply to ziddoap. Considering you tossed around "illumati-esque", I doubt you are interested. I consider social science to be a pseudoscience for the same reason richard feynmann did. Did you bother watching what he had to say? Social "science" is a humanities. It belongs in the category with philosophy, ethics, literature, religion, etc. Just because I said it is a pseudoscience doesn't mean that I think it is useless or bad necessarily. No more than I think literature, ethics, philosophy or even religion is bad. I just think social "science" is a "religion" trying to latch onto the good name of real science. Just like creationism "science" or all the other fake "science" trying to gain credibility by associating itself with science.
- spamizbad 7y ago> pretty much none of it is science ( no replicable testing possible - hypothesis, experiment, theory ) By this standard, neither is most preclinical cancer research as so few of them replicate (11% - source: https://www.nature.com/articles/483531a https://www.nature.com/articles/483531a). Even social science puts up better numbers than that (~60%)
- germanlee 7y agoThere is a difference between bad science and "not being a science" ( aka pseudoscience ). The difference is that in one you can formulate replicable science. In the other, by its nature, you can't. Because on deals with "natural law" and the other with society. There is no "replicable scientific test" to determine whether capitalism or socialism is the best economic system. There is no "replicable scientific test" to determine whether to have the death penalty or not. So on and so forth. Much of it is pretty much a "religious" endeavor. Pretty much those with power decide and social "science" is used to justify whereas in the past religion was the justification.
- Fellshard 7y ago'Patience', 'Stability', 'Reason'. Taking most results at face value seems unwise when contradictory results are so often found shortly after.
- CriticalCathed 7y agoRational skepticism? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeptical_movement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeptical_movement
- darkpuma 7y agoBelief in the backfire effect confirms the bias many people have towards believing their political opponents are idiots, immune to rational thought.
- Veen 7y agoThat’s only true if you believe your own side and yourself aren’t just as vulnerable.
- darkpuma 7y agoI didn't say one side experiences this more than another. There are rational people on all "sides". Rational people may come to disagree with each other if they have different information available to them, or if they simply have different priorities. Anybody who thinks all of their opponents are irrational, by virtue of being their opponent, are themselves irrational in that respect. However that says nothing about the political distribution of this particular cognitive bias. I have made no claims concerning that.
- stupidcar 7y agoThis is like one of those Knights and Knaves logic puzzles we used to do at school: Amy believes the backfire effect is real, whereas Ben believes it is fake. Amy reads an article saying the backfire effect has been disproven, then passes her new opinion on to Ben. What will be Ben's revised opinion of the backfire effect be if 1) the backfire effect actually exists, 2) the backfire effect doesn't exist.
- scarejunba 7y agoThe right answer is that Ben doesn’t change his position, right? The backfire effect only applies when the claim ideologically aligns. I know you’re joking, just indulging the idea.
- stupidcar 7y agoThat was my conclusion, yes. Presuming Amy and Ben are ideologically wedded to their respective backfire beliefs: If the effect doesn't exist, Amy changes her mind, so won't try to Ben out of his disbelief. If the effect exists, the negative article will reinforce Amy's belief in it, but her positive argument will in turn only reinforce Ben's negative belief.
- vbuwivbiu 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aumann%27s_agreement_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aumann%27s_agreement_theorem
- balabaster 7y agoI find this premise amusing... I find it amusing because my ex (whose name really is Aimee) often had opinions that my life experiences and education suggested to me were suspect. Aimee used to do a bunch of reading, but the material she read was often from sources or authors I didn't find credible and thus while their arguments seemed plausible, they weren't enough to invalidate my original opinion. My name really is Ben. My thoughts and opinions on such matters were largely unaffected by hers in many cases, unless she presented credible evidence that led me to re-evaluate my opinion, which did occasionally happy. Often though, it was just "someone else agrees with me, thus I'm right," which does nothing to sway my opinion. Two people having the same opinion doesn't make them right and doesn't negate my opinion. It just means they both disagree with me. Humanity also believed in the geocentric model of the universe at one point. That doesn't make it right. It took one person to change the entire opinion of the world to the heliocentric model. Now admittedly, I'm not Copernicus, but we're all capable of finding evidence to support or refute our opinions on the world. It's just that very often people use the opinions of others as support for their own instead of exercising critical thinking and forming their own opinions.
- ocschwar 7y agoI don't know. Having read it only makes me believe more strongly in the backfire effect.
- rjkennedy98 7y agoThis all depends on how you measure it. Take Roe v Wade for example. Abortion pre-Roe v Wade was really not that big of a political issue. Just yesterday I was listening to the radio on a long drive and a company called "Patriot Network" was advertising a cellphone network for "Patriots". The reason? Verizon and other big phone companies donate to Planned Parenthood.
- sb057 7y agoPart of the reason it wasn't a very big issue pre-Roe v Wade is that on-demand abortions were illegal in 46 states prior to it.
- kirsebaer 7y ago"In 1971, delegates to the Southern Baptist Convention in St. Louis, Missouri, passed a resolution encouraging “Southern Baptists to work for legislation that will allow the possibility of abortion under such conditions as rape, incest, clear evidence of severe fetal deformity, and carefully ascertained evidence of the likelihood of damage to the emotional, mental, and physical health of the mother.” The convention, hardly a redoubt of liberal values, reaffirmed that position in 1974, one year after Roe, and again in 1976." https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/05/religious-right-real-origins-107133 https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/05/religious-ri...
- zaphar 7y agoThere is an enormous amount of nuance in that statement. The real change that occurred was that nuance evaporated from the discussion of the subject.
- Ensorceled 7y ago"Not that big of a political issue" is a pretty interesting take on a massive turning point in both women's rights and the drift of conservative America increasing to the right.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- orblivion 7y agoThat thing you thought was true all your life is actually false. 1 year later: That thing you thought was false for the last year was actually true. At every turn trying to make us feel stupid. It's almost like somebody is trying to drive us crazy.
- britch 7y agoUnderstanding is a process. Believing what we have the best evidence to believe is not stupid. If the evidence changes and you shift your belief you are not stupid. I think the reality is that humans are very complex, especially how we relate to each other. Studies that try to boil down our behavior and provide actionable results are highly demanded, but are very difficult to prove.
- DisruptiveDave 7y agoBe like water. You can believe, just don't attach yourself to those beliefs. Simple in concept, not so much in execution. Worth practicing.
- bendbro 7y agoI agree, but "attachment to belief" is not solely in the mind. Your beliefs are also "attached" to all of the decisions you make based on those beliefs. Those decisions alter the "position" of your life- with that position being highly dimensional (the city you live in, the kind of house you have, how your transport yourself, how many kids you have, what kind of diploma you have, how you raise your children, etc). And changing position often comes at a great cost. Assume you have a belief that fluctuates frequently (perhaps due to changing scientific or expert consensus). Also assume that this belief is attached to the position of your life in a highly costly manner. It is entirely reasonable to insulate your beliefs, and thus the cost of altering the position of your life to match the external belief, from the frequent external fluctuation of this belief. I'd imagine this is the fundamental (non-politicized) driving force behind conservatism. I see this strategy playing out as illustrated in the graph below. The straight line is your internal belief. The fluctuating line is external belief. Effectively, you are running a filter on external belief, making you slow, but eventually able to react to the changing external belief. However, since your sentiment fluctuates less than external sentiment, your costs are kept low. s e| n| /\ /\ /\ t| _/__\____/__\____/__\__ i| / \ / \ / \ m| / \/ \/ \ e|___________________________ n time t Everyone practices this strategy to some degree. Some are more mindless about it than others. Some practice it with a greater emphasis than others. Let's call this strategy an "insulated belief system". Conservative viewpoints are traditionally associated with an insulated belief system since insulating oneself implies confidence in oneself as an isolated individual. Liberal viewpoints do not associate with an insulated belief system since liberals tend to rely less on oneself and more on the community. Despite this, it isn't impossible to be a liberal who owns an insulated belief system. It would just be rare.
- doc_gunthrop 7y ago“Read not to contradict and confute; nor to believe and take for granted; nor to find talk and discourse; but to weigh and consider.” -Francis Bacon
- diminoten 7y ago"Fact finding organization finds that fact finding matters, despite some rumors that facts don't matter." Right.
- rsj_hn 7y agoIn an age when nothing seems to replicate, this wouldn't surprise me. But 1. There is an obvious conflict of interest in having a fact checking organization claim to "debunk" studies showing that fact checking is ineffective. 2. This "refutation" is a press briefing, not a peer reviewed study, and doesn't have a lot of facts to back up the claim, other than looking at the N difference in only 7 handpicked studies. This is an amusing example of what happens when so called authorities are held to account. Let's say someone reports that fact checking organizations are a waste of taxpayer dollars. Then the fact checking organization comes out with a 'Fact Check: False'. It seems there should be some prohibition about being an authority on criticisms of yourself.
- avs733 7y agoI've always struggled with the phrase 'replication crisis.' Really we have a 'mindset to approach science crisis.' The replication crisis is a couple of things to me... 1) A problem with how research is published and treated as 'new knowledge' - some of which is being solved (slowly) by efforts such as the OSF. Other efforts include registered reports, journals for nonsignificant findings, etc. The problem is journals seek to publish a 'contribution' and define contribution in a way that misrepresents science. 2) A problem with the promotion and rewarding of academics...see 1 and also the drive to produce work in academia results in rewarding minuscule steps that don't have larger coherence because the paper not the impact is rewarded. People get tenure for publications not scientific discoveries. This obviously links to 1 3) Often replication failures are a feature not a bug - but fundamentally we think about and talk about science in way to absolutist of a frame. This is especially a problem in social sciences which try and perform 'science' to gain equal treatment to 'hard science.' They aren't worse or better...they are different, their science is harder because context matters - but it is still science. There are myriad studies in psychology performed on white men from Harvard in the 40's (forgive my facetiousness). If I rerun the experiment and it 'fails to replicate' is the theory 'wrong', 'invalid', 'incomplete', or context specific? The choice of term there is critical to a set of philosophical beliefs about science that can actually imperil science by making different experimental results into an inherently bad thing.
- emmelaich 7y agoMeta -- but does anyone else get tired of the word 'myth'? These days, instead of opinions and arguments being countered, we have 'myths' busted. It's even weirder when it is 'myth' you've never heard of.
- boomlinde 7y agoIt's like the questions no one ever asked that end up in "FAQ"
- keiru 7y agoYes, it's tiresome. Not refering to this one in particular, but many internet champions of truth aggrandize their Goliath to post shitty myth busting articles. In a recent post I chose to say "mistaken belief" to avoid sounding like captain fact-checker.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- autoexec 7y agoSo someone named Amy Sippet who works at a charity called Full Fact decided it's mostly a myth, not after conducting studies or independent research but after reading just 7 previous studies on the backfire effect and noting that some studies didn't seem to her to support it and that most of the studies she read were conducted in the US. The article links to and quotes from her twitter account. This major breakthrough in the social sciences shares space in the very same article with an observation about how you can use Instagram to find "the internet’s darkest corners.” and some random stuff about Apple. Maybe it's just the backfire effect here, but I'm not really convinced.
- sterkekoffie 7y agoLimiting a literature review to 7 studies based on frequency of citation is pretty understandable, especially for a relatively young research topic. Of the 2 studies which showed a significant backfire effect, the findings of the first were considered "overstated and oversold" by its own authors and the second only found evidence of the effect in one of four situations. The second was also partially replicated in a later study which found no evidence of the backfire effect. That being said, the author of the review probably would not want you to be convinced by a single pop-sci piece covering her work. This "major breakthrough," as you describe it, does not in fact share space with any tweets or mentions of Instagram, but can be found here: https://fullfact.org/media/uploads/backfire_report_fullfact.pdf https://fullfact.org/media/uploads/backfire_report_fullfact....
- ademup 7y agoDoes anyone know what the effect is called where you see "Instagram" in the sub heading and instantly click the Back button? /s (kind of)
- Der_Einzige 7y agoThe term used for this by philsophers at least after hegel is "the dialectic". I've always thought that many philsophers uncritical acceptance of a dialectical process within the world was absurd. I am happy to see some evidence from science indicating this to be the case.
- backfired 7y agoTo paraphrase: > The effect: "An ideologue believes a (wrong) thing. You tell them, no. They double down. Your effort to refute has backfired." This is actually rare. It doesn't matter, because we've all been there. We've all experienced clashes of opinion, and none of us like being wrong, so we resist adjusting. Lots of us do it. It's a natural part of childhood. Being afraid of the dark. Believing in ghosts. Santa Clause. The Easter Bunny. The Tooth Fairy. How did you cope? What about other aspects of belief? Religion? What aspects of religion does one regard as history? How many people remain religious in the face of contrary evidence? Suddenly, this effect seems less rare.
- username90 7y agoThe backfire effect is obviously not universal, otherwise it would be impossible to teach for example Newtonian physics. So if you present strong enough proof people will change their minds. I think the problem is that people don't really learn what a strong proof is, so when two people who each have a weak understanding of the topic tries to argue both will see that the other is ignorant but not that themselves are ignorant. After the discussion both will have correctly refuted a lot of claims from the other side, thus "strengthening" their own views. If this often happen to you then you are likely not as well informed as you think you are. In short, I believe that "you can't reason someone into a position that you didn't reason yourself into" is true, while the popular "you can't reason someone out of a position that they didn't reason themselves into" is wrong.
- Torgo 7y agoNot necessary. Science advances when entrenched proponents of the old theory die out.