16 ms·
Glass discs that can store 360TB and remain intact for billions of years (2016)
- fredsted 7y agoWhat happens at 13.9B years?
- Chris_Chambers 7y agoWarranty expires.
- xattt 7y agoHeat death of the universe
- cm2187 7y agoI don't know, but if it happens at 13.7B years you RMA it!
- Nux 7y agoNothing, it's roughly the current age of the universe.
- danbruc 7y agoMost likely the defect rate will reach a specific value so that the storage medium is no longer considered reliable.
- simonh 7y agoI'm guessing that's the estimated time it would take for entropy in the material to render the data unreadable. They specify at room temperature, so I'm pretty sure they're talking about entropic disruption of the structure due to thermal effects. Note that 'glass' is a hugely varied class of materials, so without knowing much more we can't make spot judgements about the validity of the claim.
- kragen 7y agoNo, 10–100 billion years is at 462 K, which is a lot hotter than room temperature. At room temperature the estimated lifespan (or, really, the time constant τ) is 3×10²⁰ years.
- simonh 7y agoThat's really great, precise information. Where did you get it from? Also which exact material is that for? As I said, there are a lot of different things called 'glass'.
- kragen 7y agoFrom the paper: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ausra_Cerkauskaite2/publication/297892219_Eternal_5D_data_storage_via_ultrafast-laser_writing_in_glass/links/59fb2de00f7e9b9968b962dd/Eternal-5D-data-storage-via-ultrafast-laser-writing-in-glass.pdf?origin=publication_detail https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Ausra_Cerkauskaite2/pub... They're using fused quartz, as one does. I'm guessing it would be a bit easier to use soda-lime glass, and also reasonably stable, but considerably less stable.
- hilbert42 7y ago"Note that 'glass' is a hugely varied class of materials, so without knowing much more we can't make spot judgements about the validity of the claim." As I say in part of my post the key issue here is the intrinsic property of this "glass" which will be of a crystalline-like nature, to quote: <...> 5. We know that under ideal conditions some crystals such as zircon and others have lives of much longer than 4.4 Gy. Why? Well crystal structures are known to be the most stable forms of matter in the universe that goes with the fact that they have the lowest entropy: https://www.livescience.com/50942-third-law-thermodynamics.h.. https://www.livescience.com/50942-third-law-thermodynamics.h.... — to quote: “The entropy of a perfect crystal is zero when the temperature of the crystal is equal to absolute zero (0 K).” <...>
- kijin 7y agoIt looks like somebody just said "it will last as long as the universe" and someone else translated it into an actual number using too many significant digits. How long can we realistically expect glass to last, judging from e.g. beads of volcanic glass embedded in the geological record?
- lstodd 7y agoNot much, regular glass transitions to crystal quite fast compared to those geological timescales. And who knows what the transition will do to the data stored at these densities. Nothing in the article states what kind of glass is used (which blows the bullshit detector right there). If they use crystalline quartz, it should last indefinitely. If it's regular glass, then 50 years if you're lucky, controlled conditions, etc, etc.
- vmurthy 7y agoGiven that the sun will die in about 5B Years, this is a bit of a gimmick :-D
- red75prime 7y agoSun will become a red giant in about 5 billion years. Space habitats, and habitats on moons of gas giants will still be possible.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoBy then we could probably tow Sol over to a comparable system using a Shkadov thruster and jump ship to a new sun.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoAfter one billion years, the speed would be 20 km/s and the displacement 34,000 light-years, a little over a third of the estimated width of the Milky Way galaxy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stellar_engine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stellar_engine
- v7p1Qbt1im 7y agoIn 5 billion years, humanity will either not exist anymore, or will be a Type III+ civilization. We certainly won't be impacted by anything that might happen to the sun in terms of its life cycle. A coronal mass ejection might be a problem at some point though.
- lwhi 7y agoI remember chatting to someone working on the project at the University of Southampton years ago .. I think it was back in 2004. Great to hear it's come to fruition. The length of time this type of project takes amazes me.
- yorwba 7y agoThis is about research published in 2013: https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/364916/ https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/364916/ It was recycled for a university press release in 2016: https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-update.page https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-u... Then that press release was recycled for this HN submission.
- lwhi 7y agoIn that case, I'll be amazed about the lifecycle of a news release instead ;)
- Dangeranger 7y agoDoes anyone know a resource which explains the theoretical limit for retrievable, durable, information storage? I would assume the most dense medium possible would be a collection of neutrons, since neutron stars are the most dense object other than a black hole, but retrieving information from them doesn’t seem feasible.
- bookofjoe 7y ago"'Dragon's Egg' is a 1980 hard science fiction novel by Robert L. Forward. In the story, Dragon's Egg is a neutron star with a surface gravity 67 billion times that of Earth, and inhabited by cheela, intelligent creatures the size of a sesame seed who live, think, and develop a million times faster than humans. Most of the novel, from May to June 2050, chronicles the cheela civilization beginning with its discovery of agriculture to advanced technology and its first face-to-face contact with humans, who are observing the hyper-rapid evolution of the cheela civilization from orbit around Dragon's Egg. "The novel is regarded as a landmark in hard science fiction. As is typical of the genre, 'Dragon's Egg' attempts to communicate unfamiliar ideas and imaginative scenes while giving adequate attention to the known scientific principles involved." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon%27s_Egg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon%27s_Egg Superb.
- aerique 7y agoThis is one of the few science-fiction books that I still think back on. Good, fun story and hard scifi.
- Dangeranger 7y agoThank you. This sounds like a book I need to read.
- bookofjoe 7y ago"Dragon's Egg" pdf: http://investigacion.izt.uam.mx/alva/DragonsEgg.pdf http://investigacion.izt.uam.mx/alva/DragonsEgg.pdf
- dotancohen 7y ago
- rolleiflex 7y agoInteresting side effect, this also gives us some clue about what kind of ... information storage devices we should be looking for in other heavenly bodies. Had we found a bunch of silicate glass pebbles in Europa, we'd have considered them a curiosity. After this, we have good reason to find a way to ship it back and have another look.
- tokai 7y agoSomebody should take another look at those moon glass beads.
- social_quotient 7y agoSo it’s like a Craftsman tools warranty.
- supermatt 7y agoIm always sceptical about these claims of archive longevity. IIRC when CD-Rs were first available, they were touted as suitable for century long archives. The reality was far from that.
- simonh 7y agoHigh quality discs are capable of that, the problem is the drives to read them all broke down. For an ultra-long term storage medium like this that's moot. If someone wants to read one of these in a billion years, they'll just have to develop the tech, but that would be true of any such long term mass storage medium. It's not necessarily a strike against this particular implementation.
- Krasnol 7y ago> they were touted as suitable for century long archives. I can't remember this statement from those times. Only people who said that tape is still the better/safer medium for music and backups. I even had a zip drive for that.
- simonh 7y agoMagnetic tapes suffer from print-through though. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Print-through https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Print-through
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> High quality discs are capable of that, the problem is the drives to read them all broke down. What are you referring to? I assume you're not just talking about "high quality" compact discs, since we have plenty of readers for those.
- chii 7y agoThe OP meant the drives would've broken down before the disks would degrade.
- YayamiOmate 7y agoI dunno, but it seems to me universities increasingly focus on press releases and marketing departments... 5D and 13.8 billion years? Phony. I know no sane scientist or enigneer that would say they use more than 3D physics. Sounds like catch phrases to sell. With such logic plain old HDD is at least 4D, because it uses CHS coordinates and magnetic orientation, to store data. To me such communication style undermines the real scine behind it. Do they have nothing better to brag about than excuses to call invention 5D? Why introduce such noise?
- nathanyukai 7y agoYeah isn't this '5D' yet another eye grabbing title? I think size and orientation are still 3D data.
- lvh 7y agoAnd yet, in machine learning we regularly talk about dimensions 100 and above! Just because they eventually map to three special dimensions doesn’t mean it’s not useful to talk about the different degrees of freedom you’ve managed to use for storing information. What were y’all expecting? Spider-Man: Into The Spiderverse?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jarfil 7y agoHeads is a low resolution dimension, so CHS should probably be more like 2.5D. Magnetic orientation is just binary, so not a dimension. The 5D in the article is kind of fishy, but in this case size and orientation are more of a low resolution dimension like multi-level cells in a flash drive.
- parksy 7y agoIf it's a property of an object that defines the object, it's a dimension. Spatial location gives us 3 dimensions, rotation and size give us 2 more. The dimensions don't all have to use the same units.
- 13of40 7y agoSo if one of these discs was dug up by a civilization with the level of technology we had in, say, the 70's, would they be able to tell what it was, much less make something to read it?
- sudhirj 7y agoThey'd likely know it had information on it, even if they couldn't necessarily read it immediately. Anyone storing information is likely to mark it or arrange it in some non-natural way, otherwise it'll just look like rocks.
- chii 7y agoso how do you know that the crystalline structure of some rocks aren't encoding some information? Alternatively, information encoded in rocks could've been encrypted. And encrypted information should be indistinguishable from random noise.
- jdironman 7y agoOur bodies are coded with DNA and rocks and geo formations are encoded with the earth's history.
- ryanmercer 7y ago"Hey look, I found a cool coaster!" or "Here we have an extremely rare ritualistic sex device, the male of the species placed this over his member before performing an elaborate dance and inserting his member into the female"
- benj111 7y agoCan I rant about the 5D? "It's been dubbed five-dimensional (5D) digital data because, in addition to the position of the data, the size and orientation are extremely important too" Orientation is inherently important anyway. Have you ever tried reading a book upside down, and what does size bring? Other than lowering density. And obviously position is important, it's the difference between data and randomness.
- simonh 7y agoBooks only have one orientation, so they're not actually making use of that dimension to encode data. The rest of your points... oh my. None of the dimensions count at all, really? So rant away, but it's nice if the sound and fury at least signifies _something_.
- benj111 7y agoNo 2 dimensions are important at least :) Regarding orientation, are you saying they printed half the book over the first half, but at right angles over the top? Ie you see different data from different orientations? Ps I've seen old (18th century?) letters where they wrote at 0, 90 and 45 degrees to get more on one page. Postage was charged by the page so it made sense. Newspaper also used to be taxed by the page (in the UK at least) so you had origami like folding of one sheet of paper into a newspaper, not aware of them 'double printing' in this way though. I assume that's why 'broadsheets' were so massive up until relatively recently.
- simonh 7y agoI think they encode the data as asymmetric marks in the material, with different orientations of the marks corresponding to different values. Imagine you could print a page containing just a grid of 100x100 numbers. If you can orient those numbers so the top of each digit could be facing up, down, left or right and use those 40 different glyphs to encode in base 40 instead of base 10, now you can fit 4x as much data into the same two dimensional area.
- technothrasher 7y ago
- tudorw 7y agowould this offer a safe haven for instructional code on a space ship?
- myfonj 7y agoTIL glass is not supercooled liquid after all.
- wongarsu 7y agoThere's a good Veratasium video about that [1]. But the short version is that glas is pretty much a solid, and lead is much more liquid at room temperature than glas. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6wuh0NRG1s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6wuh0NRG1s
- theclaw 7y agoLink to source (University of Southamton): https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-update.page https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-u...
- toyg 7y agoSeems a bit of a waste to dedicate an entire 360TB disc to a single text document like a bible, which is probably just a few KBs... /s More seriously, they don't talk about reading capabilities (retrieval speed etc). And what if it gets scratched? What is the error tolerance? At that density, a single speck of dust could have dramatic implications... I hope this reaches industrial viability, because we desperately need a digital format that can approximate the lifespan of simple paper. At the moment we are chained to a maintenance nightmare of periodic hops between formats, with deadly consequences any time we miss a single jump.
- bshipp 7y agoI don't disagree, but it's not really different with spinning rust. the solution would likely be similar: seal it in an enclosure to prevent intrusion of dust, scratches, etc.
- butteroverflow 7y agoI believe HDDs slowly lose stored data if you don't rewrite it periodically? I remember reading some data recovery forum a few years back with the local experts saying something about 10 years of reliable data storage for an HDD lying on a shelf. After that, all bets are off.
- bergoid 7y ago> spinning rust TIL https://etherealmind.com/network-dictionary-spinning-rust/ https://etherealmind.com/network-dictionary-spinning-rust/ > Spinning Rust – term for conventional hard disk drives with motors and using ferrous-based platters for data storage. Probably derogatory now that Flash Drives are beginning to replace conventional drives.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoTIL? Goddamnit, how old am I?
- anentropic 7y ago
- schpaencoder 7y agoI still remember the promise of the CD-Rom. Billions of years.
- akerro 7y agoIt might hold data for billions of years, but no one has CDRoms at home these days because interface and use-cases were deprecated years ago.
- halfdan 7y agoThey were only off by a couple orders of magnitude.. 10 vs 1000000000 is easy to confuse.
- toper-centage 7y agoCDs used to be sturdier and last longer. Nothing close to billions of years of course.
- wongarsu 7y agoYou could probably build CD-ROMs that last millions of years if you really tried. You can buy regular CD-Rs that are estimated to last hundreeds of years. But of course most people buy whatever is cheapest, and the cheapest CD-Rs won't last you a decade.
- nathan_long 7y agoCDs that you burned chemically with a laser at home were much less durable than those physically pressed in a factory from a glass master.
- JohnAtCC 7y agoBecause someone is around to check.
- nitin_flanker 7y agoI don't know but the article does not talk about the credibility of the claim. I mean even the way they have described the whole thing feels more like a marketing attempt than an actual scientific breakthrough. If you look at other articles of this website, they will seem more like a lame attempt at getting traffic than to provide something useful. They have articles titled like - "Ladies Get dose of Radiation From Government UFO" and "Hackers, UFO's and Secret Space Programs - Oh My!" I mean, this does not feel like an information source I'll trust. Edit: As others are mentioning in this thread. From a researcher's perspective, they should have also talked about the read/write capabilities.
- Robotbeat 7y agoA small prototype of this technology already flew in the glovebox of the Tesla Roadster launched to deep space on the Falcon Heavy’s inaugural launch (third launch just succeeded this morning): https://medium.com/arch-mission-foundation/arch-mission-foundation-announces-our-payload-on-spacex-falcon-heavy-c4c9908d5dd1 https://medium.com/arch-mission-foundation/arch-mission-foun... ...it (appropriately) contained Asimov’s Foundation Trilogy. > The Arch library that was included on the Falcon Heavy today was created using a new technology, 5D optical storage in quartz, developed by our advisor Dr. Peter Kazansky and his team, at the University of Southampton, Optoelectronics Research Centre.
- hmhrex 7y agoI just mentioned this to a co-worker last week. This was news here 4 years ago - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11140033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11140033
- SoylentOrange 7y agoI have a question for anyone here who understands how this works: is the glass from the article resilient to physical shocks like falling/shaking/heat/other mechanical stress? Documents that are meant to last a long time used to be written on vellum because it is a very physically durable material. I understand that this glass method beats existing digital storage methods for resilience, but does it best traditional analog/legacy techniques?
- kragen 7y agoYes, fused quartz has roughly the mechanical durability of granite, and it doesn't melt until a considerably higher temperature than ordinary glass (though lower than the 1650° temperature at which crystalline quartz melts). Vellum and other leathers have a lifespan of under 10000 years under ideal conditions, like those under which Ötzi was preserved. Under such conditions, the researchers extrapolate from accelerated-aging measurements that their medium will last 3×10²⁰ years, which is 3×10¹⁴ times as long. That is, this glass disc will last 300,000,000,000,000 times as long as a vellum document will, unless it's subjected to high heat. They also extrapolate that at 462 K (189°, or, in obsolete units, 372°F) it will last the current age of the universe, some 10–100 billion years. At 189° I think vellum's lifetime is a few minutes.
- SoylentOrange 7y agoThanks for the answer. Can the durability of the fused quartz be compared to the durability of this storage format though? (from a more detailed article [1]) > The information encoding is realised in five dimensions: the size and orientation in addition to the three dimensional position of these nanostructures. Is the idea that these nanostructures are themselves hyper-resilient? Or would a significant impact alter them so as to render them unreadable? [1]: https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-update.page https://www.southampton.ac.uk/news/2016/02/5d-data-storage-u...
- kragen 7y agoWell, there are a couple of different questions here. One is about resilience to physical shocks such as falling and mechanical stress, which could destroy the disc but won't do anything to the nanogratings. The other is about gradual, continuous decay processes — over a sufficiently long period of time, random thermal fluctuations will destroy any solid object, and analogous but larger-scale relaxation processes will destroy galaxies as well. Such processes could cause the nanogratings to decay long before the fused quartz itself evaporates. The nanogratings do have a certain amount of built-in redundancy; they're holographic phenomena.
- gpmcadam 7y agoHello people from the future looking back at this thread reminiscing about the old days when this claim was incredible to us.
- camillomiller 7y agoWhy is this here now? The piece of news is from three years ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 7y agoThere's a long and mostly bad history of claims around 3D storage. About twenty years ago I followed a company called Constellation 3D, later Terastor. They made many strikingly similar claims, smaller absolute numbers but a similar multiplier vs. what was already in the market. At least they only claimed three dimensions. I can sort of accept orientation as an effective fourth dimension, but size seems like a real stretch. In any case, C3D/Terastor struggled along for a few years, with more claims and more excuses, before they turned into the predictable smoking crater. I've seen several more just like them come and go since then, so I think I'll wait for more concrete proof that this particular technology can work at scale in the real world instead of just once in a lab. BTW, if you want to go even further back, who else remembers the promises about bubble memory?
- Robotbeat 7y agoOr what if it's a niche technology that works just fine at scale in the real world but nobody cares enough for super long lifetimes to pay the higher price for the equipment? No "bad history of claims," just niche technology. Not everything has to be "fake news" or "phony" just because it doesn't take over the world. I can't help but think we're cheapening the idea of fraud when we accuse every company or technology of fraud just because they don't wildly succeed.
- notacoward 7y agoI think you're overreacting, or perhaps going off on a bit of a tangent from what I actually said. I didn't accuse anyone of fraud. I even offered kudos. I'm just trying to adjust expectations because the history is indeed bad even if nobody did any wrong. Would it have been better if I'd said "sad" or "unfortunate" instead? A medium that really has these kinds of density and survivability traits is indeed a great thing, but "niche" is a bit of an understatement. Adding it to the payload of a multi-million dollar rocket is definitely a publicity stunt, so I think it's entirely fair to point out that it might be good for little else depending on how further development plays out.
- kragen 7y ago
- totaldude87 7y agoThis keeps repeating every few years i guess. https://www.theverge.com/2016/2/16/11018018/5d-data-storage-glass https://www.theverge.com/2016/2/16/11018018/5d-data-storage-... https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/160928-five-dimensional-glass-memory-can-store-360tb-per-disc-rugged-enough-to-outlive-the-human-race https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/160928-five-dimensional-... https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/92892-five-dimensional-glass-storage-could-revolutionize-medical-imaging-computing https://www.extremetech.com/extreme/92892-five-dimensional-g... or did we capture its evolution :)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ConfusedDog 7y agoThe pitch sounds very cool. For all the information given, it could well possible take 13.8 billion years to write 360 TB of data and always in the lab environment that needed to be funded. They seem to be avoiding specifics.
- masters3d 7y agoMinority Report?
- bastawhiz 7y agoThese articles pop up every few years, and it always makes me shake my head. Such storage solves no market need. Technology hardly lasts five years let alone fifty years let alone five billion years. Virtually nobody is worried about being able to read their media 500 years out. And even if that was a reason to pursue a technology, the actual storage capacity is meaningless on its own. 360TB of spinning disks isn't very expensive to buy, rack, or run. And you can read and write to them at a decent clip. Managing failures is fairly predictable. What benefit does a magical glass (or, in previous incarnations, quartz or other crystal) disk have? Optical media isn't known for its amazing random access speeds. Write-once media has very limited use and is almost never fast to write to. So who's buying this? Who has data that needs to last that long, or needs to store lots of permanently immutable data that's read back sequentially? I honestly can't think of a market for this. The article says "museums" but I don't know of any museums that would prefer glass disks for their backups over an S3 bucket. This is "on prem backup" taken to a comical extreme. I can see the academic value of exploring the technology, but this space has been exhausted many times over. I remember seeing similar articles in Technology Review and Scientific American about identical developments twenty years ago. It's just not a good idea.
- gnode 7y agoBeing able to store data densely on a commodity material such as quartz is great for archival storage (e.g. Amazon Glacier). If the storage media is cheap, then it tends not to matter if it can be reused. For random access, rapidly created and destroyed data, SSD and HDDs will continue to dominate. But for the growing use case of hoarding data forever, this is a good fit.
- kragen 7y agoVirtually nobody is worried about being able to read their media 500 years out. While this is true, the lesson I draw from this is the opposite from what you seem to be concluding. I conclude that most people are self-obsessed idiots who waste their lives on meaningless and futile things like "market need" and "survival".
- nmstoker 7y agoLooks like we need a bit more clarity on what they mean by "glass". If you look at glass in medieval glass windows it's heavily distorted by gravity (fatter at the bottom than the top) and that's after ~900 years, so presumably they're actually meaning something more robust than that!
- keiru 7y agoTurned out it was a mistaken belief. Basically, thickness invariance in medieval glass had to do with the manufacturing process, and the viscosity of glass is not observable in a human timeline. https://ceramics.org/ceramic-tech-today/glass-viscosity-calculations-definitively-debunk-the-myth-of-observable-flow-in-medieval-windows https://ceramics.org/ceramic-tech-today/glass-viscosity-calc...
- nmstoker 7y agoThat's great - I hadn't heard about that, thanks for putting me right.
- mrmondo 7y agodd if=/dev/data | tee >(dd of=/dev/glass1) | dd of=/dev/glass2 20:20 optical replication ;)
- ChrisArchitect 7y agoplease add (2016) to this title, old news
- ChrisArchitect 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11140033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11140033
- meerita 7y agoI wonder how many years our file systems will remain usable.
- jody2 7y agoarticle from 2016 https://petapixel.com/2016/02/16/glass-disc-can-store-360-tb-photos-13-8-billion-years/ https://petapixel.com/2016/02/16/glass-disc-can-store-360-tb...
- RenRav 7y agoHow does glass being amorphous affect the data integrity? What 'glass' specifically is being used?
- kragen 7y agoPresumably the amorphous nature of glass lowers the energy barrier to disrupting the stored information. They're using fused quartz glass, as one does.
- iandanforth 7y agoI guess I'll have to buy the White Album again.
- ksec 7y agoFacebook uses BluRay RW Disc for Cold Storage ( Not sure if that is still the case ). The question is nearly 4 years later are they anywhere close to production?
- leshokunin 7y agoInteresting. If we ignore whether or not this specific implementation will work, this would actually be a great way to store data for the Permaweb. I would imagine such resilient data would be a great asset when combined with content hashing!
- 5D 7y agoGreat. Now "the holy bible" is going to get dragged around for billions of years, as if 2,000 wasn't enough tedium. Oh well, at least now it's reduced to a pocket sized, machine readable glass wafer. Easily ignored and essentially worthless as ever. But yeah. Who cares about non-standardized data format design decisions. Just because you can make bigger, pointier dots in a medium doesn't mean you should. I can use a magic marker on multiple HDD platters. Does that make my scribbles optical 5D data storage? Hey, look, one of my dots is bigger than the other, and it points in a different direction. And then I put another dot on this other platter. Wow! 5D! Incredible!
- JVIDEL 7y agoIs this another tech that's "just around the corner" like holo-memory from the late 90's?