5 ms·
This is further proof that everyone was doing it. There are so many valuable lessons to takeaway from this, but weirdly for me, it's to never depend on innovat
by legitster 7y ago
This is further proof that everyone was doing it.
There are so many valuable lessons to takeaway from this, but weirdly for me, it's to never depend on innovation. Especially specific innovation.
It's important to remember that everyone a decade ago was riding high about the potential for diesel. Consumers, car producers, and regulators. And everyone was making promises about how good diesel was going to get - based on the expectation that you can just dump resources into a certain technology and get innovation, magically and predictably. But it feels like everyone just hit the innate limitation of the resource and tried to pretend it didn't exist.
- ip26 7y agoNobody specified what innovation must occur. Nobody even said you had to make diesel engines. They just said if you want to sell diesel engines they must be this good. Anyway, remember VW themselves had engines that met the spec just fine. They only cheated so they could omit the AdBlue system.
- legitster 7y agoThe push to diesel was actually launched by various European governments starting in the 90s: https://www.vox.com/2015/10/15/9541789/volkswagen-europe-diesel-pollution https://www.vox.com/2015/10/15/9541789/volkswagen-europe-die... They specifically set goals and policies to make diesels a larger presence (hence why so many power diesel sedans and small cars were made for the EU market but not the US).
- jessewmc 7y agoThis is where the blame really lies: "European nations — including Britain, France, Germany, Italy, Spain, and Austria — had been cutting taxes on diesel car purchases and diesel fuel to promote sales". The big lesson here is regulators should never ever pick winners from specific technologies.
- jacquesm 7y agoI think your conclusion is not supported by the premise. Yes, regulators fucked up. But that does not mean they are wrong all the time. And besides, it wasn't the regulators that cheated, it was the car manufacturers. The worst you can really accuse them of is lax oversight.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- legitster 7y agoThis is something that worries me about current green initiatives. We throw down subsidies for electric cars, but they still fuel on coal fired plants. Or all the money we throw away to make ethanol. It would be so much better if we just started taxing externalities like carbon or fertilizer runoff and let markets decide the tech to do it organically. But let's not let the car oligopoly completely off the hook. At some point they all took that step over the line.
- mobilefriendly 7y agoEthanol is not a green initiative, it is a subsidy program for corn growers. There's no serious green group that argues for ethanol from corn. The "green" aspect is just marketing by the corn lobby.
- marcyb5st 7y agoI think it is still a good thing to subsidize electric cars for several reasons: 1) even if powered 100% by coal plants, these plants have an higher efficiency than cars' internal combustion engines, especially if you consider the energy/co2 emissions due to the distillation process of petrol/diesel. Moreover, having a huge central plant means that you can install heavy and big filters and possibly re-capture some of that co2. You can't do this with cars 2) not all the power comes from coal plants, some from nuclear, some from natural gas, and even from renewables sources 3) when we finally crack nuclear fusion / thorium reactors / we found a way to store the surplus of renewables for underperforming times in a good way (like with molten salt https://newatlas.com/mit-molten-salt-battery-membrane/53085/ https://newatlas.com/mit-molten-salt-battery-membrane/53085/ ) we can be carbon free from as soon as these technologies spread, without having to way for consumers to change cars 4) Pushing people to use newer technologies means that companies will spend more in R&D on this subject. Imagine if someone finally invents a battery with energy capacity of 5x current Li-ion. A car like the model 3 will have ~ 1500 kms of range ... Of course there are points in favor of petrol/diesel cars, like the fact that producing current batteries is not that good for the environment, but if we don't invest on this we'll never have the incentive to overcome these problems.
- mymythisisthis 7y agoThis was a critical mistake. The push should have been for Propane. Propane is cleaner than almost any other carbon source. Also, you don't have to get it from the Middle East.
- Arbalest 7y agoYou might have been thinking Methane with the middle east comment. Natural gas is mostly methane. Also you should have mentioned LPG, to allow it to be related to existing initiatives (which have now seen decline).
- tobias3 7y agoPerhaps someone older can correct me if I am wrong, since this is difficult to research: Here in Germany the tax difference between diesel and gasoline was mainly created in 1991. Gasoline prices were increased to pay for German re-unification and diesel prices weren't taxed as much because of "European tax harmonization" -- I'd say this is code for "we want to remain competitive and lower diesel taxes gives our industry a competitive advantage". To be fair, they increased taxation of diesel passenger cars (yearly fee) as well -- just not enough. So nothing intentional. They needed to increase taxes, gasoline was a convenient target because its price was low compared to previous times or something, they didn't want to hurt the (export oriented) industry, so diesel wasn't taxed as much. Individual consumers looked at total cost of ownership of diesel vs. gasoline cars and started buying the diesel one.
- usrusr 7y agoRegulations, at least the European ones, were created with industry input. I believe that they were designed as much as advertisement for replacing perfectly fine existing cars with new ones from the factory as they were designed for actual air quality improvement. Test stand trickery was factored in from the beginning, because basic trickery had already started (for mileage) before emissions regulations entered the picture. Politicians can claim that they have wrestled major concessions from an unwilling industry, the industry feigns a struggle while happily agreeing (as long as nobody looks too hard at the trickery) so that their customers get a free clean conscience with their shiny new car. Repeat a few iterations and the gap between regulatory fiction and reality will be too large to remain unnoticed.
- perfunctory 7y ago> never depend on innovation. Especially specific innovation. This is a little bit exaggerated. How about the Internet? Or GPS?
- bschne 7y agoI think what they mean is not that we should not rely on innovation once it has been achieved and is actually working, but that we shouldn't bet our future on forcing very specific innovation in a certain area/metric as that will just incentivize people to cheat. Similar to Goodhart's Law - "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure" [1] 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- pedrocr 7y agoThis is such a defeatist attitude that lets VW off the hook. We may yet find that everyone was doing it but this isn't it. No one has been found to be doing large-scale cheating like VW so far. And the technology to make diesel cleaner has always been there. The VW scandal is exactly that they cheated to make the cars cheaper by avoiding having extra emissions hardware. Even after all the scrutiny diesel cars are still being sold and as far as we know pass emissions.
- Retric 7y agoNot just hardware but also just using less adblue fluid. That seems even crazier on the surface. Let’s kill a few people so our users don’t have to refill a tank as often.
- legitster 7y agoYeah, I scratch my head on that one. Is a DEF system that expensive for the end user? It seems like it would have been a trivial thing to include.
- DoctorOetker 7y agoI seem to remember that after the VW scandal, at some point the emissions tests were made less stringent "to keep things realistic", so it wouldn't surprise me at all if you are right that >after all the scrutiny diesel cars are still being sold and as far as we know pass emissions.
- pedrocr 7y agoAs far as I know the opposite is true and emission tests have only gotten stricter. The test cycle has been updated to be more realistic[1] and the standard has lowered allowed values across the board[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worldwide_Harmonised_Light_Vehicles_Test_Procedure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worldwide_Harmonised_Light_Veh... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_emission_standards#Emission_standards_for_passenger_cars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_emission_standards#Em...
- OnlyRepliesToBS 7y agon = 2 'further proof'
- nullwasamistake 7y agoThe EPA keeps lowering emissions requirements for future years based on speculation rather than existing tehcnology. IMO it was inevitable for this to happen. You simply can't create a deisel clean enough to meet regulations. While emissions regulations have a noble goal we would be far better off regulating farm equipment, stationary generators, and boats at this point. A single farm tractor or lawn mower pollutes as much as hundreds of cars. A container or cruise ship, many thousands of cars. It reminds me of California approach to water regulations. Squeeze the populace when industry is using 90% of the water.
- carlmr 7y agoIt's kind of like optimizing software without measuring a performance profile. We're optimizing cars for very little gain. While a lot of low hanging fruit isn't measured and could give us much larger gains. We're not looking at the hot-path.
- nullwasamistake 7y agoI think it's because, in the end, with cars you can pass the costs directly to consumers. With industrial and commercial engines you tax business. In our day they have greater political power than voting populace. Same deal with California and water. Easier to force residents to conserve, the businesses using 90% of the water are polically protected
- Arbalest 7y agoWorth keeping in mind that "emissions" targeted are actually somewhat localised. The initiatives are about reducing NOx emissions within the bounds of suburban areas, where it tends to become photochemical smog[0]. Yes CO2 is an issue, but a different issue, and frustratingly, thermal efficiency is correlated with NOx emissions[1], which is why we have these scandals coming up in the first place. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smog#Photochemical_smog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smog#Photochemical_smog [1]https://www.alentecinc.com/papers/NOx/The%20formation%20of%20NOx_files/The%20formation%20of%20NOx.htm https://www.alentecinc.com/papers/NOx/The%20formation%20of%2... Edit: Worth clarifying that thermal efficiency and combustion temperature are also correlated, which is not plainly stated in [1]
- emiliobumachar 7y agoI'll pile on with the others saying this is a bad conclusion. Storing large amounts of cash in bank vaults also creates strong perverse incentives, but we do it and create strong disincentives to practically nullify them.