6 ms·
So I take it it's NOT okay to take your hands off the wheel with Tesla Autopilot? I am not familiar with the technology. The Tesla page on it (https://www.tesl
by jrochkind1 7y ago
So I take it it's NOT okay to take your hands off the wheel with Tesla Autopilot? I am not familiar with the technology.
The Tesla page on it (https://www.tesla.com/autopilot https://www.tesla.com/autopilot) takes a while to get to describing what it does, but then says, among other things:
> Autopilot enables your car to steer, accelerate and brake automatically within its lane.
And:
> With the new Tesla Vision cameras, sensors and computing power, your Tesla will navigate tighter, more complex roads.
So it's steering... but you're supposed to leave your hands on the wheel anyway? But not actually steering, just resting there just in case? I'm not sure how realistic this is in terms of human behavior. To their credit, the page, at least as of this moment, also says:
> Current Autopilot features require active driver supervision and do not make the vehicle autonomous.
Reading just the web page, if you asked me "So, do you need to leave your hands on the wheel when autopilot is engaged on the freeway", I'd be unsure. Does "active driver supervision" mean "hands on the wheel"?
In general, it is very hard for humans to keep paying close attention to something they aren't involved in actually actively controlling, "just in case." I'm not sure if there's a way for this technology to be safe, if that's what it depends on to be safe. (not unique to Tesla).
- URSpider94 7y agoIf you don’t know, you’ll learn pretty quickly when you buy one. If you don’t keep your hands on the wheel, it will flash at you, then beep at you, then stop the car. In reality, once you are used to it, it’s actually quite easy to keep a hand on the wheel while using Autopilot.
- mdorazio 7y ago> In reality, once you are used to it, it’s actually quite easy to keep a hand on the wheel while using Autopilot. ...while you do something other than pay attention. Like take a nap or watch a movie (just search YouTube for Tesla nap).
- zaroth 7y agoI drive on AutoPilot every day. The shit I see other drivers doing on the highway blows my mind. Yesterday a guy was trimming his toes. Bare foot up on the dash and just going at it. Can’t. Unsee. Approximately half of drivers are holding a cellphone on their ear, or yawning with a look of utter exhaustion on their face, occasionally rocking out to some great tunes, which is fun when they catch you watching. None of it is OK, but it is very clearly a universal issue much bigger than AutoPilot.
- mdorazio 7y ago100% agree. Almost as bad for me was a recent conversation with a Tesla owner who said he drives his Model 3 to bars instead of taking Uber since it can take him home when he's drunk. The level to which people are abusing the system is phenomenal.
- revscat 7y agoI fail to see how this isn’t a step forward, though. Given that there will always be a subset of people who drink at bars who will drive themselves home, then the availability of things like Autopilot can only help to reduce overall the number of accidents that occur as a result.
- toast0 7y ago> Yesterday a guy was trimming his toes. Bare foot up on the dash and just going at it. Can’t. Unsee. I had that guy as a Lyft driver once.
- shoo_pl 7y agoIt's not about how easy it is to put your hand on wheel so that it can detect a bit of force (you can use bottle of water to do that). The difficult part is to stay focused when doing that. If you spent 30 minutes driving to work on a highway, and your car was able to drive itself every day for 2 months, how likely are you to take any reasonable action on 3rd month when something unexpecting happens?
- toddmorey 7y agoI think this undersells how easy it is to disengage attention when you are actively driving. The task of driving (especially your commute route) is very mundane.
- mulmen 7y agoSo the problem is the human attention span? Cars without any always-on computer aids such as automatic braking must be really dangerous then.
- Filligree 7y agoDriving a car is absolutely the most dangerous activity most people regularly participate in. I don't think you're saying anything controversial there.
- mulmen 7y agoRight so any time a computer can take over is a good thing because computers don’t get bored.
- makomk 7y agoThat doesn't follow, because making the human supervise the computer as it takes over rather than actively participating increases the risk of them getting bored and losing attention.
- 7y ago
- zaroth 7y agoAs a regular AutoPilot user, it does require active supervision. You need to be looking out the window as it drives you down the highway. It detects minute levels of torque on the wheel, so resting a hand in the wheel is enough to keep it happy. If it doesn’t detect any torque on the wheel it prompts you, and you can touch the wheel or move one of the scrollwheels to let it know you’re paying attention. > In general, it is very hard for humans to keep paying close attention to something they aren't involved in actually actively controlling I hear this a lot without citations, and I would guess it’s not specifically studied in terms of Tesla AutoPilot. But what I can say is that AutoPilot takes the strain away from driving and allows me to focus on higher level planning and situational awareness. I watch the cars around me, I look ahead down the road and check mirrors more frequently. AutoPilot makes driving significantly more pleasant while allowing me to be more aware of potential risks around me. I have no doubt some people choose to disengage. But it is by no means difficult to stay engaged in monitoring the drive, or at all boring. On the contrary, while I’ve many times “zoned out” while driving as simply maintaining position in lane is extremely tedious, I’ve never zoned out while on AutoPilot, because watching the absurd things that the drivers around you are doing never gets old.
- Swizec 7y ago> I watch the cars around me, I look ahead down the road and check mirrors more frequently. I havent tried tesla autopilot yet so I don’t know how much easier it makes driving, but if steering[1] keeps you from doing these things ... should you be on the road at all? If you’re too tired to both steer and maintain situational awareness you should probably take a rest :/ [1] steering, more like keeping the wheel steady on the freeway. Afaik Tesla can’t autopilot on the twisties yet anyway
- Retric 7y agoCognitive load is a real thing. People have a finite ability to multitask especially with similar actions. The only possible approach to driving to to not pay attention to most things as you focus on something specific and then cycle through each activity. Further, when you are forced to pay attention to something specific you must spend less time focusing on other things.
- tjoff 7y agoCorrect. And yes, it is really dangerous and has led to countless unnecessary crashes and several deaths. Humans are not capable of suddenly be required to take control of a vehicle with a split second notice. Hopefully the laws mature enough to prevent these for being road legal.
- double0jimb0 7y agoIf tesla’s autopilot were available to all vehicles for use only on highways (which is where most Tesla owners only use autopilot), the number of highway deaths due to inattentive drivers causing rear-ending accidents would drop to near zero overnight. It is so vastly superior to distracted humans on a highway, it is a “seatbelt” type revolution in terms of human safety. But Tesla doesn’t seem to push this specific use-case resticted angle of it, Musk is focus on full self driving.
- tjoff 7y agoThat is nothing unique to Tesla. If they were serious about full self driving there wouldn't be any reason to bother with autopilot.
- Dylan16807 7y agoI'm amazed that you can agree it would drop rear-endings to near zero, and then immediately say there is no reason to bother with it. Do you think a level 4/5 system would be done already if they hadn't made a level 2?
- tjoff 7y agoThat's not what I said. You can have automatic braking without having such an unsafe system. Other brands do... It isn't ethical, not that I expect them to care. But I don't think a sane company would play so loosely with peoples lives when they are fully dependent on complete trust when they launch something with full automation.
- seanmcdirmid 7y ago> So it's steering... but you're supposed to leave your hands on the wheel anyway? But not actually steering, just resting there just in case? I'm not sure how realistic this is in terms of human behavior. I have an Acura, so no autopilot, but it allows my car to steer, accelerate, and brake automatically within its lane. Also, if I don't apply control to the steering wheel (let alone have my hands off of it) for more than N seconds, it will warn me that it will disengage. The value is then more safety (the car keeps the lane by itself if you don't bother steering for some reason), which does reduce some fatigue, I guess.
- ghufran_syed 7y agoI was worried about the “diffusion of responsibility” issue, so I rented one on Turo for the day and drove around 200 miles on freeways in Northern California. The user interface is really good, you learn pretty quickly the right amount of force to hold the wheel - then you can let it “autosteer”, but taking control is instantaneous, you just make the movement you want and the car disengages autosteer instantly. I probably took over from the car around 10 times that day, mainly in the left-hand lane with the left edge of the freeway marked with 2-foot-high white concrete barriers, it felt like it wanted to go into them. But that might just have been the car trying to drive “properly” in the center of the lane, while I tend to hug the right side in those situations to have a greater margin of error on the left. It definitely reduces the cognitive load, letting you drive better in my opinion. But there isn’t an idiot-sensor in the car, so like every technology, there will be people who abuse it. The interesting question is whether those same idiots would be safer in a regular car, or if, on balance, the “autopilot+idiot” combination is safer - that seems like an empirical question to me. Even at the current level, it’s a great advance on a regular car (I have no idea how it compares to other expensive cars with various assistive technologies, I usually buy super cheap cars...). I also think that if fully autonomous driving is technically possible, then Tesla will be the one to do it - they have several hundred thousand drivers giving them training data in all sorts of weird edge cases every day. It really is worth watching the whole of the recent investor event at Tesla and then deciding what you think of their technology: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ucp0TTmvqOE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ucp0TTmvqOE
- nerdbaggy 7y agoAhh the old Tesla and orange trick https://youtu.be/rOST5S06F-o https://youtu.be/rOST5S06F-o
- dawnerd 7y agoSimilar thing people do with Passats with lane assist: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QV_FcG5NvUU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QV_FcG5NvUU
- ryeights 7y agoIMO stuff like this should be subject to the same safe disclosure procedures as security vulnerabilities. You know a bunch of idiots are going to try this after watching this video and endanger other drivers in the process
- kwhitefoot 7y agoAll very amusing, except that it no longer works.
- xvf22 7y agoOne big problem I continue to see is that the behaviour you get used to can change with a software update and I think that's dangerous. People can naturally let down their guard when things become routine and may be ill prepared to deal with an unexpected change in behaviour from the autopilot.
- pbreit 7y agoIt's OK but they have to tell you not to.
- camjohnson26 7y agoIt’s “Ok” until you’re involved in a fatal accident and Tesla blames you for not having your hands on the wheel. Doesn’t matter that Elon himself has demoed it hands off, each of the autopilot fatalities was the fault of the driver.
- pbreit 7y agoDid you know there are 1.5 million auto-related deaths per year around the world. And in 7 years around 23 associated with Teslas? And none of the autopilot accidents affecting other people?
- camjohnson26 7y agoHow many times does it have to be repeated, those stats compare apples and oranges. Luxury, modern, new vehicles driven by statistically more wealthy drivers have a much lower accident rate than most cars. When corrected for these factors Tesla’s safety rating is abysmal. None of the autopilot accidents affected other people? I guess if by affected you mean fatalities, but 2 of them smashed into tractor trailers, so that definitely affected others. There are multiple reports of Teslas on autopilot running into stationary rescue vehicles as well, thank goodness they haven’t been fatal.
- pbreit 7y ago"Luxury, modern, new vehicles driven by statistically more wealthy drivers". As far as risk aversion, I would say this group and Tesla owners are near opposites. Add in the completely different torque and breaking behavior. A completely different cockpit experience.
- scotty79 7y ago> So it's steering... but you're supposed to leave your hands on the wheel anyway? I do something like that with cruise control. I enable it but I keep my foot resting on the accelerator just in case I have to break suddenly. I'm afraid that if I keep my foot somewhere else, when my reflex kicks in, I won't hit the break pedal.
- ujoh1 7y agoHello visit http://www.virtatrade.com/index.php http://www.virtatrade.com/index.php to start making your steady daily passive incomes now without trading risk.