8 ms·
Can someone explain why in countries with established infrastructure, automation and cheaper capital cost (albeit higher labor cost) the internet cost is around
by dzhiurgis 7y ago
Can someone explain why in countries with established infrastructure, automation and cheaper capital cost (albeit higher labor cost) the internet cost is around 10-20x more than in India?
Additionally, it's often ~5x slower than in 2nd world countries...
- rocgf 7y agoNot sure this applies to everywhere, but I can talk about Romania (Eastern Europe) vs. Western Europe. Romania has some of the best Internet in the world; as far as I recall, you can get 1Gbps for like 10-15 dollars in most non-rural areas. I think that's partly because of the huge amount of competition that was present in the early 00s, when we had a ridiculous amount of ISPs per city, and partly because all the cables are suspended on top of lampposts, as opposed to buried under the sidewalks and streets. That's way cheaper than digging half the city for new, higher-speed Internet.
- krzyk 7y agoAnd also because there was almost no infrastructure to begin with. So when one was created it went straight to fiber, while the western countries still got plenty of copper. Similar thing in Poland (although our network is in worse condition than in Romania, but we still can have 1 Gbps for about 18 USD, even in some rural areas like mine :). I think this is quite similar to the banking sector, we have most of the banks internet ready, some of them are are mostly internet, with very few brick and mortar places. When my colleague went to Switzerland he was shocked how the banks there force one to visit them personally to do even basic stuff (at least in the beginning - in Poland I can create banking account without leaving my home, I just need to wait for package to sign in front of a courier) - and have crappy websites. This is also a leftover of the early internet migration, now they don't have enough incentive to do it better.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoPretty sure there were phone lines just like everywhere. Maybe no cable tho? Back in Lithuania cable was installed everywhere in early 90s, but cable internet didn’t catch on. P.S. saw an ad here the other day - €3/week for 1TB of LTE data.
- vmurthy 7y agoOne factor that helps operators in India is the massive subscriber base. Nearly a billion people ought to spread the high fixed costs of telco infra to a decent point.
- Wohlf 7y agoBecause labor costs are by far the biggest expense for companies.
- Mvhsz 7y agoand real estate is up there too. right-of-way for fiber and renting rooftops for base stations is a major telcom cost driver.
- jbarham 7y agoMobile data in Canada is notoriously expensive. The official justification is that it's a large, sparsely populated country. The actual explanation is regulatory capture by a cozy/corrupt domestic oligopoly that has successfully lobbied the government to stop foreign competitors. Like Canada, Australia is also a very large, sparsely populated country but mobile data is fast and reasonably priced (e.g., https://www.aldimobile.com.au/plans/value-packs/ https://www.aldimobile.com.au/plans/value-packs/, which I use).
- vijaybritto 7y agoWhen I worked on a project for Rogers I was shocked and surprised to see the prices they charge. Oh and the never ending confusion in those family plans! Hated that work!
- kalleboo 7y agoI remember visiting Canada (this was many years ago) and looking into local prepaid SIM cards. The cost of roaming data was actually cheaper than the data pricing on the local prepaid SIM cards...
- Scoundreller 7y agoIt’s very embarrassing as a Canadian when foreigners visit and do things with their phones here that I wouldn’t dream of doing myself on a local plan. Time for me to email my MP tonight.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoEven Telstra is offering 60GB / month for $49 https://www.telstra.com.au/mobile-phones/sim-only-plans https://www.telstra.com.au/mobile-phones/sim-only-plans I’d be all over that but it says the plan is only available for new services and I’m rather fond of my mobile number.
- aditnryn 7y agoDoes Australia not have mobile number portability?
- skybrian 7y agoTotal guess, but it seems like labor cost will do it? It drives up acquisition costs for getting customers. Combine with many customers not being very motivated to reduce costs, which both increases acquisition costs and reduces the downside from charging more.
- the_duke 7y agoComparing dollar prices in isolation makes almost no sense. You need to at least look at average/median monthly income and compare via some normalized metric, like a variant of Purchasing Power Parity [1] . Even if you do this, comparisons are hard. Completely different economies, market structures and target groups, subsidies, taxation, regulation, etc can all have a big effect. Looking at India, it has a GDP per Capita that's 1/8 of the US, and an average monthly income of 150$! That should give you a measure for how 10$ in India are very different from 10$ in the US. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purchasing_power_parity
- bildung 7y agoAbsolutely correct to note his, but e.g. Germany is above the USA in that PPP list, but for €8 I get 3GB of data and unlimited phone calls and sms.
- hailk 7y agoTheoretically this might be true, but Jio revolution is real in India. Even extremely poor blue collar workers have good internet data.
- Dylan16807 7y agoIf things are competitive, it makes more sense to look at cost than PPP-adjusted price. PPP is an overall metric that doesn't always apply to specific items; it's not like the price of an iPhone is any different in India. And GP gives a pretty fair list of things that influence cost.
- belltaco 7y ago>Looking at India, it has a GDP per Capita that's 1/8 of the US Okay, then lets multiply Indian prices by 8. Someone up the thread quoted this: >For 6 dollars 50 cents, you get 1.5 GB/day for 91 days. Where in the US can I get 1.5GB/day for 91 days for $52 ? Before someone talks about congestion, this is India, with 1.3 Billion people and "third world" infrastructure. If that kind of bandwidth can be provided to that many folks where people are routinely using it to watch TV channels (see Jio TV), why can't we do it here? I think congestion and data caps are just excuses to wring more money.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoBecause they can charge more, so they do.
- sharadov 7y agoI think this may have to do with density, India is 1/4 the size of the US and has 4X the population.
- baybal2 7y agoI once used a 200Gb per month plan on China Telecom in Pakistan. I regretted buying it as it would need few days downloading things non stop to reach exhaust that plan.
- tellme_throwa 7y agoIndia is a relatively cheap country to live in. You earn less & you spend less. And service isn't that stellar. They say 4G but 400 KiB/s is average IMO. I am from rural india & used net before that on lowend J2ME phones, which was around 10 KiB/s. Having said that, jio has done a great job, where otherwise 1GiB of 2G data cost >$5.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 7y agoBecause they have fixed-line internet infrastructure they want to sell you too. Break apart the fixed line business from the wireless business and you’ll see one crush the other.
- AFascistWorld 7y agoCheap equipment and population density, dealing with Indian companies is like testing your patience with their never-ending bid to seek even lower prices.
- southerndrift 7y agoYou have to pay rent for antennas. That's directly correlated to local price levels.