5 ms·
> It wasn’t a project without its obstacles. After stripping the backseat and the trunk of its many parts, the Model 3 refused to start. Ramirez explained that
by falcolas 7y ago
> It wasn’t a project without its obstacles. After stripping the backseat and the trunk of its many parts, the Model 3 refused to start. Ramirez explained that the car was reporting “all of its many faults” to Tesla headquarters via cell connection, or essentially “snitching” on the YouTubers who were trying to modify it.
I started the article expecting to see this. That said, I'm glad Tesla was good enough to "certify" their changes. I'm also curious what it took to get around the software lockdown; any links or pointers?
- VectorLock 7y agoIt leaves a bad taste in my mouth that you can pay so much for an object and you essentially don't truly own it and can't do whatever you want with it without it phoning home and asking permission from its true owners who can capriciously brick your device for any reason they want.
- Drdrdrq 7y agoThis is the sole reason why I would never think about "owning" (if you can call it that) a Tesla.
- naikrovek 7y agoDo you think you "own" the car you drive now? You don't. Not since cars came with any computers at all has anyone fully owned their vehicle. I don't see a problem with this, in most cases, and I only sort of understand why people get upset about it. It's simple and easy (and fully legal in most states) to just design and build your own vehicle to your own specifications, provided you meet minimum requirements regarding road worthiness. You certainly can truly own your own commercially available car if you're willing to hire a lawyer, negotiate, and pay for a license that includes whatever it is that crosses the threshold into whatever a given person considers true ownership. And I can tell you immediately that this license will cost you at least 50 times the list price of that vehicle, will not be a transferable license, and you will not be allowed to sublicense it. It's not that you can't own your car, it's that no one is willing to pay for true ownership, because it is entirely impractical and unimportant to fully own a car in today's world.
- thatcat 7y agoAn ECU is not typically remotely controlled and updated. You can also replace an ECU, to one with more control so that you can fine tune performance. For cars that do have that feature, I doubt hiring lawyers will change anything. No one is obligated to sell you anything.
- naikrovek 7y agoYou can't adjust it. If you can, you can't see the code, you can only modify data already compiled in.
- thatcat 7y agoYea maybe you're right and you can only partially modify it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- arthur_pryor 7y agohearsay from my car enthusiast friends and this cursory internet search contradict that claim. https://duckduckgo.com/?q=modify+ECU&t=ffab&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=modify+ECU&t=ffab&ia=web
- freeone3000 7y agoYou can swap out the entire thing if you want and do a reflash. It's not a beginner job but it's also not impossible, or illegal (if it still meets emissions, but that's on you)
- perl4ever 7y agoYou can replace the entire thing with a compatible and programmable module, if people care enough to develop one. There are now cars from the 80s that are modern enough to have computers, but old enough that the ECUs are starting to deteriorate, and still appreciated enough that people repair or replace them. Example: (not an endorsement and I have no experience with this product) http://roguetuning.com/rogue_tuning_ecu http://roguetuning.com/rogue_tuning_ecu
- falcolas 7y agoBased off their actions in the past, Tesla will do as much as they legally can to avoid bad press due to accidents in a Tesla. And if you are in a publicly covered accident, you can be sure that data will be used against you in the court of public opinion (see "he took his hands off the wheel prior to the accident" comment from Tesla about the gore-impact fatality).
- toomuchequate 7y agoThat is the PR reason. The real reason is aftermarket changes/repairs/services. Tesla wants 100% of that business, reminds me of Apple.
- falcolas 7y agoThey can have more than one business reason. And the PR side of things has been critical of late.
- r00fus 7y agoThey both have the same schtick - create a walled garden then restrict access. It results in predictable outcomes: * products that are beautiful and in some ways without peer * key parts/issues are only addressable through their service channel * exclusivity of membership for better/worse. * higher profit margins and healthy overall profit despite lower market share
- Scoundreller 7y agoYour Apple will still turn on if you create a Franken-book (as long as you can get drivers). They won’t sell you spare parts, but if you find some, you’re ok. This does prop up resale values to some degree (for parts donors). Although Apple is going down the Tesla road slowly (the fingerprint reader is married to the logic board on newer models).
- c0vfefe 7y agoI'm glad for the sake of the future of electric vehicles that Tesla is retaining so much control, but as a customer/user I'd rather wait until more open options can come down the path Tesla's blazing.
- avgDev 7y agoRead about new farming equipment. In US there are hackers who are hacking farming equipment, so farmers can do their own repairs. This is basically where car manufacturers will eventually try to go and it is kinda what Tesla does.
- Phillipharryt 7y agoJust going to hop in and give a bit more information regarding this situation. I assume you're referring to John Deere and their attempts to stop anyone accessing the software on their machinery. The situation is complicated because John Deere leases out a lot of their equipment in a financial lease (they do operating leases too but they're not affected by this). In this sort of lease the ownership is technically with the lessee. So I can see the reason John Deere wants to stop people who legally own their tractor from tampering with software. It's still a lease and at the end of it John Deere might get back a working tractor (depending on the life of the lease), so they don't want it to have been used in any way that could damage it. It's a legal protection and I don't think it's as malicious as every journalist and commenter tries to say it is. If you look into their financials you'll see they have 10s of billions of dollars in machinery out that is leased out, they're just trying to protect it.
- arthur_pryor 7y agopresumably they have to do some refurbishing and rehab when they get it back anyway. why not re-flash all the software then? or, somewhat more draconian, add in explicit penalties for people who tamper with leased vehicles, with a contract clause to that effect? i mean, i don't doubt that the concern you mention might be part of it. but it sure is also a convenient way to lock people out of servicing their own stuff. and i doubt they're eager to give people the ability to service their own equipment without a strong public demand for that ability. so the public should keep demanding that (as opposed to relying on the altruism of a large corporation).
- sangnoir 7y ago> That said, I'm glad Tesla was good enough to "certify" their changes. So, when you buy a Tesla, do you actually own the car? Is there any legal precedence if they brick your car if they don't like what you're doing to/with it? Or do you sign this away by agreeing to Tesla's EULA?
- falcolas 7y agoYou own the car (the hardware), and lease the software. The fact that the hardware is incapable of running witoutu the software (which is constantly phoning home to Tesla) is where you run into problems. Tesla historically doesn't want bad press due to accidents caused by "bad physical changes", and so carefully control it. To get a Tesla back up and running once it's been "salvaged" has historically required a full inspection by a Tesla approved shop.
- gambiting 7y agoThe thing that really grinds my gears is that they sell cars in certain specs which have the hardware for something, but you can't use it without paying extra. Like....you can buy one which physically does have heated seats, but you can't use them unless you pay for the option. I just wonder if wiring in a physical switch to turn on the heating is considered piracy?
- RussianCow 7y ago> I just wonder if wiring in a physical switch to turn on the heating is considered piracy? It's not piracy, but Tesla can (hypothetically) decide to prevent your car from turning on if they find out what you're doing.
- asdff 7y agoIt's probably a matter of time before someone starts jailbreaking teslas, turning off the phoning home, turning on heated seats, etc.
- 7y ago
- rmason 7y agoOne thing missing from her story. Did she pay cash for the Model 3? Because if she's making bank payments on her new Tesla I'm not sure she legally can cut it up. I'm not saying that what she's done isn't amazing. But if her bank learns what she's done they will not I would think be very happy.
- pachevjoseph 7y agoI would imagine a youtuber of her caliber would expense this as a business purchase. I doubt she took a loan for this.
- karthikb 7y agoDepends on the loan. In general, you can modify whatever you want with a car under loan but NOT under lease. However, modifications usually mean your car is worth less and you have a higher chance of being underwater, so could result in an additional financial liability in the case of a repo.
- dkarras 7y agoShe makes anywhere between $18k - $30k per month from patreon alone, on top of her youtube revenue. I think she's well past being burdened by such issues.