6 ms·
> I know it's nearby on galactic scales but it's practically about 450,000 Earth years away with current technology :-) If we had the political will, the Orion
by lmm 7y ago
> I know it's nearby on galactic scales but it's practically about 450,000 Earth years away with current technology :-)
If we had the political will, the Orion design could get people there in, what, 200 years, and that's with '70s technology.
- acidburnNSA 7y agoAre you talking about the propulsion system where a series of nuclear explosions push the vessel along? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propuls...
- tictoc 7y agoImagine being the child born on the ship on a crash course to this new planet.
- onemoresoop 7y agoAnd imagine you're the first ship to arrive only to find out a) that the planet is not habitable and there were some wrong assumptions about it b) that the planet is already occupied by a different form of life and there's no warm welcome to us
- krisrm 7y agoSounds like the premise of Aurora! Which definitely turned me off the idea of multi generational starship travel. It's not ethical.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- corodra 7y agoThis is also assuming A) Human engineering can create something that can last 200+ years of space travel. We don't even build houses anymore that can feasibly last 100 years. 2) People don't go mad and kill each other or do a mutiny III) Any number of stray objects from asteroids to rogue planets that just slams into the ship and causes major malfunctions d) Food and life support sustainability I mean... there are SOOOOOOOO many more problems than actual politics. This is where, and it hurts me to say this, the politicians are right to say "are you insane?".
- onemoresoop 7y agoOf course we’re far from it, if ever possible. I was just being playful on the whole premise of “colonizing” another earthlike planet
- corodra 7y agoOh, I'm not bashing you at all. You're absolutely correct. You bring up extremely important things to realize when discussing space travel. Especially long term missions. Political will being the reason why these missions haven't happened, as someone else mentioned, is total crap. It's just an easy excuse to not think of ACTUAL consequences and live in a scifi fantasy.
- gutnor 7y ago> If we had the political will It takes more than that. We need political maturity and stability. There is no way we can send people today on a 200 years journey and be sure they will both make it and be able to create a somewhat stable society on the other side. Also, that would be a earth level effort, another thing that is seriously irrealistic right now. The very best we can achieve right now is the ISS and that's pathetic even compared to current tech. The biggest push in recent years has been around privatisation of space exploration. It is going to take decades, probably centuries before a commercial model of space settles down and non-profit utopist project like that would be conceivable.
- brianbreslin 7y agoWould a vessel from 50 years from now beat the original crew there? If we assume we are advancing speed-wise by X% each year, the poor folks sent and likely put into cryo-stasis would get lapped by people who left 10 years or 25 years after them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kjs3 7y agoThere are a number of SF stories where this is the plot.
- booleandilemma 7y agoImagine waking up out of your cryo-stasis and seeing humans already living on the planet you were sent to colonize? That would be weird, to say the least.
- Moxdi 7y agoI bet there's a science fiction novel about that
- brianbreslin 7y ago
- Retra 7y agoYou could get their corpses there, sure.
- corodra 7y agoJust got to make sure we put on the side of the ship, "Greetings from Earth!" "They sent us a space ship full of corpses?" "Must be an intergalactic message of war." That's almost as bad as receiving an unlabeled box with a copy of Misery in it.
- DCKing 7y agoThe Orion program had this potential on paper. Nuclear bomb propulsion is a complicated thing, but we don't understand if it's a feasible propulsion method in practice, like, at all. Political will in this case brings us more understanding of the feasibility of this propulsion method, but it's way too big of a stretch that political will alone would get us to the nearest starts in 200 years.
- techdragon 7y agoActually we do know it would work. The fundamental physics are sound. A pusher plate can in fact transfer net positive momentum from a series of explosive shockwaves detonated aft of the pusher plate in the desired direction of travel. There’s plenty of video footage from the Hot Rod tests showing it working. https://youtu.be/Q8Sv5y6iHUM https://youtu.be/Q8Sv5y6iHUM The hot rod test article was actually donated to the national air and space museum unfortunately it is not currently on display. https://airandspace.si.edu/collection-objects/propulsion-test-vehicle-project-orion https://airandspace.si.edu/collection-objects/propulsion-tes... And for the realities of scaling up from conventional explosives to nuclear detonations you can read a little more here http://www.spacedaily.com/news/nuclearspace-03h.html http://www.spacedaily.com/news/nuclearspace-03h.html and http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/realdesigns2.php http://www.projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/realdesigns2.ph... (scroll down till you get tot project Orion and they have a pretty good summary) And the Project Rho information has links to lots of the technical details and material as well if you want to learn a lot more.
- r00fus 7y agoThe propulsion could work. What about sustaining life for 200 year biospehere without any external resources? What about interstellar debris? What about deceleration? And that's just the feasibility of the colony ship, then there's colonization/terraforming, etc. I'd be thrilled to see such an effort take shape, but to say "it would work" has marginal relevance to "the project is feasible".
- corodra 7y ago"What if I told you that your family and your next 4 generations of offspring will live on a space ship that'll hopefully reach a distant planet without encountering a massive malfunction due to age or some cosmic phenomenon that'll kill you all? And if that planet is habitable for human life, hopefully it won't have terrifyingly violent lifeforms that'll rape you in the mouth so they can reproduce. Are you interested, very interested or quite interested?" It's a slightly wee bit more than political will that stops people from wanting to live in a tin can for their entire lives, and their children from living on it...and their grandchildren. All for a "maybe".
- kerabatsos 7y agoMouth rape sounds disagreeable.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post like this here.
- marcosdumay 7y agoIf I remember it correctly, the fast project would make 4 light years in ~150 years. So that would be 450 years (probably less, because it's on constant acceleration).
- dragonwriter 7y ago> If I remember it correctly, the fast project would make 4 light years in ~150 years. 133, but that's getting there as a missile (one-way acceleration, no turnover and decel to relative rest.)
- jtolmar 7y agoIf you enjoy the idea of propelling space ships using nuclear explosions, look up nuclear salt-water rockets (NSWRs, or Zubrin Drives). The idea is to dump pipes full of sub-critical amounts of radioactive salts out engine, combining outside the ship in a continuous nuclear explosion.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> If we had the political will, the Orion design could get people there in, what, 200 years, and that's with '70s technology. No,the version of Orion that is mostly an integration challenge over 1970s tech would take almost 7 times that long to get to Alpha Centauri as a missile (i.e., without turnover to decelerate to relative rest.) The even more speculative version was estimated to cut that by a factor for ten to only 133 years, but that's still to a target 1/3 the distance of this one, and still without deceleration.