4 ms·
The bright side of Google's anti-ad-blocking efforts is that ad-blocking is clearly no longer just an insignificant blip on their radar. There must be enough u
by pmoriarty 7y ago
The bright side of Google's anti-ad-blocking efforts is that ad-blocking is clearly no longer just an insignificant blip on their radar. There must be enough users of ad-blockers now to start to significantly affect their bottom line.
There might even be a critical mass of people who are against advertising to attempt to make some legal headway on this issue in Washington. Just as there has been legal action against telemarketers, there might be something on the legal front that can be done against online advertisers, who could be considered just as much or even more of a nuisance than telemarketers ever were. In addition, online advertising has repeatedly been a vector of malware, and perhaps companies which try to circumvent or forbid ad-blockers could have some legal consequences -- and, if not, perhaps laws could be introduced to make such consequences a reality.
IANAL, and this is just a pipe dream of mine at the moment -- but plenty of pro-consumer legislation has been made over the years. Perhaps the dawn of an unsolicited-advertising-free world is upon us.
- PostOnce 7y agoI would think it's more likely they legislate against us, i.e. making it a crime to circumvent advertising (see: circumventing DRM).
- pepr 7y agoYou wouldn't download a car, you wouldn't block an ad! :)
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAs always: I would download a car if I could :).
- vimslayer 7y agoFun fact: the line of the ad was twisted by internet people for meming purposes. The actual line is "You wouldn't steal a car".
- rusk 7y agoI always thought a good answer to this was "well I'd think about copying a car if I could..." How sweet would that be? Friend gets a car, I make a copy of it at zero cost! I guess the standard answer to that would be "but you're depriving the manufacturer of money to cover the costs of providing the car in the first place" Which is reasonable, but I'd have to question their business model if their manufacturing costs are so high and yet I can copy it for free ...
- TeMPOraL 7y agoNah, the standard answer isn't reasonable. They're depriving themselves of that money by choosing a business model that matches neither the customer needs nor physical reality. In hopes it'll one day turn into a catchphrase: no one is entitled to have a particular business model working for them forever.
- rusk 7y agoIn fairness I'd give them that much. There is a quid pro quo between me having a need, and a business providing that need. If it's not commercially viable for a business to then perhaps my need may go unfulfilled. What irks me is that such a gracious outlook leaves me open to being gouged by profiteers. So copying it is!
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 7y agoDMCA was hard to get people upset about. It was all new stuff that most people didn't understand or care about. This was before Napster, even. People clearly care about net neutrality, and they would/do also care about browser ad blocking. At this point it's clear to people what the issue is and how it affects them. Taking something away from people is much more painful than preventing them from getting it in the first place. Even if there could be enough lobbying pressure to seriously propose such a law, it would be deeply unpopular and have difficulty passing.
- Valmar 7y agoYep, this is what greedy corporations are willing to do to protect their profit margins.
- lone_haxx0r 7y agoI wish them good luck with that.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoIt's already copyright infringement. In USA Fair Use probably does the necessary; but in UK I'm pretty sure it's infringing (you've modified the work without permission).
- leeter 7y agoI believe they tried, but it basically never made it out of committee as it's basically the same as banning people from using a highlighter on a book. It became very very clear that not only was it not enforceable but trying to go after the people supplying the adblocker would run into serious human rights issues.
- Rychard 7y ago> The bright side of Google's anti-ad-blocking efforts is that ad-blocking is clearly no longer just an insignificant blip on their radar. There must be enough users of ad-blockers now to start to significantly affect their bottom line. I think the issue is that shareholders want to see significant year-over-year growth, something that isn't sustainable in the long-term. We're merely being seen as an untapped market than can keep the needle moving for a few more years. I like capitalism, but I think it's entirely unreasonable for shareholders to expect such gains in perpetuity. After all, there's a finite amount of money that can be extracted from any user. The trendline will inevitably start to level off after a period of time, and I'm frustrated by the fact that this eventuality has negative connotations associated with it.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoHere's a thing: the shareholders may very well know not to expect gains in perpetuity, but surely something could be done to boost growth just this last time? Given how much money is at stake, plenty of extreme things can be done before the particular growth source is exhausted. And we all have to suffer the collateral damage.
- stevekemp 7y ago> There must be enough users of ad-blockers now to start to significantly affect their bottom line. I host a bunch of websites, and about five years ago I stuck adsense adverts on them. Due to the decent traffic I was earning about £80/month and that was stable for 3-4 years. This year, and last year, I instead earned about £100/year, despite having much more traffic/visitors, and more "aged content". When I get a chance I'll rebuild all the sites and drop the adverts. Adblockers - which I use myself - have rendered them almost pointless.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoSimilar for my blog/site (>20 years old). But, it used to pay me my hosting costs + a computer component upgrade. Now I get a few pence here and there, an order of magnitude less. So now it costs me to run it (excluding time considerations of course) whilst before it paid for itself. Also with sites like Stack Exchange I tend to use them for what I blogged before (computer fixes mainly), so most of my new content nowadays is UGC on other people's sites too. Personal stuff goes on Facebook, on the whole.
- newman8r 7y agoYou can always do a direct ad deal if it's the right niche. Better privacy for your users and it's impossible to block.
- MrGilbert 7y ago> [...] and it's impossible to block. That's not entirely true. Troy Hunt had (and still has) that[1], and his banner got added to EasyList none the less. [1]: https://www.troyhunt.com/ad-blockers-are-part-of-the-problem/ https://www.troyhunt.com/ad-blockers-are-part-of-the-problem...
- literallycancer 7y agoSo he added an ad to his site and it got added to a list of ads. What's noteworthy here, besides the fact that he doesn't understand what ad blockers are for? This is the whole point of those filter lists. Otherwise I would have to remove his ad manually, which is undesirable.
- Causality1 7y agoThey're more likely to outlaw adblocking than they are outlaw advertising. Frankly I fear we're nearing the end of a golden age, where those in the know have an incredibly easy time blocking ads with a simple extension while our content providers are funded by the ignorant tech commoners watching ads. I don't want a future where ads are baked right into the YouTube video stream and articles refuse to load until they get confirmation the ads have been downloaded from an ad server.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThis is a problem for the advertisers, they don’t want their most valuable prospects walled off by adblockers. My guess is we will see much more sponsored content as a response to this.
- feanaro 7y agoWe are not helpless in this and we should not just lie down and accept our fate. On what grounds and by what rationale could adblockers be possibly outlawed? If you cannot answer this question reasonably, then please don't even mention this as a reasonable possibility.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoLobbying from the advertisers? I personally don’t think it’s very likely, for one thing I expect most of the staff at the likes of Google run an adblocker.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe funding to produce the media people want to consume has to come from somewhere. If it’s not baked into the video stream, it will be baked into the video itself, aka product placement. Watch any new movie or TV show, and it’s unbearable to see the videography just to catch a car logo or drink logo. Shame. There’s even been full on descriptions by the actors of a car’s features, basically a commercial within the dialogue of the media. My solution is to stop consuming it, not that I consumed a lot to begin with, but there’s no other option.