8 ms·
Load-Bearing Internet People
- ForHackernews 7y ago> As final and obvious point: yes, I think I’m a worthy LBIP, go ahead and do that $10 thing at me, > Google+ Haha, when was this written? Is this just him begging for money? This is going to sound harsh, but has Eric Raymond done anything except whine about feminists in the last 20 years? I'm sure he's an interesting guy, but absolutely not a "load-bearing" anything. The OpenSSL maintainers -- those are "load-bearing internet people"!
- thinkingemote 7y ago3 minutes after your comment was posted there is no link to Google+. There is a link to patreon.
- ForHackernews 7y agoThe signature line is a Google+ link. I was making fun of it because Google+ is over now and that link goes to a shutdown page. (Hence "when was this written?")
- dfrage 7y agoPeople who follow his blog will be familiar with at least some of the following: http://www.catb.org/~esr/software.html http://www.catb.org/~esr/software.html Some distance down the list is reposurgeon, which has been used to convert Gnu Emacs and many smaller/younger repositories to git, and is in the process of converting GCC: http://esr.ibiblio.org/?tag=reposurgeon http://esr.ibiblio.org/?tag=reposurgeon Not directly software: http://www.catb.org/~esr/projects.html http://www.catb.org/~esr/projects.html
- cromulent 7y agoI'm not trying to be argumentative, but I'm just curious - what on that list is "a critical Internet service or library"?
- dfrage 7y agoSecond item from the top: > gpsd > gpsd is a service daemon that monitors a GPS attached to a serial or USB port, decodes the position/velocity/time information it sends, and republishes in a simple uniform format on an IANA-designated TCP/IP port. This enables multiple applications to read from a GPS without contention. The distribution also provides C and Python libraries to encapsulate the client side of talking with gpsd. From the core team page on the following project (https://ntpsec.org/core-team.html https://ntpsec.org/core-team.html), with at least one falsifiable claim: > Eric S. Raymond has been the technical lead of GPSD, a close peer project of NTP and one of its principal time sources, since 2004. GPSD has billions of deployments in Android smartphones world wide and is a mission-critical component in most of the world’s drones and driverless cars and robot submarines. The top item, where he's also the technical lead: > NTPsec > A stripped down-security-hardened and generally improved version of the NTP reference code. Features code bulk reduced by a factor of 4, better monitoring and diagnostic tools, and Network Time Security. Aspires to become one, but it's early in the process to see if it'll succeed. Those are projects I've vaguely followed over the years. Reading down the list, this claims to be one, and the claim is partially falsifiable: > giflib > The ubiquitous service library for rendering GIFs. I handed off the project 1994 to avoid problems with the U.S. patent system, but accepted back the lead in 2012. This code had the odd effect of making me virtually omnipresent; it seems nobody has ever bothered to write a replacement, and it's now ubiquitous in web browsers, cellphones and gaming consoles. In a nicely ironic touch, it earned me an appearance in the credits of the Microsoft XBox.
- cromulent 7y agoSincerely: Thanks for your detailed reply, I'm more knowledgeable now :)
- dfrage 7y agoA perfectly cromulent reply, you're welcome. :-)
- KirinDave 7y agoGPSD was historically an important project, but I wouldn't call it "load bearing" in the same sense as core networking or service contributions. It's also increasingly less important as the changes dropped in 4.19 are picked up by downstream software authors. Most software installations that care about gps are deployed in SBC configurations. A lot of other folks (e.g., hobbyists with external microcontrollers or arm SBCs) are parsing directly. Folks most interested in linux attached hardware are either older school hardware hackers (who rely on this project) or folks using new LoRa radios (in which case that stuff is in the card and annoyingly locked down because it's part of some LoRa monetization schemes). Sooooo yes. Not a bullshit project. But no, not a ILBS project.
- KirinDave 7y agoBut none of these are within the implicit scope of "Internet Load Bearing Software" though, are they? We're aware of his prior involvement with ILBS, but he hasn't been sharp in that game for a long time now.
- dfrage 7y agoNTPsec aspires to be "Internet Load Bearing Software".
- KirinDave 7y agoWell good luck to them. One day the might be. But I think ESR's point about recognizing how load bearing individuals and small groups are being crushed in the wave of monetizable internet growth is a good point. We should folks on people currently in that position.
- gravypod 7y agoI'm also pretty sure that if these incentives were in place we would see a lot of engineers switch to these really interesting tasks. No one wants to shovel http requests back and forth, they want to build things. I think a lot of internet, and software, infrastructure is more compelling work than what most high level engineers work on.
- thrwayxyz 7y agoIt is but the number of people who can understand it's value is inversely proportional to the interest of the work. I had to setup a TAI server for a trading company I worked in because no other time mechanism could record the trades happening reliably without duplicates. I would have been interested in making it a universal service. It would take me an hour long presentation to explain to other programmers with a physics background why this was absolutely essential. I can't imagine ever convincing a suit as to why they should pay for it.
- nitrogen 7y agoI can't imagine ever convincing a suit as to why they should pay for it. ...no other time mechanism could record the trades happening reliably without duplicates. Start with the core value added, describe the world with and without in cost/benefit terms, and work from there.
- thrwayxyz 7y agoMy opportunity cost is a mid six figure salary vs the hustle of trying to sell something that can be copied very easily by others. Not worth my time or effort any more.
- NickBusey 7y agoPersonally I think the problem with a lot of these kind of Patreon setups is they are generally pitched as "I once wrote some very useful software, and sometimes I maintain it." While that's great and all, for me at least it doesn't justify why I should send them money every month. I think the Open Source model needs to evolve, and if these people want monthly income, they should be "showing their work" a lot more. Put out a regular (weekly or more often) YouTube or blog series. Maybe stream your work on Twitch (like I do :) ). Provide some active community involvement. Then I would be far more inclined to donate to someone, rather than having to wonder all the time if I'm paying for them to work on this stuff, or if I'm paying them so they can go on an extra vacation next year for work they completed years ago and have mostly ignored since then.
- cs02rm0 7y agoI had similar thoughts about how they could use YouTube or something equivalent to open access a little in return. Grow the cake and all that. I then had quick Google and it seems a few years back some were seeing a conflict between ESR's Internet Civil Engineering Institute and something called the Core Infrastructure Initiative[1] which it seems is pulling in millions. Perhaps it just lost out. [1] https://www.coreinfrastructure.org https://www.coreinfrastructure.org
- thrwayxyz 7y agoThese people are not entertainers. Demand they post their work on YouTube makes as much sense as demanding architects use smoke signals to communicate their progress.
- erikpukinskis 7y agoThey could just stream work sessions on Twitch, answer questions from a handful of viewers. It doesn’t need to be a big production.
- cs02rm0 7y agoThey're not entertainers, there should be no demands. But I'd think talking a little about their interesting work might serve to better convey what they do to those who are aware of it and reach a wider audience. What ESR has tried obviously hasn't worked, would a half hour chat about their work once a year or a twitch session, or whatever else really make no sense under any circumstance?
- wbl 7y agoSome of the examples are people who are actively harmful. Harlan Stern is the reason NTP WG is so dysfunctional as he insists that his implementation and his private plans are more important then what everyone else wants, and the WG exists to ratify his plans.
- toyg 7y agoWell, it is ESR speaking...
- dfrage 7y agoWho just happens to be the tech lead to a partial answer to this problem: http://ntpsec.org/ http://ntpsec.org/ Which implicitly criticizes the reference implementation.
- tptacek 7y agoAs I understand it, NTPsec, a hostile fork of ntpd, is not a well-regarded project. Look at the "project accomplishments" page and see what they don't claim to have accomplished: the elimination, prior to publication, of any vulnerabilities in a msinstream/default ntpd configuration. They reorganized a bunch of code, swapped strcpy's (and strncpy's) with strlcpy, moved the project out of Bitkeeper (something that has nothing to do with security but is the first listed achievement on the site), and generally removed stuff nobody enables in ntpd. Before it lost funding, Raymond was openly discussing rewriting the whole thing in Go, which sort of gives the lie to the idea that the project was operating in good faith.
- dfrage 7y agoAccusing ESR and the rest of the NTPsec project of fraud is a very serious claim. Could you explain in more detail why contemplating rewriting of most or all of the project in Go as he was learning the language is such a definitive tell?
- 7y ago
- harryh 7y agoThe idea that ESR is a LBIP is laughable. Do not give this horrible person your hard earned money.
- _vertigo 7y agoI’m out of the loop, why do you say he’s a horrible person?
- KirinDave 7y agoIt's sort of out of scope so let's not dwell on his slow descent into predictably cantankerous obscurity. You can descend into his blogs, sword and torch in hand, ready to do ideological combat with the horrors from beyond the stars that lurk there on your own time. The key idea: that he is an ILBP (or has been in 10 years) is absurd. He is not, and he claims he's not hurting for money.
- dfrage 7y ago> The key idea: that he is an ILBP (or has been in 10 years) is absurd. He is not.... This attitude denies support to projects like NTPsec, for which he's the technical lead, your take on this concept only applies to current maintainers of existing projects. Even then, he's converting GCC to git, the latter indirectly bears a great deal of "Internet Load".
- KirinDave 7y agoI deny support for NTPsec specifically because I think it's an idea who's time has passed and now soldiers on because of inertia rather than good sense. It's sort of a meme that any project ending in "sec" is vestigal. So no: they don't get my support. Why would they? Same with DNSsec. Useless project, please desist.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- praptak 7y agoWhat software for a critical internet service or a library does ESR maintain? I checked his Wikipedia entry and have not found anything.
- cromulent 7y agoI asked the same question and dfrage gave a great answer: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20195743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20195743
- plorkyeran 7y agoESR's whole life has been spent pointing at people who actually do important things and saying "I'm with them", and he's done it so much that people assume that it must be true.
- QuadrupleA 7y agoIn spite of all its amazing aspects, one obvious drawback of the open source movement is that it devalues a lot of stuff that you could once build a business around and support a lot of people making a living. Category after category of software businesses have declined in the face of great free alternatives - OS's, languages and compilers, server software, databases. Tears for Larry Ellison aside, I do feel social systems / economies work best when there's a mutual exchange of value, a win-win rather than a win-lose, and the classic simple payment in exchange for software has a certain fairness and sanity to it. E.g. the iOS app store was a lot nicer and high quality before ad-supported / in-app purchases became the norm. Anyway something like ESR proposes here seems promising. I'm not an open source maintainer myself (except for my magnum opus https://github.com/QuadrupleA/private-secure-sharing-buttons https://github.com/QuadrupleA/private-secure-sharing-buttons) but seems like a lot of important-project maintainers find themselves in a demanding position with little reward besides ego-stroking or future promise of job opportunities to make money elsewhere.
- trevyn 7y agoThe value of everything approaching zero is a signal of a post-scarcity world, which seems like a good thing, even if it requires some adjustment.
- jackyinger 7y agoIf the useful open source software development work was not scarce these maintainers would certainly not be under immense pressure. To boot, the entire idea of post scarcity is preposterous. Until the theorized heat death of the universe, there will always be uneven distribution of resources and some things that are better than others.
- mattmanser 7y agoI think it's more because there's a lot of software that's too cheap to charge for, but has too many edge cases for the average programmer to get right. Logging is a perfect example, server-side logs are all handled by free frameworks (too cheap to charge for, but everyone needs it), but client-side is often handled by companies (just complex enough to make money on). The former is often handled by LBIPs like Eric, where-as the latter is either written in house (usually badly) or you get something like Sentry.
- icebraining 7y ago(Without getting into the discussion of who is an LBIP or not) > Where there’s no profit stream, markets are not going to directly solve this problem. The market is a process of matching suppliers with consumers, and contrary to the previous statement, it has solved the problem, by finding a very cheap supplier: you. LBIP are admirable selfless people, but I think this attitude is as misguided as a parent doing their kid's homework for them. The rest of us won't care to find a better solution until we start feeling the pressure, and we won't feel it while the load is being born by them. And the author is essentially asking regular individuals to throw a few tips to the LBIPs, so that the current broken model can be maintained. I'm not sure we wouldn't be better off letting it fail.
- jauer 7y agoNo mention of a org that's funding things that are actually "internet load bearing": https://www.coreinfrastructure.org/grants/ https://www.coreinfrastructure.org/grants/ Also, this might be better described as Load-Bearing Individual Participants. If only to avoid distraction around what counts as internet-critical. Beyond funding, what happens when they get burned out or take a vacation? Walls have many bricks. What makes these people unique? I'd expect anyone in a senior position to be working on growing people to help share the load, open source or corporate. There's only so much you can do by your self.
- tptacek 7y agoOr, you know, he could just get a job like everyone else does, including virtually everyone who actually does maintain critical internet infrastructure. Meanwhile, for those keeping score at home, a quick recap of the ways in which Raymond, esteemed author of fetchmail and maintainer of gpsd, has referred to himself: * A "load-bearing Internet person" * "one of the senior technical cadre that makes the Internet work" * "one of the half-dozen or so most influential people" in open source, "in fact, a lot of people would put me among the top three". * Hisham ibn-Sindbad (the Black Wazir) in Arabian Nights * Someone you could reasonably infer is "the most famous programmer in the world" (but Knuth doesn't count because he's not famous outside of CS, nor is Bill Gates because he's not famous as a programmer, nor is Kevin Mitnick or Aaron Swartz). * A member of a "small cadre of old hands" like Vint Cerf and Dave Taht with "the specialized technical knowledge required for Internet disruption on a massive scale". * A person "creating the computer code that makes your digital world work"; "every time you use a Web browser, locate yourself on Google Maps, draw money from an ATM, or play on a game console, you rely on computer code I wrote and gave away."
- pvg 7y agoThere's a succinct summary of his position in the classical literature: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f9aM_dT5VMI&t=182 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f9aM_dT5VMI&t=182