5 ms·
Ken White’s rule of goats: “The Rule of Goats applies. Slightly paraphrased — for this family newspaper — the rule states: If you kiss a goat, even if you say
by MBCook 7y ago
Ken White’s rule of goats:
“The Rule of Goats applies. Slightly paraphrased — for this family newspaper — the rule states: If you kiss a goat, even if you say you're doing it ironically, you're still a goat-kisser.”
You don’t get off scott-free just because you say “I was only being ironic“.
- beatgammit 7y agoLet's say I am on a forum talking theoretically about robbing a bank (say I'm a fan of the PayDay series or something). Let's say that someone on that forum ended up robbing a bank, perhaps using information that I provided. Did I commit a crime? Am I am accomplice? There's a big difference between planning a real crime and planning a fictitious one, but they can look identical to an outside observer. As for your quote, I don't think it really applies here. You can say all sorts of trouble things, but I don't think you can accidentally become an accomplice, at the very least need motive.
- krapp 7y ago>There's a big difference between planning a real crime and planning a fictitious one, but they can look identical to an outside observer. The /pol/ boards on 4chan and 8chan aren't role playing boards. No one there is discussing race war in the context of an ARG or a fictional universe. The people being ironic here know perfectly well they are ironically supporting actual racists who actually sometimes commit violence in the real world.
- Dylan16807 7y ago>The /pol/ boards on 4chan and 8chan aren't role playing boards. They often are. Lots of threads are about fictitious things. Don't make me go there to find examples. > The people being ironic here know perfectly well they are ironically supporting actual racists who actually sometimes commit violence in the real world. That's different. If you post something racist, that's a general statement and lots of people will see it. If you post about a story someone is telling, with specific facts, you have no idea if it's connected to reality or not.
- krapp 7y ago>They often are. Lots of threads are about fictitious things. Don't make me go there to find examples. Not a fictitious setting, which makes the comparison to a game forum inapt. It would be reasonable to assume that someone discussing theft on a GTA forum is not discussing theft in the real world. It would not necessarily be as reasonable to assume that someone posting anti-semitic or racewar content on /pol/ isn't referring to the real world, or to assume insincerity as a default. It certainly wouldn't be reasonable, if you were that person, to assume everyone else was as insincere as you were, or, if you were a racist, that you weren't talking to a comrade in arms.
- Dylan16807 7y agoThere is a difference between being a comrade and a specific scenario being real.
- floatingatoll 7y agoA racist story that cannot proven to be connected to reality is still racist.
- Dylan16807 7y agoYes, that agrees with my point. If you encourage someone to go to mcdonald's and throw caviar at hispanics, you're saying racist things for real but the actual crime of assault is almost certainly fictional.
- floatingatoll 7y agoSuch an encouragement is, again, a terrible idea: not only does it promote racism through implausible fictional story, but it also opens the author to legal risk if someone then implements the implausible story in reality. “Almost certainly fictional” is a Rule 34 problem: If you can conceive of a belief or outcome, then someone on the Internet will agree so strongly that they will act upon that belief or deliver that outcome.
- XaoDaoCaoCao 7y agoIs unprovoked violence any more tawdry because of racism? Most violence in the world stems from causes other than modern "racism". Any communication channel, by virtue of human nature, is going to enable assaulters and murderers. If you look at assault and murder, most people are victimized by their own kind.
- krapp 7y ago>Any communication channel, by virtue of human nature, is going to enable assaulters and murderers. If you look at assault and murder, most people are victimized by their own kind. We're not talking about a purely neutral and general "communication channel" on which violent discussion or reaction occurs, when it does, merely by happenstance wholly unconnected to the nature of the community. We're talking about a channel for which racist and violent expression is an explicit part of its culture, identity and raison dêtre. Not a knitting forum in which one knitter just happened to have assaulted another knitter IRL, but a channel for racists in which one racist decided to shoot up a synagogue, in which said shooter linked his motivations and inspiration to that channel. Also, given that we're discussing a specific instance of racially motivated violence, I don't know what relevance mentioning the existence or relative prevalence of other forms of violence actually has to the topic at hand.
- floatingatoll 7y agoIf someone on that forum says “should I try this IRL” and you say “theoretically, it should work fine” then, yes, you will probably be convicted. If you say “no, that’s illegal” and consistently do so any time you’re asked then you will probably not be convicted. If you say “that’s a great idea” you will be definitely be convicted. If you say “that’s a terrible idea ;)” you will probably be convicted while having angered the judge and jury for assuming they’re idiots.
- Dylan16807 7y agoWhether you are for or against bank robberies at nonspecific banks at nonspecific future dates shouldn't be the deciding factor in whether you're an accomplice. I hope you're not right.
- floatingatoll 7y agoI do indeed strongly encourage not trolling people to do illegal things using the Internet or any other method, as the law does not require the courts to take your motivation for encouraging them into account if they then commit the crime you trolled them to do. I note that you, in essence, shifted the point from “encouraging a person on a forum to commit bank robbery” to “nonspecifically encouraging bank robbery in general”. You’re on your own for interpreting that latter one. ps. From elsethread: https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-time-to-stop-using-the-fire-in-a-crowded-theater-quote/264449/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/11/its-tim...