9 ms·
“Amazon’s Choice” is determined by an algorithm and not always reliable
- Fnoord 7y ago"Google I'm Lucky" is determined by an algorithm and not always reliable. That by itself isn't news since it doesn't describe how severe the problem is. I've had that the first hit on Dutch Google for locksmith was a scam. That also doesn't describe how severe the problem is. A good argument about this problem contains a careful analysis (probably involves some kind of reliable algorithm runs). As for the lockpicking. The general locks available and in use are mostly security through obscurity these days. Knowledge about how to pick them (or by using a pickgun or '999' key + 'tomahawk') is abundantly available. These locks are meant to slow an attacker down, not stop them. They're a terrible security measure if they're the only layer of defense.
- dvdbloc 7y agoFraud aside, seems like a more clear choice of terms to label these “Customer’s Choice” if the label is based on higher ratings and fewer returns etc.
- JohnStrangeII 7y agoI'm surprised. I've always thought that "Amazon's Choice" was paid advertisement and have avoided these suggestions. When I buy something on Amazon, I usually take reviews from elsewhere into account or click on the most negative Amazon reviews to check whether there is a particular problem with the product. It seems hard to believe that many customers take into account some label that looks like paid advertisement.
- dahfizz 7y agoI'm curious why you think it looks like an ad? You should also consider that the average Amazon user is not the average HN user. Even if it was a paid ad, any sort of endorsement from Amazon would certainly "fool" all the middle aged parents out there who can't be arsed to do extensive research on third party reviews.
- luckylion 7y ago> I'm curious why you think it looks like an ad? I've had that impression as well. It's not anything particular about the look for me, but that I expect any highlighting / positioning on Amazon to be paid for.
- defertoreptar 7y agoI thought it was an ad too, and would devalue those items compared to others because of that pretense. Why? Because it's a similar pattern that we see on other websites: the "sponsored" content gets the top spots. The real content comes directly after.
- toomuchequate 7y ago> Even if it was a paid ad, any sort of endorsement from Amazon would certainly "fool" all the middle aged parents out there who can't be arsed to do extensive research on third party reviews. What is surprising that educated people are more aware of marketing/advertising/capitalism? I only had to see some fake business accounts for large companies(Aldi) acting like real users to put my on high alert for anything on the Internet.
- freeone3000 7y agoIt's an item being explicitly promoted by the store I'm at - if that's not an advertisement, I don't know what is.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAnything a store promotes is an ad. In the very rare cases of mom&pop stores, it could even be because the product is good. In a typical case, it's because the store needs to cycle inventory, the product is bad and therefore doesn't sell well, or the supplier paid for it. A rule of thumb for urban shopping is to always ignore "helpful" store recommendations, especially unsolicited ones. They have little interest in doing right by you, and every reason to trick you into a purchase that's better for them and worse for you.
- solarkraft 7y ago
- maxerickson 7y agoYou don't think that lots of negative reviews are written by people with rather odd expectations? It certainly pays to take reviews into account, it's just that a soft survey style approach yields more information than a hard rules based approach.
- notahacker 7y agoYou can generally get some idea of how odd the expectations are by reading them. Although I tend to agree that reviews with 2, 3 and 4 stars are generally more likely to contain useful nuance (and less likely to be paid for by someone) than those at the extreme ends of the spectrum.
- rc_mob 7y agoMe too. Or more realistically Amazon pushing whatver product they make the best profits from.
- fapjacks 7y agoAh. More "revelations" from Buzzfeed "news".
- tzs 7y agoIf you are puzzled by the downvotes, it is because you apparently have overlooked that a few years ago, Buzzfeed hired a bunch of real journalists and spun off BuzzFeed News as a separate, legitimate news organization, which has gone on to win several awards for its reporting (National Magazine Award in the category of Public Interest, two National Press Foundation awards, a Sidney Award, a British Journalism Award, and a George Polk award), and were finalists for the Pulitzer Prize in International Reporting twice, and for the Online Journalism Award twice, and once for the Goldsmith Prize of Investigation Reporting.
- acollins1331 7y agoDid BuzzFeed news says that Mueller was gonna charge trump and grandstand about it after being proven wrong?
- mft_ 7y agoI didn't interpret the comment quite as you did. Rather, I assumed it was being (rightly) critical that Buzzfeed news spent such a lot of words and effort on a topic that wasn't especially newsworthy. In particular, it was a frustrating read, being padded out by too many examples and testimonials, when the real meat of the article could have been summed up in a sentence: "Amazon Choice recommendations are algorithmic and not very reliable." (It seems to be trying to tap into the zeitgeist of looking for a critical angle in everything that Amazon does. Which is weak and clickbait-y.) Honestly, it's a bad (or good?) example of what the internet has made "journalism" into - and I put journalism in quotes here not because I'm knocking Buzzfeed news as being able to sometimes produce good journalism, but because this isn't one of those times.
- fapjacks 7y agoInteresting, considering the number of things they say which are demonstrably false. Interesting also how these Buzzfeed "news" links are so fiercely defended here lately, by people with very specific information about Buzzfeed "news".
- blueboo 7y agoIt’s not just that oh, Amazon’s Choice is algorithmically picked from recommendations. It’s that seemingly more often than not, it’s a truly inferior choice to an option next to it in the displayed matrix.
- dageshi 7y agoIt's usually the cheapest option that's ok in my experience, which is probably what most people are looking for.
- YokoZar 7y agoI was actually surprised when I learned this. The biggest complaint about Amazon had been a lack of curation and all that entails -- foot long brooms that photograph well, brands you've never heard of, cheap things that break quickly, counterfeits, etc. It feels like an online dollar store, even when you're spending thousands. It doesn't take that much effort to have a human in the loop to pick something for the top thousand or so product categories, and naively that's what I expected when I saw the "Amazon's Choice" seal of approval on these things.
- oftenwrong 7y agoAs mentioned in the article, Amazon does have "Editorial recommendations" that appear for certain queries, which are basically buying guides written by third parties. They can apply titles to products, like "Editors' Choice", "Best Value", "Our Pick", "Top Choice", "Upgrade Pick", "Splurge-worthy", et cetera.
- 3JPLW 7y agoI assumed that even if it was algorithmic they’d consider things like return rate that we cannot see.
- whoopdedo 7y agoWhen you have to pay for the shipping cost of a return buyers won't return bad products.
- colejohnson66 7y agoFor “changed me mind”, yes, but for defective products, you don’t have to
- AJ007 7y agoMy view of Amazon is already so degraded due to counterfeit and defective products that I wasn’t surprised when reading this article and I have actually been explicitly avoiding the products labeled “Amazon’s Choice.” I’m not joking.
- resoluteteeth 7y agoI thought it was pretty obvious that it was generated automatically based on how much it depends on the exact keywords you search for. I think that given a certain set of products, the algorithm actually seems to do a pretty good job of making a recommendation for the best product out of the set based on the ratings or whatever it looks at, but the bigger problem is that if you aren't searching for exactly the right keywords the choice of the best product becomes completely meaningless, and blindly tacking on the "amazon's choice" recommendation obscures the fact that your search is too narrow to provide a meaningful recommendation in the first place. (I'm sure there is some filtering based on ratings but because of how common fake reviews are, if you're looking at niche products they'll almost all have fairly high ratings anyway.) It's probably better to not provide a recommendation than to recommend a bad product, so maybe they should try to narrow it down to more common categories.
- apple4ever 7y agoI always thought the same- it was based on an algorithm that took into account review score and number purchased. It seems to get things right most of the time, but I always look at others and compare to be sure. Sometimes I don't get the Amazon's Choice.
- rc_mob 7y agoAmericas Test Kitchen saves me when buying things for the kitchen. Is there any equivalent for yard equipment and tools?
- jcheng 7y agoWirecutter has a section: https://thewirecutter.com/home-garden/gardening/ https://thewirecutter.com/home-garden/gardening/
- jcomis 7y agowirecutter is not at all reliable anymore. Nearly all their picks get massive complaints in the comments and do not stand up to fakespot/reviewmeta. I know comments are not really a reliable indicator, people will always complain, but I used the site from the start and there has been a distinct shift once they were bought out.
- alexhutcheson 7y agoConsumer Reports is good, but sadly covers way fewer products than it used to. It has pretty solid coverage of yard and garden equipment, though.
- derefr 7y agoAre there any browser extensions that stick actual third-party human-determined best-choice labels on things in the Amazon store? Maybe one for Wirecutter recommendations, or Consumer Reports? Maybe a meta extension that aggregates all those recs where you can turn the rec-sources you like on and off in the extension?) (It’d be nice if Amazon themselves gave you the ability to subscribe to a given reviewer-user’s opinions and have them show up as labels on your search results—but new features like this popping up on the Amazon store seem pretty unlikely, somehow. Has the Amazon store stagnated?)
- ikeboy 7y agoAmazon has been including "editorial reviews" on certain searches. See https://www.geekwire.com/2015/amazon-partners-with-the-wirecutter-to-feature-third-party-reviews-on-travel-gear/ https://www.geekwire.com/2015/amazon-partners-with-the-wirec... and https://www.channeladvisor.com/blog/marketplaces/icymi-amazon-expert-recommendations-what-this-new-feature-means-and-what-to-do-about-it/ https://www.channeladvisor.com/blog/marketplaces/icymi-amazo...
- LordAtlas 7y agoWater is wet.
- dang 7y agoOk, but please don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- SubiculumCode 7y agoInitially I thought Amazon Choice meant it was their own product, and figured that they'd want some minimal quality standards associated with their name. Now that I know that it was an algorithm, I think that years ago it may have indicated quality products, but as the review system and other aspects are thoroughly hacked/gamed, it does the opposite. I've been purposely scrolling past Amazon Choice items for a while now Actually, I think I am going to drop Amazon Prime. Only money is going to convince Amazon to right their ship.