8 ms·
Another reason: Even today the energy density of batteries is SUBSTANTIALLY smaller than that of fossil fuels. [0] We frequently see this graph [1] showing how
by godelski 7y ago
Another reason: Even today the energy density of batteries is SUBSTANTIALLY smaller than that of fossil fuels. [0] We frequently see this graph [1] showing how far batteries have come (they have! and we need to keep going) but not understanding this is part of the issue too. [0] is why we need to keep researching, but [0] is why electric was never going to win in the beginning. It is taking very advanced materials to get to pretty decent energy densities and also advanced materials to use electricity more efficiently. Advanced materials that would likely^ not have been invented that far back even if there was a demand.
[0] https://static.financialsense.com/historical/users/u242/images/2013/Energy-Density.jpg https://static.financialsense.com/historical/users/u242/imag...
[1] https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Gp_Pandey/publication/231064871/figure/fig1/AS:300535103148037@1448664560867/Comparison-of-energy-densities-of-different-battery-systems.png https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Gp_Pandey/publication/2...
^ For you hopefuls, I say likely not impossible. The machining to create these state of the art batteries requires a lot of other technologies.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI still think there is a limit in chemical density that cannot be overcome without significantly changing technological principles of current batteries. Maybe hydrogen fuel cells would be a better solution after all if we can find an efficient way to contain it. Easier said than done...
- gambiting 7y agoEnergy density of hydrogen per litre is few orders of magnitude lower than that of petrol. Really the only saving grace of hydrogen vs batteries is the speed of refueling.
- chadcmulligan 7y agoIf someone invented a cheap round trip processing method CO2 -> petrol then EV's would have a hard time I suspect
- kozak 7y agoBut we would still need batteries to store regenerative braking energy (i.e. it would be a hybrid).
- rightbyte 7y agoYou can have a flywheel for that.
- benj111 7y agoDon't know why you're getting downvotes, this is a thing. https://www.racecar-engineering.com/articles/f1/williams-f1-kers-explained/ https://www.racecar-engineering.com/articles/f1/williams-f1-...
- clouddrover 7y agoYou can use ultra-capacitors. Like Nawa's: https://newatlas.com/nawa-technologies-carbon-ultra-capacitor/54972/ https://newatlas.com/nawa-technologies-carbon-ultra-capacito... https://newatlas.com/nawa-nanotube-ultracapacitor-production/59684/ https://newatlas.com/nawa-nanotube-ultracapacitor-production... Formula E would be a good proving ground for them.
- clouddrover 7y agoHere are two such efforts: https://carbonengineering.com/ https://carbonengineering.com/ https://www.prometheusfuels.com/ https://www.prometheusfuels.com/
- make3 7y agoisn't it still much better than batteries?
- cinquemb 7y agoI think molten salt (latent heat) batteries could push the boundaries further as researchers continue to design salt mixtures with lower melting points and higher and higher delta_k's (economic considerations of compounds included). Though for usage in cars would imply some kind of small/portable vacuum storage tanks and a way to put the heat to work (most likely initially through a steam engine and eventually directly to electricity via advanced thermocouples[0]) [0] https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.5935 https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.5935
- clouddrover 7y ago> Really the only saving grace of hydrogen vs batteries is the speed of refueling. And range, weight, and (eventually) price. Batteries need to improve in all these areas. Fuel cell cars are expensive at the moment because they're produced in such low volumes. But Toyota thinks that if they produced FCEVs at scale they could build them cheap: https://www.thedrive.com/tech/26050/exclusive-toyota-hydrogen-boss-explains-how-fuel-cells-can-achieve-corolla-costs https://www.thedrive.com/tech/26050/exclusive-toyota-hydroge...
- magduf 7y agoToyota is the only company pushing hydrogen as a fuel for cars, and it's puzzling why, because they really don't have many advantages, and a ton of disadvantages compared to BEVs. Everyone else is working on BEVs, including the Chinese.
- clouddrover 7y agoHyundai is working on fuel cell cars as well: https://www.electrive.com/2019/06/05/hyundai-to-sell-their-fc-drives-to-competitors/ https://www.electrive.com/2019/06/05/hyundai-to-sell-their-f...
- raxxorrax 7y agoStill better than current batteries. You could pump that up if you store it in a liquid state to a level above common fossil fuels. Not saying you don't open a can of worms for implementing it...
- gambiting 7y agoHydrogen in liquid state leaks out of any container that you put it in. 70kg lead bottle stores only 1L of hydrogen and all of it evaporates naturally in 1-2 months through the metal. So no, storage of liquid hydrogen is a terrible idea.
- raxxorrax 7y agoIt does diffuse through everything, but there are several research projects in that direction. It is the smallest element and it helps if that bottle is solid, but I still see potential.
- magduf 7y agoBesides in-vehicle storage being completely infeasible for many reasons, how exactly do you propose to safely allow consumers to refill a tank with liquid hydrogen? They use it for rockets sometimes, but it's handled very carefully by highly trained technicians under very controlled conditions and the fueling procedure is nothing like a stop at your local gas station.
- snakeboy 7y agoAm I misreading the gp's cited chart? According to that, it seems like hydrogen is only a factor of around 4x worse in terms of volumetric energy density, and is better than petrol in weight density.
- imtringued 7y agoAnd you can always refine it into methane for an even higher density.
- namibj 7y agoWeight density is better. Nothing else comes really close. The volumetric missmatch could be right.
- magduf 7y agoWeight density doesn't help you in a car; these aren't rockets where most of the weight of the vehicle is fuel. In a car, the weight of the fuel is barely noticeable. What's much more important is the size of the tank, and a hydrogen tank takes up a lot of room (to get decent range), and is also quite heavy to contain a pressurized gas that literally leaks out constantly because its molecules are so small.
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoDont you forget something- hydrogen if hydrolizes takes place in situa - aka directly below a windpower or solar-plant, has the lowest conversion loss right there.. Also storage can be improved by now chemically - meaning you bind it to a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_storage#Liquid_organic_hydrogen_carriers_(LOHC) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_storage#Liquid_organi... and reduce that to a nearly solid material with extremly high energy density. Its okay to be a tesla fanboi, its not okay to propagate ancient technological "insights".
- pjc50 7y agoTo me, there's not so much difference between batteries and fuel cells - one stores the redox reaction components outside the electrode/electrolyte setup, that's all. The advantage of hydrogen in this setup is the ability to pull oxygen from the air and then dump the reaction product.
- raxxorrax 7y agoDepending on the process of extracting hydrogen, it could also be more environmental friendly overall. I don't know much about the battery life cycle, but I image there to be "casualties". I know there are many, many problems to solve for fuel cells and if you are scared of some burning batteries, this solution probably doesn't provide much consolation.
- hwillis 7y agoThis is an incredibly myopic take masquerading as "first principles". First, you're flat wrong on the differences between gas and batteries, especially for cars. Second, you need an actual reason energy density is the fundamental metric- cars aren't rockets and weight isn't the end-all. It's impossible to neglect the efficiency here. Car-scale combustion engines have a real world efficiency of around ten percent compared to electric. A gallon of E10 contains 34.9 kWh and randomly picking a Toyota Avalon you'll get a real world 17 mpg with that[1], which works out to 16.4 mpge. Compare that to real world measurements of a Tesla Model 3, a car that is MUCH more powerful and heavier, but gets 147.4 mpge[2]. The Avalon gets 11% as many miles per unit of energy stored. E10 is equivalent to 1.32 kWh/kg (4.8 MJ/kg). Not to mention that graph of battery energy density is significantly out of date. Normal li-ion, is at 300 Wh/kg (1.1 MJ/kg) and li-sulfur is commercially available at 500 Wh/kg[3] (1.8 MJ/kg). Even Tesla's batteries are above 250 Wh/kg. So the bottom line is the difference is ~5x right now. Is that enough to matter? 15.5 gallons of gas (standard fuel tank) weighs 44 kg, or 2.7% the total weight of the Avalon. The full capacity in batteries at 250 Wh/kg would weigh 232.32 kg, or 11.4% more. As much as 2 people + luggage. That's a totally irrelevant increase in weight; luxury or performance cars in a given class can weigh DOUBLE the lightest cars in the same class. The energy density of batteries is a red herring for all vehicles except cargo/tanker ships and long-distance airplanes. It's completely irrelevant for vehicles. The charging speed is arguably minorly important but by FAR the most important things are the upfront and lifetime cost. That is related to energy density... the energy density of the power plant's fuel, not the battery. And again, it's incredibly naive to assume the weight is the major factor in cost. [1]: https://www.fueleconomy.gov/mpg/MPG.do?action=mpgData&vehicleID=37105&browser=true&details=on https://www.fueleconomy.gov/mpg/MPG.do?action=mpgData&vehicl... [2]: https://www.fueleconomy.gov/mpg/MPG.do?action=mpgData&vehicleID=39836&browser=true&details=on https://www.fueleconomy.gov/mpg/MPG.do?action=mpgData&vehicl... [3]: https://sionpower.com/ https://sionpower.com/
- gameswithgo 7y agoadding mass increase the costs of tires (ongoing) wheels, shocks and other suspension bits that have to be stronger and bigger to support the mass, and it increases wear on roads too. so energy density does affect upfront costs and lifetime costs.
- magduf 7y ago>Another reason: Even today the energy density of batteries is SUBSTANTIALLY smaller than that of fossil fuels. That's irrelevant. The thing people keep forgetting with fossil fuels is that most of that energy is being wasted to just produce heat. With an EV, 95-98% of the battery's energy is being used for propulsion (unless you turn on a heater of course). In short, you're comparing apples to oranges.
- gnu8 7y agoThat heat is not wasted if you live in a place that has seasons. I’d like to see EVs with a petrol burning heating system that could provide cabin and battery heat during winter. Many gas stations sell untaxed kerosene that I think could be used because it’s for heating, not motor fuel.
- avar 7y agoIt's not irrelevant. The high water mark for Li-Ion efficiency is 0.875 MJ/kg[1] (in practice e.g. a Tesla seems to be 0.7 MJ/kg). For petrol that's 46.4. Now, let's adjust that for the efficiency of the power train. Let's give the electric car 100% (in practice it's 95-97%). Production ICE engines are around 20%. That gives us 46.4 x 0.20 = 9.28 MJ/kg. That's a 10.6x difference in favor of petrol if we take the optimistic 0.875 number. The most fuel-efficient cars sold today consume around 5L/100km. A liter of petrol is 0.78 kg. A 1000 km of range is the probably holy grail for an electric car. A a car powered by petrol needs to carry 39 kg of fuel at the start of a trip for that range. That'll be at best ~390 kg for the Tesla at its theoretical limits, which isn't counting overhead weight associated with the battery pack, and unlike a petrol-powered car the weight doesn't reduce as you go through the trip (a significant hurdle for e.g. electrically powered airplanes). Of course the power train of an electric car is lighter than on the ICE-power vehicle, but the ICE still wins, and all of this is before we get to the battery needing much more volume than petrol, although as the Tesla shows you can win back some space by placing it in the floor, which isn't a realistic option for ICE. None of this means electric cars aren't viable, but the weight and volume differences for the same MJ are inherent, and aren't going to go away. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density