6 ms·
It's well known in the telecom/internet infrastructure business that Huawei: a) bugged the hell out of Nortel's ottawa area offices, both physically, by rootki
by walrus01 7y ago
It's well known in the telecom/internet infrastructure business that Huawei:
a) bugged the hell out of Nortel's ottawa area offices, both physically, by rootkit, and by getting their own people hired to physically smuggle out documents and design data
b) Copied the entire DWDM / optical transport product line
c) Released a nearly identical product a few years later, and sold it at a ridiculously low price, effectively killing Nortel.
Many years later the vacant ex-Nortel office buildings came up for lease. One of the candidate tenants for that large of an office space were parts of the Canadian federal government, ministry of defence, etc. Every serious tenant passed on the space because it's so riddled with bugs.
https://ottawacitizen.com/news/national/defence-watch/the-mystery-of-the-listening-devices-at-dnds-nortel-campus https://ottawacitizen.com/news/national/defence-watch/the-my...
https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/dnd-may-abandon-1b-move-to-former-nortel-site-because-of-surveillance-bugs-1.1477766 https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/dnd-may-abandon-1b-move-to-for...
https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/department-of-national-defences-new-1-billion-facility-falls-short-on-security/article31685234/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/politics/department-of-...
- aswanson 7y agoBut, I mean, other than that, what do you have on them?
- deroisas2y 7y agoFunny, because the articles OP posted suggest they don’t even have that.
- intended 7y agoThe article by the wsj seems to be more than sufficient.
- m463 7y agoInteresting - in silicon valley Huawei has a building just a short distance from both Intel and Nvidia's main headquarters.
- xyzzy_plugh 7y agoThey had an office next to Apple and Amazon and Seagate in Cupertino as well.
- kyriakos 7y agoThis could just mean they want to reinforce their brand by being next to the big guys. Doesn't mean they are spying even if that is a possibility.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThey might also want to poach employees, being close to where they work already is a good way to do that.
- kyriakos 7y agoPossibly true, but these are tactics any tech company could use. Not illegal. Snooping on competitor communications is a different story though.
- upofadown 7y agoNone of the provided links as much as mentions Huawei or provides anything but uncertainty that there were any bugging devices found at the Nortel offices.
- walrus01 7y agoYou would have to be familiar with the technical details of DWDM platform system architecture, photonics, etc in order to grok a full explanation. The Huawei product released was identical. It was identical down to the ASICs on the individual linecards and other things that would have been impossible to reverse engineer in a "Clean room" environment. I know I'm not providing a citation here, but among the community of ISPs and backbone carriers that actually have a need for this sort of equipment, it's a known fact as solidly as "water is wet". https://www.afr.com/technology/web/security/how-chinese-hacking-felled-telecommunication-giant-nortel-20140526-iux6a https://www.afr.com/technology/web/security/how-chinese-hack... https://business.financialpost.com/technology/nortel-hacked-to-pieces https://business.financialpost.com/technology/nortel-hacked-... https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/former-nortel-exec-warns-against-working-with-huawei-1.1137006 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/former-nortel-exec-warns-ag...
- mises 7y agoCan confirm this from another source. Old guy I met waiting for a flight in Vegas; he was on his way back from CES. Had run his own ISP a while back for a special purpose. Talked about this, Huawei's refusal to remove a back-door ("remote assistance and diagnosis feature" or some such malarkey), etc. They're not nice guys.
- codedokode 7y agoBut Huawei is not different from other vendors here. For example: Windows has telemetry that cannot be disabled and sends data into American data centers, Apple has control over its phones around the world, can remotely block them and know their location, and who knows what else, Google tries to convince users from around the world to store all their data in an American cloud (not their own cloud, or a cloud in their country they can trust, but the cloud in US), and almost every Intel CPU has an additional CPU (ME engine) that has full control over the system, with encrypted firmware, and is not documented. Yet I don't see any accusations against Microsoft, Apple, Android or Intel.
- codedokode 7y ago> Released a nearly identical product a few years later, and sold it at a ridiculously low price, If it violates the patents, then why did the company not sue Huawei and get a compensation? If it doesn't violate the patents then what's the problem?
- AFascistWorld 7y agohttps://www.anandtech.com/show/12462/matebook-x-pro-2018-huaweis-flagship-laptop-upgrade https://www.anandtech.com/show/12462/matebook-x-pro-2018-hua... https://www.anandtech.com/show/12848/honors-thinandlight-magicbook-with-amd-ryzen-mobile-listed https://www.anandtech.com/show/12848/honors-thinandlight-mag... https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/8/31/17803516/huawei-ai-cube-alexa-speaker-4g-router-amazon-ifa-2018 https://www.theverge.com/circuitbreaker/2018/8/31/17803516/h... https://consumer.huawei.com/cn/support/accessories/ai-speaker/ https://consumer.huawei.com/cn/support/accessories/ai-speake... The company just can't quit copying. You can get a whiff of the company culture from this guy. https://m.weibo.cn/u/3626485974?uid=3626485974&luicode=10000011&lfid=100103type%3D1%26q%3DHW%E5%89%8DHR https://m.weibo.cn/u/3626485974?uid=3626485974&luicode=10000...
- codedokode 7y agoWhat's wrong with Matebook? It has the same color, a similar shape, and a similar keyboard as a Macbook? If Apple feels that it violates their patents, why don't they sue? US patent laws are pretty strict and this is the normal way to resolve such cases. Also if you Google a bit, you can see that there are similar lawsuits against US companies. For example, a Korean company believes (and had win in courts in some countries) that Apple has stolen their intellectual property: [1] Also it is noteworthy how some countries' courts agree that Apple has infringed the patents while other countries' courts disagree. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc._v._Samsung_Electronics_Co https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc._v._Samsung_Electron....
- AFascistWorld 7y agoYeah you can always be inspired by others. https://wx2.sinaimg.cn/large/9196f7a9gy1g08e99znw9j20u01s612u.jpg https://wx2.sinaimg.cn/large/9196f7a9gy1g08e99znw9j20u01s612...
- dnomad 7y agoWhat a bunch of pure bullshit. 1. None of those links provide anything like evidence or support of your accusations. 2. It's absolutely remarkable that Huawei had somehow committed all these crimes and yet nobody has ever managed to prove anything significant in a court of law. All we get are wild accusations and law suits that get thrown out. Here's the really remarkable aspect here: the US government doesn't need to actually force propaganda on its citizens. If there's one thing we can learn very clearly from this entire ridiculous episode it is that American citizens and the American media will happily propagandize themselves. They will eagerly believe the most far fetched claims without a shred of proof, despite all actual evidence to the contrary, and they will spread those claims to each other in a kind of extremely intense decentralized disinformation machine. There's nothing else like this in the planet. You would think after Iraq Americans would learn even the tiniest bit of skepticism... But no. I won't even bother pointing out any more how HN has devolved into a 24/7 racist anti-China Two Minute Hate system. At this point it's beyond clear that the community has abandoned any kind integrity. I don't think there's anything to be done which is why I'I've left and had to go through the embarrassing exercise if unrecommending the site to people I've previously recommended it to. People will say this is just a phase but I doubt it. When a community abandons any kind of Truth standard and just embraces bullshit I don't think it recovers.
- scoot_718 7y agoNice comment history.
- whitexn--g28h 7y agoDefinitely a good read, reminds on when I was in Hong Kong and my guide would always say June 4 Incident around tourists from the PRC. The mainlanders would always immediately start defending the government.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deroisas2y 7y ago
- fc373745 7y ago>So what happened? Were listening devices found at the Nortel Campus or not? The Department of National Defence keeps changing its story on that issue. >But after the Citizen article was published, Julie Di Mambro, spokeswoman for then Conservative Defence Minister Rob Nicholson, noted in a statement that, “security officials have assured us that they have not discovered any bugs or listening devices.” The first article seems to heavily imply that there is no definite conclusion to this matter.
- jhanschoo 7y agoNote that it is possible that for political or national security reasons they decided not to provide a public statement for the matter. I've seen a news story reporting similarly about espionage victims unwilling to go public on the matter due to lack of benefit on it, though I don't think I can find it now.
- dmix 7y agoIf they did hide that information (which is still a big if) then they exposed many Canadian businesses to potential risky relationships with Huawei. If people just went public with this earlier we could have ended the "Huawei isn't hacking people and stealing their data" charade. Everyone get's to act so outraged publicly today but that Nortel case started in the early 2000s: > An internal security study by Nortel suggested that hackers had also been able to download research and development studies and business plans as far back as 2000. It's good enough for intel agencies to quietly warn the big businesses when it's seems 'necessary' which seems like the new modus operandi, at least in the US.
- igravious 7y ago> It's well known in the telecom/internet infrastructure business that Huawei: > a) bugged the hell out of Nortel's ottawa area offices, both physically, by rootkit, and by getting their own people hired to physically smuggle out documents and design data The links you provide do not mention Huawei. > b) Copied the entire DWDM / optical transport product line > c) Released a nearly identical product a few years later, and sold it at a ridiculously low price, effectively killing Nortel. Why is this two bullet points? It's the same issue, no? The links you provide are not related to this issue. Could you provide proof or evidence of some kind to back up your claims? > Many years later the vacant ex-Nortel office buildings came up for lease. One of the candidate tenants for that large of an office space were parts of the Canadian federal government, ministry of defence, etc. Every serious tenant passed on the space because it's so riddled with bugs. bugged the hell out, riddled with bugs « But after the Citizen article was published, Julie Di Mambro, spokeswoman for then Conservative Defence Minister Rob Nicholson, noted in a statement that, “security officials have assured us that they have not discovered any bugs or listening devices.” » « Again, a DND official dismissed concerns that listening devices could be hidden in the sprawling complex, noting that none had ever been found. » « Five days later in another statement to the Citizen – and contrary to what Norman had said earlier – the DND was once again claiming that no bugs, surveillance equipment or listening devices had ever been found. » --- So to sum up … You have made two (though you made it look like three) claims of criminal activity by a specific Chinese company. You provide three links giving the appearance of supporting your claims. After following the links I discover that the links only address your first claim and direct quoutes from government officials counter the narrative of suspicions in the article. Not only that, the company your are making the claims against is not mentioned in any of the articles. When I Google huawei DWDM / optical transport product line to try to find proof or evidence for your second claim the only allegation I find is your post on HN. Your first claim makes three separate allegations: (1) bugged the hell out of Nortel's ottawa area offices, both physically, (2) by rootkit, (3) and by getting their own people hired to physically smuggle out documents and design data. The article only talks about the suspicion of "legacy bit and pieces" meaning (1) but no mention of rootkits (2) and nothing about planting moles (3). Come to think of it you're really only making one claim – that Huawei engaged in industrial espionage against Nortel to such a degree that they put Nortel out of business. And nothing in the links you provide substantiate that claim. Where is your proof or evidence that Huawei directly put Nortel out of business by engaging in industrial espionage?