4 ms·
One expects the US to be behind the EU, a place generally more concerned with the welfare of its citizens than the US, where corporate profits are King. But wh
by ncmncm 7y ago
One expects the US to be behind the EU, a place generally more concerned with the welfare of its citizens than the US, where corporate profits are King.
But when we fall behind Brazil and China, too, alarm bells should be ringing -- if they weren't, already, over US infant mortality soaring past that in dozens of other countries, or life expectancy reverting to a persistent downward trend.
You don't get declining life expectancy without really concerted mismanagement and corruption at the top.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoChina isn’t really a rule of law country, so they have the option of banning things without really banning them (the law can be on the books but enforced only very seductively that most people ignore it). I’m not sure about Brazil, but in general it is very difficult to compare a developed country with a developing one.
- inflatableDodo 7y ago>in general it is very difficult to compare a developed country with a developing one. I don't know about that. Is done all the time. Also, 'developing/developed' is a incredibly crude taxonomy with few useful contexts and a very fuzzy border.
- kazen44 7y agoNot to mention, economic development is not the only factor that determines if a country is doing well for it's citizens. Heck, what people regard as a country "doing well" is different between different countries and their cultures.
- jimclegg 7y ago>China isn’t really a rule of law country I don't know about that, slightly unrelated but I'm 4 times less likely to get murdered in China than in the USA. The population seems to adhere to laws against harming fellow humans better than we do in the USA.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThat has nothing to do with rule of law. Laws are definitely enforced on China, it’s just up to the officials on what laws to enforce when and on whom. They will enforce pesticide bans, for example, on farmers they don’t like or where it is politically convenient to do so. Likewise, one can get away with murder if they are politically connected enough and in good grace (well, until the publicity gets bad and they become pariahs like Bo Xilai).
- NicoJuicy 7y agoNobody cares if you get killed in China. They need to pay less if you die then if you're wounded. So they run you over again to be sure that you are dead. Video surveillance isn't launching everywhere, because of corrupcy. And they don't care about foreigners ( with something happens). Chinese protects Chinese, no one else. They will also work with favors above law.
- benj111 7y ago"Nobody cares if you get killed in China" Whatever evidence you're using to support this assertion, I'm sure theres equal evidence from any other country.
- NicoJuicy 7y agoHere's an example, not the article that opinionated me in the past though. Since that was more a discussion about Chinese "culture", it was an fictive example there that happens regularly. https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/2123499/chinese-driver-who-hit-nine-year-old-car-killed-her-avoid-high https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/2123499/chin...
- jimclegg 7y ago>Nobody cares if you get killed in China. They need to pay less of you die then if your wounded. So they run you over again to be sure that you are dead. People protesting police/army violence in USA share the same view of our state agents.
- eunos 7y ago> the law can be on the books but enforced only very seductively that most people ignore it I think the issue of enforcement should be separated to the issue of the spirit of the "rule of the law".
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoSelectively, not seductively.
- vkou 7y ago> so they have the option of banning things without really banning them Anyone who spent more then 30 seconds observing motorists on a freeway highway will know that this sort of selective enforcement is not limited to China.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoMotorists in China are much worse than what you think is bad in the states.
- oscargrouch 7y ago> I’m not sure about Brazil, but in general it is very difficult to compare a developed country with a developing one. The context for Brazil is mostly that it is a democracy from 1888 til nowadays, but with a shadow institutional period from the 60´s to the mid-eighties. So the country had to rebuild it´s own institutions from the eighties til now, to serve a democracy instead of serving the wills of a dictatorship. Now, its in a point of testing its institutional maturity, and the rule of law, by the ongoing crackdown on corruption and organized crime. A lot of big political figures from all sides (and executives) are in jail right now, and theres a current crackdown going on in the organized crime front. But the big test right now is the current Brazilian government with its backwards policy. Will the organized institutions from the society, and the other powers besides the executive able to make a stand against going backwards? Theres a big test going on in Brazil right now, if 'we' are able to pass this dangerous phase and still have the democratic institutions and balances in one piece, than i guess it will probably move foward and get stronger with time. In this sense also, the US was lucky to have England as a cultural parent, because England was/is great in making solid institutions. From government to the academy. The colonization process of the countries colonized by the spanish and the portugueses, were mostly a vampire-like kind of relation. Where they took everything they could, leaving a trail of exploitation and slavery behind. The portuguese colonizers even used to forbid Brazil of the colonial/empire era to have a University, which we only manage to create the first one here in the 20´s. Anyway, i guess the answer to the rule of law, is both; is "good enough for most things", and "we are getting there". Not something to be proud of, not something very advanced, but not bad either..
- tcgv 7y ago> I’m not sure about Brazil In Brazil most federal inspection agencies are under funded and short on staff, limiting their operations. Offering bribe to inspection agents is also very common but risky since the government has been pushing a campaign and reforms against systemic corruption for the past few years.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>One expects the US to be behind the EU, a place generally more concerned with the welfare of its citizens than the US, where corporate profits are King. It's real easy to ban things that make it easier to farm when you don't got much farming.
- Geimfari 7y agoI'm not sure what you're referring to, the agricultural sector in Europe is rather strong. The US is the world's top exporter of food, but the Netherlands come second.
- adventured 7y agoEurope's agriculture sector is strong largely because of tariff and political protections that keep out competition. The EU's agriculture tariffs are about 100% higher than the US. The US and Australia have the lowest agriculture tariffs of any major economies or groups such as the EU. Drastically lower in fact. Russia for example - a wheat juggernaut now - has agriculture tariffs over 3x that of the US.
- kazen44 7y agothe CAP is their for good reason though. Having your own food supply is far more important then having a free agricultural market. Also, it's not like the US is not guilty of this either, just look at it's massive corn subsidies.
- gtirloni 7y agoIn general, Brazil has been quite strict with controlling pesticides because we depend a lot on the rich countries to want to buy our products. The current government, not so much. The president has appointed a Minister of Agriculture that is known as the "Poison Muse". We shall see how that goes but there's a tendency of conflating liberalism with not having any rules that is getting scary with the current administration (e.g. taxes are the system crushing entrepreneurs, traffic laws are a "fee industry", everybody should have a gun, etc)