11 ms·
The first step up from 256GB is 2x512GB, and there's configurations up to 2x2TB. My guess is that the 256GB configuration is meant for users that work primarily
by duskwuff 7y ago
The first step up from 256GB is 2x512GB, and there's configurations up to 2x2TB. My guess is that the 256GB configuration is meant for users that work primarily with data that's kept on network storage.
- kstrauser 7y agoRight. If you're working with multi-terabyte files that live on a NAS or an external directly-attached storage, the local drive is basically a cache of the OS plus whatever you're physically working on at that moment.
- cm2187 7y agoAnd it seems to come with 10gbe by default which is consistent with it.
- jandrese 7y ago2x 10GBE actually. Plus four 40Gbps Thunderbolt ports.
- cm2187 7y agoI find that link aggregation is pretty much useless and/or unstable. Not sure what good two 10gbe ports do. But seeing 10gbe becoming part of the standard spec is a really welcomed improvement. Not the least because it will drive prices down.
- Spooky23 7y agoWould be second interface be for a storage network?
- kbirkeland 7y agoI'm curious what your experiences are here. With enterprise-level networking equipment and LACP (802.3ad), I've never run into any weird issues.
- cm2187 7y agoI tried between two enterprise dlink switches, and also between a synology NAS and a dlink switch. Link aggregation in general only provides performance with multiple connections to multiple machines, so using link aggregation between one client (Mac) and one NAS will like result in zero performance improvement (the packets will only use one of the cables). It only makes sense if you have two or more NAS that you want to access simulatenously (or two or more clients accessing the same NAS, but that wouldn't be a use case for 2x 10gbe port on a client). Synology also supports balance slb bonding, which in theory goes around this single connection restriction. However I ran into some connection problems with some Windows clients. Never went to the bottom of them but they went away when I disabled the bonding. In any case, it is hard to saturate a 10gbe connection with a single NAS, unless it is packed with SSDs, which I wouldn't assume for mass storage. So I am not sure there is much value in aggregating the links in the first place.
- snuxoll 7y agoD-Link gear isn’t exactly what I’d judge networking standards on, they work I suppose but they’re hardly what I would install in even a small business office. I have multiple LACP bonds on my Juniper EX2200 at home working without issue, though the single stream limits you mentioned are the one thing LACP can’t fix.
- justinclift 7y ago> enterprise dlink switches "enterprise" DLink switches aren't really a thing yet, regardless of what their marketing team wants to brand them as. :( Cisco, HPE, etc have "enterprise" switches. DLink might be in a decade. > it is hard to saturate a 10gbe connection with a single NAS, unless it is packed with SSDs No, it's just a matter of having enough spindles behind it. As a rough guide, with a (say) average spinning rust HDD able to push out 100MB/s when reading, you'd only need 10 such drives to push out 1000MB/s (raw). In the real world, you need extra spindles as some of the data being pushed out is just internal checksum/redundancy, and doesn't go over the network. But for reading back large files in mostly sequential access, you'll hit 1GB/s from about 10 drives onwards pretty easily. More drives, more throughput.
- eropple 7y agoI'm not mad that it's 10GBASE-T, but I'd personally rather 10G over SFP+. The sorts of shops that can afford these probably already have some pretty burly networking infrastructure, and 10GBASE-T is both expensive and (IME) less reliable. The encoding/decoding capacity of Ethernet-over-twisted-pair seems to be reaching a point of sharply diminishing returns and the hardware for 10GBASE-T is really expensive for what's been, in my experience, a less reliable experience than SFP+. I'd rather tell somebody who needs 10GBASE-T to use an RJ-45 adapter than to have to go grab yet another Mellanox card to stick in a computer this expensive.
- cm2187 7y agoBut isn't SFP+ not compatible with 1G (i.e. can only be used with a 10G network equipment)? If you are selling a machine that people will plug into either a 1gbe or 10gbe network, you'd rather have some interface that can downgrade.
- buildbot 7y agoYou can use SFP in an SFP+ socket, but not the other way around. The downgrade to 1GB would work fine. Since this is still a desk focused machine vs. datacenter, I'd expect most offices to be wired to cat6 ethernet which can do 10GB if needed vs. SFP+ cables or SFP+ to Fiber.
- eropple 7y agoThat, and I'd still expect an RJ-45 port somewhere.
- Hikikomori 7y agoNot always true, it needs explicit support for SFP as it's not backwards compatible.
- Unklejoe 7y agoYou can find SFP+ modules that support both 10G and 1G.
- 7y ago
- cbsmith 7y agoEven without link aggregation (which does generally work quite well), this would allow you to have a dedicated SAN + network solution, which is often very useful.
- jlgaddis 7y ago> Not sure what good two 10gbe ports do. 1 x 10 GbE for your regular Ethernet/IP traffic and 1 x 10 GbE for your storage traffic. You do run your network storage over a physically separate network, right?
- Koshkin 7y agoI am not sure what “a physically separate network” means when it is used by the same computer. (Also, what about accessing your storage over WiFi? Or, you have to have cables strewn all over the place?)
- __d 7y agoFor a lot of "pro" usage scenarios, the local environment will have one "LAN" that has Internet gateway, and various local services on it, plus a dedicated storage network using a separate switching infrastructure (and thus, separate NIC port on your machine). WiFi is not really an option, for performance but also often for security reasons. So yes, you'll have two cables from wall-jacks to the machine for networking.
- justinclift 7y ago> you have to have cables strewn all over the place? Of course. WiFi isn't going to work in shared user environments that chew bandwidth for breakfast. Not having to worry about the security issues of WiFi too can be helpful (depending on your security requirements).
- cm2187 7y agoI don't know. Intuitively I would have thought that a NAS that updates itself automatically, with SMB1 disabled, is less dangerous that a NAS that is in theory insulated from the internet but not patched for security vulnerabilities (since not connected) and connected to machines that are on the internet and could be infected.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- TimTheTinker 7y agoIf you're a developer on a large (multi-GB) codebase, a beefy multicore system can be great for quick compile times, but hefty storage may not be a necessity.
- llampx 7y agoThere's no professional that would buy a machine with 256GB of storage. Let's call it what it is - a throwaway configuration meant to hit a price point.
- aczerepinski 7y agoA lot of people are disagreeing with you but I certainly concur. Sure, there are ways to work around it, but this is a $6,000 computer and you could get more storage than this in the 2004 iMac. I refuse to believe that meticulously emptying out your trash and downloads folder so that you can continue to squeeze by with 256GB is now acceptable for ultra high end, "I don't know a single person who can afford this" computing.
- wayoutthere 7y agoYou would if you had a storage appliance on a SAN, as the SAN is almost certainly faster than a single SSD. This is an extremely common setup for video production, so it’s not out of the target market at all.
- ianhowson 7y agoThere are plenty of cheap NVMe SSDs that can push 3.5Gbytes/sec (Samsung 970, Adata XPG). Even with dual 10Gbe NICs, you can't match that, nor the low access times of local storage. But I do agree that SAN storage is the norm here.
- chx 7y agoWe are past that now, new PCIe 4.0 SSDs just have been showcased along with the new AMD chips and they can do 5GBytes/s read and a bit above 4GB/s write (AMD is rumored to have invested in the R&D of the controller). You'd need 40 GbE to match one -- and EPYC Rome, also scheduled for this fall, will have 160 lanes allowing for dozens of them. You could very easily reach 100 GByte/s read which no network will match.
- deleted 7y ago
- ljw1001 7y agothat just shows that they put the tiny, essentially useless HD in to keep the base price artificially low.
- chrisseaton 7y agoIsn't providing a lower cost option a good thing?
- rwmj 7y agoBait and switch is a dark pattern, even if it's a common one.
- chrisseaton 7y agoIt's a product with a price tag and spec sheet anyone can find. Can't really see how they can be any more transparent.
- Spivak 7y agoIt's not a transparency issue, this dark pattern exists everywhere. You advertise "New X starting at $x" which is low enough to attract customers. But the thing you sell for $x is actually lacking in some small but important capacity making it unattractive for actual use. Then you sell an upgrade for the target price and customers are more willing to pay because it feels like they're paying a small premium for the thing they want. It's a neat psychology trick. Customers are far more receptive to upsells when they're the one doing the upselling.
- chrisseaton 7y agoWhere do you think the 'switch' is in that? At what point do they switch something from what was previously offered to something not expected? I don't think there is any switch. The specs are presented as up-front as any hardware spec is.
- jimbokun 7y agoOr is this meant to be the "I just want to buy my own disks separately model", with 256GB drive just there to allow OS to be pre-installed? EDIT: I see now there are only two internal drive bays, so that would mean tossing the 256GB that comes with it if you wanted to max out the internal storage.
- wtallis 7y ago> I see now there are only two internal drive bays, so that would mean tossing the 256GB that comes with it if you wanted to max out the internal storage. Or using some of the several PCIe slots to add lots more SSDs. It looks like the default configuration has enough spare PCIe slots and lanes to accommodate 8 M.2 SSDs in suitable risers. That can get you another 16TB for ~$1.8k (consumer-grade SSDs).
- duskwuff 7y agoYou can't buy drives separately. Storage is almost certainly raw flash, exposed as NVMe through the Apple T2 controller.
- imagetic 7y agoThey didn't mention storage expansion. This was a big red flag. While 250gb is fine for an OS drive, should I ever want to upgrade, what is the catch?
- machz 7y agoThe 256GB model is an old Apple hack to show a lower starting price (which rarely anyone would buy at this time) and which quickly goes up as you upgrade the components.
- _Codemonkeyism 7y agoAnd how many people here who claim to use a SAN for sure use a NAS is funny. From maintaining large image storage FC SANs with Apple xServe and IBM DS for some years this is no fun to administrate for peak performance and I would assume most smaller shops have NAS instead of SANs (no arguing larger shops have SANs as we did driving ten photo studios).