12 ms·
That price is just absurd. I waited for Mac Pro announcement to decide whether I'll stay with Windows or jump to macOS. Macbooks are not for me, but I hoped for
by vbezhenar 7y ago
That price is just absurd. I waited for Mac Pro announcement to decide whether I'll stay with Windows or jump to macOS. Macbooks are not for me, but I hoped for a remotely reasonable priced computer, something like $2000 with another $1000 to expand with more memory, etc. But $6000 for 8-core CPU, 256 GB SSD, GPU that is less powerful than my old $200 NVidia 1060? It's just laughable.
Otherwise seems like a good machine. But not at this price. Probably configuration that I would like to have will be something around $10k and I'll build this configuration for $3k myself.
- dcow 7y agoBut where are you going to find a quality $1000 stand for your display?
- _bxg1 7y agoThis is the one aspect that was truly ridiculous. When that number was quoted you could hear the crowd pause in disbelief, followed by a rumble of conversation interspersed with laughter. From The Verge: > Still, all hope isn’t lost: we also don’t know how robust the box that the Pro Display XDR comes in is. It’s entirely plausible that you’ll just be able to prop up the $5,999 display with a hunk of cardboard or by leaning it up against a wall. Just be careful not to drop it.
- dllu 7y agoIt's competing against machines such as the Boxx dual-CPU workstations, which start at $8000 [1]. I can see movie studios and such shelling out the big bucks to buy these for their 3D modellers, but only the super rich would buy one for themselves. [1] https://www.boxx.com/systems/workstations/d-class https://www.boxx.com/systems/workstations/d-class
- opencl 7y agoIt's also competing against machines such as their own iMac Pro whose base model is the $1000 cheaper and has 4x the storage and a faster GPU aside from the built in 5K monitor. That $8000 base model Boxx workstation has 20 cores instead of 8, 50% more RAM, and twice the storage.
- shawnz 7y agoCompeting on what, markup? What advantage does this hardware give for movie studios when consumer grade hardware outperforms it?
- PascLeRasc 7y agoIt runs macOS and those consumer grade computers don't. If the best colorist in the area is working on your film, you give them the tools they ask for.
- MagicPropmaker 7y agoThe color graders here run 10-bit/color HDR monitors that have a wide gamut. Apple doesn't have monitors that support this. (The new one _might_ do the trick; we'll see.) Everyone here doing professional color work is on PCs supplied by Thinkmate. This is standard in Hollywood, too.
- PascLeRasc 7y agoInteresting, thanks for the info! It's probably obvious I don't know anything about filmmaking, audio's my domain.
- boopk 7y agoThe new ones aren't great you need a broadcast monitor that will show how things look for broadcast and not a computer.
- bscphil 7y agoWow, is that really true? Given Apple's popularity among creatives I assumed their top end monitors were HDR10 or better. That's really shocking.
- shawnz 7y agoAs others have noted in this thread, the iMac Pro outspecs this unit at a cheaper price.
- internobody 7y ago3D modelers want NVIDIA cards, not Radeon, as NVIDIA supports CUDA. This has been a longstanding issue with 3D folks; the old trashcan Mac Pro had NVIDIA GPUs even with otherwise-outdated internals. When rumblings came of new Mac Pros a few years ago there was excitement that they could get some fast machines again; alas this appears not to be the case.
- pat2man 7y agoIn theory you can stick any nvidia cards you want into this machine. Don't have to stick with the stock AMD GPUs.
- jakemauer 7y agoUnfortunately for reasons that remain murky Nvidia still hasn’t put drivers out for Mojave and their absence from the keynote leads me to believe they won’t have drivers for Catalina. Nvidia blames Apple saying they’re not approving drivers. So yes you can slap a 2080ti in your Mac Pro but without drivers it’s useless.
- jandrese 7y agoAnybody know what Apple's problem with nVidia is? Are they still feeling burned from the BGE failures several generations back?
- mises 7y agoThis is a professional machine. No one wants to buy it and use hacky work-arounds, they want good drivers. Which aren't an option with nvidia on macos.
- martin_bech 7y agoThe old Mac Pro has AMD FirePro GPUs. Not Nvidia
- tedivm 7y agoDepends on your definition of "old". From 2006 to 2009 they were nvidia, and then in 2010 they switched.
- swah 7y agoBut your build doesn't run macOS.... that's all that matters for so many folks. (I aggree - I feel like maybe I will never be able to afford or justify a Mac-based system in my 3rd world country...)
- goda90 7y agoStrides have been made in virtualizing macOS, so that might not be holding people back much anymore.
- StillBored 7y agoLegally, when not run on apple hardware? Its not like people haven't been able to run it illegally in a vm for at least a decade. That was one of the preferred ways of running it if your machine didn't have the exact correct hardware requirements back when I paid attention to such things.
- chaostheory 7y agoMacOS is what keeps me on Apple for now, but this box is not the answer everyone is looking for. People just want an affordable desktop that you can easily expand over time. At $6000 just for the starting model, in my head I'm already planning to move back to Windows. The only major thing I might miss is iCloud. The cheese grater lineup is still the best incarnation of the Mac Pro overall. People don't want to be forced to buy an integrated screen, nor do they want a headless laptop, and not everyone can live with a laptop alone. In other words, I don't want a semi-powerful machine trapped in amber or a larger version of an iPhone / iPad. I just have to figure out a good replacement for iCloud and its related apps.
- rayiner 7y ago> People just want an affordable desktop that you can easily expand over time. Who wants that? You can tell what people want based on what’s selling in the market. Most people want a laptop. Most of the rest want a Word/Excel machine. A small minority want an expandable desktop.
- vesrah 7y agoHow does the Mac Mini not meet what you're asking for?
- vbezhenar 7y agoI want tower case, silent and performant. I want powerful GPU for few games I'm playing. I want ECC memory. I want to put one or two HDDs along with main SSD. Mac mini does not sound like something I would like to use. I don't need small size, I have enough room. I don't need portability, I work from one place.
- fooey 7y agoI don't know why people still keep waiting for Apple to support gaming in any way at all. Worse than just not supporting gaming, they're antagonistically blocking companies like Nvidia who tried to fill in the gap with external GPUs. https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/01/18/apples-management-doesnt-want-nvidia-support-in-macos-and-thats-a-bad-sign-for-the-mac-pro https://appleinsider.com/articles/19/01/18/apples-management... If you want to game, you buy Windows, end of story.
- vbezhenar 7y agoBlizzard released a lot of games for macOS. Also I played Rimworld, Factorio recently and those games seems to have Mac version as well. I'm not very involved gamer, I just play sometimes and it seems that Mac supports almost all games I need.
- mcphage 7y ago> Blizzard released a lot of games for macOS. Also I played Rimworld, Factorio recently and those games seems to have Mac version as well. I don't think any of those games are GPU intensive. Blizzard seems to want their games to run on as many machines as possible, and Rimworld and Factorio are both 2D.
- 7y ago
- CoolGuySteve 7y agoSame here, I'm looking to build a machine to process large data sets. So far nothing can beat Linux on an EPYC or ThreadRipper on price/performance. It would cost half as much for a 1TB NVMe SSD, RTX 2080, at least 16 cores, etc. The only reason I'm even waiting is because Zen 2 is right around the corner. The 256GB SSD is so confusing. The price difference between a 970 EVO 256GB and a 970 EVO 512GB for example is only $50 (I couldn't even find a 256GB 970 PRO or 980). Are they really that desperate for margin on a machine this expensive? The lack of NVidia is also strange, do the AMD cards in this config even support Tensorflow?
- vbezhenar 7y agoI think that Nvidia will release cards for this Mac. May be even existing ones will fit. There are PCI-E ports there after all.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoWill they be able to release drivers with the new kext situation? They still don't even have drivers to use their newer cards in Mojave
- mises 7y agoHere's to hoping. Maybe I can finally get my nvidia card working on my hackintosh laptop.
- vbezhenar 7y agoFor me it's win-win situation for Apple. They help Nvidia with drivers, more people buy Mac Pro to use Nvidia GPU. I have no idea why Apple don't want to work with Nvidia. They are not selling desktop GPU after all. May be they have some hidden agreements with AMD.
- penagwin 7y agoWell obviously they have agreements with AMD. Apple gets special treatment from AMD/Intel/Nvidia, they get to see unrevealed roadmaps, custom contracts etc. Whether it's an exclusivity deal or not we may never know. But it does seem strange given Nvidia cards generally have lower TDP/performance (something all macs struggle with)
- thomasjudge 7y agoWhere do you see pricing info? Or did they talk about it in the keynote?
- jakobegger 7y agoThey mentioned it in the key note. Mac Pro will start at USD 5999, Pro Display at 4999 (without stand), matte version will cost 5999, stand for display 999 or 200 for the vesa mount adapter.
- ultrarunner 7y agoI know this can be controversial but I do all my work at home on a computer I built myself for ~900 running macOS. I had a Coffee Lake processor before you could get one straight from Apple. It's fast and with three monitors, plenty of ram, and NVME storage I noticed increased productivity over a laptop with an external display. With the T2 chip this may not be an option forever, and the initial setup means it may not be an option for everyone. But right now it feels like a very stable and viable option for those who were never going to buy a $6000 cheese grater in the first place.
- reaperducer 7y agoI know this can be controversial but I do all my work at home on a computer I built myself for ~900 running macOS Awesome. It's great that you choose to do that. You're also not the target market for this product. This is a product for people and companies for whom increased performance equals increased revenue.
- saagarjha 7y agoI’d like to think that the target market is people who want performance and a computer that is stable.
- ultrarunner 7y agoI know several people who were waiting to see what Apple offered for a pro desktop machine. I replied to a comment that said "I waited for Mac Pro announcement to decide whether I'll stay with Windows or jump to macOS". The whole issue is that there is a segment of the population demanding a product that Apple is, again here, not offering. Had I been able to justify it, I could have also chosen n-core Xeon processors (some people do go this route) and I still wouldn't have been anywhere near $6000, and that's the base model here. That's obscene, and in that light I think that my original comment is relevant.
- Nelson69 7y agoThey just need some sort of minitower, a mac mini with a couple slots, a couple m.2 connectors and room for 64GB of removable memory.. I don't know why but I've thought something like that would almost be an ideal vehicle for xeon-d type parts.
- chaostheory 7y agoPeople have been begging for this for over a decade now. It doesn't take much to see demand if you look at the Hackintosh community or the eBay market for old Mac Pros.
- pfranz 7y agoThey've been purposefully avoiding the mini-tower market for decades. For whatever reason (prestige, cannibalizing other product lines, etc) they're not interested.
- Nelson69 7y agoI know, and I get it. Maybe "mini-tower" is the wrong description. It should be a maxi-cube. I'm not holding my breath for it though, the things they sell huge numbers of aren't terribly configurable or expandable and it gives them an edge that way.
- PascLeRasc 7y agoThe new Mac Pro, like Mac Pros always have been, is for music/TV studios and design agencies that bill their time starting at $500/hour. It's really not for individuals, and that's ok. Apple made a computer "just for the pros", like HN begs for in every butterfly keyboard thread. I'm thrilled about it even though I know I'll never touch one. It's for people who don't know what a CPU core is but know how to produce a platinum album, get an Oscar nomination, or bring a revolutionary industrial design to market. This is really something where the price is superfluous. I personally wish it was higher so that was more obvious.
- _bxg1 7y agoYep. For me personally, it's a reassuring signal that Apple is doubling down on macOS and professionals, and gives me hope that next year's MacBook Pro redesign won't be a disappointment.
- aczerepinski 7y agoI disagree that it’s always been this way. I bought a G4 tower when I was in college and it sure as heck wasn’t $6,000 back then. This is the only traditional desktop computer that Apple sells, so it’s disappointing that everybody outside of movie studio employees has to fall back to an iMac or a Windows/Linux machine.
- rkho 7y agoThe new Mac Minis are really powerful. What doesn't it have that you're hoping for?
- matthewmacleod 7y agoGPU for me. I’d snap one up if it had a GPU in line with that in the MacBook Pro. I don’t particularly want a large external GPU hooked up over Thunderbolt.
- aczerepinski 7y ago
- _bxg1 7y agoYou are not the target market.
- mantap 7y agoAnd who is? Who exactly is buying $13000 workstations with AMD GPUs?
- _bxg1 7y agoPixar.
- hu3 7y agoNot according to electricslpnsld: > I worked at two movie studios (Pixar, Weta Digital) and they were both almost 100% Linux with a smattering of Windows machines here and there. Apple stuff was mainly iPads for story boarding and that kind of stuff. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20088170 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20088170
- _bxg1 7y agoThe point isn't that they use Apple, it's that they would be willing to pay 5 figures for a workstation: https://schuttejoe.github.io/post/disneypostmortem/ https://schuttejoe.github.io/post/disneypostmortem/ > This image was rendered at 2048x858 with 256spp and took 3.5 hours to render. I allowed it access to 28Gb of RAM but had to estimate how much embree would use for BVH data so it occasionally would exceed that number enough that the OS would start paging.
- mantap 7y agoOf course there are people and companies willing to spend 5 figures on a workstation but most of them want Nvidia graphics. When you are paying tens of thousands of dollars you don't want to be stuck in Apple's weird AMD-only walled garden.
- robdachshund 7y agoI mean apple has always been a joke in terms of hardware and value. I wouldn't expect anything less. Look at the most recent imacs. Base model is some absurd price and comes with a 5400rpm drive. I don't get why some developers are still clinging to them as if their ecosystem provides something that linux and windows don't. Being unix based and having Adobe products is not worth the price. At least people are finally figuring this out and moving away from the last few generations of terrible macbook models. Why developers of all people eat their crap up is just plain inexplicable.
- empath75 7y agoWhy is the iMac pro not what you want?
- rogueresearch 7y agoGlossy display.
- throwayEngineer 7y agoMacs are for uninformed consumers, you are willing to shop around. They are prepackaged fashion statements. College kids and middle class mom's, basically when someone else is paying, Apple wants your business. Devs don't use them unless they absolutely must to compile an iOS app.
- yzxku 7y agoWhen I absolutely must compile an iOS app I use a vmware virtual machine I download from the pirate bay :P
- shoo_pl 7y agoWell, I did not even hope it would cost $3k. The moment they released iMac Pro at $5k it was obvious it will cost at least that much. I hoped for the same price point since it comes without a monitor.
- Sophistifunk 7y agoNo, no you won't. Xeons and boards that will run 2TB of ram cost a bloody fortune. Just because it's not for you, doesn't mean it's not a valuable product for others. I'll certainly be getting one (not for a while, but eventually) because I want an upgrade path, and dev tools and Docker can put to good use every GB of ram I can afford.