8 ms·
These guys are just like every other group that wants to setup their own society "free" of government. But look closely at their plans. They don't want to get
by sandworm101 7y ago
These guys are just like every other group that wants to setup their own society "free" of government. But look closely at their plans. They don't want to get rid of nation states. They just want to setup their own nation states under their own legal structure, one that sees them atop everyone else too poor to build their own floating palace.
Ask them their opinions on the big crimes (murder/rape/arson etc). Will they allow me to keep slaves on my seastead? Of course not. May I operate an industrial smelter and dump the waste overboard? May I buys some guns, capture other seasteads and setup my own dictatorship? These people don't want to escape the real laws, just the handful of minor regulations with which they disagree. These are nothing more than rich randians complaining about their tax bracket.
- sammyo 7y agoAnd if they ever manage to build a few houses on a barge outside territorial waters, about 12 miles, they'll call on the closest government for emergency rescue a few hours into the first good storm.
- sandworm101 7y agoOr when they need an appendix removed. Then they want a "real" doctor, someone who learned their trade at a well-regulated hospital. Someone who is licensed by a medical board. Someone who has access to nice clean drugs manufactured in a lab subject to inspections. And then they want insurance coverage so they aren't out of pocket if something goes wrong during the operation. And then they expect some sort of rules-based enforcement structure to regulate all of these things. And don't forget some sort payment structure to support all these people ... This is getting complicated. Someone should write all these complicated rules down in a big book. Just don't call them laws.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThen not too different from living in a undeveloped/least developed country?
- mycall 7y agoThere are two big problems with 12 miles: 1) not far enough for economic zones [0] and 2) once you leave a country, you need a visa to return, which can be problematic. [0] https://www.theadvocates.org/2019/05/couple-could-be-imprisoned-or-executed-for-seasteading-off-of-thailand/ https://www.theadvocates.org/2019/05/couple-could-be-impriso...
- apocalypstyx 7y agoPretty much what China Mieville pointed out about them.[1] [1] http://inthesetimes.com/article/3328/floating_utopias http://inthesetimes.com/article/3328/floating_utopias
- Nursie 7y ago"It is a small schadenfreude to know that these dreams will never come true. There are dangerous enemies, and then there are jokes of history. The libertarian seasteaders are a joke. The pitiful, incoherent and cowardly utopia they pine for is a spoilt child’s autarky, an imperialism of outsourcing, a very petty fascism played as maritime farce: Pinochet of Penzance." That is cutting :) An enjoyable read, thanks for the link.
- chr1 7y agoWhy would anyone want to get rid of nation states? Merging them would create even larger and slower bureaucracies, breaking them into smaller pieces would not be allowed. The only solution is to let them be and try to build something new. > Ask them their opinions on the big crimes (murder/rape/arson etc). Will they allow me to keep slaves on my seastead? Are you complaining that there are not enough crazy people? No one wants to escape the real laws, because they are proven to be necessary for the society to work, and everyone agrees about them. The "minor regulations" are the laws that make all the difference. > These are nothing more than rich randians complaining about their tax bracket When this "rich randians" make the technology for living and working in a floating city cheap, they not only will get what they want but also will make it possible for "brave marxians" to try out their ideas too, and maybe they'll finally will build the society that will show to everyone that high taxes and planned economy are the best things.
- dexterdog 7y ago> maybe they'll finally will build the society that will show to everyone that high taxes and planned economy are the best things. I'm not holding my breath
- chr1 7y agoNeither do i, but if some people truly believe that communism/socialism can work without iron curtain keeping people inside, they should be happy about seasteading as it will give them a way to test their hypothesis.
- hobofan 7y ago> No one wants to escape the real laws, because they are proven to be necessary for the society to work, and everyone agrees about them. There are (next to) no laws that are internationally agreed upon.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoWhile not the exact specifics, no, but can you point to a society which actively encourages theft and murder? I'm talking not for special circumstances (ie. execution for crimes), but the straight up "I just wanted to stab a dude" murder.
- jameslk 7y agoI think the whole point is to test the assumptions on governance. Countries don't start with answers to those questions because they aren't problems yet and they may never be problems for them. And to assume those are solved problems anywhere else is myopic. Existing countries don't even agree how those issues should be handled.
- seanalltogether 7y agoAdditionally they want (need) to leech off whatever larger nation they are floating nearest to. So they get to take advantage of all the benefits and conveniences provided by a mature country without contributing to the costs required to maintain it. Its like all the people who claim they want to live out in the wilderness tax free and be left alone but in reality they live just on the edge of society so they can continue to come and go as they please.
- bubblewrap 7y agoSo if you live off the coast of some country, that country is liable to take care of you? Or maybe the seasteaders would simply pay for whatever services they need? Just like humans have traded for most of their existence? Or maybe by "take advantage of" you mean "trade"?
- fooblitzky 7y agoIf the navy deters pirates from operating in the area, even if the sea-steaders never see the pirates, would they still have to pay the navy?
- bubblewrap 7y agoWould the seasteaders be their own country? Then maybe the navy of another country wouldn't automatically come to their aid, unless they negotiate a deal?
- luckylion 7y ago> So if you live off the coast of some country, that country is liable to take care of you? If they ever get into a storm and need help: yes.
- lojack 7y agoI don't get the feeling from their site that their mission is to eliminate government or create a truly "free" society as much as it is to experiment with ideas around governance.
- tylersmith 7y agoThis exactly. Many seasteaders are anarchists but many just want to be able to experiment with governance.
- stcredzero 7y agoThese guys are just like every other group that wants to setup their own society "free" of government. But look closely at their plans. They don't want to get rid of nation states. They just want to setup their own nation states under their own legal structure So, basically following the precedent of human beings across all of recorded human history and almost certainly for much longer. Ask them their opinions on the big crimes (murder/rape/arson etc). Will they allow me to keep slaves on my seastead? Of course not. In 2019, savvy humans should look askance at everyone who proposes new governments or changes to existing governments without prioritizing a first-principles approach to preserving fundamental human rights. As far as we know, such a principles based approach -- which disperses power and takes into account people's natural tendency towards groupthink/tribalism, bias, and corruption -- does the best job of preserving human rights and increasing the general welfare. It's not perfect. It will have problems, but it's a lot better than everything else we've tried. There isn't something magic in people that suddenly changes them to angels, if we'd only make some deep, profound realization. That's some of the oldest ideological snake oil there is. It's no more valid now in 2019 than when stone buildings were the technological marvel of the day and mythologies were the best societal and epistemological proposals going around. The best we have ever done is a set of rules that keeps individual people from being treated unfairly like garbage and acts to disperse power. These are nothing more than rich randians complaining about their tax bracket. Everyone is "nothing more" than _insert reductive term here_. History shall judge them by their works.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Allower 7y agoI like your words
- sangnoir 7y ago>So, basically following the precedent of human beings across all of recorded human history and almost certainly for much longer Fair enough, but do they have a navy? A few months (years?) back, there was a "territorial dispute" between seasteaders and a South East Asian state - Singapore IIRC; the side with the tax-funded, floating gun platforms won.
- jmull 7y agoIt doesn't look like your criticism has much to do with what they are proposing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 7y agoPlenty of apparently innocuous proposals have an agenda or ulterior motive behind them.
- dmix 7y agoTherefore this one does?
- ceejayoz 7y agoNot necessarily, but Peter Thiel combined with "enrich the poor, clean the atmosphere, feed the hungry" sets off substantial doubt for me, and thus I suspect the stated goals to be akin to corporations engaging in greenwashing.
- dingosity 7y agoyes. this one does. just talk to the people involved.
- randyrand 7y agoIs there a difference between anarchy and libertarianism? I always thought there was...
- thinkingemote 7y agoI see then as hackers of society and laws. That they will probably end up with a replica is not the point. We hack to hack, to grok the systems. Let's not stop hackers hacking because we know better.
- joe_the_user 7y agoHacking a computer is great in that you probably cannot damage the internal components of that machine. Hacking society has issues given that random internal change of a society can have serious consequences for the members of that society. Modern democratic society has various safety nets that to various extents cushion members from random fluctuations that happen even without hacking. Sure, it seems fine when a group of individuals start-up a system "knowing what they're getting into". But it's generally no really possible for 19 year old joining the latest new trend to really know what they're getting into. We saw a whole flock of cults and unfortunate effects coming out of the hippy communes in the 1960s. But when a commune went bad, it was somewhat minor because the people could just leave. I shudder to what happens if things go bad in a platform in the middle of the ocean (and recall problems have already appeared).
- vinceguidry 7y agoIt wasn't always the case where hacking computers could be done without consequence. In the beginning a great war was conducted by the original MIT hackers against university officials who were trying to pry control of the system away from them. Similarly, it's the dream of every hacker to find a sandbox world where they can experiment to their heart's content. These government and society hackers as much as anyone. There have been examples throughout history of 'partial sovereignty', the one closest to mind is that of the Native American nations in the US. They're sovereign in most of the ways that matter while still retaining the ability to bring in the grownups when things get serious. The other example I can think of is the British concept of political devolution, whereby four independent countries with their own governments fit neatly into the collective United Kingdom, whereby the countries can demand ever greater self-rule through democratic process. This is how Ireland became both the Republic of Ireland and the UK country of Northern Ireland arose. What's now the Republic of Ireland wanted a complete break, while Northern Ireland still wants to be a part of the UK. This is different from the federal system that most countries use, where provinces are forever subordinate to the larger collective. There is no political process available for secession in the US or most anywhere else except the UK, so demands for self-governance usually result in nothing or in civil war. We should greatly encourage people to experiment with new political structures, and we can look to the Brits for inspiration on how to make that work. They tolerated Sealand until the whole project collapsed under its own weight. Which is pretty much how you want it to happen. War is the usual instrument by which new sovereignties are created. A peaceful way to blow away political cruft has great potential to eventually improve a lot of lives. It's been shown that the primary thing that keeps many people in perpetual poverty is rules, it's the founding principle behind the concept of charter cities. There's room for experimentation here.
- Gravityloss 7y agoYeah. Like some libertarians who want to live on a space ship with no darn environmentalists.
- olalonde 7y agoI have some questions for you. Is it possible to distinguish between someone who believes taxes are bad for society, or immoral, from someone who's unhappy about their tax bracket? Between someone who believes regulations do more harm than good from someone who is pissed off at a couple of minor regulations? Between someone who believes in experimenting with new forms of governance and someone who wants to dominate the poor? Surely some of those ideas attract selfish people, but is it that unreasonable to think that a lot of them actually believe in the stated mission?
- skywhopper 7y agoProbably not really. If you really hate paying taxes you can convince yourself that taxes are bad. If you ignore all evidence to the contrary and just really hate filing paperwork and following rules, you can convince yourself that regulation is harmful. If you actually want to experiment with new forms of governance, you will need to convince lots of other people to go along instead of just declaring yourself sovereign and then complaining that other countries don't recognize your right to do that just because you're rich.
- DuskStar 7y agoAnd if you hate the rich, you can convince yourself that no tax rate is too high. If you just really hate big business, there's no such thing as a bad regulation, because anything that makes life harder for business is a good thing. Is it possible to distinguish someone who thinks taxes are good from society from someone who hates everyone better off from themselves?
- defterGoose 7y agoAbsolutely you can distinguish. The person who hates everyone better off than themselves would have to make a special exemption for themselves so that all their money wouldn't be taxed away too and leave them at best on an even playing field with those they (previously?) hated. The person who believes taxes are good for society would of course happily (or at least voluntarily) pay their share of whatever the mandated tax was. Inverting the original question semantically doesn't mean that you've provided a valid counter-example.
- dingosity 7y agowow. i came here to post a few snarky comments. strangely happy to see others have beat me to it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 7y agoSee also: "Galt's Gulch of Chile" (2014). https://www.salon.com/2014/09/16/ayn_rands_capitalist_paradise_lost_the_inside_story_of_a_libertarian_scam_partner/ https://www.salon.com/2014/09/16/ayn_rands_capitalist_paradi...