9 ms·
Millennials ‘Make Farming Sexy’ in Africa, Where Tilling Soil Once Meant Shame
- jobigoud 7y agoWhat is up with the Millenials Do X, Millenials do Y? I don't remember reading this kind of stories for previous generations. Why are things attributed to a collective like this, it's weird.
- Sniffnoy 7y agoOn the contrary, it's not weird at all. It's incorrect, but such thinking in collectives is entirely natural. It's seeing past such things and recognizing that one should not to attribute things to collectives like this that is unusual.
- yoz-y 7y agoMaybe it's an immune system reaction to so many articles insinuating that millennials are lazy, doomed or spend all of their time on Instagram.
- andai 7y agoYou left out the part where we aren't getting laid.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- navigatesol 7y ago>Why are things attributed to a collective like this, it's weird. Because when you look at broad trends you can see patterns among cohorts, and sometimes those patterns are important in economic and government policy.
- LargeWu 7y ago1. We have a lot more data now 2. We have a lot more publications now, that publish continuously, and those writers have to write about something.
- dfxm12 7y agoThere were a lot of "Gen X" stories around 10-20 years ago. Controversy, in this case pitting one tribe against another, creates cash.
- NikkiA 7y ago"grows snails and rats" come on NYT, the word 'raises' is right there.
- mjfl 7y agoin Ghana, how well are property laws enforced? Is there violence against farmers, like there is in South Africa? Article does not touch on this, but could be another reason why people choose not to farm.
- claudeganon 7y agoI’m not sure if you’re aware, but this is largely a conspiracy theory concocted by the far right: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/aug/23/white-farmers-trump-south-africa-tucker-carlson-far-right-influence https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/aug/23/white-farmers-...
- gubbrora 7y agoThat article is heavy on how "the other" is talking about this, but light on facts about the situation on the ground. Here is an article about the farm attacks https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/africa/south-africa-white-farmers-plaasmoorde-cyril-ramaphosa-anc-economic-freedom-fighters-gabriel-stols-a8262306.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/africa/south-africa...
- deogeo 7y agoIt is very curious that an article so heavy on how others talk about something, wouldn't mention the leader of a major South African political party saying "We are not calling for the slaughter of white people‚ at least for now" [1]. A statement that was explicitly not commented on by the largest party. In fact, he received their support when he got in trouble for repeatedly singing "shoot the boer". Seems rather comparable to if the KKK had 10% of the senate in the US, and the tacit cooperation of one of the two major parties. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_Freedom_Fighters#Anti-white_prejudice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_Freedom_Fighters#Anti...
- Rebelgecko 7y agoThe article doesn't really seem to back that up. Lots of the people pushing that theory are definitely alt-right types, but when the article doesn't present any facts to contradict them it doesn't make it seem like they're actually wrong. For some "conspiracy theories" it can be impossible to prove someone wrong, but there should be some pretty straightforward statistics to help figure out if this is bogus or not. FWIW it seems to be a commonly held belief by South Africans. The ones I know told me that in SA they won't stop at a red stoplight ("robot") in certain areas. The risk of getting carjacked and murdered is higher (or perceived to be higher) than the risk of getting in a deadly car crash when running a red light.
- Mikeb85 7y agoAt the end of the day, people need food to eat. If farming can provide a decent living (in this case, it looks as though Ghana is under-served in this sector), people will fill that gap. Even more than that, farming is an essential human activity and we could use another green revolution.
- mc32 7y agoTrue. I think Ghana has it s bit easier than other places, because they haven’t suffered a prolonged disaster. Weak countries affected by ongoing disasters get international aid which can have “dumping” effect by undercutting the native farmers and making their enterprise less viable. In countries where this happens they (aid) have to be careful they don’t end up undercutting local economies when they try to “help”,
- gridlockd 7y agoDo economies really need to go through that "farming phase" to grow? I don't see the connection. Modern farming employs less than 1% of the population. Non-modern farming can not compete at all except in tiny niches. So how are those "native farmers" going to bring their societies from poverty to prosperity, by being completely uncompetitive, but protected at the same time?
- imtringued 7y agoPeople without incomes can't afford cheap imported food.
- gridlockd 7y agoWho says they don't have incomes? Let's say they don't have incomes, who says the solution is becoming a farmer as opposed to performing any other form of work? In 2019, being a farmer without modern machinery is pretty much the least valuable form of labor one could perform, unless we're talking about very specific foods that need special care, i.e. not the kind of food that actually feeds a population. Only narrow-minded "back-to-the-roots" westerners who idealize farming could come up with such a non-solution. Thankfully, the Chinese who idealize money are building factories in Africa to turn that labor into real economic value.
- nhhilltopper 7y agoTry finding capital, infrastructure, stable and non-corrupt government, and competent legal system in most of Africa (it is a large continent - not just Ghana, Nigeria and South Africa). Going much beyond sustenance in Africa is still a massive challenge.
- gridlockd 7y agoTo add to that, Ghana, Nigeria and South Africa are "easy mode". Those countries are far more developed than people imagine, despite massive corruption.
- rmason 7y agoThis is a great development for a number of reasons: 1. You've got high unemployment and a homegrown agriculture will put people to work. 2. Citizens diet is less dependent on a long supply chain 3. A local agriculture will drive down the cost of food. This will make a measurable difference in everyone's life. In America we pay 6.4% of our income for food, in Africa it's 60%. If the cost of food goes down people will have more money for other things. https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/12/this-map-shows-how-much-each-country-spends-on-food/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/12/this-map-shows-how-mu...
- zizee 7y agoFrom your linked article, the reason people spend a greater percentage of their incomes on food is not because of the cost of food, but that their incomes are much lower: > The figures do not mean that food is more expensive in Nigeria than in the US. In fact, quite the reverse. The average American spends $2,392 per year on food, the average Nigerian half that: $1,132. The average Kenyan spends just $543 a year on food. There are many benefits of Africa having the infrastructure/skills/industry to produce food in a more scalable way, but % of income is possibly not the metric to measure by. [edit] changed last sentence.
- infogulch 7y agoLook at it this way: if the percentage income spent on food dropped from 60% to, say 20%, that would effectively double their remaining income! I don't see how that could not affect a local economy, regardless of the absolute scale.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoIf food prices drop, won’t farmers make less too and hence lower income? Maybe I am not understanding the math properly. Food is cheap in the USA because we import them from poorer countries where labour is cheap. And we also consume a lot. This benefits the exporting country. But if we were to produce our own food, the local production won’t be cheaper.
- 7y ago
- bayareanative 7y agoYum. Escargot and rats. Michelin 3* in Tokyo, no problem.
- neodypsis 7y agoOne thing that shocked me is they breeding "giant rats" (Cricetomys gambianus). These are known vectors of monkeypox. Also, snails usually carry very harmful parasites to both humans and plants.
- IloveHN84 7y agoBut snails are really delicious, also for EU.
- consp 7y agoBreeding them in captivity might actually solve those problems as you can control the livestock.
- Double_a_92 7y agoIf they breed it it's a farm animal like anyone else.
- neodypsis 7y agoSure, but, e.g., pig, chicken or cow breeders are subjected to strict sanitary controls and microbiological testing programs.
- mmsimanga 7y agoTo add more information to the article. I have been slowly trying to build up a hydroponics shaded structure. I have to finance this myself so this will take a few years. There a few reasons I am doing this. I want an alternative to an office job. Sometimes just sitting in front of a computer drains the soul. I don't trust the financial systems in my home country and have my doubts if my pension will support me later in life. I do think there is a profit to be made. A fare amount of food is imported. The weird thing is that small scale farming will only be viable as long as Africa is not attractive to big farmers. The moment big farmers can get going I think it will be the end of small scale farming.
- titzer 7y agoFrom a long line of farmers...this is just one of the first steps of industrialization. It took two generations to eradicate family farming in America (at least where I am from), and it will happen faster for Africa. It's great that people have better and more effective local food production, but when the real economics kick in, and these people are competing with corporate farming, their way of life will change, sadly, for the worse, as it did in America. Enjoy the sense of freedom and pride now, and defend it as long as you can, because there are serious doubts as to whether this will be feasible in 50 years.
- mmsimanga 7y agoYou hit the nail on the head! See my second paragraph in a sibling comment[0]. I will just expand on the point here. Investing in Africa is not for the faint of heart and your stand a good chance of losing your money. You also have to be prepared to pay some bribes to ensure that you can do business. This makes mining and oil about the only places external investors will invest in Africa. This is what has left a gap for the small farmer. We are small farmers because getting a loan isn't easy so we self fund. South Africa on the other hand, the country I work in is very different from other parts of Africa. There are large commercial farms which produce most of the food for the country. Suppliers are not interested in small scale farmers. Animal medicines only sold through vets or in quantities of 10 000. Suppliers of shade cloth and other farming materials largely ignore you when you want to buy a handful of stock. It is very different to my home country where everyone has a few animals and you can buy whatever you want in small quantities. South Africa represents what Africa will be in the next generation or two. I full agree with your comment and I would like to enjoy the small scale farming while it is possible. [0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20080828 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20080828
- majani 7y agoI live in Kenya and this has already happened. The 'make farming cool' movement is very emotionally driven and ill advised. Small scale farming is just not sustainable any more.
- Quipunotch104 7y agoIs there such a thing as an "African millennial"? Are there Gen-Xers in Africa? Was there a baby boom to produce Baby Boomers? Aren't these generational terms relevant to the USA only? NYTimes recently covered the distinctions between Millennials and Gen-Xers, and none of those cultural touchpoints or characteristics of Millennials seem to be appropriate for describing any generation in Ghana.
- simonask 7y agoSo it is absolutely and obviously not true that generational terms like 'millenial' and 'Gen-X' only apply to the USA, because the same characteristics apply (and are used) in all of Europe, most of Asia, Australia, New Zealand, South America, and so on. Africa is a very big place, though, in varying stages of development. Several places have burgeoning middle classes, with access to similar amounts of consumer goods as the rest of the world. Is there any reason to think that these middle classes don't face similar generational shifts?
- IkmoIkmo 7y agoMillennials are typically defined as an age-cohort. So yes, you could apply that term to denote a certain generation of Africans, no problem. It may not be useful or confusing, but there's technically nothing wrong with it. One of the key traits (stereo)typically discussed in the media w.r.t. millennials is a sense of entitlement, growing up with technology. And to a lesser extent, millennials tend to be more understanding of the importance of the environment and diet. That happens to reflect exactly the article's premise: agriculture is seen as something that poor, illiterate rural people do. Whereas millennials in Africa are urbanising, have mobile phones, are literate and went to school and are looking for a manufacturing or services job, not an agricultural one. The concept of the millennial translates just fine to the African context, in the case of this article. The average age in Africa is 24, yet the average farmer is 60. That's where millennials come in, reshaping the idea of farming, and giving it a modern touch. That's what the article is about. > Aren't these generational terms relevant to the USA only? I mean, even if you disagreed that an African millennial made sense as a concept... there's hundreds of millions of people living in countries with very similar concepts. (e.g. much of Europe, Canada, Australia, Japan etc). It's not a term exclusive to the US.
- timwaagh 7y agoIn Holland, land of many onions, being a farmer usually means having over a million in assets. it's not a career choice for young people without significant assets. things will go in that direction everywhere and it means small farmers will go the way of the dodo. so they are in fact wrong in trying to get a lot of people to choose farming. you only need a few rich guys.