4 ms·
[edit] warning: you might find this comment irrelevant, annoying or even false You forgot the juiciest parts: - private company plays on legal gray areas on p
by agumonkey 7y ago
[edit] warning: you might find this comment irrelevant, annoying or even false
You forgot the juiciest parts:
- private company plays on legal gray areas on purpose
- private company invest aggressively to expand faster than law can react in order to grab said monopoly
This is basically capital cancer, they had a real value but dismissed everything a company is to a society:
- stable for employees
- stable for users
- stable for society
Any company can play rough when let loose with massive funds, but when reality occurs, just like anybody else, they'll have to round their corners and .. surprise.. they stop being interested and competitive.
- quotemstr 7y agoThis is a bad comment. The OP had a valuable point that applies to companies inside and outside of this "gray area[]". You're just making a tired and repetitive dig at Uber itself. It may be that Uber's gig economy model has important downsides of its own, but the salient problem is of private control of what's become public infrastructure, and that has nothing to do with Uber being cancer or something.
- tracer4201 7y agoDid Uber not do exactly what op said? Aggressively grow to capture markets before the legal system could react? How is that a bad comment? I mean, the original article is about Uber. How is op in the wrong by describing exactly the business model they adopted?
- quotemstr 7y agoThe OP isn't wrong: the problem is that his point is irrelevant. The real question, to which nobody has an answer, is this: what do we do as a society when a small number of private companies corner the market for an essential part of modern life and then institute arbitrary criteria for refusing service to people? How this situation came about doesn't matter. Uber making all drivers full employees would not change the dynamic one bit. Complaining about Uber's employment model instead of discussing this really important control question just annoys me. It deflects a potentially interesting conversation into grievance-airing about gig jobs.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIt's somewhat relevant because it was plain as a day through continued behaviour that Uber is a sociopathic company. So while not all companies would follow the mechanic in question, and different companies may follow it at different pace, it was always obvious that Uber will screw riders over as soon as possible.
- kolinko 7y agoWhat we do? Well, that's what antitrust laws and offices are for. In Europe they tend to work quite nicely.
- enraged_camel 7y ago>>How this situation came about doesn't matter. On the contrary, we need to really understand how we got here first, in order to be able to recognize patterns of the problem and determine how to avoid it in the future. As the saying goes, those who don’t know history are doomed to repeat it.
- tracer4201 7y agoIt’s irrelevant that a company is able to skirt regulation? Would Uber be in the position to “institute arbitrary criteria” if they had to compete in an environment with proper governance being in place? The crux of your argument is we shouldn’t care about how we get there but what happens next or essentially, how do we react. If you want to solve a problem, identify and fix the root cause instead of reactively applying some patch to cover the bleeding. Getting “annoyed” at someone discussing the root cause is misguided.
- agumonkey 7y agoFair point. I was a bit easy to comment. But there's a public side to my point. Services can be wiped with such business models which is detrimental to society. Amazon pushed a lot of people aside, now their prices are all but guaranteed to be fair.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wbronitsky 7y agoWhy is it tired? Because you don’t agree with it? I would argue that your comment is the bad comment. Lots of unproven assertions, and it all began with a needless, toxic attack
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoHow is Uber anywhere near a monopoly? Also, taxi companies were worse in all your criteria, Uber is actually an improvement regardless.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoNo, they weren't. Taxi companies operated legally. Uber routinely broke the law. Also it still perplexes me that Uber managed to convince so many people with their bullshit PR campaign about the small upstart facing the Taxi Mafia - when from the beginning it was a heavily-funded company, later turned multinational corporation, fighting small local providers with underhand tactics.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoTaxi companies provided a horrible customer experience, routinely discriminated, and often defrauded their customers. I know because I suffered from it long before Uber ever existed.
- nradov 7y agoI'm not trying to excuse Uber but taxi companies in some places also routinely broke the law by refusing to travel to certain areas, pick up some minority passengers, or accept credit cards. In theory they were accountable to local taxi commissions but in practice that was totally ineffective in forcing drivers to obey the law.
- onemoresoop 7y agoAnd, in addition, in many places taxi companies became a cartel: remember the TLC medallion madness where some crooks were reaping the cream of the crop.
- dclusin 7y agoIt sounds like you've never been stranded late at night waiting hours for a cab that was "5 minutes away." I don't participate in the bar scene anymore. I don't benefit from the increased user experience of knowing exactly where your cab is, and if they cancel. Legal or not, I sure am glad those jackasses got their comeuppance.
- manfredo 7y ago> This is basically capital cancer, they had a real value but dismissed everything a company is to a society: > - stable for employees > - stable for users > - stable for society No. Stability comes at the expense of dynamism. Innovation disrupts stability, and society is more often than not better off for it. You pay a needless tax whenever you buy a CD or flash drive which gets handed off to record companies in the presumption that you will pirate music. Politicians decided that the music industry needed more stability, and passed laws to make consumers fork over tax money to subsidize them. There was a push to make ride-share companies wait at least 30 minutes before pairing riders up with a car. Not to guarantee any sort of safety or to fight congestion. It was literally just degrading service in order to make taxi companies more competitive with Uber, Lyft, etc. Trying to achieve stability frequently hurts users and degrades quality of service.