5 ms·
It's also possible to be for social progress, but also think the world is over-populated. In fact if a person generally worries about the future of humanity, I
by simonh 7y ago
It's also possible to be for social progress, but also think the world is over-populated. In fact if a person generally worries about the future of humanity, I would not be surprised to see a strong correlation between those two attitudes.
A fertility rate of 1.7 isn't the same as 'not reproducing' and doesn't imply 'going extinct'. You can't just extrapolate a trend at any given moment indefinitely. Otherwise if you pick a moment of rising population you'll extrapolate up to infinity or if you pick a moment of falling population you'll extrapolate to zero. Reality doesn't work like that. Arguably it's just a trend towards right-sizing the population.
Globally fertility rates have been falling for many decades. It's hardly surprising that the poorest countries are among the last to see fertility rates decline the most, but as income and education rates in those regions rise, their fertility rates will also fall.
As a for secularization, which you seem to conflate with social progress, counting 'Muslims' and 'Christians' isn't a simple exercise. Counting everyone born to Muslim parents as Muslim doesn't make any more sense than counting everyone who gives presents at Christmas as Christian. In fact attendances at Mosques and actual participation in religious activities is in decline across most of the Muslim world. In Europe most 'Muslims' do not pray every day. Egypt is a good proxy for trends in the Muslim world due to it's cultural influence. There are steep declines in religious practice and support for imposing Sharia Law has more than halved over the last decade.
- Ygg2 7y agoWorld isn't overpopulated. I don't think there is a hard limit on number of people. >You can't just extrapolate a trend at any given moment indefinitely. I assume the model probably looks at chances that offspring of Muslim parents share parents religion. > fertility rate of 1.7 isn't the same as 'not reproducing' and doesn't imply 'going extinct'. When you have countries with median age 40+, you know their health care and other systems are also struggling. The lower your fertility the older your society, the older your society, the lower your fertility. Can't attract immigrants? You are fucked basically.
- simonh 7y agoMy main concern with overpopulation isn't how many people the world could support as a maximum, I'm sure it's very high, it's how many it can support without dramatically degrading the environment. An ageing population has negative consequences, sure, we'll just have to manage them. Allowing the population to increase indefinitely isn't a solution though, it's just kicking the can down the road until you do hit a hard limit, and then you're in _real_ trouble.
- mymythisisthis 7y agoAll the good land is now dedicated to farming. What's left is the stuff that is hard to grow on; too rocky, too cold, too north for any light, too dry. It turns out the oceans are the opposite of robust, for how large they are. The economy of N. America depends on building cheap housing, to attract more immigrants, so they can work building housing, to sell to new immigrants. I have nothing against immigrants. Just pointing out how the economy really works, despite what a small handful of people in a booming (but slowing) tech sector feel about what drives the economy - it's the housing market.
- whatshisface 7y agoThat's a humongous assertion about the US economy and not at all in line with the data. Construction is only 4.0% of the GDP, and the lump of finance and real estate (renting, reselling mixed in with the entire stock market) is 20%. >The economy of N. America depends on building cheap housing, to attract more immigrants, so they can work building housing, to sell to new immigrants. As described, that would fall into the 4%. https://www.bea.gov/data/gdp/gdp-industry https://www.bea.gov/data/gdp/gdp-industry
- smaddox 7y agoThe housing market is not really what drives the economy. It is where a massive amount of credit has been funnelled in the last few decades, though. We do need to change how our macro-economy functions, but unfortunately politicians and most of the economists advising them are oblivious to the critical role that credit plays.
- avar 7y ago> I don't think there is a hard limit on number of people. We have around 7 billion people now. At the current growth rate of about 1%/yr the biomass of human beings will exceed the current weight of the planet Earth around the year 7200. Not long after that this hypothetical growing humanity would collapse into a black hole under its own weight. It'll already be quite cramped in the year 5400 with 1% growth. We'll have 5 people for every square meter of the surface of Earth (we have 510.1 trillion m^2). That's about the density near the front-row of a standing concert.
- syshum 7y ago>World isn't overpopulated. I don't think there is a hard limit on number of people. Yes there most certainly is a hard limit on how many people this plant can support. We have increased it, and continue to increase that limit with technology at a faster rate than reproduction but there are social trends that are seeing that progress rolled back. Anti-GMO, Organic, and several other social trends in food production means the amount of land, water, and other supplied needed to a feed a person is growing not reducing. With out Advanced Farming, pesticides, GMO Crops and other advancements we would have exceeded the planets ability to provide long ago.
- djg321 7y agoNow that there is a strong incentive to produce organic non gmo food, technologies will be developed to increase crop yield given those constraints (in addition to existing permissible technologies in organic farming such as drip irrigation, tractors and: https://interestingengineering.com/video/this-flamethrowing-tractor-gets-rid-of-weeds-without-the-need-of-chemicals https://interestingengineering.com/video/this-flamethrowing-...). Sure, yields would always be higher if gmo and chemical pesticides were allowed, but in the long run we can still expect yields to increase.
- syshum 7y agoGMO is not just about increasing yields but also getting crops to grow in wider more diverse climates, something we may very well need with Global Warming Take for example the Semi-dwarf wheat that has been claimed to save billions of people and makes up pretty much all wheat grown today. This adversion of GMO is not based in science but rather F.U.D. I find it amusing that many people that are Anti-GMO are also very very concerned with Climate Change, and laugh a people that question climate change for being "anti-science" then then spread all kinds of lies and misinformation about GMO...
- __HYde 7y ago> I don't think there is a hard limit on number of people. Humans through our metabolic process generate waste heat and Earth can only radiate so much so that does put a hard cap, albeit one much higher than people generally image, but a cap nonetheless. If we assume only the heat generated by our metabolic process that puts the limit over 250 trillion[0] but if we account for energy for food and industrial purposes that puts the limit closer to 10 trillion[1]. [0] https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/19441/whats-the-highest-population-the-earth-could-possibly-sustain https://worldbuilding.stackexchange.com/questions/19441/what... [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XAJeYe-abUA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XAJeYe-abUA
- diebir 7y agoThe world is overpopulated. Humans have already eliminated as many species as other great extinction events. Our industrial activity has changed the Earth climate. There is very little wilderness left anywhere. The forests are getting clear cut and eliminated. We have exceeded the Earth's capacity to support us already and there is no end in sight, unfortunately. Humans are the disease and unless we learn to live sustainably (as opposed to infinite expansion), the life is going to get worse for every subsequent generation and we are toast in the end.
- perl4ever 7y ago"A fertility rate of 1.7 isn't the same as 'not reproducing' and doesn't imply 'going extinct'. You can't just extrapolate a trend at any given moment indefinitely." Apart from that, if you speak of group A going extinct and group B not, you are implicitly defining them as separate species. I don't think that's an accurate description of the present nor a plausible description of the future.
- snowwrestler 7y agoRight, it’s really hard to talk about this subject without running into bigotry, accidentally or on purpose. Almost all the distinctions in the GP comment are not inherent and can (and will) change during a single human lifetime—like religiosity or whether one lives in a “developed nation.” In the long run, all nations are developed nations, and then what will we use to draw distinctions between human beings? I’m sure folks will think of something.
- antepodius 7y agoYou don't really need to look. Culture, race, will do fine.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bregma 7y agoThe very use of the term "developed nation" surfaces a priori bigotry. It's a dogwhistle word for "becoming westernized" or "joining Christendom". It just goes to show.
- rayiner 7y agoAre you from a “developing nation?”
- asark 7y agoIs it? A big chunk of the "developing world" is (generally) Christian—pretty much all of the Americas, big chunks of Africa. The Philippines. Russia and some of the former Soviet bloc states. Meanwhile everyone agrees Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan are among the "developed" states and I don't think it's fair to characterize them as Christian. I prefer to just shorthand this as "OECD" versus "non-OECD" which manages to just about cover all the states everyone actually means when they use "Western" (including tons of countries that aren't Western at all) or "developed", though the latter's a decent enough term IMO. "Western" is especially silly, of course, for a bunch of reasons, including that pretty much all the "original" Western states were themselves at some point "Westernized"—rolled over by Generic European-ish Capitalist "Culture", erasing most of what was there before, and absorbing and exporting those elements that could be sold to others (those parts becoming "Western")
- rayiner 7y ago> Counting everyone born to Muslim parents as Muslim doesn't make any more sense That is, in fact, exactly how it’s defined within that religion. Also, using Egypt as an example is deeply ironic: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZIqdrFeFBk https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZIqdrFeFBk
- simonh 7y agoWhy ironic? To this day the Hijab is not required in Egypt. Why should someone not in a religion care how that religion defines things? I'm not quite clear what you're trying to say here.
- rayiner 7y agoYou need to be aware of how the religion defines things because that definition has teeth for people actually living in those countries. The punishment for leaving (apostasy) is generally death. A third of people in the country where I’m from believe that really should be the punishment. (And it’s one of the “moderate” ones—in Egypt it’s about 2/3.) It’s a self-perpetuating system, which goes to the soundness of OP’s counting methodology above. In Egypt, the rate of wearing some form of veil went from almost zero in the middle of the 20th century to 90% today. For the most part, that trend is enforced through various degrees of social coercion.
- g8oz 7y agoSocial coercion goes both ways https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-44411333 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-44411333
- rayiner 7y agoIn those countries there is a big divide between the liberal elite, which tends to be more secular, and everyone else. But any “coercion” caused by classist attitudes pales to the coercion on the other side. To put that article in context for our American readers: it’s like someone writing an article about how someone from rural Georgia went to Atlanta and someone mocked their accent. Except it’s written against the backdrop of the state passing the heartbeat abortion law.