10 ms·
If the number of children is not growing, why is the population still increasing
- rahuldottech 7y agoTL;DR: life expectancy is longer now than ever before, so more women in the reproductive bracket, and this basically cancels out a falling fertility rate.
- 0n34n7 7y agoNo. The reproductive bracket has remained fairly constant in the last 100 years - i.e whether people get to 70 or 100, reproduction stops at ~50. The interesting point here is the concept of “population momentum” which acts like a capacitor that buffers decreasing fertility rates in the short term - yet - “peak child” has been reached. I think the takeaway here is people who extrapolate global population in 2100 at 15+ Billion have it wrong.
- nn3 7y agoIt could be also more females reaching reproductive age. Traditionally a lot of kids died early before they could reach it. This was a traditional limiter on average life time.
- simonh 7y ago>No. The reproductive bracket has remained fairly constant in the last 100 years - i.e whether people get to 70 or 100, reproduction stops at ~50. You're looking at the wrong thing. It's the life expectancy of the children that matters most, not the life expectancy of adults into old age. The reason the number of women in the reproductive bracket has risen is that more of those births are surviving to child bearing age.
- AstralStorm 7y agoTo a point this trend does continue, with developing countries taking up some slack. We'll see soon if this theory is correct with globally stagnating population or not.
- simonh 7y agoI prefer to say stabilising.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoHow you choose to spin it does nothing to change the very negative economic situation that a non-increasing population would bring.
- ido 7y agothat sounds like a problem with our economic system more than with our reproductive trends. At a certain point population growth would have had to plateau, it couldn't have continued growing forever.
- jcadam 7y agoIt's all self correcting in the long run, I say. A non-increasing population leads to economic stagnation (at best). That, coupled with a decline in religiosity leading to a loss of societal cohesion will eventually bring down the whole house of cards that is modern civilization. Famine, war, etc. follows. And we're back to a less populated world with high infant mortality again. Hard times lead to a return to religiosity and large families. Hopefully this all happens after I'm gone.
- simonh 7y agoWhat makes you believe secularism leads to reduced social cohesion? Surely it eliminates a source of friction between religious groups?
- antepodius 7y agoSuppose every member of a small town went to church every sunday. Everyone interacts with everyone else in the area, for a bit. You don't get that in secular society.
- em-bee 7y agoso that means the replacement rate of 2.3 should be dropping or has dropped
- ido 7y ago15B+ at 2100 is not the main-stream prediction anyway: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projections_of_population_growth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Projections_of_population_grow...
- ArnoVW 7y agoOr, for those who want a more entertaining version (by the excellent and late Hans Rosling) https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_on_global_population_growth https://www.ted.com/talks/hans_rosling_on_global_population_...
- rjf72 7y agoAs an aside, I think looking at the global fertility rate is not very informative. The only reason that global fertility rates remain above 2 is because of Africa and the Middle East. The people of developed nations are, for the most part, going to gradually go extinct. This is list as of nations by fertility rate. [1] And that list is also an aggregate. Things such as education, modest or secular religious views, and income all work as major factors against fertility when looking at the composition of what is already, even as an aggregate, below replacement fertility rates. This paints an interesting picture for the future. This [2] is a study from Pew showing the expected changes in religiosity in the future. Unaffiliated are expected to decrease from 16.4% to 13.2% by 2050, Buddhists down 7.1% to 5.2%., Muslims to increase from 23.2% to 29.7%, and so on. I don't understand why fertility rate is not a bigger consideration for people who consider themselves interested or invested in social progress. Fertility is arguably the biggest factor there is in what this world will look like in the coming years. If helping people to become economically comfortable, secular, and educated leads to them no longer reproducing - you're going to end up taking two steps back for every step forward. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_dependencies_by_total_fertility_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_d... [2] - https://www.pewforum.org/2015/04/02/religious-projections-2010-2050/ https://www.pewforum.org/2015/04/02/religious-projections-20...
- simonh 7y agoIt's also possible to be for social progress, but also think the world is over-populated. In fact if a person generally worries about the future of humanity, I would not be surprised to see a strong correlation between those two attitudes. A fertility rate of 1.7 isn't the same as 'not reproducing' and doesn't imply 'going extinct'. You can't just extrapolate a trend at any given moment indefinitely. Otherwise if you pick a moment of rising population you'll extrapolate up to infinity or if you pick a moment of falling population you'll extrapolate to zero. Reality doesn't work like that. Arguably it's just a trend towards right-sizing the population. Globally fertility rates have been falling for many decades. It's hardly surprising that the poorest countries are among the last to see fertility rates decline the most, but as income and education rates in those regions rise, their fertility rates will also fall. As a for secularization, which you seem to conflate with social progress, counting 'Muslims' and 'Christians' isn't a simple exercise. Counting everyone born to Muslim parents as Muslim doesn't make any more sense than counting everyone who gives presents at Christmas as Christian. In fact attendances at Mosques and actual participation in religious activities is in decline across most of the Muslim world. In Europe most 'Muslims' do not pray every day. Egypt is a good proxy for trends in the Muslim world due to it's cultural influence. There are steep declines in religious practice and support for imposing Sharia Law has more than halved over the last decade.
- cacucho 7y agoLess people dying
- lunchables 7y agoMaybe I'm missing something but I feel like the title is misleading. >If the number of children is not growing, why is the population still increasing But, it is, isn't it? The best TLDR I can grok (and forgive me, it's early and the coffee hasn't kicked in) is that there are fewer births per woman but more women in the reproductive age, so more births overall? Hopefully someone can help correct my misunderstanding.
- delecti 7y agoFrom the article, the number of children hasn't increased. The decrease in births per women cancels out the increase in women of reproductive age, resulting in the same rough number of births per year. It really comes down to this: > But it of course also matters that all of us today live much longer than our ancestors just a few generations ago. Life expectancy is now twice as long in all world regions.
- cblades 7y agotwice as long?! That is nuts, what's the math on that. Am I wrong in understanding that to mean, e.g., in lots of places the life expectancy was 40 and now it's 80?
- cadlin 7y agoLife expectancy is largely driven by infant mortality. Each marginal child that lives to 60 is equal to 12 adults living 5 years longer.
- YayamiOmate 7y agoBecause new people are still being crated and they live longer, it means that saturation level is higher. To me the title sounds like we were in "children of men" or "handmaid's tale" but the supply of people is the same. Amount kids is the same because they "die" when they become adults. So simple math tells us there's more adults. It's easy to imagine as a stream of ants going out of a wall crack. they walk straight and they die. If you take 1st few inches or cm, those are children, they enter and leave this area at a constant pace so the count is the same. Now you count ants on the rest of the path. How there can you make more ants there? They gotta die later. You can make them die statistically, cut path into sections and see how total or each section count change.
- g8oz 7y agoRelated: Japan's birth rate is 1.43 children per woman now, far below replacement rate of 2.1. If the trend continues forever (which is a silly assumption) the Japanese people will completely disappear by the year....2500. I don't think we need to worry about extinction. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/12068068/Mapped-how-a-demographic-time-bomb-will-transform-the-global-economy.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/12068068/Mappe...
- dev_dull 7y agoIt’s not really extinction that people worry about. It’s insolvency in virtually every social program the government runs. And it really doesn’t take much because those programs were created with very generous predictions in growth. For social security the insolvency date is 2025 according to our own governments accounting.
- moorhosj 7y ago==For social security the insolvency date is 2025 according to our own governments accounting. == Without changes, the Social Security system will pay out 79% of benefits starting in 2034 [1]. The concept that there will be no money paid out is oft-repeated, but mistaken. Certainly a 21% cut is very significant, but there will still be funds. Obviously, the sooner we make small changes, the better funded it will be long-term. Things like changing the inflation index, removing the income cap or adjusting the full-retirement date could fill the gap entirely. [1] https://www.ssa.gov/policy/trust-funds-summary.html https://www.ssa.gov/policy/trust-funds-summary.html
- toomuchtodo 7y agoDon't forget technology deflation. The less dollars you need overall (cheap energy, cheap electric mobility, technology used to make healthcare more efficient) makes a benefits haircut more tolerable (although we are a very wealthy nation and have the means to avoid a benefits haircut). When we get to universal healthcare, if my house is paid off, I have solar on my roof, and I have a paid off electric car, I don't expect my expenses to simply survive to be that high (and could live on less than 50% of my estimated social security benefit).
- erickj 7y agoI had assumed it would have been due to zombies... who knew?