6 ms·
Well like it says there's two kinds. One is "Hey, did you know this thing exists? Check it out! Here are all the tests it passed, realistic cost of ownership,
by lordnacho 7y ago
Well like it says there's two kinds.
One is "Hey, did you know this thing exists? Check it out! Here are all the tests it passed, realistic cost of ownership, and locations where it is in stock".
The other is "Look at this woman, isn't she fascinating? People like her will desire you more if you buy the thing she's lying on top of. Actual woman not included."
Unfortunately, people have discovered type 2 is effective for a lot of things. Not only that, there are no scruples at all with appealing to people in this kind of way. It's not lying in the normal sense, but it is manipulation, or an attempt at it. Current dogma seems to be that rational people can just take the type 1 info out of your type 2 advert and think with the appropriate organ.
- rwc 7y agoBut can you point to a time in human history where type 2 wasn't the predominant form of advertising? This is not some modern discovery or exploit.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoactually, subjectively I get the feeling looking back at older ads post-industrial revolution that the weight has shifted, and that the abundance of it (such that almost all advertising is psychological/social manipulation rather than presentation of facts) is some modern phenomenon. Previously the idea that you would struggle to know what specific product an ad is selling, where to buy it, what it costs, and what it's features are would seem obscene, but these days concepts of brand, desire, status, aspiration, are so omnipresent that deriving any pertinent details is now a common experience. Pre that, it probably is all the same, because modern advertising is, fundamentally, just propaganda rebranded by ad men.
- wk_end 7y agoSome historians of advertising - probably most famously, Adam Curtis in "The Century of the Self" - argue that "type 2" directly fell out of World War-era propaganda research redirected towards consumerism.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoCurtis must have missed the Victorian periodicals that are full of Type 2 ads. See e.g. http://christinetrent.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/cigs-1024x460.jpg http://christinetrent.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/cigs-10... http://christinetrent.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/pills.jpg http://christinetrent.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/pills.j... http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/copy-1-146-f6341.jpg http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/0... Industrial printed advertising started in the early 19th century with the first stirrings of printed mass media. But flyers and noticeboards have been around since at least Roman times, and limited-run pamphlet and newspaper/gazette ads were already a thing as far as back as the 16th century. The propaganda research is more Type 3 - tailored ads designed and monitored for effectiveness. Before Bernays ads were hit and miss, usually made by someone with a brush who could draw and set type. After Bernays it became a huge industry of influence, and concepts like branding, image, narrative, demographics, and dramatisation began to be used consciously.
- comex 7y agoThe first two ads seem pretty Type 1 to me: they mostly consist of text straightforwardly describing what the product supposedly does, except for a smallish image in the first one. The descriptions are incorrect (cigarettes are not safe, and whatever was in those pills was certainly not as efficacious as the ad claims), but that’s basically an orthogonal issue. On the other hand, your third example is definitely Type 2.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoI see Type 1 as essentially honest and realistic, and Type 2 as essentially dishonest and unrealistic - the implication of non-existent benefits and lifestyle enhancements in a misleading way. The presence of pretty women is a popular way to dramatise the "benefits", but it's not obligatory.
- projektfu 7y agoI’m put off by the image of a pretty young lady who reeks of carbolic (phenol).
- craftinator 7y agoI think type 2 has been around since Ogg sold "bright hot magic" to Urgh the thatcher. The big change is that within the last 60 years or so, we have developed very accurate scientific models of human cognition and behavior, and those models are being used to shape advertising to have measurable effects on how humans perceive the world. It's like we've developed Persuasion, the Force skill from Starwars, and now we are using it to control peoples' buying habits, and doing so in ways that are actively harmful.
- Gibbon1 7y agoMarketing has a light side and a dark side. Light side: Closing the loop between what the customer wants, what their actual problems are, and what engineering and manufacturing can deliver. Darkside: Ladies you need to use our spray or else your hoo-haw will stink.
- munk-a 7y agoThe light side is of so little value that I think we should just throw it out with the bathwater and kill this modern experiment in advertising. Our society is paying huge costs to support this industry in terms of wealth, novel innovations, productivity and sanity. It's terrible.
- jimktrains2 7y ago> The light side is of so little value that I think we should just throw it out with the bathwater and kill this modern experiment in advertising. I don't think that's true at all. Where else would you learn about new services or products? Here are some examples from a 2010 model railroader. https://photos.app.goo.gl/RvRzECgs7MaTo7tP8 https://photos.app.goo.gl/RvRzECgs7MaTo7tP8 Some, especially the Kato model Amtrak one, have some aspects of an aspirational ad, but I don't know if I'd condem them as such. They usually, as the Kato one has, information about the specific items that are now available and often some "ambiance" information that many hobbiests, especially people new to the hobby like to look at. I don't mind ads like these as they're not designed to make you feel as though you need to purchase something to be better and they're not in a public space. They're they're to matter-of-factly says a service or product is available. I could also show you the local pennysaver or Craigslist. All of those are also add, but they're not the "aspirational" kind. They're more matter-of-factly that someone is selling so (used) item, or provides some kind of service, or that there is a garage or estate sale at such-and-such address. How else would this information be made redily and easily available?
- dwaltrip 7y agoHumans learned about new things for thousands of years without the modern of advertisements. I have no fear that the news of useful and interesting products will spread just fine even if advertising is massively reduced.
- burntoutcase 7y ago> Current dogma seems to be that rational people can just take the type 1 info out of your type 2 advert and think with the appropriate organ. I'd rather just consign the type 2 adverts to the nearest null device and pick up a copy of Consumer Reports when I want factual information about a product. It helps that most of the women used in advertising are just skinny blondes that you can get for a dime a dozen in Stepford, CT.
- dTal 7y agoYour comment would be much improved without the second sentence.
- deogeo 7y ago> One is "Hey, did you know this thing exists? Check it out! Here are all the tests it passed, realistic cost of ownership, and locations where it is in stock". I almost never see ads of type one - in fact, even finding that information is usually made accidentally or deliberately difficult.
- zacherates 7y agoThe Wirecutter (https://thewirecutter.com/ https://thewirecutter.com/) is a site dedicated to this kind of advertising and it is extremely useful.
- mrob 7y agoYou say that, but the very first thing I see is "Father’s Day Gifts Your Dad Will Love". Not "Recommended Gifts for Father's Day", or something similarly objective, just straight up manipulation like all the other adverts.
- zacherates 7y agoThat's fair, the gift guides don't seem to be particularly useful; however, I've found the buying guides to be really useful, to the extent that I have developed muscle memory for "best X wirecutter" whenever I need to buy a thing I don't have strong opinions about / don't want to do a bunch of research for. For instance "The Best Steak Knife Set" [1], lays out a couple of options and why you might pick them as well as their criteria and test methodology so you can figure out why you might want to pick something else. [1] https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-steak-knife-set/ https://thewirecutter.com/reviews/best-steak-knife-set/
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoWire cutter is manipulation masked in honest reviews. I’ll say the unpopular because people are so hellbent on convincing themselves those reviews give a damn about products with no affiliate links. Oh “but they make recommendations for nonadfiliated products!” Yeah, what percentage of the whole is that? Mmmmmmmhmmmm.
- JohnFen 7y ago> One is "Hey, did you know this thing exists? Check it out! Here are all the tests it passed, realistic cost of ownership, and locations where it is in stock". I'm pretty sure that I haven't seen that sort of ad since the late '80s.
- drdeca 7y agoI have seen an ad that informed me of the existence of a product with a certain property, which I had wished existed but didn’t think did, and this led to a purchase of the product being made. However, I don’t remember the content of the ad, so I can’t be confident that it didn’t also have an emotional appeal to it. The company in question later did something else I didn’t like, but the added feature (really, the removal of a ubiquitous mis/anti feature) continues to be something I appreciate. This was in the last 5 years I am pretty sure.
- asdff 7y agoEver been to the 'gear' section of WiRED?
- JohnFen 7y agoNo, I stopped reading Wired about a decade ago.
- mc32 7y ago"We" had a chance to re-set this at the dawn of Internet Indexing and Search and discovery Optimization, but Overture (and then Google and later FB and TWTTR, at al) and "us" enabled and encouraged advertising to become the driving force of the internet. We could have had a different ad-free internet, but no one was willing to pay that bill.
- nostrademons 7y agoWe did reset this at the dawn of the Internet. Google's text ads were basically Type 1, and they almost completely replaced the earlier Punch-the-Monkey banner ads we had during the dot-com boom, largely because Google was so much more effective as a discovery platform that sites which advertised on it replaced sites that tried to do their own TV/banner ads. The problem is that Type 2 ads are more effective than Type 1 ads for mainstream consumers, the ones that think with their emotions rather than carefully weighing competitive alternatives. So even though Google started as a Type 1 only company, the text ads on it have gradually been creeping back to Type 2 manipulation since, and they've expanded into more manipulative ad segments with the DoubleClick and YouTube acquisitions. They also face competition from Facebook (which has been manipulative from the start). Manipulative ads became the face of the Internet because they work. For them to stop being the face of the Internet, they'd have to stop working. That either requires that 3B people take ownership of their emotions (which seems unlikely, given the general state of emotional education in the world) or that the Internet serve only the few million people in well-off, hyper-rational, educated professions (which also seems unlikely, and not even desirable).
- hathawsh 7y agoI remember that. Google ads were actively helpful! I clicked them because they were cool. Today, I run an ad blocker because most ads are manipulative again, I recognize I can be manipulated, and I have to do what I can to avoid it. I wonder if there is some way to configure uBlock Origin to allow informative ads while blocking manipulative ads.
- JohnFen 7y ago> We did reset this at the dawn of the Internet. Google's text ads were basically Type 1 I remember those. Those ads were actually useful and welcome.
- elorant 7y agoAnd then there is a third kind which says hey dude we know you bought a pair of Timberlands last year so here are offers from their new line-up. The web has enabled unprecedented levels of intrusion for advertisers.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm not a copywriter in the sense of "person who writes adverts," but I am someone who writes copy for website content. One of the problems is that it isn't even good communication to say (for example) "This device has a 7 inch screen." That's mostly useless information for most people. It's much more genuinely helpful to tell people something like "You can easily read our large screen even in bright sunlight." Most people aren't going to see specs concerning screen size and mentally translate that to "Woah, this will make my life easier because it will be more readable than the dinky thing I currently use." Good product descriptions explain to you what this thing will do for you. If it gives a spec, such as weight, it needs to also tell you why this matters -- such as "this is lightweight for this type product, making it much more portable than average so you can take it with you to the work site." There is no clear dividing line between the kind of description that explains you can do X with this product and the kind of advertising that leaps to implying "And then women will fall madly in love with you and you will be the new Don Juan of your neighborhood!" Over the years, I've wondered a great deal where the dividing line is between good communication and active manipulation. I think that line is actually quite fuzzy. When push comes to shove, if you want to tell people about X, you can be assumed to have an agenda of some sort. But, most days, I'm reluctant to suggest the world would be a better place if we all just stopped communicating entirely.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoI don't see why it's hard to see the line. Real benefits are real. If Gadget X is easy to read and light, it's easy to read and light. Imaginary benefits are imaginary. If you buy Gadget X you will not instantly become attractive to the opposite sex, nor will you be the envy of your friends. The line is where you shift the emphasis from real benefits to imaginary social, emotional psychological, and sexual - i.e. lifestyle - boosts that the product can't possibly provide.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThere is no clear dividing line because lifestyle enhancement isn't imaginary. If you brush your teeth, dress well etc, it actually does improve your sex appeal. So does being able to signal a good income by having certain goods, like a nice car. Homeless men (granted, an extreme example) aren't seeing a lot of action. From what I gather, not owning a car as a man in the US is a serious barrier to having a romantic life. Etc. Sure, some things are pretty ridiculous. But lifestyle enhancements that impact your love life are not simply imaginary. They can be quite real and tangible. That's part of why it is tricky. If studies show owning a nice car helps a man's love life, is it outright lying to imply the connection by having some gorgeous woman lay across the hood of the car you are promoting? That connection is not purely made up, though it may well be an exaggeration in some sense.
- tim333 7y agoYou've missed one of the biggest kinds which is buy these things from us for 25% less than the competitors. I quite like that kind if genuine.
- harry8 7y agoonly two? Neither is negging either. How does "Look at this beautiful person, just look. Your life isn't like this. Ha. You suck. You're a failure. You're ugly, you're stupid and nobody likes you and you haven't even got $product" "This family is so much happier and more well adjusted than yours, you're a rubbish parent and you don't even have $product" Every ad in fashion be it for cream or stink or (gasp) sometimes even clothes. Loads of mirrors in every shopping centre aren't there? Negging is exactly right. Make people afraid and sad. Fear of missing out, fear of weapons of mass destruction, fear that "maybe they don't really like me." Sometimes it's subtle eg Clooney selling coffee and sometimes it really isn't, eg Life Insurance ads and the Iraqi invasion. (Maybe some pushing the idea believed in WMD - that's not the point. It was levered very thoroughly to sell the war - be right or wrong). Teaching children to identify and analyse psychologically manipulative techniques is essential for their mental well-being. Obviously it's not just ads. There's a load of academic research that follows the same pattern. "You need to be terrified about your children's screen time." Maybe I do but do you have the research or are you just stoking fear to promote your career? The latter definitely exists.