10 ms·
Isn't this what you would expect? Advertising fundamentally is trying to convince you that you need something. If you're perfectly happy with your current sit
by jandrese 7y ago
Isn't this what you would expect? Advertising fundamentally is trying to convince you that you need something. If you're perfectly happy with your current situation then what else would you need? So the advertising has to convince you that you're not happy but that there is a product that you can buy that will increase your happiness.
You're basically being negged by advertisers.
- maxxxxx 7y agoI guess that’s the current form of advertising. It tries to create demand where there has been none before. You could also imagine advertising that tries to address your actual needs. Unfortunately that probably would make a much smaller market.
- anoncake 7y agoCurrent? A German philosopher wrote in 1844: > every person speculates on creating a new need in another, so as to drive him to fresh sacrifice, to place him in a new dependence and to seduce him into a new mode of enjoyment and therefore economic ruin.
- maxxxxx 7y agoI was thinking about people Edward Bernays who took things to the next level.
- smogcutter 7y ago> A German philosopher Subtle, I like it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rimliu 7y agoI would not say it works that way for me. I see most advertising as a visual noice and/or annoying interruption. I think majority of the time I am not even aware what is being advertised.
- djtriptych 7y agoProbably it's almost impossible to measure one's own reaction to ubiquitous advertising. Ignoring it consciously does not mean you are unaffected.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- BonesJustice 7y agoSame, but (unfortunately) I suspect we are in the minority. Whenever I visit my parents' house, there are at least two separate TVs on, regardless of whether someone is actually in the room watching. There's probably a 50% chance that there's an ad playing in that house at any given moment. I ask my dad, "Why do you pay $300/month+ to have ads shoved down your throat?" He responded with some non sequitur like, "How else do you know what's going on in the world?" Wat. Apparently there is some value in watching the same catheter ads over and over that I was not previously aware of.
- funkymike 7y agoPeople still look at me strangely when they say "hey have you seen that new ad for X" and I tell them I avoid advertisements. Likewise when I change the radio station the moment an ad break starts. I think the idea of ads as a negative influence has not penetrated very far in US society.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoThe 'I'm not watching anything but have to have the TV(s) on' is genuinely dystopian-esque behaviour that's seen as relatively acceptable. Have an in-law that does it (even when staying with us) and drives me insane...
- lordnacho 7y agoWell like it says there's two kinds. One is "Hey, did you know this thing exists? Check it out! Here are all the tests it passed, realistic cost of ownership, and locations where it is in stock". The other is "Look at this woman, isn't she fascinating? People like her will desire you more if you buy the thing she's lying on top of. Actual woman not included." Unfortunately, people have discovered type 2 is effective for a lot of things. Not only that, there are no scruples at all with appealing to people in this kind of way. It's not lying in the normal sense, but it is manipulation, or an attempt at it. Current dogma seems to be that rational people can just take the type 1 info out of your type 2 advert and think with the appropriate organ.
- rwc 7y agoBut can you point to a time in human history where type 2 wasn't the predominant form of advertising? This is not some modern discovery or exploit.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoactually, subjectively I get the feeling looking back at older ads post-industrial revolution that the weight has shifted, and that the abundance of it (such that almost all advertising is psychological/social manipulation rather than presentation of facts) is some modern phenomenon. Previously the idea that you would struggle to know what specific product an ad is selling, where to buy it, what it costs, and what it's features are would seem obscene, but these days concepts of brand, desire, status, aspiration, are so omnipresent that deriving any pertinent details is now a common experience. Pre that, it probably is all the same, because modern advertising is, fundamentally, just propaganda rebranded by ad men.
- wk_end 7y agoSome historians of advertising - probably most famously, Adam Curtis in "The Century of the Self" - argue that "type 2" directly fell out of World War-era propaganda research redirected towards consumerism.
- 7y ago
- jressey 7y agoI would go further and state that our entire economy and society are based on the manufacturing of demand. There are so few things we actually need. Food, water, clothing, shelter. Everything else is a luxury you've been convinced to buy (or it was given to you by someone who was convinced). I'm not talking about ethics here, just straight facts.
- WalterBright 7y agoPrison provides food, water, clothing and shelter. We send people there to punish them.
- jressey 7y agoYou will notice 'being locked in cages' is not in my original list.
- WalterBright 7y agoMy point is that subsistence allocations of food, water, shelter, and clothing is not enough, and such are part of the punishment of prison.
- rogual 7y agoI wouldn't even consider prison to offer "shelter" since you're locked in there with violent people.
- parallel 7y agoWords work because we agree what they mean in advance. You can't redefine "shelter" to suit your argument. Just make it with the standard definitions of words.
- rogual 7y agoWould you consider that a non-standard usage of "shelter"? I had a quick look online and I'm seeing definitions like: a position or the state of being covered and protected a shielded or safe condition; protection a place giving temporary protection from bad weather or danger
- lovecg 7y agoAt its best, advertising is a form of search technology. If I have a need A and there’s a company out there providing exactly A, it’s awesome if I find out about it - both sides benefit from the transaction. To me this sort of advertising seems ethical and useful. Unfortunately there’s of course the other kind, based on deception, psychological tricks, and appeal to emotion.
- frenchy 7y ago> At its best, advertising is a form of search technology That's not advertising. That's curation. Mixing these up is like mixing up astronomy and astrology.
- dTal 7y agoAdvertising is not a good system for that. If there are multiple companies providing A (the usual situation), advertising will not help you choose well. If you think you need A but in fact A is quite harmful and you're best off avoiding it in favor of B, but there's no money in B, advertising will actively attempt to mislead you. There is no magical ethical kind of advertising based on informing the customer. All advertising is 100% biased towards the decision of purchasing the product. That's what makes it advertising.
- anoncake 7y agoIt's also one reason we fail to stop the climate crisis. It's hard to reduce our emissions if we "need" as much as our economy can produce.
- teawrecks 7y agoI think advertising is to marketing as space travel is to rocket science. An ideal situation for space travel is to be able to teleport anything anywhere, but that's not possible yet, so they build rockets to travel as fast as currently possible. Similarly, an ideal situation for advertising is to read each person's mind, determine exactly what products they are looking for but aren't yet aware of, and make them aware. But that's not possible yet, so they use marketing spam to make aware as many people as possible.
- bediger4000 7y agoThat seems like an unreasonably optimistic viewpoint, based on the history of advertising, and indeed, mass market product of anything. Optimistically: determine exactly what products they are looking for but aren't yet aware of, Realistically: determine what high-margin products you could possible convince them of, and show those products in as intrusive a manner possible The Internet seems to have made us all aware that the depths of human dishonesty and unethicality have no bottom.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoexcept the goal of marketing is not inherently to meet a person's needs. At the macro level, it's maximising needs met, but at the micro level this is done by both initiating and implanting desires that otherwise aren't present or necessary, and by creating problems/pain points (which then, as a second order effect, create a need, which is met by the product). In economic terms, advertisers aim to maximise locally measured utility, but they do this by externalising the costs of the dis-utility they deliberately create. Like the proverbial glass salesman, garbage man, or mafia, they provide a theoretical good, but they've found business booms if they can generate their own demand by throwing rocks through windows, trashing the town, or partaking in their own crime to sell their protection services. In our instance, the town is our own psychological and social state, and while we don't account for these externalities andnegatives, they will keep actively damaging us because its in their interest and locally optimal from their pint of view...
- teawrecks 7y ago
- conanbatt 7y agoHumans enjoy things more based on their subjective interpretation of it. Advertising makes you enjoy things more.
- jandrese 7y agoThat's a bold claim. Can you elaborate on it some more? I'm not sure how the advertising is helping our interpretation in this case.
- rfrey 7y agoNobody would enjoy having a diamond without advertising. Maybe a child, to put with her collection of other rocks and shiny things. While I agree with your parent that advertising can help people enjoy things more, I don't agree with the implication there's a positive side to ads. Everything I can think of that people enjoy more because of advertising, they'd probably be happier not enjoying. Also: advertising can make you enjoy things less (usually things you already have). Maybe things you'd be happier if you enjoyed more.
- conanbatt 7y agoIt's a fairly established finding of social science that associations change your appreciation. By pre-configuring your initial reaction or associating it with something positive you feel actually better about it. There are plenty of documented examples of this: Patients being told that they are switched from a brand drug to a generic one report worse results, or the mere increase in the price tag of a drug increases placebo effects. Its a completely different experience to drink a coke from an official can, than to drink it from a silver-slated can and being told "it is cola". And lets not even get into politics! Basically the game of changing how people react to moral issues. The person that believes ads and marketing have no effect on what they like simply doesn't understand himself.
- JohnFen 7y agoI am not willing to let others tell me what to think and feel. Particularly not advertisers, who don't have my best interest at heart.
- spinach 7y agoIt doesn't just convince you of something, it even drives culture, like beauty and fashion. Advertising has changed how women look and perceive themselves and the products they buy. None of it is needed. Make-up, shaving products, creams, etc. Fashion has turned into fast fashion. It's just a waste of natural resources and creates plastic waste.
- m463 7y ago> Advertising fundamentally is trying to convince you that you need something. I think this is how we have an increase in hoarding behavior.
- baddox 7y ago> So the advertising has to convince you that you're not happy That claim doesn't follow. Some people actually are unhappy, or would actually be happier if they discovered and purchased certain products. I'm not claiming that advertising is or isn't a net positive, but this part of your argument doesn't hold up. It's kind of like saying "dating, or asking someone on a date, is fundamentally trying to convince someone that they would be happier with you; if they were perfectly happy already what else would they need?; so you have to convince them that they're not happy just to get them to go on a date with you; thus asking someone on a date if basically negging."