3 ms·
They’ll just incinerate it, which is probably what they should have done in the first place. Companies in third world countries bidding unrealistically low for
by seanmcdirmid 7y ago
They’ll just incinerate it, which is probably what they should have done in the first place. Companies in third world countries bidding unrealistically low for recycling contracts has made recycling seem more viable than it actually is.
- dev_dull 7y agoAnd it’s cheaper to dump it in the ocean than to dispose of it safely.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoCheaper to ship it to Malaysia and have them dump it in the ocean than convince a bunch of 1st world NIMBYs that a modern incinerator plant won't give their children a .000001% increased chance of cancer.
- dalore 7y agoLandfill is better then incinerating. Burning it releases toxic chemicals and is effectively dumping it in the air (vs dumping it in the ocean). Landfill (dumping in the ground) is the least worst of all the options. From what you may believe there is plenty of land available.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoIncineration works well when modern technology is brought to bear. It also doesn't create later water/land pollution problems. In any cases, one solution might work better than the other depending on the context.
- joe_the_user 7y agoBurning, recycling or burial all could be OK if they were done right. But doing them right involves more costs than doing them wrong. The US and other countries hire companies and pay them to do the disposal. Sure, the companies get paid for the estimated cost of doing the disposal right but companies make all their extra profit from doing the disposal wrong. The entire approach of subcontracting is misguided but given vast vested interests behind the subcontracting approach, given you know this stuff is going to be done wrong, which wrong to do you do want? Pollution of the air, the earth or the water?
- ars 7y ago> Companies in third world countries bidding unrealistically low for recycling contracts This is a false impression, they are not bidding to be paid for recycling, rather they pay for the recycling, because they purchase it. The trouble is when it's mixed with garbage, they remove the good stuff, and the rest? Well, who knows. There is this storyline that first world companies are dumping their trash on other countries. That's not the truth. The story in the article is someone bought recycling, and was shipped trash. They don't care about the trash, they are upset they didn't get what they purchased.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoNowhere in the article did it say Malaysia paid for this recycling. In fact, often times recycling is costs more than its worth, and municipal systems pay recyclers rather than the other way around. The only recycling that someone might make more than the effort put in would be e-waste.
- ars 7y agoThis article did not mention it, but that is in fact how it works: Other countries pay for the recycling. > and municipal systems pay recyclers rather than the other way around. Yup, because the value of the recycling is not quite enough, but the recyclers then sell the recycling. That's why there is a whole list of what they won't accept. It's not because they can't reprocess it, it's because there is no one to sell it to. If this is news to you, well, now you've learned something new.
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoIncineration solves the problem of storing recycling but is worse in every other way. > It also doesn't create later water/land pollution problems. Where do you think all that carbon goes?