18 ms·
Steep decline in nuclear power would threaten energy security and climate goals
- SlipperySlope 7y agoYeah. But lets get rid of nukes when battery storage, solar and wind are plentiful. No new nukes. The $billions can be spent better elsewhere. That goes for fusion too.
- battletested 7y agoInteresting, especially when you consider the environmental disaster that occurs when something goes wrong with nuclear power. Think Fukushima or Chernobyl. From the actual HN list right now: https://moxie.org/stories/chernobyl-scene-report/ https://moxie.org/stories/chernobyl-scene-report/
- ilaksh 7y agoI grew up in San Diego. I have seen a very encouraging amount of solar deployment on houses there. But there is still a massive potential for more residential solar. When I visited my brother in Ft. Worth I saw almost no residential solar. I also noticed that there was a massive supply of wind blowing around the neighborhood. Is it really not feasible to harness solar and wind better? Maybe it requires moving to a more distributed system with suburbia becoming much less dependant on the power companies. To me you just really need to be sure it's not feasible to do it with solar and wind before you get too serious about reviving the nuclear power industry.
- throwanem 7y agoGiven the lead time required to bring new nuclear generation capacity online, it probably makes more sense the other way around: before you get too serious about letting the nuclear power industry die, you just really need to be sure it's feasible to replace it with solar and wind. (I don't love that nuclear reactors, as opposed to the turbines that generate electricity from the steam they produce, should be in the hands of industry at all; having a profit motive involved in such a safety-critical set of processes is a recipe for disaster. Given a choice between for-profit nuclear reactors and not-for-profit ones, I'll take the second every time. But given the criticality of reliable baseload supply to so many of the processes that support the style of societies on which we've grown so dependent, if we have to choose between for-profit reactors, with all the attendant problems, and no reactors at all - we may very well still be better off with the former than the latter.)
- TheHypnotist 7y agoI'd like to point out that nuclear generates power via steam that spins a turbine. It's how you create the steam that's different. As far as for profit reactors vs. non-profit, do you have any examples of this? The ones I'm aware of (in the U.S.) are utility owned but tightly regulated.
- throwanem 7y agoThat’s the steam to which I’m referring, yes. The best example I have of nonprofit reactor operation, and the safety culture which such a paradigm can support, is the US Navy; while nuclear-powered submarines have been lost on two occasions, neither loss resulted from a reactor accident, and indeed the US Navy has never had a reactor accident. [1] I’m not the first to suggest this model could be productively applied to civilian power generation; I remain uncertain why it seems so uncommon for other “Atomkraft? Ja, bitte!” folks to do so. [1] https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2008/jun/09/john-mccain/navys-record-unblemished/ https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2008/jun...
- BurningFrog 7y ago> having a profit motive involved in such a safety-critical set of processes is a recipe for disaster The empirical evidence of Chernobyl is a small sample, but points in the opposite direction.
- throwanem 7y agoChernobyl had a different perverse incentive, in that perceived failure to perform under a command economy such as that of the Soviet Union could be and often was individually punishable.
- icegreentea2 7y agoI think you have the onus of responsibility backwards. Nuclear power's ability to achieve the amount and type of energy production appropriate for today's energy usage patterns is proven. We should be determining the feasibility of scaling solar and wind energy production, creating enough multi-scale storage, and long distance load balancing, and demand shaping before winding down nuclear. I think it's obvious that we need to do both. Nuclear plants have a lifespan of ~50 years. Reaching and sustaining zero carbon lifestyle isn't a one time occurrence, it'll be an on-going journey for centuries. We'll have plenty of opportunities later to drawdown nuclear.
- denimnerd42 7y agoFt Worth is fed by a massive supply of cheap wind energy from West Texas as well as natural gas and coal plants. Roof top solar isn't that viable here. Not many people want a $20-30k installation on top of a $200-400k house and the energy prices just aren't high enough to substantiate it.
- francisofascii 7y agoMostly right. Thought installation is more like $10-20K these days.
- hindsightbias 7y agoWhat's the insurance cost in Ft. Worth? https://www.star-telegram.com/news/local/community/fort-worth/article228370299.html https://www.star-telegram.com/news/local/community/fort-wort... My relatives have had to replace their roof twice in the last 15 years. What's the hail-proof solar cost?
- sh-run 7y agoI've been a Fort Worth resident for nearly 4 years. Anecdotal, but my old neighborhood (far south - near Crowley) had tons of residential solar (relatively speaking - probably 1/6 of the homes). It was a new development with no mature trees. TXU actually has a pretty attractive [residential solar program](https://www.txu.com/savings-solutions/renewable-energy/solar-sunpower.aspx https://www.txu.com/savings-solutions/renewable-energy/solar...) that lots of my neighbors took advantage of. I've since bought a house built in the 60s. My new neighborhood (Ridglea) has lots of mature trees. There is no way solar would work here. My roof only gets sunlight for a couple of hours a day.
- auiya 7y agoA big problem is solar installations aren't seen as equity items in homes through Texas and indeed the southeast US the same way they are on the west coast. I'm not sure why this paradigm exists though, considering these homes come with essentially free energy utility for the lifetime of the panels. You'd think that would be a major selling point, but it isn't.
- TheHypnotist 7y agoThe simple answer is that San Diego has a great amount of Sun exposure, not every state does. Also, you may be on to something with smaller distributions of power generation, but know that a large amount of solar fields are owned by utilities and this may be happening already to some degree.
- Robotbeat 7y agoThe urgency of needing to deal with climate change mandates we do both renewables and nuclear. We have the resources to push hard on both sides. There's this idea that we should prioritize resources on one or the other. In my opinion, we have plenty of resources such that we'll reach diminishing returns (due to employment/skill/geographical/material bottlenecks) if we applied all of those resources to one or the other such that there's nothing lost by investing in both. As an example, at very least we can address the siting constraints of nuclear by installing any new reactors at existing sites and maintaining and upgrading existing reactors. Solar and wind can both saturate an area and reach diminishing returns (see: duck curve) and require curtailment such that the resources become much less economic than you think they would be. And curtailment is not a totally bad thing, either. So absolutely it's feasible to add more solar and wind (even to the point of curtailing a lot of it), but there's no time to waste by not also pursuing nuclear. We have more money than time (and costs of nuclear, if scaled out, are exaggerated).
- pjc50 7y ago> We have more money than time (and costs of nuclear, if scaled out, are exaggerated). Getting the money from the taxpayer or energy consumer is the number one obstacle to all of these things. The costs of nuclear if anything seem to be underestimated: https://www.theguardian.com/news/2017/dec/21/hinkley-point-c-dreadful-deal-behind-worlds-most-expensive-power-plant https://www.theguardian.com/news/2017/dec/21/hinkley-point-c...
- Robotbeat 7y agoThe cost of nuclear is maximized when we're speaking of one site. That's why I mentioned scale out of nuclear. You're not going to get a beneficial learning curve unless you're building and siting lots of power plants with the same contractor(s). Even with inflated costs, however, the extremely high latitude of the UK and its need for wintertime heat mean that the amount of renewable curtailment needed to ensure sufficient carbonfree wintertime energy make nuclear still cost competitive in a carbonfree scenario. Generally speaking, no halfway competent investment in carbonfree energy should be opposed, IMHO. We don't have time to fight such internal battles when we're fighting anthropogenic climate change.
- umvi 7y agoHaven't nuclear waste recycling and safety features gotten really good in the past few decades? I feel like not many people know just how little waste is created with modern recycling and just how safe nuclear is with modern safety features. Seems like we need a positive PR campaign to help convince folks that nuclear is way better than fossil fuels. This could easily be bipartisan.
- Tepix 7y agoNo, quite the contrary. Just as an example, in Germany the search for the ultimate disposal place has just started over from scratch after decades of failed attempts. In the US, a nuclear waste dome is leaking in to the Pacific: https://www.civilbeat.org/beat/a-dome-holding-nuclear-waste-is-leaking-in-the-pacific/ https://www.civilbeat.org/beat/a-dome-holding-nuclear-waste-... Here's another story from 12 days ago: "Years of mismanagement, delays at nuclear waste sites could pose risk, report says" https://www.wsbtv.com/news/2-investigates/years-of-mismanagement-delays-at-nuclear-waste-sites-could-pose-risk-report-says/949422394 https://www.wsbtv.com/news/2-investigates/years-of-mismanage... Excerpt: "According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, cost estimates to clean up the legacy radioactive tank waste and contamination at the facilities increased $214 billion from 2011 through 2018. During that same period, DOE spent $45 billion on cleanup efforts. DOE spent $170 billion on cleanup since 1989, but the most challenging work remains. Estimates now stand at $377 billion to clean up the waste, but that amount does not include cost to clean sites where no feasible remedy exists."
- jjoonathan 7y agoWould this waste have been moved to Sequoia Mountain had Obama not torpedoed it to get support from Harry Reid?
- pfdietz 7y agoYucca Mountain. Realize this thing is a sideshow. Having it open would not have helped the market acceptance of nuclear power. Even if waste disposal costs are totally ignored (as the Lazard levelized cost numbers do) new reactors are totally out of the running economically.
- Taylor_OD 7y agoSo many people are grossly unaware of nuclear power and it's potential vs its risks. Many people in the USA live much closer to a nuclear power plant than they realize. It has huge potential but its scare factor keep it from widespread adoption.
- gravy 7y agoThis is kind of why I'm a little concerned with how well HBO's Chernobyl is being received...I really hope it doesn't lead to widespread fears of nuclear plants.
- arethuza 7y agoHBO's Chernobyl really is very good, but the writer made an execellent point: "The lesson of Chernobyl isn't that modern nuclear power is dangerous. The lesson is that lying, arrogance and suppression of criticism is dangerous. The flaws that led to Chernobyl are the same flaws shown by climate change deniers today." https://twitter.com/clmazin/status/1115135743045718016?lang=en https://twitter.com/clmazin/status/1115135743045718016?lang=... Edit: Purely by coincidence I read "Chernobyl: History of a Tregedy" by Serhii Plokhy a few months back - one of the few books that has moved me to tears - the self sacrifice of many who worked there with full knowledge of what the awful consequences would be is stunning. "If not us then who?"
- gravy 7y agoThat's exactly true. That's the lesson I'm getting out of the series.
- ambicapter 7y agoIts just as forbidding for the future of nuclear though. If there's one thing you can count on, is that people don't change.
- mooseburger 7y ago
- Tharkun 7y agoPlacing economic sanctions on oil states which want to build nuclear reactors does seem counterproductive wrt climate goals.
- briandear 7y agoHowever in the case of Iran where they have both stated and have made significant nuclear weapons progress as well as expressed an official position of “wiping Israel off the map,” it would be a folly. But Europe, North and South America and much of Africa doesn’t have destroying another county as a stated ambition. Iran, for example, could be pursing rapid expansion of solar in addition to nuclear if getting off fossil fuels was their actual goal, but it’s not. Same for North Korea. There are some governments that absolutely can’t be trusted with dual-use nuclear technology. I would be equally nervous if Saudi Arabia were to develop a sudden interest in nuclear power.
- Tharkun 7y agoOnly one government has ever used nuclear weapons.
- jessaustin 7y agoIf other low-carbon sources, namely wind and solar PV, are to fill the shortfall in nuclear, their deployment would have to accelerate to an unprecedented level. In the past 20 years, wind and solar PV capacity has increased by about 580 gigawatts in advanced economies. But over the next 20 years, nearly five times that amount would need to be added. This is misleading enough to make one question every "fact" stated in TFA. 20 years ago was essentially a zero point for the statistic they cite. It was less than 5 gigawatts, anyway. It grew by over 100 times in that 20 years, and it will be "unprecedented" to grow by 5 times in the next 20? (5 < 100) Is anyone at this agency numerate? Don't believe me, take a look at the charts here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_of_photovoltaics Sure those don't include wind, but when you find those charts they will look the same. Anyway wind isn't growing as fast as solar.
- isolli 7y agoIt reminds me of this: https://twitter.com/AukeHoekstra/status/866313289306963969/photo/1 https://twitter.com/AukeHoekstra/status/866313289306963969/p... tl;dr The International Energy Agency kept predicting, year after year, in the face of all the evidence, that solar production would plateau.
- tim333 7y agoThat's quite impressively wrong from the IEA. I wonder how come.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoOne of the comments there points it out: The government keeps passing subsidies for solar that nominally expire, then renewing them again before they expire. Then the government's models assume the subsidies expire when the law says they will rather than getting renewed time and again.
- pfdietz 7y agoIf you could predict the future, would you work for the IEA?
- nickik 7y agoNuclear power was once the fasted growing energy producer in world history. Adoption happened faster then coal, faster then oil or pretty much anything else. The world was on track to essentially replace fossil fuels with nuclear on a pace that was outside of human experience. Humanity was quickly entering a new age. But then a small number of accidents lead to a political change, witch lead to regulatory changes that essentially killed nuclear power in most places. Since the US regulatory system changed the amount of new plants built has essentially gone to 0, far below replacement. And many of the same effects were mirrored in most of the west with the US taking the lead. The worst thing is that the new regulatory system not only killed the building of new plants, but essentially ended any hope of getting new reactor types into commercial use. No new reactor type have been licensed since then. This seems rather strange because in the 60-70 new reactor-types were build at a rapid rate, constant innovation even with relatively small amounts of money. All of this was destroyed. Even in places where nuclear power is so clearly a huge win like NASA. Nuclear fuel storage issues has entered into a political limbo where anti-nuclear lobby has essentially managed to deadlock the whole process and can since claim that nuclear storage issues can't be solved. At the same time the government collects money from nuclear power stations to handle the waste issue. This is one of the saddest and most depressing stories in human history if you ask me. There is 0 scientific or technical reason why shouldn't have cheap nuclear power even in remote places, even in space.
- asdff 7y agoThis is what happens when the free market is the only method to drive change. The only thing stopping the US from using the navy to produce reactors for cities and not battleships is lobbyists from the oil industry threatening to primary any elected official who goes against good old fashion american capitalism for the sake of public good. I can see the attack ad now.
- nickik 7y agoThis is 100% wrong. The free market was driving the change pretty quickly and then regulations came in and made it illegal to do most of those things. Illegal to produce a proper prototype, incredibly restricted access to materials, incredibly high cost to entry and pretty much every other regulatory burden that exists. The nuclear industry is probably one of the un-freest markets ever. And whats stopping the Navy from doing these things is not oil lobbyists, but rather the Navy having no interest in such tasks and that such tasks are not in their political mandate from congress. That's what the DoE and others are for (in theory). Not to mention that the Navy doesn't really care that much about cost. I don't think you need a free market, if government wants to drive energy policy, then they can do it successfully with nuclear as well, see France. At least successful compared to most nations. Either method works fine, specially in a market the size of the US. Currently both paths are blocked.
- Zigurd 7y agoArticles like this carry the implication that current-generation nuclear technology should be subsidized. There are reasons to subsidize new energy technologies, but not ones that have failed to become practical, safe, and economically viable over the long term. Subsidizing current-generation nuclear power is what we have had all along. The cost of nuclear power was imposed on ratepayers without them having a say. It didn't work. Nuclear plants are still too expensive. Still uninsurable due to unbounded risk. Still ending up with shortfalls in decommissioning funds. Still without waste disposal. Practically nothing you would expect a period of subsidy to get to practical market-supporting economic models. I could support government funding for demonstrator reactors using genuinely new technology that can make a case for solving the problems of nuclear power. I will not support extending the life of reactors that do not even meet current site requirements (like Fukushima) or current containment standards. I will not support building new reactors based on old technology that does not transform the safety and economics of nuclear power.
- JTbane 7y agoI often hear the argument that "nuclear is bad because there is a chance of a catastrophic loss of life". Well, there has not yet been any large scale nuclear disaster. Cars kill hundreds and we still use them.
- mncolinlee 7y agoBoth coal and nuclear have potentially killed millions. Just because it can take decades for Chernobyl, Fukushima, and coal air pollution to result in some cancers, that does not mean they aren't primarily responsible for those deaths. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_accidents_by_death_toll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_...
- jcranmer 7y agoThe estimation of excess cancer deaths for Chernobyl and Fukushima is based on exposure results and the LNT model of accumulated dose response instead of actual observed cancer incidences, because it's impossible to actually assign specific incidences of cancer to specific causes. Thus, the counts for deaths caused by Chernobyl--the only nuclear power plant to cause significant death--will include deaths that have yet to occur. The total estimates for deaths to nuclear power, even including the use of Hiroshima and Nagasaki atomic bombs, struggle to amount to a million, even if you start using the high outlier estimates of anti-nuclear groups.
- godelski 7y ago> Both coal and nuclear have potentially killed millions. If you remove nuclear from that sentence it is still true. If you remove coal from that sentence it certainly is not. You are being EXTREMELY misleading. The page you show lists under 10k for nuclear (even if we take the highest estimates from Chernobyl we are around 100k). 20 times that more Americans die per year from coal ash. PER YEAR! 3x that die from cars, or opioids, or guns PER YEAR! Lumping nuclear into this statistic is grossly misleading at best and manipulative at worst. Considering the link you provided, and that I believe you have the ability to count, it suggests the latter. So I just have to ask: why?
- deleted 7y ago
- jhallenworld 7y agoSolar is growing so fast that it is creating its own waste problem: https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2018/05/23/if-solar-panels-are-so-clean-why-do-they-produce-so-much-toxic-waste/#41619b7e121c https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2018/05/23... What happens when we add the necessary batteries (to replace the nuclear base) to this problem?
- Tharkun 7y agoLead acid batteries have a recycling rate of around 100%. LiIon can be recycled with relative ease. This seems like a much easier problem to solve than PV cells or nuclear waste.
- Meandering 7y agoThis is one of the issues with solar power that gets overlooked. The physical 'stuff' needed to build a large solar farm is far more than a base nuclear plant. After a quick search: Solar Panels Lifespan - ~25 years - Good Grid Battery Lifespan - 5-10 years - ehh.. If we switched to 100% solar, with a majority of the equipment probably manufactured in China, there would be an orders of magnitude more physical product in the manufacturing and logistics pipeline. ...At least our top notch recycling programs will be able to handle all the waste product properly...
- sprash 7y ago> Solar Panels Lifespan - ~25 years - Good I don't know where these numbers come from but the solar panels on my house were installed about 20 years ago and have so far not shown any degradation assuming a 5% margin of error in measurement.
- politician 7y agoNuclear plant lifespan - 75+ years - Best
- pfdietz 7y agoIn an environment of rapid technological change, a long lifespan has little value. Would you buy a PC because it was promised to last for 75 years?
- sprash 7y agoLooking at mid term solutions: Nuclear fission is just not cost effective if you factor in all total cost of a building a secure nuclear power plant and safely dismantling it after its lifetime. Also uranium ore is a limited non renewable resource. Nuclear fusion looks similarly bad but at least deuterium and tritium is rather abundant. Looking at ultra long term solutions: Wind power is nothing else than reducing the speed of rotation of the earth. This is similarly true for tidal power plants. Geothermal power plants will eventually destroy earths unique magnetic field. Solar is the only true sustainable "renewable" way to produce energy in all scenarios for literally the next million years. So lets concentrate on that and not waste time on the other stuff.
- bcatanzaro 7y agoNuclear looks bad if you restrict it to 1940's technology. Which we have done. We don't allow ourselves to dream any more when it comes to nuclear. We are still building the same plants we designed for submarines and bombs, and wondering why they aren't great for power. There are safer, cheaper, lower waste alternatives if we'd allow ourselves to try them (Thorium reactors, for example). Does wind power really reduce the speed of the earth? I'd assume wind energy comes from the sun heating the atmosphere, so wind power is really just solar power in a different form. Solar makes me really sad. The amount of land it consumes is staggering. Land that can't be used for other living things. I saw the most beautiful farmland in Italy this month smothered under sterile black waves of solar panels.
- blackbrokkoli 7y agoDevastating! Chernobyl on the other hand is one of the most beautiful tourist locations to this day! Really though, it baffles me how people can bring degrading postcard quality into a discussion with stakes of a few billion human lives with a straight face...
- bcatanzaro 7y agoPeople didn't care about the externalities of burning coal until we had scaled the technology. The externalities of large scale solar PV are not just bad, they're impossible. https://www.ted.com/talks/david_mackay_a_reality_check_on_renewables?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/david_mackay_a_reality_check_on_re...
- lokimedes 7y agoIt feels like something out of Asimov’s Foundation trilogy. A telltale sign of a civilization in decline when the most advanced energy form accessible to mankind is being replaced by wood burning and windmills. Meanwhile people delusion themselves with arguments that renewable is more advanced. Our first energy source was renewable, but the energy density of wood is pitiful compared to nuclear. I Want my future back.
- pfdietz 7y agoI don't think subsidizing a losing technology just to let you avoid having to deal with your misconceptions about the future would be good public policy.
- jchook 7y agoA handful of Uranium can power an entire lifetime of electricity usage. Why would we litter the planet with toxic, 20-year solar panels with no solid recycle plan when we can have cheap, clean nuclear energy?
- Ygg2 7y agoBecause, Simpsons. I admit, it's only half joking. But it seems more and more nuclear + renewables (+ some carbon removal) is the only solution forward. For those interested why that might be look at this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5cm7HOAqZY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h5cm7HOAqZY
- pfdietz 7y agoSolar panels are not toxic, recycling plans do exist, and nuclear is not cheap. So the answer to your question is "because you are wrong".
- vbuwivbiu 7y agoSolar power _is_ safe nuclear power
- halfjoking 7y agoIt’s too late for nuclear. We’re facing 1 meter sea level rise within 20 years. When human civilization collapses I’d rather have a field of unused PV battery cells leaking, than nuclear waste from all the meltdowns around the world.
- Flip-per 7y agoWhile I agree about not wanting nuclear waste, a sea level rise of one meter within 20 years is way above the general scientific prediction. In the last 17 years the rise was pretty stable at 3.3mm per year: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sea_level_rise
- halfjoking 7y agoI know it’s been stable but recently there have been signs we’re on the verge of some exponential growth.
- jabl 7y agoSeems Germans are starting to sour on energiewende, here's Hans-Werner Sinn (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans-Werner_Sinn https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hans-Werner_Sinn) describing the situation: https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/germany-nuclear-power-by-hans-werner-sinn-2019-05 https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/germany-nuclear...
- algaeontoast 7y agoMost "common" people who hold themselves as "climate conscious" have no clue how the science of modern nuclear reactors or economic implication of energy production systems / distribution infrastructure work at all. Anything nuclear they think, "fukushima was nuclear and it went bad", even though it was near the coast and a known fault-zone... The rhetoric of "anything nuclear is bad" will likely be looked back upon as a core reason the human race didn't meaningfully curb climate change.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe IEA is totally not biased against solar. Totally! https://16iwyl195vvfgoqu3136p2ly-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/iea-prediction-2017-update4.png https://16iwyl195vvfgoqu3136p2ly-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-...
- 8bitsrule 7y agoPerhaps this piece (set in Vancouver) is a response to the agency formed in 2009 in response to the IEA's assertions, known as IRENA. https://irena.org/ https://irena.org/ Here is IRENA's front page article on Vancouver: https://irena.org/newsroom/articles/2019/May/2050--Vancouver-roadmap-to-urban-sustainability https://irena.org/newsroom/articles/2019/May/2050--Vancouver... Vancouver currently uses fossils for 69% of its energy. It's aiming for 100% renewables by 2050. Since 1986, Vancouver has continued to build its all-electric skytrain system to 50 miles. Automated, it's Canada's longest mass transit system.