31 ms·
Nancy Pelosi and Fakebook Dirty Tricks
- DyslexicAtheist 7y agoI wonder if it would have taken FB that long to demote the video if it had depicted Sandberg or Zuckerberg slinging racial slurs.
- tomek_zemla 7y agoThat is an interesting question and could be empirically determined with an experiment.
- Gibbon1 7y agoThat's my suggestion.
- m0meni 7y agoHate speech and a slowed down video are two very different things.
- DyslexicAtheist 7y agoslowed down to make the person look .... well sloooooooooow and senile. fact is the campaign was successful in fulfilling it's goal: disinformation. do we have to discuss if ageism is worse (more evil) than racism or vice versa? who will be the judge? isn't a spade a spade and "toxic" is simply toxic?
- darkpuma 7y agoChanging two things at once (the target of the slander and the nature of the slander) is bad science.
- dominotw 7y agoCan be argued that Sanburg isn't a public figure. Very few ppl know her outside tech/leanin circles.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- frequentnapper 7y agoWhy can't Nancy Pelosi sue facebook for $100 billion for allowing a doctored video about her to spread? They can't use the Napster defense of "we're only a platform."
- Despegar 7y agoYes they can. Section 230 immunizes them from liability and allows them to moderate (or not) as they please.
- kbrwn 7y ago$1.5 million reasons why she doesn't sue: https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/totals.php?id=D000033563&cycle=2016 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/totals.php?id=D000033563&cy...
- MaxLeiter 7y agohttps://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/toprecips.php?id=D000033563&cycle=2016 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/toprecips.php?id=D000033563... $16,450 to her in particular for those interested
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- azangru 7y agoI am confused. Facebook is a person-to-person(s) interaction. If someone wants to show their followers a doctored video, why should Facebook prevent it? (The other day, someone on Reddit reminded that in Russia it’s illegal to repost the Putin gay clown meme [1]. And of course there is the famous Chinese ban of Winnie-the-Pooh images. Is this in any way worse than removing the doctored video of Nancy Pelosi would have been?) [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/04/05/its-now-illegal-in-russia-to-share-an-image-of-putin-as-a-gay-clown/?utm_term=.e0c202192e35 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/04/05...
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Macross8299 7y ago>so are New York Times articles, because classy journalism looks good on the platform Interesting that a journalist thinks that Facebook is optimized for what "looks good" rather than what drives eyeballs. Facebook is just giving the people what they want. (To say nothing of how self-congratulatory that sentence is)
- Despegar 7y agoThere's nothing self-congratulatory about that sentence at all. Facebook's algorithm used to promote a certain kind of clickbait until they changed it in favor of real news (which killed a bunch of media startups that were optimizing for Newsfeed traffic). Facebook has specifically courted media organizations with Instant Articles or video for Facebook Watch.
- Barrin92 7y agoThe most baffling quote from the article, citing Zuckerberg >“I’m Jewish, and there’s a set of people who deny that the Holocaust happened. I find that deeply offensive,” Mr. Zuckerberg said. “But at the end of the day, I don’t believe that our platform should take that down because I think there are things that different people get wrong. I don’t think that they’re intentionally getting it wrong.” Ah yes, the very common good faith nazi. You seriously have to wonder if Mark Zuckerberg would have such nonchalant views about speech and misinformation if he didn't have a tail of private security and a fenced in mansion. What's the Muslim store owner in Myanmar going to do when the mob comes knocking on the door after some lie about him got the local village riled up? The degree to which these people live in an alternate reality isn't even funny any more. Nothing has consequences for Zuckerberg et al and it has distorted their worldview.
- gfodor 7y agoI'm assuming people railing on Zuck here don't like Zuck, so it's odd to me they would prefer he become the world's arbiter of permitted speech.
- Barrin92 7y agoI don't prefer he become the arbiter of speech. I'd prefer the government would regulate his business and hold him accountable for the damage that lies and misinformation cause on his platform. Given that he recently called for more regulation, surely he'll agree.
- darkpuma 7y agoWhen Zuckerberg calls for more regulation, he's actually requesting regulatory capture that ensures future competitors to facebook will be fighting an uphill battle.
- chias 7y ago> I don't prefer he become the arbiter of speech. I'd prefer the government would [...] hold him accountable for the damage that lies and misinformation cause on his platform I'm understanding you correctly, you believe that Zuckerberg should be held liable for untruthful content hosted on its platform, but you also believe that Zuckerberg should not be allowed to choose what content is hosted on its platform. How do you harmonize those two fundamentally contradictory viewpoints? Or do you feel that the only "correct" way forward is to excise Facebook in its entirety?
- williesleg 7y agoI believe everything on the internet. It doesn't polarize me either.
- friggeri 7y agoI'm very uncomfortable with the current trend of trying to get big tech to self police. They'll never get it right because of moving goal posts and moreover I don't want a private company to have that power in shaping social discourse. If we as a society deem that type of content to be improper and that it should not be allowed on such platforms, then let's make that explicit from a legal perspective and regulate them.
- daenz 7y ago>that type of content Therein lies the problem. The video was slowed down and the audio slightly distorted. I don't see a set of metrics that can capture that "type" of alteration that doesn't also capture tons of content. Unless, of course, you go down the route of saying "it's illegal to post any altered video or image of any politician."
- devoply 7y agoI don't see any such law passing first amendment challenge that's why the modern censorship for the right reason supporting centrist is down relegating it to private corporations that are not beholden to the US constitution. Ultimately the fact is that freedom of speech does not actually work if people have actual freedom of speech. It only works under certain circumstances where most of the media toes the line with the political establishment and is relatively controlled.
- raxxorrax 7y agoI disagree profoundly. Free speech only "works" if it isn't free? Would need additional arguments for that...
- sgt101 7y agoWhat would be the problem of making it illegal to alter video or images of politicians?
- cr1895 7y ago
- ar-jan 7y agoInteresting how they're sidestepping the actually rather disfluent speech from Pelosi that prompted questions. Compare https://twitter.com/robbystarbuck/status/1131242531503534080 https://twitter.com/robbystarbuck/status/1131242531503534080 with the C-SPAN video: https://www.c-span.org/video/?460990-1/speaker-pelosi-president-trump-took-pass-infrastructure-bill https://www.c-span.org/video/?460990-1/speaker-pelosi-presid... (e.g. from around 3:00): not edited.
- ar-jan 7y agoMy my Hacker News! How dare I link to an actual C-SPAN video, huh? Downvote away! Ignorance is bliss!
- dang 7y agoPlease don't break the site guidelines by posting like this. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 55555 7y agoThat is indeed quite disfluent... odd.
- neilv 7y agoI think part of the problem here is that Facebook doesn't want to be an impartial common carrier, so they have to take responsibility for "content". Then you have one of the most influential venues (which has taken over much of the use cases of the original open Web and Internet) having to answer to politicians about what speech it should censor.
- raxxorrax 7y agoYou forget that the most influential venues all have business ties to Facebook for visibility reasons. That is a huge problem, since Facebook might indeed be interested in these venues staying influential and to suppress peoples ability to meet on other platforms. Hard regulation would fortify their dominant position. I remember some years ago that when papers wrote articles about how they will keep being critical on Facebook, despite their cooperation. That was sad to read.
- rlt 7y agoA bit ironic coming from Kara, who jumped on social media to condemn the Covington Catholic students before the whole story was out, but at least she admitted her mistake https://twitter.com/karaswisher/status/1087443815269584897 https://twitter.com/karaswisher/status/1087443815269584897
- Simulacra 7y agoThe tech media is just as much about gotcha stories as the rest of the media. Worse so, because the tech media is absolutely dependent upon its access to the tech industry, which it must always be careful to curb their reporting so as to not lose access.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- astazangasta 7y agoHow does the NY Times have a leg to stand on complaining about disparaging videos of any sort when they released this homophobic cartoon about Trump and Putin? https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/25/opinion/trump-bites-putin-love-story.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/25/opinion/trump-bites-putin...
- davidw 7y agoI think several things can be true at the same time: * It's pretty worrying that our fascist-adjacent president is spreading doctored videos with essentially no repercussions. * Asking FB/Twitter/etc to police videos could be quite a mess in its own right. * This is a pressing problem for democracies around the world. (Note: I don't use the 'f word' lightly. Too many on the left use it freely with "people on the right they don't like". I think a person who loathes the free press, loves dictators, chafes at the idea of the rule of law, and threatens violence against political opponents fits the bill, though).
- dominotw 7y agoI was watching bill maher show on hbo and there was some older female guest( don't remember the name) and she was like maybe we should contact our uae friends and have them give our president the khashoggi treatment. Everyone in the room started clapping and cheering. wtf.
- suby 7y agoI can't really comment on that without seeing the clip myself, but in general, I find that show and other's like it to not be conducive to good conversation. The audience is always extremely biased, and stops the flow of conversation every other sentence to clap and cheer. People in turn seem like they're just trying to get a soundbite off with a rise out of the audience. And then on top of this, the panels are 5 people, which feels like entirely too many.
- jnbiche 7y ago> Note: I don't use the 'f word' lightly. Too many on the left use it very freely with "people on the right they don't like". I think a person who loathes the free press, loves dictators, chafes at the idea of the rule of law, and threatens violence against political opponents fits the bill, though) You forgot "hates an independent judiciary" and "uses office for personal enrichment". Some may quibble with the use of fascist to describe him, but he's very clearly authoritarian and anti-democratic. What has surprised me is the relatively large percentage of my compatriots who are also authoritarian and anti-democratic. All that stuff about the constitution was just lip service.
- hirundo 7y agoA partial distributed solution would be for trusted sites to vouch for a hash of the video file, and the browser to be configured to flag or filter untrusted content. E.g. NYT, the DNC, Pelosi's own site, etc., would flag a hash of a file as valid. Those sites would be aggregated into a web of trust. Users subscribe to nodes of that web, e.g. I trust reporter A, celebrity B, newspaper C, advocacy group D ... and their trust webs out to a depth of X. Is there anything like this in the works? Kind of a DNS service for propagating networks of trust ratings?
- ng12 7y agoCorporate censorship built in to my browser? I'll pass.
- TimJRobinson 7y agoYou'd decide who you trust.
- TimJRobinson 7y agoI'm working on a design of a system that does almost exactly this. I'd also be interested if anyone else is working on it. Where you can not only trust sites but individual people too. The core issue I've come across is that it would make cults happen more easily.
- chillacy 7y agoI’ve thought of it but it doesn’t allow news sites to remix the content into edits. Maybe if you did some sort of content based hashing which is sensitive to playback speed and pitch but not added compression or cropping?
- codyb 7y agoIt’d be interesting if there was a feature which would let you generate hashes from time series. You could specify what second or millisecond and duration and the trust web could provide the hashes for those segments. Memoization might help although if it’s to the millisecond maybe not.
- Nition 7y agoI don't fully understand why people think Facebook should be policing content, yet no-one thinks the phone company should delete SMS messages that are spreading misinformation, or the postal service should destroy false mail etc. It it because Facebook makes it much easier to share something with a wide audience? Is it because "the algorithm" means Facebook has more responsibility than if it were a simple chronological feed?
- khuey 7y agotl;dr: yes, it's "the algorithm" Facebook (and Youtube et al) have chosen not to be content-agnostic distribution platforms (unlike the postal service and SMS). They perform a variety of editorial functions to curate content and provide recommendations with the objective of maximizing engagement and hence advertising impressions that they can sell. This is popularly known as "the algorithm". Given that these platforms have chosen to selectively display content for profit, many people believe that they should have some sort of responsibility for the editorial decisions they make.
- Macross8299 7y agoFacebook isn't an editor, though, it's a curator. You use them interchangably but I think there's a crucial difference. An editor modifies to inject their own standards into the work. A curator just includes or disincludes as-is.
- jacobush 7y agoCurating on a fine grained enough level, you are not only an editor but even a story teller. You can make a narrative only quoting other people and it has been done many times in books and movies. That this story is driven only by an advanced self-adjusting Skinner box to maximize advertiser revenue, is very weird. You never expect sci-fi to be so mundane when it becomes reality, but it always is.
- sgt101 7y agoFacebook does modify content at the level of the feed; first it includes sponsored posts, second it promotes posts to people leading them to promote them to others.
- manfredo 7y agoI don't think the idea that companies should host all content except for illegal content is a better approach. Porn is legal, as per the first amendment. Does that mean every social media platform is obligated to allow it? Furthermore it would eliminate the possibility of themed platforms. Things like pixiv and DeviantArt would have to allow content totally unrelated to art. The whole discussion is moot, at least not without a significant reinterpretation of the fist amendment. Remember, the first amendment also protects against compelled speech. The government cannot mandate people or companies to make speech it does not want to. There's some talk about whether making these social media platforms utilities could allow the government to compel speech, but that seems far fetched at the moment.
- rlt 7y agoI completely agree when it comes to small to medium-sized websites, but Facebook is effectively a monopoly. At a minimum they should have clearly defined rules and transparent processes for censoring content and banning users.
- manfredo 7y ago> At a minimum they should have clearly defined rules and transparent processes for censoring content and banning users. They do their best to document this: https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards/ https://www.facebook.com/communitystandards/ The simple reality I see is that Facebook has to please the majority of people, but people are reluctant to confront the fact that some of their views are significantly out of line with the majority. So people react negatively when their own content is banned, and also when content they think should be banned is allowed. That and an either an unwillingness to accept or understand the limitations of automated content moderation. There was a post on the front page of Reddit about an artist who got their Facebook page taken down for making KKK-style MAGA hats, and nazi-style MAGA armbands (crucially, with a swatstika). It's unambiguously anti-Trump in context, but of course it's going to get automatically flagged when it prominently features items strongly aligned with hate speech.
- 7y ago
- kneel 7y agoFacebook didn't doctor the video, out of all the content they could be blasted on this is pretty trivial. This is part of a larger trend in MSM to pry eyeballs away from social media and back to traditional one way media.
- Traster 7y agoFacebook knew the video was doctored- it was a mainstream news story for days. They chose not to content ID it, but instead to continue spreading it. That seems deliberate.
- Macross8299 7y agoWhy is Facebook obligated to play the role of referee in games of political fact?
- sgt101 7y agoBecause that is the role they have chosen by becoming a non neutral information distributor.
- raxxorrax 7y agoKind of true. The only way I see it is to remove content moderation. Yes, you will find something you don't like. Maybe your kids too, but they are probably more fluent in online spaces anyway.
- kneel 7y agoThe medium is the message, study the medium and it's effects on how information is distributed. The genie is out of the bottle. Unless you want a 1984 style propaganda you have to accept that media is different from 10 years ago and it'll never be the same.
- sgt101 7y agoYou are right, it will never be the same. However I reject that the only alternative is 1984. The medium (facebook, social media) is malleable, the current choices are turned up to "engage 10" but this is only one of a range of options. Manufacturing can be run to pollute rivers, the air, kill folks, but with some short term costs manufacturing can be cleaned up. Social media is the same. Just as Shell and BP should be loaded with the cost of carbon hitting the atmosphere Facebook should be loaded with the cost of destroying civil society.
- hsnewman 7y agoPropaganda is not new, especially to fascist run governments. I for one am very concerned about our republic.
- nailer 7y agoPlease don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It destroys intellectual curiosity, which the site exists for.
- _cs2017_ 7y agoWhat should be the rule about what videos are banned? We don't want to ban parodies I suppose? What if the author of the Pelosi video claims it's a parody? It would be great if we could allow parodies and jokes as long as a reasonable person can tell that this is indeed a joke. But that won't work since people disagree about what's "reasonable". I guess we can require that parodies and jokes are tagged as such, so people don't confuse them with real stuff. Is that too overbearing? Are there any better solutions that have been proposed?
- raxxorrax 7y agoI just want people to accept the fact that not everything you read/see on the internet is the absolute truth. Younger people learn early to navigate the web and additional education can keep their data safe. So what is the problem? Facebook is too popular? I agree, but that is something everyone has to decide for themselves. I do think people who are frustrated about current global politics want to restrict the net in the hopes that people adopt "correct" positions.
- MarkMc 7y agoMy preferred solution is for Facebook to assess whether a video is presented as accurate but has been altered with intent to deceive. If so, it is tagged "This video has been flagged as deceptive. Click here for details". Yes, from time to time I might disagree with Facebook about the accuracy or intent of a video, but it would be an improvement on the status quo.
- _cs2017_ 7y agoThen what would prevent people whose videos were banned from suing Facebook because Facebook didn't get their intent correctly? And similarly, people appearing in videos that aren't banned could sue because Facebook didn't see the evil intent. Such lawsuits can be numerous and costly enough to kill the entire concept of hosting user uploaded videos. How to avoid this? Maybe it's better to drop the intent thing and just ban any videos that look real but aren't? Even if it means banning some parodies such as this https://youtu.be/cQ54GDm1eL0 https://youtu.be/cQ54GDm1eL0 Even then we'll need to figure out how do it at scale, since a human reviewer will often not know if it's real. I don't think we can limit the ban to videos where you can see people's faces; you can create quite bad misinformation by showing a military boat of some country sinking a civilian ship etc.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bArray 7y agoFirstly, if you watch both videos side by side, the effect isn't that great [1]. I thought she was drunk in the original. Secondly, do you really want to make Facebook the great filter of political truth? Is this a role you want to give to a private company with its own agenda? Of course, for somebody working at The New York Times this kind of power is a dream scenario, where truth is simply whatever they write. Criticism of the opinion article itself: > Facebook decided to keep up a video deliberately and > maliciously doctored to make it appear as if Speaker Nancy > Pelosi was drunk or perhaps crazy. Interesting wording, did Facebook decide to keep the video up or did it not decide to take it down? An assumption of malice is a dangerous place to start. > The social media giant deemed the video a hoax and demoted > its distribution, but the half-measure clearly didn’t > work. This is the truth of their opinion, only wiping all traces of problematic material from the internet is an acceptable solution, anything else is a half-measure. What if this video was a piece of art, a political statement, a meme? Is there anyone who we can trust to make the decision without asserting their own bias? > “We think it’s important for people to make their own > informed choice for what to believe,” [..] This is > ridiculous. When did a company passing the responsibility of interpretation to the viewers become controversial? Why is it ridiculous to think of content consumers as having the ability to decide what is real and what is not? > Would a broadcast network air this? Never. Would a > newspaper publish it? Not without serious repercussions. > Would a marketing campaign like this ever pass muster? > False advertising. Newspapers and serious repercussions? You mean a (comparatively) small monetary fine at most? The biggest consequence of bad journalism I've ever seen was the phone hacking scandal for News of the World, where Rupert Murdoch was basically told to reorganize his assets and make the name "News of the World" disappear [2]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDOo5nDJwgA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDOo5nDJwgA [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_International_phone_hacking_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_International_phone_hacki...
- gopher2 7y agoSo, what's the normative suggestion here? All content on user-generated websites should be moderated for truth and anything edited, editorialized, fictional, or not strictly representing reality should be removed? Or is the idea that only when there is enough public pressure to take down a particularly popular and deceptive video ... then it should be removed? It seems sort of ridiculous that we should engage in across-the-board censorship of anything mis-representing reality in any way. OTOH removing things only as they become popular enough to go viral and meet some agreed upon definition of "fake" enough seems like it would establish a permanent, weird shouting match with no clear rules. Or is the idea that we should ban and penalize Facebook specifically? Because they're Facebook. I don't really get that, but okay. We could do that. I don't think it would solve the user-generated content problem or the fake news problem. We could not allow any website with posts, images and comments that isn't filtered through a some sort of sacred guardian of truth/editorial board. That sounds like a pretty locked-down version internet. As some other commenters mentioned, the fact that the President/right-wing seem into this sort of approach and that this video became popular in the first place is a separate, sad issue. I'd love for the NYTimes to spell out what they're advocating FOR as the solution. If it's just "delete facebook" and read our comments section instead, well-played I guess.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- PixyMisa 7y agoFarhad Manjoo asked that on Twitter. The response was "Hate speech comes down." which was remarkably unhelpful.
- codyb 7y agoMaybe there should be a threshold such that things seen by a million or more people could could be flagged for a moderator to take note of and tag with certain contextual clues for the next however many viewers (“satire”, “unproven”, “doctored”, “verified”, “trustworthy source”).
- ntetsuo 7y agoThis whole thing seems retarded (go ahead and knee jerk). To argue that social media should be regulated because ignorant masses may be politically swayed is not “progressive”, it’s just another way to control information.
- Proven 7y agoHaha that is funny. Gotta watch that video! To the critics of free speech: I don’t think it will make me think less of Nancy Pelosi - in my book she is already ranked at the very bottom.
- warp_factor 7y agothat article is pushing the idea that Social networks should be better at policing speech on their platform. As said in other comments pushing for more self policing is the worst thing that could happen for democracy and free-speech. The last thing I want is for a small clique of silicon valley tech execs to decide what I should or should not see on my feed. I see two solutions on this: - Censorship is coming from an elected government body - No censorship and we let people decide what is news and what is fake news. But having Zuck and his team manipulate newsfeed to push a political or social agenda is a terrible idea. This article is a shame.
- bfdm 7y agoHow are people supposed to make that decision if they are not armed with the information needed? If they only see the fake version, how will they know to even question it? Truth matters. News distributers are expected to fact check and should be held accountable when spreading falsehoods. Removing provably false manipulated media is not itself a manipulation. It is a correction.
- ng12 7y agoAgreed, except Facebook is not a news distributor.
- anonymousab 7y agoThey are a de-facto distributor, even if it wasn't their intention to be one.
- vharuck 7y agoBut isn't "self-policing" the failsafe of free speech? Anyone can share their ideas, no matter how dumb or wrong. Except in certain cases, even deception is allowed. Then everyone else decides what is a good idea worth sharing, or just drivel. Facebook is a non-government entity. They're "people," too. They can totally decide to stop sharing junk when they notice it. And other people, like the article's author, can ask them to do just that.
- tus87 7y agoLOL
- m0zg 7y agoEstablished, "old media" news sources routinely spread misinformation as well either deliberately made up, or by omitting facts that don't fit the narrative of their owners. News outlets haven't been about "news" for several decades now, it's all about, to quote Chomsky, "manufacturing consent". It's just that now anyone with a webcam and a video editor can do the same thing on social media. Some, in fact, get more viewers than "traditional" media, too.
- tarcyanm 7y agoThe correct way to counter disinformation is with information. This does assume a sufficiently aware populace able to process its own confirmation bias (which is actually a learnable skill). Sometimes it takes incrementally more information and that's okay. Widespread availability of high quality media capture and technologies such as facial manipulation will inevitably lead to a future with many, many unverifiable snippets that go viral. This video is unique in that verification is possible, but the future will likely hold far more unverifiable content than otherwise. It is more positive to expect that humans will gain the ability to balance disinformation in the face of further information than to expect that benign dictators will censor perfect knowledge into cognisance.
- IlegCowcat 7y agoFacebook invades privacy at minimum. It threatens our democracy.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoWe have to kill facebook. They simply know to much! [irony/joke]
- merpnderp 7y ago“No other media could get away with spreading anything like this...” Meanwhile several major media sites are claiming the video Trump shared was this same doctored video, when it was merely a montage of regular video clips. We can’t even begin to have a conversation about censoring private companies without it immediately being used as a political weapon.
- ddffre 7y agoI don't see any problem of posting some humor related content.
- Tsubasachan 7y agoAmerica right now is the best show on television. Emmy's for Nancy and Donald.
- StanislavPetrov 7y agoThousands and thousands of videos and pictures are edited and altered to mock famous people and politicians every day, why is this suddenly an issue? Its astounding to me that anyone would support having overseers like Facebook (and their government partners at the Atlantic Council and elsewhere) deciding what is okay for people to post and view.