8 ms·
I used to be Pro Anandtech and consider them one of the best Sources online for Hardware News. But the fact they have yet write a single post, big or small abou
by ksec 7y ago
I used to be Pro Anandtech and consider them one of the best Sources online for Hardware News. But the fact they have yet write a single post, big or small about Intel's Zombieload and its implication on performance worries me a bit.
Then there is the "Intel" benchmarks as usual [1] on GPU. Trying to suggest the 2 CPU were both running at 25W TDP to give a "fair" comparison, without mentioning the Ice-Lake U CPU were running with 50% more memory bandwidth vs the AMD Ryzen. And we know Graphics Benchmarks do depend a lot on memory bandwidth. The memory used was somehow mentioned in Toms or Other Sites but not Anandtech. ( Although none of them had mentioned the bandwidth difference, it was up to the reader to work them out )
Anyway none of these Consumer CPU upgrade interest me anymore ( Although any improvement to iGPU would be great ) I am eagerly waiting for a 2S - 128 Core EPYC 2 on a Server or AWS to play around with it.
[1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/14405/intel-teases-ice-lake-integrated-graphics-performance https://www.anandtech.com/show/14405/intel-teases-ice-lake-i...
Edit: And the lesson here, never trust a single news source. Always have a few option opened and fact check yourself. ( If you have the time )
- dual_basis 7y ago> ... none of these Consumer CPU upgrades interest me anymore What about the Ryzen 3000 line up? The benchmark leaks make it seem like it is going to be a huge improvement and AMD isn't susceptible to Zombieload.
- ksec 7y agoThe problem is I am on Mac ecosystem, which means I don't have much of a choice ( I doubt Apple will ever switch to AMD ) . And since most of my casual gaming are done on mobile, ( I am quite old and don't have time like I used to spent hours on UO or WoW ), none of these upgrade means anything to me. So my interest is in Servers where most of my time are spent now in Web Development.
- berbec 7y agoApple might switch to ARM, but I think you're right on AMD
- blitmap 7y agoThis probably doesn't contribute to the conversation but with the number of serious vulnerabilities that have popped up recently I'm not inspired to solve the truth table for the CPU vendor that leaves me the least exposed. As others have said - and I have seen - some of these can be exploited with Javascript in the browser. (I do not know much about Zombieland presently) Looking forward to a less complex architecture even if it means cutting me off at the knees with execution speed (for a few years): RISC-V
- rbanffy 7y agoI remember mentioning before we should have learned with the first Xeon Phis to program microkernels for high core count in-order CPUs. Because the future is looking increasingly in-order high-core-count with hard partitioning between security contexts.
- spamizbad 7y agoIt's not just Anandtech. I feel like the entire "PC enthusiast" review space has dropped the ball on hardware vulnerabilities. Reevaluating performance between microcode and OS patches is an afterthought, and when a new CPU hits the market the numbers are presented without the obvious disclaimer that these performance gains may evaporate within months. Some even perpetuate the "only relevant to datacenter" myth despite the fact that security researchers have shown to be able to exploit these vulnerabilities with JavaScript in the browser.
- gameswithgo 7y agopc enthusiasts aren’t really into running javascript either.
- phpnode 7y agoI've seen a number of comments like this over the last few days and I don't really get it, gamers use the internet right? Vast overwhelming majority of them are going to be running javascript programs hundreds of times per day
- gameswithgo 7y agosure, and maybe browsers or os need some way to say “running untrusted code please turn off performance for a sec” for that use case. until then ill just use one tab at a time or disable js before i opt in for slow.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI expect that the vast majority of PC gamers keep Javascript enabled in their browsers.
- ChickeNES 7y agoCS:GO also uses JS for its new GUI, and there's already been one exploit that took advantage of it.
- tatref 7y agoBenchmarking cpu firmwares is forbidden by the license (same thing for databases)
- mycall 7y agoI would setup a scenario where safety is a concern (V2V) so you could get court order to benchmark firmware.
- gambiting 7y agoWhat licence? You don't have to agree to a licence to use a CPU. I mean Intel might think otherwise, but those kinds of licences("you agree to this licence by just opening the product") are not worth the paper they are written on in EU, so even if there is such a licence it wouldn't be applicable everywhere.
- tinus_hn 7y agoIntel could license the microcode update.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- throwaway2048 7y agoIntel quickly walked back that crap https://www.tomshardware.com/news/intel-cpu-microcode-benchmark-mitigation,37684.html https://www.tomshardware.com/news/intel-cpu-microcode-benchm...
- AmVess 7y agoAnand Lal Shimpi left Anandtech 5 years ago, and the quality articles he wrote have not been replaced. It's basically a tech lite blog now.
- treeevor 7y agoI would say Ian is really the only writer at anand i care to read from anymore. His articles always take time to come out compared to everyone else but they at least cover every thing he can think of to tell you about and are well researched
- skavi 7y agoAndrei Frumusanu is also great in the mobile space. The only tech reviewer to run SPEC on phones. Great overviews on the arch of new cores too.
- ksec 7y agoSo Despite what I wrote, I still think they are one of the best. Both Ian and Andrei are good with many in depth article, I really do miss Anand's article though. I think, the real problem is Anandtech is short on staff. Anand has been working in Apple for a few years now, I wonder what has he been up to.
- gameswithgo 7y agoits gaming centric news, nobody cares about these exploits when running fortnite
- gameswithgo 7y agoexplain why i should care instead of downvoting. a windows program can already just directly look at the memory of other running processes, so why do i care about sidechannel attacks outside of javascript snooping on things which i can mitigate with simple behavior changes.
- bayindirh 7y agoBecause intel strictly forbids publishing benchmarks of their processors with the "hardware vulnerability mitigations" applied. Even OEMs cannot show them to their enterprise customers. You can do your own benchmarking after buying the systems. So, no money, no real-world benchmarking.
- pfortuny 7y agoAnd you have to abide by those unjust rules because... ?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- randallsquared 7y agoNo free hardware for reviewing, and having to wait until the hardware is available to the general public, so every other site has scooped you.
- bayindirh 7y ago...you sign a legally binding NDA to be able to early-access the CPUs, test & review them; get the semi-classified technical documents to develop your new servers. If you don't sign that NDA you can't buy the CPUs from intel to resell them. Even if you are able to buy the CPUs from them, there's no guarantee that you'll buy from the list price or get the discounts for big, prestige projects which require tenders. It's a deep and ugly rabbit hole.
- wtallis 7y agoIntel has never told AnandTech not to benchmark their microcode updates or a third party's OS updates. They haven't threatened to stop sampling CPUs for review. I haven't seen any evidence that Intel has ever attempted to enforce such a restriction against anyone. It's just a stupid clause that one of their dumber lawyers slipped into the EULA text, and does not appear to be something they actually care about at an organizational level or expect to be able to enforce in the real world.
- twblalock 7y agoMost of the people who write these articles for review sites do not really understand CPUs in depth. They know how to run benchmark suites and talk about new features mentioned in Intel's marketing material. Most of these people are writers, not engineers. If they were experts they could make a lot more money working at tech companies instead of working for review sites. In fact, I would bet that most professional software engineers could not correctly explain Spectre, Meltdown, and Zombieload without making at least a few mistakes.
- skavi 7y agoAnandTech is different. They cover μarch, and their writers clearly understand what they're talking about.
- nobrains 7y agoThat's because Anand Lal Shimpi is not doing the writing anymore...
- MikusR 7y agoZombieload is two week old. Testing take time. And a minute of googling brings up multiple articles about Spectre/Meltdown including two comparisons. https://www.anandtech.com/show/13659/analyzing-core-i9-9900k-performance-with-spectre-and-meltdown-hardware-mitigations https://www.anandtech.com/show/13659/analyzing-core-i9-9900k... https://www.anandtech.com/show/12566/analyzing-meltdown-spectre-perf-impact-on-intel-nuc7i7bnh https://www.anandtech.com/show/12566/analyzing-meltdown-spec...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nl 7y agoTheir October 2018 i9 benchmark review was subtitled "Hardware and Software Security Fixes", and literally began with the following sentence: The Spectre and Meltdown vulnerabilities made quite a splash earlier this year, forcing makers of hardware and software to release updates in order to tackle them. https://www.anandtech.com/show/13400/intel-9th-gen-core-i9-9900k-i7-9700k-i5-9600k-review/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/13400/intel-9th-gen-core-i9-9...
- spronkey 7y agoAnandtech went downhill when they lost Anand. Not sure what the hell he could possibly be doing do that's useful to Apple, but the conspiracy theorist in me wants to think it was Apple getting him out of the media.
- pizza234 7y agoI think the point about the Ice Lake announcement is a mischaracterization. It's typical for news sites to report individual announcements, with little or no analysis; this is fair, as long as the post clearly specifies its nature (which, in this case, does). Anandtech did something very interesting actually on the Intel subject, which I didn't see on other sites - it made an article about the performance of the i9-9900k locked at its nominal TDP (95W), which showed very significant losses.
- close04 7y agoI was put off AT the day I noticed they forgot to cover the Threadripper launch for weeks while they flooded the front page with dry half pagers about new Intel motherboards (not benchmarks mind you, just snippets from the OEMs Press release). I asked about it in the comments and got a boilerplate answer that they strive to present quality articles to the readers. They also had the Intel series 6 launch where they praised the 6600K and compared it to the 2500K to show “massive” improvements over the years. This while all the other websites noted “minimal speed boost for too big price”. Perhaps both true but the spin on it makes all the difference when showing the intention. AT shows quite the Intel bias. And it’s not the Intel part that bothers me, it’s the bias part. They go out of their way to make Intel look better without outright lying, just selectively presenting the truth in a way that shines a much better light on Intel. This for me casts doubt on other articles. I’m glad Andrei Frumusanu’s mobile reviews still have a home, being the best I have seen on the entire internet. But that’s the only segment on AT where I can be reasonably sure about impartiality.