9 ms·
I don't know about cheering, but let's be honest here. Assange let himself be used by the Russians, either knowingly or naively, and he willingly jumped into a
by rootusrootus 7y ago
I don't know about cheering, but let's be honest here. Assange let himself be used by the Russians, either knowingly or naively, and he willingly jumped into a hyper partisan US election. Just like some people want to put Hillary Clinton in prison, some are going to want to see Assange punished. Snowden released a lot of information that was very valuable to the citizens of the US, and that's great, but he also went well beyond that and there is a legitimate argument to be made that such behavior should be punished. He's also currently accepting the hospitality of the Russian gov't, which just adds another reason to be skeptical of his neutrality. Manning is kind of the same thing, he went far beyond releasing a controversial video showing misconduct, so some punishment was just. And the commutation by Obama was just.
There are lots of people in the US that believe strongly in the rule of law.
- dpwm 7y ago> Assange let himself be used by the Russians, either knowingly or naively, and he willingly jumped into a hyper partisan US election. Believing that narrative actually requires trusting the US security services, who may or may not have something to gain from a new cold war. There are simpler explanations with just as much evidence behind them. > There are lots of people in the US that believe strongly in the rule of law. And that it applies to foreign citizens who have – quite sensibly – never set foot on your soil?
- microwavecamera 7y ago> There are lots of people in the US that believe strongly in the rule of law. >And that it applies to foreign citizens who have – quite sensibly – never set foot on your soil? Of course it does. That's like saying a foreign terrorist can't be charged for an act of terrorism because they're not a U.S. citizen. Furthermore, because Assange is a foreign national, 1st Amendment protections do not apply in this situation.
- dpwm 7y ago> That's like saying a foreign terrorist can't be charged for an act of terrorism because they're not a U.S. citizen. One man's might-is-right flag-waving US exceptionalism is another man's terrorism.
- kortilla 7y agoEverything is so relative man... /s
- microwavecamera 7y agoLook I'm not defending anything our country does and what they did to Manning was unconscionable. I think Manning acted in good faith, she may have crossed the line some but the punishment far exceeded what the situation merited. But I can't say the same about Assange. Now I'll admit the espionage charge is very "odd" for attempting to crack a password. But Assange did some stupid dangerous crap and got himself caught up. Simultaneously embarrassing and royally pissing off the CIA, NSA and the DOD is an epically dumb thing to do. I don't know what he was expecting to happen or what his game plan was. What the hell was he thinking? Manning got thrown under the bus, Assange stood in the middle of the road and dared it to run him over. I don't know how sorry I should feel for him at this point.
- raxxorrax 7y agoIf Assange is beholden to hold up US law, why would that only be applicable to some of them? And what about the issue of war crimes?
- belorn 7y agoWe live in a world where if you criticize the government enough to piss off the espionage department of your country, your only choice is to run to east if you live in the west and west if you live in the east.
- fit2rule 7y agoYeah, the flip side to this argument is pretty heinous: American war criminals can be prosecuted any time, any place they show up outside of Americas' borders. Except, they can't, because the USA will protect them, even threatening to INVADE any country which attempts to reign their war criminals in. Duplicity is the order of the day.
- gnaritas 7y ago> Furthermore, because Assange is a foreign national, 1st Amendment protections do not apply in this situation. Not remotely true, the first amendment protects anyone and everyone from government infringement. All of the bill of rights applies to anyone, citizens or not. Try reading them, they say what the government cannot do, nowhere will you find it saying but only to citizens.
- kelnos 7y agoThere's a [dead] reply that seems to refute this, and I'm not sure why it's dead. The First Amendment states: "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances." Nowhere in there does it mention "citizens". Only "people". And you don't need to be a US citizen to be a person. The first result[0] of a quick Google search suggests that federal courts do indeed believe that the Constitution protects to non-citizens. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2017/01/30/does-the-constitution-protect-non-citizens-judges-say-yes/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2017/01/30/does-th...
- jolfdb 7y agoIt should be obvious that that Constitution doesn't apply to people who aren't even in USA at all.
- Zak 7y agoThe Constitution applies to the government; it says what the government must, may, and mustn't. do. The government mustn't interfere with anyone's free speech.
- rootusrootus 7y agoCan't say why it was downvoted to oblivion. But I personally don't know what the right answer is. We already rely on SCOTUS to tell us what the First Amendment really means and how it applies, since as written it just says "Congress shall make no law..." which is kinda specific. So it seems like we're past the point where we can interpret any other part of that clause literally. Now, all disclaimers given, I figure the Constitution ought to apply to anyone within it's jurisdiction, which to my mind means that if you are subject to our jursdiction for criminal purposes, you're subject to our constitution for it's protections as well.
- drewmol 7y ago>I figure the Constitution ought to apply to anyone within it's jurisdiction, which to my mind means that if you are subject to our jursdiction for criminal purposes, you're subject to our constitution for it's protections as well. I fully agree, hopefully the SCOTUS will confirm this in a ruling at some point. Additionally the Declaration of Independence included this statement: "That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed" I think the consent to be governed should be established whether implied or expressed in a way more specific that just being a person somewhere on earth.
- rootusrootus 7y ago> And that it applies to foreign citizens who have – quite sensibly – never set foot on your soil? There is a lot of precedent here. Break the law in another country, and you may very well find yourself tried in their courts if you ever step into their jurisdiction. It's not like the US is snatching him off the streets in a foreign country under cover of darkness and dragging him to our jurisdiction, we are using very well established legal channels.
- jolfdb 7y agoAssange was snatched from a foreign country.
- rootusrootus 7y agoWas he? He's not in the US. He fled the UK's jurisdiction to accept the jurisdiction of Ecuador, but of course that carries the risk that Ecuador could change their mind and transfer him to another jurisdiction, which they did. Perhaps the next stop is Sweden, then the US. In any case all of it is being done through accepted legal channels. If the US wanted him on our soil without regards to consequences, we could certainly have him in a US jail in a matter of hours.
- cyphar 7y agoAssange was refused the ability to travel to Ecuador (a country that he became a citizen of) from the UK, which might be a violation of the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations (Article 44) -- though I'm not a lawyer: > The receiving State must, even in case of armed conflict, grant facilities in order to enable persons enjoying privileges and immunities, other than nationals of the receiving State, and members of the families of such persons irrespective of their nationality, to leave at the earliest possible moment. It must, in particular, in case of need, place at their disposal the necessary means of transport for themselves and their property. There is an argument to be made that since he is not embassy personnel he isn't granted any such rights (in fact that's the most likely explanation). But then again, there is some grey area here -- in the 1984 someone in the Libyan embassy in the UK shot into a crowd killing a police officer[1]. The UK police weren't granted access to investigate whether the individual who did it was embassy personnel (and thus under diplomatic immunity) or not. The UK then cut diplomatic ties with Libya and all the personnel were forced to leave and return to Libya. However, if the UK had the legal right to refuse passage for non-embassy personnel then surely they would've done so and captured all non-embassy personnel for questioning. But they didn't do that. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Yvonne_Fletcher https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Yvonne_Fletcher
- zajd 7y ago> but let's be honest here > Manning is kind of the same thing, he went far beyond releasing a controversial video showing misconduct, so some punishment was just How do the bottom of those boots taste? Even had to misgender her, really quality stuff.
- caconym_ 7y agoCan you blame Snowden for accepting that "hospitality"? You only get one life and I don't blame him at all for not wanting to spend the rest of his time on Earth rotting in an American prison. I don't think we can say anything about his true intentions just based on the fact that he chose one of the few (possibly the only?) alternatives presented to him. Unless we think the information he provided is intended to be misleading, the ball's in our court now (and we are dropping it). Whether or not he chooses to martyr himself to the American "justice" system is irrelevant now.
- rootusrootus 7y ago> Can you blame Snowden for accepting that "hospitality"? If he does not want to stand on principle, then no, I cannot blame him for choosing what is likely his only opportunity for any amount of freedom. Part of being a martyr, is, well, being a martyr. He knew the game when he released classified information, even if the ends may eventually justify the means (for some, not all of the information he divulged). I agree that he is essentially irrelevant at this point, he has said what he had to say, and done as much as he will ever be able to do. But I cannot blame reasonable people for believing that it is important he stand trial for breaking the law, regardless of how damning the information released. There is an argument to be made that we don't want to make it okay for every individual person to make their own judgement call about what classified information should be kept secret and what should not.
- kelnos 7y ago> There is an argument to be made that we don't want to make it okay for every individual person to make their own judgement call about what classified information should be kept secret and what should not. I would argue that we do want this to be okay, at least on a case-by-case basis. Unfortunately this means that it's incredibly subjective as to whether an unauthorized release of classified information was justified or not. We currently live in a world where unethical (and often illegal) activities continue, secretly and silently, likely because people who do have some shred of a conscience are too afraid of the consequences of stepping forward and speaking out. We tighten that status quo only to our detriment and the continued erosion of our civil rights.
- scotty79 7y agoManning jailed forever. Assange self imposed home arrest for last few years, probably will be jailed forever in US soon. Can't really blame Snowden for staying in the one place on earth US can't buy or blackmail.
- leeoniya 7y ago> Manning jailed forever. in case you missed it: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/17/us/politics/obama-commutes-bulk-of-chelsea-mannings-sentence.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/17/us/politics/obama-commute...
- dpwm 7y ago> in case you missed it: In case you missed it, she's currently in jail. [0] [1] [0] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/mar/08/chelsea-manning-judge-jails-wikileaks-case https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/mar/08/chelsea-mann... [1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/may/16/chelsea-manning-jailed-again-as-she-refuses-to-testify-before-grand-jury https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/may/16/chelsea-mann...
- manfredo 7y agoShe's in jail for refusing to testify to a grand jury. This is not directly part of the leak.
- k_sh 7y agoYes, refusing to testify to the grand jury... in the WikiLeaks case.
- maxlybbert 7y agoShe was released when the last grand jury ran out of time. A new grand jury was called, she refused to appear before it and was put back in jail. Presumably there’s an upper limit on how long she can be in jail (this grand jury also has a time limit, plus once Assange’s trial gets far enough along, there won’t be any point to demand that she appear before the grand jury).
- smileysteve 7y ago> He's also currently accepting the hospitality of the Russian gov't That's massaged a bit. if only he'd have had other travel plans to any other non extradition countries (he did), but stopped in an international terminal (for weeks before entering Russia) after diplomatic planes were being force grounded.
- chaostheory 7y ago> I don't know about cheering, but let's be honest here. Assange let himself be used by the Russians, either knowingly or naively, and he willingly jumped into a hyper partisan US election I don't blame him. He's doing everything to survive, when everything was being cut off. I think everyone can agree that Trump is an insurgent and outsider. He was a wildcard for Assange at the time. He didn't exactly have a lot of options given his desperate situation.
- briandear 7y agoMy problem is the publishing the names of assets that risked their lives to provide information. That doesn’t serve “the public,” that serves the enemy. If we are going to argue against spying, we can have that debate, but there is no question that releasing the names of spies is absolutely espionage. Names could have been redacted without compromising the public’s apparent “need” to know. If we outed the names of dissidents in Turkey or China, wouldn’t that be met with outrage? Yet as long as it is in the interests of opposing the US, it seems like there is a significant crowd that celebrates that. In the context of the United States and Western Europe, espionage was committed.
- rplst8 7y ago> There are lots of people in the US that believe strongly in the rule of law. You mean like the First and the Fourth amendments?
- rootusrootus 7y agoOf course! As applied in a court of law.
- effie 7y agoU.S. gov. probably would put Snowden through a secret court process, which is widely regarded as a kangaroo court in service of the spook branch of the government. They will make sure he becomes a terrifying example of what happens to heroic whistleblowers.
- markdown 7y ago> Assange let himself be used by the Russians, either knowingly or naively What if Assange was being "used" by the United Nations Human Rights Council, or by Canada, or Oxfam, or Letsie III, or Burger King? The premise here appears to be that the Russians are somehow evil. The US isn't at war with Russia and Assange isn't a citizen of either state. In any case, how was he "used" by Russia? Isn't this sort of leak exactly the kind of thing that Assange and Wikileaks have always stood for? Do you think he'd not have leaked the info if the Russians weren't a factor?
- droithomme 7y ago> Assange let himself be used by the Russians Which Russians? Is it the Russians that ran "Jesus can help you beat masturbation" and "Support BLM" ads on Facebook as part of their ad farm site scam? Or perhaps you mean the "Russians" who was a disgruntled DNC employee that handed DNC emails on a thumb drive to Craig Murray in Washington DC, who then flew to England and delivered the thumb drive to Julian Assange? Which Russians?
- soraminazuki 7y agoYou make it sound like Snowden is trying to flee justice, but he has made clear multiple times that he intends to return to the US if he is allowed to defend himself before a jury in an open court, something that the Espionage Act prevents him from doing. You’re not the only person who “believes strongly in the rule of law.” And by the way, when exactly did Snowden “go beyond the limits?” As far as I’m aware, he made sure to hand over every copy of the documents he possessed to professional reporters so that every disclosure made was legitimately in the public interest.
- jijji 7y ago> Assange let himself be used by the Russians, Has there been any actual evidence that Russian people were involved in the leaking of the john podesta emails? To the contrary, Seth Rich was mentioned as the likely leaker from the very beginning, and his unsolved murder and the various agencies that refuse to investigate it are involved in this to hide the truth.... What if any evidence has been presented to show any link to russian people with regard to john podesta emails. The treasure trove of information about illegal activity by the Clinton campaign was well worth any harm the publication of the emails presented.
- nl 7y agoYeah it's absolutely clear that the whole Seth Rich thing was completely made up, and now we can see that the timeline of events makes it impossible. https://www.thedailybeast.com/mueller-report-julian-assange-smeared-seth-rich-to-cover-for-russians https://www.thedailybeast.com/mueller-report-julian-assange-...
- jijji 7y agoThe story you are quoting talks about how at the time when wikileaks was going to publish the john podesta email archive, he received another message about more financial information relating to hillary clinton campaign. The story appears to conflate the receiving of this message about financial documents with the prior public release of john podesta emails, using the Meuller report as evidence that this must be a hoax. I don't buy it. The email trove came before it and IMO is unrelated. We may never know, but this is not evidence.
- nl 7y agoDon't try to complicate it. It's extremely clear: The Mueller report demolished that final moral refuge. Rich had been dead four days when Assange received the DNC files
- nl 7y agoIt's interesting how hard this is getting downvoted. Take a look at the facts rather than the interpretations of random events which are used to try and make it seem like he's involved in any way at all. It's just a bunch of QAnon-lite conspiracy theories. It's a pity people fall for it so easily.
- apazzolini 7y ago> Manning is kind of the same thing, he went far.. Please correct me if it was an honest mistake, but you're revealing your bias by choosing to use "he" instead of "she".
- pvaldes 7y agoIs undeniable that Manning is biologically a man with both X and Y chromosomes. It happens also that psychologically is/feels like/wants to be a woman. Both cases can be applied perfectly. People is complex and can be more than one thing at the same time.
- jonathanstrange 7y agoThat's roughly equivalent to intentionally mispronouncing someone's last name all the time or using a derogatory nickname for them. It's a light form of bullying. Unless they insist on being called "Master" or "King" or any nonsense like that, it is always best to respect people's wishes and call them the way they would like to be called.
- pvaldes 7y agoNot even close. Telling the truth is begin honest, not bullier or derogative, and the truth is that people is complex and should embrace their complexity. Being complicated and not plain is that makes us unique and interesting.
- jonathanstrange 7y ago> Telling the truth is begin honest This is nothing but a cheap excuse on your behalf for your bullying. Transgender people already way more about their real genes and the issue as a whole than you do, and the idea that you're doing them a favour by telling them the truth would be highly patronizing at least, but in reality you're just being hypocritical, because you know that they already know more about it than you anyway. It's not as if someone just decides to change his or her gender from one day to another, and you know that very well. What you say about telling the truth is also not true in general, of course. You know very well for yourself that it wouldn't be okay to tell your boss that he's fat and ugly, even if that was the case. We lie for politeness and courtesy several times a day, and that's not just fine, it's indispensable, since we cannot always choose whom to deal with. These things concern basic values of our society that people like you choose to ignore whenever it's convenient to them. But God forbid somebody uses the same whacko principles that you propose on you and tells you the truth about you... > Being complicated and not plain is that makes us unique and interesting. Still, that gives you zero reason not to respect other people's 'complexity.'
- fit2rule 7y ago>There are lots of people in the US that believe strongly in the rule of law. I find this argument specious. If it were the case, Americas criminal, illegal wars would not be happening. And they are criminal, and they are illegal - and the world is having a very hard time prosecuting the criminals behind them. Which is why we need Assange and Snowden and Manning, and the people they inspire, more than ever before. Because real crimes are being committed, and the American people are complicit.
- Nasrudith 7y agoThat is a very strange definition of rule of law - not being subservient to your own demise is bad for rule of law but not the exposed misconduct which goes completely unpunished? Rule of law isn't harmed by even the most vile criminals running away from enforcement or even the most ineffectual enforcement - those undermine its power but not its legitimacy. It is misapplication of the law in the first place that does it. Fuck that authoritarian "You have to accept the unjust punishment because rules is rules!" mentality. Rules are meant to serve the people not the other way around. The scales are already weighted against justice and the power.