13 ms·
> I do not believe we have enough control over our government. And that's probably something that needs to be argued in front of the Supreme Court. It is vital
by mcv 7y ago
> I do not believe we have enough control over our government.
And that's probably something that needs to be argued in front of the Supreme Court. It is vital in a democracy that a government can be held accountable. The government should not have a carte blanche to break the law in secret. There has to be some way to address this, and at the moment there clearly isn't.
Manning, Assange and Snowden provided a public service to the American public by showing them what their government was doing.
- dpwm 7y ago> Manning, Assange and Snowden provided a public service to the American public by showing them what their government was doing. And swathes of the US public seem to be cheering as they go down. Strange times.
- mcv 7y agoSwathes of the US public seem to be cheering as their own country is going down. Strange times indeed.
- oreo83 7y ago?
- jolfdb 7y agoThe source of your confusion is your conflation of a criminal government with the country itself.
- codehalo 7y agoSomebody's voting them in.
- jdironman 7y agoThen we need more power voting out.
- wallace_f 7y agoMost people are voting based on emotions which are pre-occupied with issues that are at the forefront of American politics. These often are exceptionally philosophical, emotional or religious topics; or in other cases, dramatic misrepresentations, lies or handouts. Outright corruption, unconstitutionality and waste are the main part of the show, but hidden behind that stage going on in front that most Americans are watching.
- hedora 7y agoAn increasingly small minority is voting them in. Democrats won the popular votes for the president, house and senate (they had 56.9% in the senate, in 2018, FFS!) in 2016 and 2018, but the republicans somehow managed to get complete control of the house senate and presidency, and unconstitutionally packed the courts in 2016-2018. Now, the democrats have control of just the house, and the executive branch has decided to simply ignore the constitutional limits on its power, since, as Trump has boasted, he could shoot someone in public for no reason, and there’s still no way the senate would impeach him. Also, it is apparently legal for state legislatures to override their popular vote. If even one swing state decide to do that, democrats won’t have enough votes in the house to prevent Trump from being reappointed (despite having a vast majority there, because of the way those votes are counted). Florida, or Ohio are likely candidates. In 2000, Florida would have used this power if the courts hadn’t stepped in, and would have voted for W. After recounts, Gore won Florida. In Ohio, in 2004, the vote was decided by a ballot box that republicans illegally transported to Indiana, and then transported back for tallying. Exit polls disagreed with the tally. We need to eliminate the electoral college, and get rid of per-state representatives. In our lifetimes, demographic trends suggest that the majority of the US will be represented by just 18 senators (with 82 for the minority). One person, one vote!
- themaninthedark 7y agoThe problem we are talking about has existed far before Trump became president. The secret AT&T closet started during Bush, since then we have had Obama and now Trump. The Patriot Act was passed and renewed with bi-partisan support.
- antonvs 7y agoIf what you really want is a religious ethnostate, you're going to cheer the demise of a multicultural democracy.
- cat199 7y agowhich is why the progressive democrats have made removing these programs such a core tenet of their platforms? this isn't partisan. perhaps skewed one way or another, but both parties seem to be quite happy with the state of domestic surveillance as a whole..
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- magduf 7y agoThey don't see it as their country going down, they see it as "making it great again". As the other poster said here, what a very large fraction of the US really wants is a religious ethnostate, and they're very good at voting for that, so that's where we're headed.
- geggam 7y agoThat is why the US was created as a Constitutional Republic. To prevent the catastrophe of a pure democracy Problem is the leaders of the country are profiting from the demise. I see an "interesting" future for the next 20 years of the US
- magduf 7y ago>That is why the US was created as a Constitutional Republic. To prevent the catastrophe of a pure democracy Why do people like you bring up this canard? Can you point to any pure democracies, anywhere, ever, aside from Ancient Greece? The US isn't special; every decent country (and many not-so-great ones too) now is a democratic republic of some kind, usually constitutional (UK is a notable exception here).
- geggam 7y agoBecause as you age you see how change is implemented. You watch the drift. Example. In my youth police were called peace officers. Their main mission was to enforce the peace at the expense of bending the law. Today law enforcement disrupts the peace to enforce the law. Society is not better off because of it. Watching presidents change what they called the nation from Republic to Democracy has also been something that happened. A republic is a nation of laws where everyone has the same rules. A democracy is simply a majority vote and currently the constitution and the laws are being marginalized. That is why folks bring up this "canard" FYI calling something constitutionally guaranteed, a canard is exactly to what I refer The United States shall guarantee to every State in this Union a Republican Form of Government, and shall protect each of them against Invasion; and on Application of the Legislature, or of the Executive (when the Legislature cannot be convened), against domestic Violence. ARTICLE IV, SECTION 4
- scardine 7y agoI'm halfway "parable of the talents" by Octavia E. Butler (I'm trying to read all the novels that won a Nebula Award). I can see it happening if US keep the current trajectory.
- rootusrootus 7y agoI don't know about cheering, but let's be honest here. Assange let himself be used by the Russians, either knowingly or naively, and he willingly jumped into a hyper partisan US election. Just like some people want to put Hillary Clinton in prison, some are going to want to see Assange punished. Snowden released a lot of information that was very valuable to the citizens of the US, and that's great, but he also went well beyond that and there is a legitimate argument to be made that such behavior should be punished. He's also currently accepting the hospitality of the Russian gov't, which just adds another reason to be skeptical of his neutrality. Manning is kind of the same thing, he went far beyond releasing a controversial video showing misconduct, so some punishment was just. And the commutation by Obama was just. There are lots of people in the US that believe strongly in the rule of law.
- dpwm 7y ago> Assange let himself be used by the Russians, either knowingly or naively, and he willingly jumped into a hyper partisan US election. Believing that narrative actually requires trusting the US security services, who may or may not have something to gain from a new cold war. There are simpler explanations with just as much evidence behind them. > There are lots of people in the US that believe strongly in the rule of law. And that it applies to foreign citizens who have – quite sensibly – never set foot on your soil?
- microwavecamera 7y ago> There are lots of people in the US that believe strongly in the rule of law. >And that it applies to foreign citizens who have – quite sensibly – never set foot on your soil? Of course it does. That's like saying a foreign terrorist can't be charged for an act of terrorism because they're not a U.S. citizen. Furthermore, because Assange is a foreign national, 1st Amendment protections do not apply in this situation.
- dpwm 7y ago> That's like saying a foreign terrorist can't be charged for an act of terrorism because they're not a U.S. citizen. One man's might-is-right flag-waving US exceptionalism is another man's terrorism.
- tide_ad 7y ago> And that's probably something that needs to be argued in front of the Supreme Court. do you really want that? the supreme court will rule 5-4 in favor of the administration, where 2 of those 5 judges were placed there by the current president what people want is for the thin fabric of society to not be challenged when people already recognize that it exists on shaky legal ground, not nearly in line with the social contract in their head obama administration had considered an espionage act charge but didn't want the first amendment challenge, if they had the supreme court they would have done it as well
- zaroth 7y agoI don’t believe the source of the secret files is ever protected in a court of law from prosecution, but the publisher may be. For example the Pentagon Papers were released by Daniel Ellsberg and published by The NY Times. From Wikipedia; > For his disclosure of the Pentagon Papers, Ellsberg was initially charged with conspiracy, espionage, and theft of government property, but the charges were later dismissed after prosecutors investigating the Watergate scandal discovered that the staff members in the Nixon White House had ordered the so-called White House Plumbers to engage in unlawful efforts to discredit Ellsberg. An FBI agent, military enlisted or officer, etc. would rightly face charges for doseminating classified materials. There is no carte blanche to break the law because of something you don’t like that your Administration is doing. Sometimes the offense is so egregious that it’s a sacrifice someone is willing to make. In those cases if the court of public opinion is enough on the side of the leaker, there is always pardons or jury nullification to fall back on. But I do think that it’s still precipitated by an illegal act (the leaking) which can rightly be prosecuted because generally classified material is classified for a reason and it’s not up to each individual that comes across it to decide if they agree or not. The publisher also has to be careful that they are not soliciting or assisting the leaker in providing the materials lest they become an accomplice. I assume, although I’m not fully up to speed on the case, that this is the angle for charging Assange.
- foota 7y agoI disagree. We have whistleblower protection for corporate whistleblowers, why not governmental? Edit: turns out we do, but it has to be actually illegal behavior as opposed to just unethical.
- bb88 7y agoThe gold standard here is Daniel Ellsberg who sent the pentagon papers to the Washington Post. Those were the documents that revealed that America had an illegal secret war in Cambodia. In short, Assange is no Daniel Elssberg.
- mjevans 7y agoThat's fine to say, but what does it actually mean? How do we protect forces providing oversight and sunlight to parts of the government that we the people really should know about to be informed voters? How do we reasonably protect 'watchers', and how can we have reasonable oversight of the 'watchers'? Part of the issue is that there is not a clear standard that must be adhered to; where does selection bias count as an editorial action and where does it count as being an agent of a foreign power? If someone is a completely dumb conduit that does not evaluate the data but republishes it without inner knowledge do they have more or less protections than someone that evaluates and 'publishes' the content (I.E. in technical terms 'the press', even if not part of something traditionally obvious as a news organization.)?
- bb88 7y agoThe first amendment doesn't protect conspiring to illegally access a computer system. Further, not all dissemination of classified materials can be classified as a first amendment activity. In short, there has to be a difference between a spy and a journalist. Further, it's worth noting that Snowden agreed to sign his life away when he signed the SF-86 form to apply for a US clearance. Glenn Greenwald did not.
- salawat 7y agoPersonally, I think this should be part of the duties of the Office of the Inspector General, and the OIG should be shunted to being answerable to the either the Legislature, or the Courts. Of course, I also believe that OIG should be hounding the Executive constantly, and have the authority and onus to declassify anything classified as soon as possible too. That means that classification stops being a privilege of the Executive, and instead becomes a maintenance item That requires periodic review to reclassify.
- coldtea 7y ago>And that's probably something that needs to be argued in front of the Supreme Court. It is vital in a democracy that a government can be held accountable. And why wouldn't the government be in bed with the Supreme Court?
- danso 7y agoThe Supreme Court is part of the government — you mean the executive? Of course that could be a situation, that’s ostensibly why the founders separated the 3 branches, including giving SCOTUS life terms to increase their independence.
- mirimir 7y ago> There has to be some way to address this, and at the moment there clearly isn't. I don't see how it could ever happen. It's arguable that democracy and government accountability in the US ended in the early 1800s. If it ever existed at all, really. I mean, consider history. The New Deal was arguably appeasement to forestall revolution. We finally elected a black president, who had cultivated almost a "black power" reputation in Chicago, and he ended up barely more liberal than Nixon.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- droithomme 7y ago> And that's probably something that needs to be argued in front of the Supreme Court. Perhaps the Supreme Court review is what makes everything OK since they are the best of the best. Viva Dred Scott.
- tylersmith 7y agoYou want to ask the Supreme Court of the United States if the United States government has too much power?
- ls612 7y agoI’d say it’s virtually sure that if this case goes to trial it will eventually end up at SCOTUS based on the profound 1st amendment issues involved.