6 ms·
> This corresponds rather well with a non-corrupt process largely blind to companies' nationality, assuming that US companies are rather well-regulated in the U
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> This corresponds rather well with a non-corrupt process largely blind to companies' nationality, assuming that US companies are rather well-regulated in the US compared to Asian companies.
The trouble is this doesn't really prove anything for the exact reason you're identifying. What you have to compare is the level of enforcement compared to the level of compliance. If US companies are more compliant than average then there should be less enforcement than average, but then you still don't know whether there is more or less than there should be. If US companies are fined 75% as much even though they break the rules 50% as much, that's evidence of bias rather than a lack of it.
Moreover, major US companies are hard sticklers for following rules. They're full of lawyers because their home country is and they'll get their pants sued off otherwise.
That actually seems to be the problem. The EU passes some complicated stack of rules, the US companies have their lawyers go through them and figure out how to comply without disrupting their business, but disrupting their businesses was the motivation for the rules. Then the EU comes around and fines them again. Everybody who dislikes them cheers, but it smells rotten because the companies knew they were under scrutiny and had good lawyers, so it's difficult to find explicit violations and consequently huge fines get meted out over behavior which is not even clearly a violation of the rules.
- anoncake 8y agoThe issue is that US companies are following the letter of the rules while violating the spirit. If the spirit of the law is to ban your business model, switch to a different one or stop operating. A company that tries to weasel around the rules while knowing exactly what the EU meant is just taking the regulators and courts for fools. > good lawyers If US companies keep getting fined despite having "good lawyers", maybe those lawyers aren't that good after all.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> The issue is that US companies are following the letter of the rules while violating the spirit. "The spirit of the law" is the refuge of people that can't be bothered to make good laws to begin with and just want to make up whatever rules they want ex post facto. > If the spirit of the law is to ban your business model, switch to a different one or stop operating. If the spirit of the law is to ban their business model then stop pussyfooting around it and just make that the letter of the law. > If US companies keep getting fined despite having "good lawyers", maybe those lawyers aren't that good after all. A good lawyer can't always overcome a bad court.
- anoncake 8y ago> "The spirit of the law" is the refuge of people that can't be bothered to make good laws to begin with and just want to make up whatever rules they want ex post facto. That's a good approach if you want to play silly games, but fortunately the EU prefers effective regulation. And its courts are reliable enough that we can rely on its judges having common sense when interpreting the law. Maybe the US is different. > If the spirit of the law is to ban their business model then stop pussyfooting around it and just make that the letter of the law. It is, actually. But the good lawyers of US companies apparently believe, for example, that "freely given consent" means "clicking a button to make an overlay go away because we make the provision of our service conditional to spying on them". What does the GDPR say? > When assessing whether consent is freely given, utmost account shall be taken of whether, inter alia, the performance of a contract, including the provision of a service, is conditional on consent to the processing of personal data that is not necessary for the performance of that contract. US companies are openly breaking the GDPR and violating people's privacy. Frankly, 4% is far too low for this kind of insolence.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> That's a good approach if you want to play silly games, but fortunately the EU prefers effective regulation. Regulation can only be effective if people know how to follow it. Otherwise you're just a bully punishing people for things they can't predict ahead of time, and you can't produce the desired behavior because you've failed to identify what it actually is. > It is, actually. But the good lawyers of US companies apparently believe, for example, that "freely given consent" means "clicking a button to make an overlay go away because we make the provision of our service conditional to spying on them". You seem to be claiming that things like this do not exist: https://myactivity.google.com/ https://myactivity.google.com/ How is the service "conditional to spying" if you can turn it off or delete the data and still use the service? > US companies are openly breaking the GDPR and violating people's privacy. Frankly, 4% is far too low for this kind of insolence. You obviously have strong opinions about Google. But is there a reason you don't just stop using their services? I can't think of any that has no competitors.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y ago>If the spirit of the law is to ban your business model, switch to a different one or stop operating. That may end up happening. With the copyright directive and these fines, companies may find that serving EU consumers is not worth it and may start blocking EU users from their services.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoSpirit is subjective and letter is objective. It is easy to follow objectively defined rules but impossible to follow subjectively defined rules.
- anoncake 8y agoI'm sorry that you find it impossible to follow "subjectively defined rules". Fortunately, most people have no issues doing that.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoHuh, so you prefer rule by law over rule of law? Most people don't prefer that.
- anoncake 8y agoThe difference between rule of law and rule by law is that rule of law is primarily about the spirit of the law while rule by law is what you want.
- seanmcdirmid 8y ago> about the spirit of the law while rule by law is what you want. And the difference is? Those are both very subjective. The EU could get around this by not writing crappy laws, but I guess this is why we have courts.
- anoncake 8y ago> And the difference is? Those are both very subjective. Compared to what is the letter of the law subjective? Pure math? > The EU could get around this by not writing crappy laws, but I guess this is why we have courts. People not making mistakes and having infinite foresight would solve so many problems. Probably not the one of natural language being fuzzy, though.