8 ms·
Google will argue that while this data is intimate (religion, age, personal preferences), it is not personally identifiable. I have access to one of these data
by londons_explore 8y ago
Google will argue that while this data is intimate (religion, age, personal preferences), it is not personally identifiable.
I have access to one of these data feeds of bid requests, and for the most part, they're right. Pick a random entry and even after hours of searching and correlating with the other data we have on file, it's unlikely I'd be able to identify exactly who it was (ie. Their name and address) on that website.
Some requests totally are identify-able though, for example if the user goes on to click one of our ads, buy something, and give us their postal address. In the eyes of the law, we have broken the rules there by re-identifying previously anonymous data.
While I think Google is technically in the right here, they're gonna loose big time because they're a foreign company and don't have much love with the public.
- levosmetalo 8y ago> Some requests totally are identify-able though, for example if the user goes on to click one of our ads, buy something, and give us their postal address. In the eyes of the law, we have broken the rules there by re-identifying previously anonymous data. You are either compliant or not. Claiming that you are 90% GDPR compliant still makes you non-compliant. > While I think Google is technically in the right here, No, they are not technically right, because even being 99% right makes you 1% wrong, which in case of Google would affect 70M people. > they're gonna loose big time because they're a foreign company and don't have much love with the public. The love of the public doesn't have any legal influence, and being a foreign company doesn't mean that company can play by it's own or their home country rules. By the same logic, one could argue that Volkswagen, Deutsche Bank and Monsanto got fined hefty only because they are foreign companies, and that they would be either not fined, or fined much less if they were US based. Oh, wait ...
- matt4077 8y ago> they're gonna loose big time because they're a foreign company I think it's somewhat irresponsible to throw out accusations this big without even feeling the need to offer any evidence for them. FWIW I once summed up the various fines (anti-trust etc.) doled out by the EU by country/continent. It turned out that US companies were, collectively, fined slightly less than their share of economic activity in the EU, while Asian companies were fined more and EU companies were about level. This corresponds rather well with a non-corrupt process largely blind to companies' nationality, assuming that US companies are rather well-regulated in the US compared to Asian companies. I haven't done the reverse for US fines of European companies. But, subjectively, the cases that made the news (mostly VW and Deutsche Bank) gel rather nicely with my (Germany-based) impression of companies with malignant corporate culture and do not require any nationalistic motivation to explain. I know it may seem like a minor point in this context. But if we always assume all institutions are corrupt, that becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy. Institutions such as the court system and, more generally, the rule of law, are the reason we (some of us) can enjoy life in peace, and shouldn't be torn down just by empty cynicism.
- the_seraphim 8y agoI wish you would do the reverse - would make interesting reading considering the current situation re: huawei - would also be interesting to compare the fines levied by asian countries against US and EU companies
- brownbat 8y agoYou're right it's important to unpack these allegations, but I don't think they are just random cynicism. > US companies were, collectively, fined slightly less than their share of economic activity in the EU, I can imagine why you would control for economic activity, but I have no idea what impact that had on the results relative to other reasonable controls. If we're wondering about punishing bad decisions, you could have instead controlled for the number of decisionmakers from these companies in the EU. Or you could have controlled for the number of different endeavors or types of products or lines of business (because each different source of revenue is a source of malfeasance moreso than each individual euro earned). I'm really mostly concerned about that last one. What is the chance each revenue stream will get more scrutiny by being foreign? Court cases don't target individual euros earned, they target a certain product or way of doing business. Regardless of controls, it doesn't change the tortured logic in some high profile cases comparing US and EU institutions under the same standard. If the Spanish media publicizes something as widely as it can, that's great, because it's good for the public to have that information. If an American tech firm allows people to access those publications, that's bad, because it's bad for the public to have that information. I'd love to change my mind about the bias in the EU, I'm open to new evidence. All it would take is a few EU cases where they found that the big American company was blameless, but the small European company should be fined.
- anoncake 8y agoSomehow I think it's unlikely that Google is not violating a law that was in part passed to stop Google from doing what it's doing. > While I think Google is technically in the right here, they're gonna loose big time because they're a foreign company and don't have much love with the public. They don't need love with the public, just with the ECJ.
- perlgeek 8y ago"personally identifiable" is a tricky thing. Even if you cannot use the data to identify a person, maybe your ISP or the police could, making the information "personally identifiable". According to https://www.groundlabs.com/what-is-pii-for-gdpr/ https://www.groundlabs.com/what-is-pii-for-gdpr/ IP addresses count as PII. > Some requests totally are identify-able though, for example if the user goes on to click one of our ads, buy something, and give us their postal address. And if you operate at scale, that might happen thousands of times per day. IMHO this is a serious GDPR infringement. Do you notify users that you process PII, even if you don't bind on this request? Do you give users the option to opt-out before you do? If not, you are in serious trouble.
- w_t_payne 8y agoI also used to work in buy-side ad-tech and the industry cannot possibly function without making a wide (global, industrial scale) swathe of individuals and institutions vulnerable to espionage, social engineering, blackmail etc... The fact that these vulnerabilities are not exploited more widely or more aggressively is a minor miracle (then again ... maybe they are and we just don't know about it yet...)
- Ensorceled 8y agoThis presumes that the customers of the ad industry would stop buying ads without this personal data. It's an arms race, advertisers buy ads from the best source and more personal information makes your market better. Eliminating this arms race won't make advertisers stop advertising.
- w_t_payne 7y agoTrue ... but then it would no longer be ad-tech. Just advertising.
- acd 8y agoYour Google search history will show if you have searched for a political party, religion and then your Google profile name is visible. How is that GDPR filtered? I am also dubious since its Ireland and Google offices,servers is located on Ireland. Thus Ireland data regulation authority might rule in favor for Ireland.
- makomk 8y agoIt's worth noting that the same re-identification problem also applies to advert placement that doesn't use any information about the person being advertised to and is based solely on the topic of the website or webpage, and - according to this blog post - this investigation is in fact going after Google for using that information in ad placement. They're basically trying to kill Google's online advertising business full stop.
- prepend 8y agoThis is something that annoyed me about “anonymous” ad techniques. It’s pretty easy, I think, for an unethical company to make a very specific ad that still has thousands of people “10 miles of DC, male, >60, English speaker, Spanish speaker, college graduate, etc” that still has a population in tens of thousands and have the click through offer a signup with email. So the site gets the email and knows from the targeted campaign lots of info about the person they would not share with the site normally. Do this enough and you end up in Cambridge Analytica-town with portfolios on millions of email addresses that can then be sold independently of the advertiser’s knowledge.
- AJ007 8y agoIt is going to kill European websites that rely on ad revenue and all third party European ad networks too.
- takeda 8y ago
- hnarn 8y ago> Google will argue that while this data is intimate (religion, age, personal preferences), it is not personally identifiable. IANAL but I would assume that all it takes is one incident of it actually being personally identifiable to erase this argument. All it takes is one data point that is "unique enough" to map it to one person. Imagine a very unique combination of these three values (religion, age, personal preferences: muslim, 21, likes curling) and add an equally unique location (Iceland) and you may be in trouble.
- Aaargh20318 8y agoAs the linked article (and the API docs linked from that article) indicates, it contains a Google user ID, which is unique to a user. That by itself already makes it PII. Furthermore, you probably know the IP of the user you're serving a page to, that combined with this data also makes it PII.. It's not about wether you can determine the person's name, mail address or whatever, it's wether this combination of data is or can be unique to a single person.
- mottosso 8y agoI've just made a unique ID for you, it's XYZUser. This is unique to you, and I'm storing this on my computer indefinitely.
- jimktrains2 8y agoDo you also store all of their email, searches, and websites they visit attached to that id?
- vageli 8y ago> I've just made a unique ID for you, it's XYZUser. This is unique to you, and I'm storing this on my computer indefinitely. I was under the impression that individuals keeping notes for non-commercial purposes is not governed by the GDPR.
- kenbaylor 8y agoNot true unfortunately under the GDPR nor it's predecessor, if the notes are publicly available: Bodil Lindquist v Åklagarkammaren (2003) Mrs. Lindquist (whose purposes were mostly charitable and religious) published on a private home page personal data about her colleagues, including telephone numbers and information about a coworker’s injured foot and medical leave. This case raised the question if a private home page accessible to only those who have the address is permitted under one of the exclusions (household activity). The European Court of Justice ruled that it is not.
- 8y ago
- mtgx 8y agoObama should have never intervened to stop the FTC from suing Google on antitrust issues in the U.S. either. Google has only gotten much more brazen after that to the point that many people no longer believe the company's "don't be evil" propaganda, which I believe has served Google very well initially. Google started ruining its own image through its recent actions and it will only make government actions against the company that much more likely to succeed now. Google used to have a lot of "soft power" on these issues, and it's been rapidly declining over the past few years. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/13/technology/ftc-staff-prepares-antitrust-case-against-google-over-search.html https://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/13/technology/ftc-staff-prep...
- nostalgk 8y agoIt's just like power in any other form; legitimate power comes from the ability to influence others, but exercising that power to coerce others is a trade. If Google wants that power back, they need to earn it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wund3rb4r88 8y agoHaving seen Twitters data on me (they think I’m older than I am by a decade, and have 4 kids, when I have 2), I too wonder how accurate this data can really be. Anymore I just straight up “lie” about personal details. A relationship with a tech company is based upon serving my needs first, not theirs, IMO. And at least for me the need they fill is convenience of not having to build the service they provide. Which I would do if said service did not exist. So there’s that. Have my fake data. Sell emotional but technically inaccurate promises to advertisers all ya want, SV.
- dijksterhuis 8y agoI do exactly this unless I absolutely need to give out shipping/payment deets. Also... use a xxxxx@mailinator.com email address to avoid having to sign up for real.
- londons_explore 8y agoLying about personal details online might get you into trouble with fraud laws. Sure they won't directly come after you, but if you're in court for some other reason, the fact you put 'hwpsn62#!' as your mother's maiden name might add one more charge...
- feanaro 8y agoIn which country do you think this might happen? Sounds pretty absurd where I'm from.
- PhillipRed 8y agoI think he's referring to the CFAA and cases like this in the USA: https://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/legal-consequences-of-lying-on-credit-card-application-fraud-1282.php https://www.creditcards.com/credit-card-news/legal-consequen...
- geocar 8y ago> I have access to one of these data feeds of bid requests, and for the most part, they're right. Pick a random entry and even after hours of searching and correlating with the other data we have on file, it's unlikely I'd be able to identify exactly who it was (ie. Their name and address) on that website. That's you, but what if Vodafone buys this data? They know the personal data of their broadband users but they don't necessarily have religion or other personal preferences... should they? Or how about when it's me? Maybe I just know this space better? I can get email addresses from pretty much anywhere, md5 them, check against the email hash from Lotame (or someone; it's almost always unsalted md5), and match that against Google's Bidstream. Bingo: Now I have email to "intimate" data[1], which probably surprises a lot of people! [1]: I like that term better than both "special category data" and the older "sensitive personal data"... I think I'm going to use it
- mbrookes 8y agoLet's not confuse Personally Identifiable Information (PII) the US definition, with Personal Data, the EU definition. From the UK ICO [1] "Personal data is information that relates to an identified or identifiable individual. (Emphasis mine.) So, if it is possible to correlate the personal data with other records that identify an individual (whether by you or a third party with whom the data is shared) it is personal data. Full disclosure: I work for Veritas Technologies, which, among many other things, provides technologies that help companies find, filter and take action on PII and personal data. Opinions shared here are my own, and do not necessarily represent the views of my employer. [1] https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protection/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/key-definitions/what-is-personal-data/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...
- CriticalCathed 8y agoSo, if you can tie this information that you receive from Google to a particular person then wouldn't this violate the spirit of the law? Similar to the way precursor chemicals are illegal or tightly controlled in drug law.