8 ms·
The same thing happened in Venezuela in the early 2000s when they initiated price controls to make food more "affordable" for the poor. The variety of products
by dmix 8y ago
The same thing happened in Venezuela in the early 2000s when they initiated price controls to make food more "affordable" for the poor. The variety of products was the first thing that dropped to only the necessities. Then even the necessities started to drop in supply:
> Further yet, price controls, expropriation of numerous farmlands and various industries, among other disputable government policies including a near-total freeze on any access to foreign currency at reasonable "official" exchange rates, have resulted in severe shortages in Venezuela and steep price rises of all common goods, including food, water, household products, spare parts, tools and medical supplies; forcing many manufacturers to either cut production or close down, with many ultimately abandoning the country as has been the case with several technological firms and most automobile makers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Venezuela#1999–2013 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economy_of_Venezuela#1999–2013
- rayiner 8y agoMy wife was a student in the eastern part of Germany in the early aughts, when life in pre-unification eastern Germany was still fresh in peoples’ minds. One thing that people would say is that “before the wall fell, we had plenty of money, there just was never anything to buy.” When I hear people say “X shouldn’t be subject to the market” I want to bang my head on the desk. You can’t just decide that, e.g. food won’t be subject to market forces by, e.g., imposing price controls. If you push on the balloon on one side, it will expand on the other side.
- areoform 8y agoHowever, it is fruitful to point out that not all markets are created equal. Even if an exchange of money takes place in return for goods and services, the market that exists is not necessarily a free market. Sometimes this is true even in the most idealized of cases. For example, healthcare isn’t composed of one market, but several between different operators operating under different market forces and regulatory rules. As it’s too complicated to go into each, I’ll go into one that’s most apparent; the market between patients and healthcare providers (not insurance companies!). Assuming the most idealized of cases that exist without external constraints and regulations, this market would never be a free market. Because the buyer will never be in the position to make the decision to not buy the good. Even a rational free agent would not be in a position to disagree from making a purchase. The value each sentient lifeform places on their life is for all intents and purposes infinity in the healthcare context. No sane suicidal individual or hero would sign up for a purposeless, slow and painful death. This removes the essential mechanism that free markets have to regulate themselves; the freedom to not participate. In most markets, if a good or service is too expensive then the business selling them will go bankrupt or remain small due to a lack of buyers. This creates an incentive for a cheaper mousetrap to exist. But healthcare isn’t like that. Your choice is severely limited. At best, you can choose between providers (though for serious, and sadly incredibly routine, issues the immediacy of needing treatment trumps this) and at worst you’re unconscious and unable to make any decisions yourself. So the element of choice isn’t present making it axiomatically not a free market. Please note that I am not going into ancillary factors like the difficulties patients face in making informed decisions, the viral component that exists for certain classes of disease (you choosing not to do X in the case of a serious enough pathogen could lead to a sick household or an epidemic. See: the return of measles), the difficulty of rationing care (Americans spend more partly because they see their doctors less by design and are discouraged from accessing preventative care), and overall incentive misalignment between doctors, pharmaceutical manufacturers, hospital staff, insurers, HMOs etc that creates runaway effects. We treat all markets in the same way, but they aren’t all the same. The market for healthcare is different from consumer electronics and the market for plastic surgery (a procedure where I must note there is an option to say no). Reductively put, you can choose not to buy a MacBook Pro. But you can’t choose not to treat sepsis. So why does our literature usually assume that both are the same?
- CryptoPunk 8y ago>>this market would never be a free market. Because the buyer will never be in the position to make the decision to not buy the good. A free market does not mean a market where a buyer has a choice of not buying something. It only means one where the market choices of agents are not constrained by coercive intervention of other agents. We need to buy food, but the market for food is still quite free, and consequently, very efficient.
- areoform 8y ago> A free market does not mean a market where a buyer has a choice of not buying something. It only means one where the market choices of agents are not constrained by coercive intervention of other agents. That's not how I was taught this concept. I know, Wikipedia is a bad source, but I would like to point out how widespread my specific interpetation is amongst the economics textbooks I've read; In a free market, individuals and firms taking part in these transactions have the liberty to enter, leave and participate in the market as they so choose. Prices and quantities are allowed to adjust according to economic conditions in order to reach equilibrium and properly allocate resources. Note, enter and leave. This means both as a producer and a consumer, without this we cannot have efficient allocation. > We need to buy food, but the market for food is still quite free, and consequently, very efficient. The food market is a really good counter-argument to mine, but when I was first making my observations, I found that food is a very different market that was originally constrained in similar ways but isn't. First is that it's a "market" that's nearing globalized post-scarcity (this doesn't preclude localized scarcity). We produce enough food that we can feed the global population twice over https://ourworldindata.org/food-per-person https://ourworldindata.org/food-per-person (3k+ per capita for developed nations and 2k+ for underdeveloped ones). Humans have reached this state due to government-sponsored research and sponsored application of revolutionary new technologies. Second, our ability to process food has also led to a surplus in stored calories. We can feed ourselves even during catastrophes (though distribution will remain a challenge). And third, historically (as I am not certain about this particular point, but it is consistent with my reading of history), prior to the green revolution, the food market was never this free - it has always been state managed to a varying degrees. From feudal lords and chieftains to the Roman grain dole, food has been a carefully managed resources until our time. Due to its oversupply and heterogeneity, the food market has a very different structure and dynamics that are inherent to it. But, taking my argument at face value, I would argue that it is indeed possible to exit the food market - we can grow our own food! Even a small-ish farm with good practices can feed a family for a year or more using wild seeds, natural compost and herbicides alone.
- duxup 8y agoMy understanding was that East Germany actually had a better standard of living generally than your average Russian at that time. So their thoughts that they were doing alright compared to Russia at that time was probably right.
- tinus_hn 8y agoThe government had an interest in making the areas close to the ‘free world’ look better so these were propped up using resources from farther away.
- ahartmetz 8y agoI think the GDR was just a more effective country, just like Czechoslovakia and Hungary were. In the case of the GDR, despite being led by a very small-minded clown basically sanctioned by the USSR. Russia has never had it good in hundreds of years and it kept the tradition under communism.
- JetSpiegel 8y agoThat cuts both ways. Eastern Germany was also the best capitalism can buy.
- duxup 7y agoBased on my understanding they were simply better managed and benefited from some cross border stuff that exposed them to other markets that weren't readily available to everyone in Russia. Similar to other states that had some association with the west where in the end they could sell products and goods outside the planned economy and that helped keep things going.
- dmix 8y agoIt's basically people with good intentions volunteering themselves into poverty during the greatest time of abundance of food in human history. Of course it comes with plenty of western/foreign capitalist sabotage conspiracies thrown in to justify why their grand economic experiment didn't work. Then it devolves into basically purposefully underfeeding your population because of a giant lingering sunk-cost fallacy and, most importantly, an ideology to defend - on which the current power structures were built on.
- fao_ 8y ago> Of course it comes with plenty of western/foreign capitalist sabotage conspiracies thrown in to justify why their grand economic experiment didn't work. An economy cannot work without foreign trade, being blocked from that by a major player essentially does that. If you look at communist countries that are small enough to be self-sufficient, it tells a different story. Take Cuba, it is blocked from trade with the US and a fair chunk of other countries, however, Cuba is self-sufficient enough that it has not only survived but it has flourished, with a ridiculously high literacy rate, and a universal public health system that puts much of the world to shame. I have but two observations left to make. 1. If the communist system was inherently a fail-state, then the US would have to do nothing but sit back and wait until it collapses. Instead of that they try relentlessly to sabotage any form of it. They tried, for example, over 600 times to assasinate the leader of Cuba. It's a real shame because it forces the communist parties to be anti-free-press, and anti-free-speech because of the risk of foreign countries abusing that to seed a revolution (Indeed, it was admitted on record that the only reason the CIA hasn't done that in Cuba is because it lacks resources, and Cuba doesn't allow full internet access (as I understand it)). 2. It took over 800 years to establish a stable republic. That doesn't mean that it could not be done, or that the republic was an inherently broken system, but it took a number of 'failures' to make a success, and the right political and societal advancements to be made.
- llamaz 8y agojust because you don't agree with something shouldn't be a reason to downvote
- 4ntonius8lock 8y agoJust curious as to how you think fire fighting services should be priced by the market? I'm generally very conservative and against regulation, so no need to preach Adam smith to me (I actually read Wealth of Nations... not the synopsis). Though I will say, by ycombinator standards, I'm a centrist (way too left for the right, way too right for the left).
- thaumasiotes 8y agoMarket-priced firefighting is the norm, not the exception. See e.g. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0925753598000459 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092575359...
- frosted-flakes 8y agoWell, the state pays the market price, but people who use firefighting services ("consumers") typically don't pay anything. Just like health care should be, I suppose.
- thaumasiotes 8y ago> when life in pre-unification eastern Germany was still fresh in peoples’ minds. One thing that people would say is that “before the wall fell, we had plenty of money, there just was never anything to buy.” This is a pretty striking echo of Kipling's verse commentary: In the Carboniferous Epoch, we were promised abundance for all by robbing selected Peter to pay for collective Paul But though we had plenty of money, there was nothing our money could buy and the Gods of the Copybook Headings said: "If you don't work you die." (The Gods of the Copybook Headings, 1919)
- ohdangbanme 8y agoThat's the ultimate goal of socialism: let poor be even poorer, as long as rich are less rich. Envious morons like Bernie with true believing Goolag employees as their helpers and níggêrs as their pets are accomplishing this now in the United States. Dang, please report my IP to Google!