22 ms·
Folks can say what they want about religion, but I have a feeling that church plays a larger role in maintaining a healthy society than it is given credit in so
by jcims 7y ago
Folks can say what they want about religion, but I have a feeling that church plays a larger role in maintaining a healthy society than it is given credit in some circles.
- fwip 7y agoAgreed, it's important to have community.
- Circuits 7y agoOkay but religion and church aren't a necessary component for community.
- penagwin 7y agoI'm not religious, but I certainly think there's value in large groups of people with similar interests meeting in a positive environment.
- blotter_paper 7y agoI think that a bunch of basic social functions started out as religious and are now carried out by atheists and the like (marriages, potlatches, etc.). In a pre-scientific world, everything was religious. What is a church but community and religion? If we can strip the religion from marriage, why not church? I know atheists who attend Unitarian Universalist churches for the community (and my parents took me as a kid, my dad an atheist and my mom a mushy-not-really-religious-but-believes-in-somethingist). It's not for me, but that's probably a social issue related to how I respond to those sorts of groups and not really related to religion. Secular churches do exist.
- Circuits 7y agoIn my experience (15 years or so) most people who attended my church didn't rush home or spend any time outside of church worshiping/praising their god. Even when I was at church, outside of the sermon, no one was talking about god or religion. Hell.. in my experience, with my religion, most people have never even read the book that the religion was based off of and knew very little about it when quizzed and yes I did quiz them from time to time. So, aside from a few outliers, I have always been under the impression that most people attending church get far more enjoyment from the social aspects than the religious ones.
- tathougies 7y agoMy experience is the complete opposite. Of course there's the social aspect, but almost every family had their own devotions they did outside of church. I remember clearly our teachers asking everyone in our class of 30+ in Catholic school to share our family's family-specific religious traditions. I think coming from a tradition rich with symbolism and tangible activities as devotions (Catholicism) helps with that.
- humanrebar 7y ago> I have always been under the impression that most people attending church get far more enjoyment from the social aspects than the religious ones You were clearly not a Pentacostal then.
- FabHK 7y agoIt is very important to have community. However, church is but one way to achieve that (others are good city planning, with pedestrian oriented small town centres; a strong secular society with institutions and clubs supporting hobbies and sports, etc.) The problem with the church as the main provider of community (and values) is (at least) twofold: 1. It tends to impose some bad values with the good values (not to mention bad epistemology and ontology), and, 2. when people notice that and leave church, they a) also lose their community (which can be devastating), and b) sometimes throw out the good values with the bad.
- toasterlovin 7y agoThe problems you've described are problems with all human organizations, not just churches/religions.
- FabHK 7y ago1. Few human organisations nowadays promote values as bad as most religions. 2. You can be a member of several overlapping organizations, but only one church, normally. So, the problem of losing a community is exacerbated with church.
- toasterlovin 7y ago> 1. Few human organisations nowadays promote values as bad as most religions. It sounds like your mind is inhabited by a caricature of religion, rather than a realistic conception of the thing. For instance, our neighborhood church uses their facilities to provide (secular) services to the local community. They also organize a monthly service day where community members (not just their congregation) provide help to people in need. Many other churches do similar things. And there is a reason why so many hospitals in the U.S. have religious names: they were started by churches. If you want to hold religion to account for the bad that they contribute, you also have to give them credit for the good. And I think once you start doing that, you'll find that it's all pretty much a wash.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- iagooar 7y agoI have to agree with this. One thing I miss the most after realizing I didn't believe in God and after I stopped going to church (= being part of the community) is that I had a lot harder time to find a group that I truly belonged to. It's not as much that you have to like each and every person in the group, is more about knowing that you're there for each other and share a bigger, common understanding of life. I guess that volunteering kind of has the same advantages, since people volunteering have a bigger goal (= serving others) and accept that they need to be together in this with other volunteers.
- LurkerAtTheGate 7y agoFor years, I attended church with a girlfriend, despite not believing as they do. Many were very accepting, particularly the church officiate - gf + I went out to lunch with him weekly for debates. 4 years and no one convinced the other of anything but it definitely refined my own arguments. No church member ever complained of an extra atheist's hand when volunteering.
- Spectral 7y agoI'm in the same situation as you were, except just starting out and going for some nice discussions/debates. What's your situation now (assuming you don't attend anymore) and any important learned experiences & lessons you care to pass on?
- true_tuna 7y agoPerhaps you could explore some humanist groups in your area. There’s nothing special about the religious ideology that means it’s the only one that can create community. Keep in mind that when you leave your religious ideology behind you don’t have no ideology, you have a new ideology. There are surely people out there who have adopted a similar ideology.
- hangonhn 7y agoSome churches and most volunteer organizations have one thing in common: altruistic people . That's not to say there aren't annoying people involved but I've made some excellent friends via volunteering because those organizations don't have much of an appeal to jerks. Also a shared purpose can help bridge some gaps and initiate contact between people. The number of organizations that can use people skilled in STEM is quite high. It doesn't even have to be directly related to our profession. Even understanding algebra is good enough for many mentoring/tutoring organizations. One organization I was involved with for years told me that just showing up on time every week was pretty damn good for the students I mentored because they so rarely get a stable adult relationship in their lives. All that to say that if you're on HN, you have a lot to offer and maybe get some great friendships in return.
- User23 7y agoBoth churches and non-profits are actually jerk magnets. Why? Because jerks know they can buffalo the altruistic majority to gain power in and eventually control over the organization.
- tdb7893 7y agoI would agree with the caveat it really depends on the church and organization. From growing up I'm definitely familiar with people in churches acting very petty and I assume non profits are the same.
- c0nsumer 7y agoI would posit that it's almost best if your volunteering is not really related to your profession at all. This keeps it fresh and interesting. I started riding bikes about 11 years ago and volunteering about 10. I've met a LOT of people, made some good friends, and after accomplishing some goals felt a nice sense of achievement that work stuff just doesn't quite get me. Pretty sure I'm a better person than I was 10 years ago, and the social and community aspects of volunteering stuff are almost guaranteed to be a big part of that. (Note: Long-time lead-type IT person here who volunteers as a board member, trail builder, and map maker for a local mountain biking group. What I do at work is helpful for the volunteer stuff, but as it's not related it's something neat that I look forward to; not just more work.)
- mymythisisthis 7y agoNo, don't do it. The people that attend churches are the most egotistical, delusional, and vapid people you'll meet. Think of an elderly, out of touch grandmother, getting to tell people how they should lead their lives. Go and volunteer at cool organization. I don't know where you live but most cities have a couple of organizations that are with it. Start with hacker spaces.
- toasterlovin 7y agoHave you actually participated in a church community? If so, have you participated in more than one? What you're describing does not match my experience at any of the churches I've belonged to. At all.
- bluedino 7y agoCertain churches are definitely filled with very judgemental people and full of cliques.
- bobblywobbles 7y agoYes, but that happens everywhere. It's very easy for us to point fingers at a group labeled as "good" and point out their flaws, when in fact these flaws exist everywhere. Much easier to call out a group that is "good" that they are "bad", when in fact the "bad-ness" gets spread equally around people whether or not they are in this "good" community.
- bluedino 7y agoConversely, high school was a great time for some people as they had friends and support, while it was the worst time of other peoples lives. There are many people who were forced out of churches or treated poorly and will never go back.
- ionised 7y agoThe 'badness' in people is supposed to be tempered or mitigated by these 'good communities' though. That's their whole point. If they can't even manage to better people as part of their church than the average person is then what good is it other than creating cliques and an 'us versus them' mentality?
- kurthr 7y agoAnd in the UK, the local pub. Community is a good thing.
- WalterSear 7y agoExactly. Church.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y agoTotally agree with this. As an American, I really came to envy "pub culture" of the UK and how much of an integral part of socialization that it is.
- loblollyboy 7y agoExcept when there's 10+ hours of footy on Sat and Sunday, then meeting up with all your rowdy mates for some Monday Night Football, taking it back to the continent Tuesday-Thursday before ringing in the long week with [Corporate Sponsor] Cup Final on Friday.
- seppin 7y agoThere is a lack of a third place in American society. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_place
- raverbashing 7y agoBut I have the impression this does not work so well with younger people They're usually in their own groups also they try different pubs every time so not really regulars (except for bigger club type places) Local pub seems to be more the older people
- wesammikhail 7y agoI have, for as long as I can remember, held the Sam Harris / Dawkins view that religion is nothing but an archaic and evil form of cattle management system. But the older I get and the more I contend with what religion actually is rather than what it is understood to be by the anti-theists, the more I approximate your understanding of the matter. The social fabric is being torn apart and there are virtually no institutions left to hold it together. This will most likely not end up in a very promising future for my generation and the ones to come after it.
- FabHK 7y agoYes, but one reason they are torn apart is that people see the (terrible) flaws in these old systems of holding society together and abandon them, while new and better systems are slow to gain a foothold. Some places manage to have community without religion, and that, I think, is what one ought to aspire to. (Edit -> Some places)
- leereeves 7y agoPeople see the terrible flaws and little else because the media distorts the truth. The Westboro Baptist Church gets more media attention than a thousand inclusive churches.
- FabHK 7y agoWell, I think reading "holy" books is quite enough to see those flaws, and the media in many places are far too reverent to the regionally prevailing religion; but maybe that's a discussion for a different venue. My point pertinent to this discussion was that community is important, and thus it's a problem if community is based on wrong or unethical ideas. It puts you in a terrible quandary (consider also Nazi Germany, the Sowjet Union under Stalin, etc.).
- leereeves 7y agoYou can't fairly judge modern churches by the text of ancient books. Most churches have abandoned a literal interpretation of ancient holy books in favor of some variation of the idea that God's true message was distorted, embellished, or censored by the flawed humans who recorded it.
- maxxxxx 7y agoThat’s something I sometimes envy in religious people. Wherever they go they have a ready network in place. That’s pretty nice. I think one of the advantages of the US is that for me as a foreigner the patriotism here also feels like a religion which gives the country cohesion.
- trevyn 7y agoYou might want to check out the Unitarian Universalists, they provide many of the social benefits of organized religion without a specific belief system attached.
- revx 7y agoAs I mentioned on another comment: I am a Unitarian Universalist and an athiest, married to a seminarian in the religion. Happy to answer questions about UU and what it's like. It has definitely made me far less lonely to belong to the UU community, and I don't feel pressured to "believe" anything I don't want to.
- bscphil 7y agoOkay, I have a question. You guys have weekly services, right? What do you do? I assume there are no songs to sing, and so someone has to do the speaking. What do they talk about? Since there's no formal religious principles to promote, my naive picture of it is being the sort of stuff you'd see in self-help books. Which seems, I don't know, boring? (Personally I don't think there's much of value in self-help books.)
- revx 7y agoHey! So services vary widely from place to place (since congregations run democratically). The form is based on a traditional protestant service, but with modern adaptations. We sing a lot of songs - I've heard everything from christian hymns to buddhist chants to the Beatles and Peter Meyer (probably not during the same service). We have three hymnals, including one in Spanish. UUs have seven principles (https://www.uua.org/beliefs/what-we-believe/principles https://www.uua.org/beliefs/what-we-believe/principles) but none of them require any sort of supernatural belief. Coming from an anti-theist background they were all already things I agreed with. Some people say that you can believe in anything and be a UU, which isn't quite true - any belief system that sees others as "less than", for example, would be incompatible. As for who does the talking, most congregations have a trained minister (like my partner) who leads most services. They talk on a variety of topics, but mostly about community, justice, activism, and lessons from other religions. Hope this helps!
- cjmcqueen 7y agoAmen.
- jchw 7y agoThis is something I didn’t understand as a child questioning God. As an adult, I view church in a much more positive light. I do wish I had social circles outside of work and old highschool friends. I think for some folks church does that, and that’s great. It’s certainly not for me, though.
- Swizec 7y agoI have found being a regular at a gym has worked wonders for a sense of community. Even if we don’t chat all that much it’s still 4x a week that I see all the same familiar faces that I’ve been seeing for years. It’s great. Sometimes you chat more sometimes less and you don’t know too much about their life outside the gym, but they’re your peeps.
- sametmax 7y agoAny communty really. Sport, book or chess clubs too. Theater lessons, shared houses, gay bars, anything where you can recreate a sense of being part of a group and not just being among people. The quality of the community matters though, some are human, some are mechanical. Leaders matter of lot for creating the right mix. And work is less and less a good place for that, because of policies, specialisation, compartimenting, but also because of lack of meaning . Meaning is a very important component for a group, and religions sell plenty of it, which make them strong people binders. A lot of other factors like common values, language, symbolism and stories reinforce this effect, but you can find that elsewhere, although it is very natural for spiritual groups to include all of it.
- hirundo 7y ago> Any communty really. There are plenty of toxic communities. Belonging to them may salve loneliness without being healthy. If for example the community is built around resentment, revenge, purity, a charismatic leader, etc., fellowship may still provide a strong attraction ... that is best fulfilled elsewhere. If nothing else, better to get a dog than a cult.
- sametmax 7y agoYes including toxic churches, soccer teams and anime forums. Humans being humans and all that. Plenty of people prefer to be victims in group than alone though. We are weird creatures.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chii 7y agoWhat exactly is a toxic community? How does one identify that they are in one?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- brookside 7y agoI don’t think many would deny churches provide their members community. Reinforcement of social ties with weekly meetings is strong. This isn’t a good reason to permit superstition to remain at the center of community life. We can find something better.
- TallGuyShort 7y agoI actually recently had a discussion on here about how, as a religious person, I'm baffled at how arbitrary some religious people are in their religion (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19915081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19915081). Yet at the same time, I'm equally disturbed by the way we seem to have a problem "permitting" a belief in something? edit: And I realize your point, which is one I do agree with, is that the benefits of community are not a reason to be religious and is distinct from that. But your choice of words is indeed reminiscent of many things I've heard from people in somewhat mainstream political discussions about how freedom of religion essentially needs to just go away. And as someone who has campaigned and voted for the very things many people are against on religious grounds precisely because I think anything that doesn't hurt somebody should be legal, I can't stand to see it backfiring equally on my self as it does upon religious bigots.
- Apocryphon 7y agoBy discounting religion, there’s also a tendency to minimize the human need to embrace the transcendental, while maximizing one’s own secular beliefs as well-founded and not superstitious. How many non-theists will just as readily believe in irrational things that they take as dogma?
- veddox 7y agoI suspect you won't find it quite as easy as that to divvy apart a church community from its creed. Most of the New Testament writings are devoted to teachings about how the church and its community ought to function, and it's all very firmly grounded in the "supernatural" aspects of Christianity (especially the resurrection of Christ). Take away the latter, and I think you're likely to lose much of the former.
- RandallBrown 7y agoI've wondered what a religionless church would be like. Would it be different from something like a rotary club or an elks lodge? I have a group of friends that get together every week for what we call "Mountainbeering" where we drink beer and go over planned hiking/climbing objectives. There's been talk of doing some trail work and other volunteering. It feels a little "churchy" except instead of a church it's at a brewery or someone's house.
- cheald 7y agoThe Unitarian Universalists, are, as I understand it, pretty close to a "religionless church". There's a general sense of "search for the truth", but there's no specific confessed creed.
- RandallBrown 7y agoVery interesting. I'm somewhat tempted to go to a service just to see what it would be like.
- ducktypegoose 7y agoUnitarian services are interesting. I have only gone a couple times with the atheist lesbian neighbors who invited us, and the sermons focused on some utilitarian concepts, power in community, and the goodness in helping others. I did not feel pandered to or prostylytized. Pretty sure if you're looking for a church that is accomodating to atheists, focused on community and good-will over dogma, then you'll find Unitarian services amenable.
- Balgair 7y agohttps://www.uua.org/find https://www.uua.org/find
- revx 7y agoI am a Unitarian Universalist and an athiest, married to a seminarian in the religion. Happy to answer questions about UU and what it's like. It has definitely made me far less lonely to belong to the UU community, and I don't feel pressured to "believe" anything I don't want to.
- agumonkey 7y agoI used to criticize church until I realized that people spent hours every day watching extreme dumb shows alone on their couch. Religious rituals give a pace to social and mental life that, even though archaic and even absurd in a way, seems a ton better than the modern life we were fed :)
- lotsofpulp 7y agoProblem is when church starts asserting their infallibleness and rejecting science.
- tarruda 7y agoDo you have an example of the Church rejecting science in the last 100 years?
- nanny 7y agoWhat? They're all over the place, especially in the US. edit: I go to one, despite it.
- ArnoVW 7y agoQuestion of semantics is mixing up your conversation here I think. Is "the church" the religious authority (i.e. the Vatican), or just simply anyone religious? Because the Vatican has not persecuted people for their scientific views for a long time, but I agree with you that it's not that complicated to find examples of religious people being anti-scientific. The question is : how many are there, and how representative are they.
- smileysteve 7y agoIn the U.S. it's strict creationism that's the biggest anti-science aspect of many of the protestant religions. Snopes monkey trial was so divisive that very few people I have met in Georgia are aware that intelligent design is a thing. Each of these people more or less accepts that their church doesn't believe in Dinosaurs.
- albertshin 7y agoGive Putnam's Bowling Alone a read if you haven't already
- smacktoward 7y agoIt's worth noting that Bowling Alone was published in 2000, and grew out of a magazine article Putnam wrote in 1995. So this is a problem that's been slowly growing for a long time now.
- sien 7y agoIt would be interesting to see the impact of the internet on these kinds of things. With Meetup and Eventbrite and Facebook organisation of a lot of social things has become easier. Hopefully some researchers are looking at this.
- Eleopteryx 7y agoAfter having read the article your comment comes off as a non sequitur. The article doesn't even mention churches or relate volunteering to churches or churchgoers... You didn't even make an effort to correlate churchgoing with the topic of volunteering or the topic of loneliness. Even from a tangential perspective I have no idea where you're coming from. The article mentions widows alleviating loneliness through volunteering for two hours a week. "Church plays a larger role in maintaining a healthy society" without really qualifying how, why, or in what way it pertains to the article, seems like a massive logical leap. What about for the widow? What about the man waiting for a chess opponent? Are you saying that "church" is a function solution to their loneliness? Could you maybe elaborate on that? You stated something impertinent, explained nothing, and somehow got a slew of upvotes. I don't even know where I am right now.
- gpm 7y agoChurch was a weekly social activity shared by practically the entire community... Not to mention larger events organized by church's, and charity performed in the local community by many churches. It's unfortunate IMO that there is no non religious equivalent.
- lostphilosopher 7y agoChurches also do this in an intergenerational fashion. My office does volunteer work, but my kids and my parents don't take part. That's a hard bit to replicate in other groups even if those groups are actively engaged in charity.
- lostphilosopher 7y ago> "Research using the UCLA Loneliness Scale and Meaning in Life Questionnaire has shown that more loneliness is associated with less meaning. This makes sense, given our deeply rooted need for belonging. By volunteering for social causes that are important to us, we can gain a sense of purpose, which in turn may shield us from negative health outcomes. For example, purpose in life has been linked to a reduced likelihood of stroke and greater psychological well-being." You didn't see a connection between people suffering from a lack of meaning and purpose and the decline of an institution that basically specializes in that? Note that no one (here) is saying "church provides the correct meaning/purpose" or even "church provides a good meaning or purpose." Just that churches are out there specifically and directly trying to provide meaning and purpose. Another angle is that churches often engage in volunteer work. Much more so than your average softball team or book club. If the secret sauce of preventing loneliness is the purpose/meaning/"je n'ais se quoi" of volunteering specifically - churches are/were major players in that space. Even if that connection was coincidental there's a possible link between the decline of church engagement and the rise of loneliness. Anyway, I'm not the OP. Maybe they thought they were typing in another window and it ended up here, but these are some the connections I was thinking about / reasons I upvoted.
- kemiller2002 7y agoWhen I was in college, I listened to a speaker talking about the history of blues in the United States and as an aside gospel music, etc. One thing he talked about I thought was interesting was the history or purpose of religion in African American culture. He said, at least historically, church wasn't just about worship. It was like an all day event. People would go to church and then afterwards, there would be a picnic or gathering of the church goers. It was a community event. As neither an African American, nor someone who's family was particularly social at church, I never experienced that and was caught completely by surprise in the fact that much more revolved around church than going for an hour and being bored.
- Sundog 7y agoThis is true of Korean American churches as well, with lunch, weddings, etc. It's an all-day affair and the center of the community where people meet, do business, etc. The younger generation is trickling away but it was a bedrock for the immigrant community.
- rchaud 7y agoIt makes sense. The ancestors of African-Americans were in many cases forced to convert to Christianity after being transported to America. In those circumstances, you need to add a lot more to the experience than just scripture if you want to maintain your flock.
- jtr1 7y agoI grew up very conservative and very evangelical and left as an adult because I couldn't honestly hold the basic beliefs in an honest way. I was also really angry about a bunch of things: the prevalence of narcissism among preachers, authoritarian organizational structures, treatment of women, etc etc - I could give you a whole litany. If you pay any attention to religion in the US, you could probably anticipate much of it. Years later, not much has changed. The anger has faded, particularly as I watch some of those old churches dying (although not without some degree of satisfaction, I'll admit). BUT, I do agree that it's widely under-appreciated just how sophisticated a social technology the congregation is. And there's not, as far as I've found, a viable secular alternative. Take away shared conviction about the transcendent and you seem to lose some kind of binding agent, like baking without gluten.
- bigred100 7y agoPretty wacky when many American Christians I meet seem to be more prideful and puffed up than even the atheists, who are often caricatured as very impressed with their own intelligence. So much for “Learn from me, for I am meek and humble of heart”
- Apocryphon 7y agoNational chauvinism could be a factor.
- marnett 7y agodo not forget the social cohesive elements like worship. i have strongly believed the church's biggest advantage as a social institution is due to collectively performing some unifying ritual. i think these rituals are instrumental to the social cohesion that is the congregation.
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoBut there isn't social cohesion for folks like me. I'm female. I do not believe in god. I'm bisexual. I am exactly the sort of person left out of worship unless I pretend I'm someone I am not and don't reveal my true self. I'm a fraud if I want to fit in - these groups rarely simply accept me going there for the social aspect.
- izzydata 7y agoThe harm far outweighs the good in my opinion. There is no reason such communities can't exist without pushing their agenda on young minds.
- war1025 7y agoAll communities push agendas. It just doesn't feel like agenda-pushing when it's something you agree with.
- izzydata 7y agoChildren don't know what they agree with. It's unfair to them to be forced into a particular beliefs due to fear of repercussions in an "after-life".
- veddox 7y agoIs it unfair for parents to pass on to their kids what they themselves are firmly convinced of? Isn't that what all parents (are supposed to) do?
- izzydata 7y agoThe method of passing on knowledge is extremely relevant.
- tathougies 7y agoOh really? What way of passing on knowledge do you have that is free of all bias?
- izzydata 7y agoWhy do you believe this is a matter of bias? I'm talking about the difference between handing your child a book and whipping them into submission. Clearly one of those methods is terrible. I'd consider instilling fear of damnation on your children much closer to the latter. One of those things promotes critical thinking and the other locks them into a singular set of beliefs. I can't think of anything worse for society.
- scrape_it 7y agobut how does that explain the sharp rise in suicide rates amongst WASP males approaching middle age?
- icxa 7y agoQuoting a tweet from my feed: "Married people are happier than single people. Frequent church attenders are happier than people who rarely (or never) attend. "Liberation" from religion and marriage has made millions miserable. Sexual revolutionaries have some explaining to do." And the quoted article which it is in reference to: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/04/happiness-recession-causing-sex-depression/586405/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/04/happiness-... There was also research done to try and show that the “gender pay gap” will continue to rise due to an increase proportion of single/unwed mothers. Turns out when you have a support system consisting of a spouse and their families, you are able to also have more economic mobility as well. I couldn’t imagine my wife climbing the ladder at her Finance job without me to help take half the parental responsibilities, and a very supportive grandma and grandpa. Turns out maybe marriage wasn’t a tool of the patriarchy after all.
- TylerE 7y agoIgnorance is bliss, personified. I'm sure it IS much more pleasant to imagine the magic sky fairy will take care of all the world's problems.
- tathougies 7y ago> I'm sure it IS much more pleasant to imagine the magic sky fairy will take care of all the world's problems. The alternative of course is nihilism in the face of the inevitable heat death of the universe. My magical sky fairy seems pretty good right now.`
- Apocryphon 7y agoIt’s also somewhat telling that transhumanism and Singularitarianism, some of the more prominent post-religion religions, are about building magical sky fairies. In the face of the second law of thermodynamics, even purveyors of secular scientism seek to escape oblivion by inventing Asimov’s AC.
- 7y ago
- shanxS 7y agoI am agnostic to religion. But I cannot agree more that region (all of them) play a key role in maintaining fabric of society. I don't know how true the scriptures are, given that most of them contradict each other but regardless, more or less they all tend to drive society towards stability and tolerance.
- Retra 7y agoI don't see any evidence that society tends to be driven toward stability or tolerance, and even if it did, why you would attribute that to religion.
- FabHK 7y agoI'd argue that over time society has in fact become more stable and more tolerant (read Steve Pinker's latest tome about the enlightenment), but that it was possible because of the simultaneous decline of religion.
- Retra 7y agoWhat society has done or is doing is a rather different matter than what it tends to do.
- sharadov 7y agoIt does, unfortunately, with a lot of folks turning away from religion, there is no support system left anymore.
- jacquesm 7y agoChurches are - pun intended - a mixed blessing. Religion gives comfort when people are in pain and can help impose some sense where there is none so on the short timescales it looks positive. But on the longer timescales it is just another powerstructure that aims to keep people in check and productive towards the aim of maintaining the structure itself and at tremendous cost to society as a whole and in many cases at tremendous cost to the lives of the individuals that are a part of it. Personally I prefer to live without such influences in my life in so far as that is possible but I fully respect others' rights to do as they please. But a healthy society can be had outside of religion.
- ip26 7y agoHave there ever been democratic or republic churches?
- Apocryphon 7y agoMost Protestant churches are run democratically with voting on elders and so forth
- jacquesm 7y agoThat's a good point. When it comes to 'how to run a church' it is a pretty good basis, unfortunately protestantism is very fragmented, but then again, if it wasn't then it would be more like the structure it broke away from so maybe that is actually a good thing.
- lukev 7y agoIt isn't clear that this leads to "better" outcomes, though. The larger denominations are pretty standardized, the smaller churches with more independence are where you find more sectarianism, extremism, and even cult-like behavior.
- QuercusMax 7y agoThe Society of Friends (AKA Quakers) doesn't have professional clergy, and decisions are made democratically. They don't even have pastors; my parents were married in a Quaker meeting house, and their marriage license was signed by the secretary of the congregation. Here's an article about their decision-making process: http://quaker.org/legacy/tqe/2005/TQE118-EN-Democracy.html http://quaker.org/legacy/tqe/2005/TQE118-EN-Democracy.html
- scarejunba 7y agoI actually think it's oversold. I used to feel a bit lonely but found a bunch of friends through work and just said yes to everything. Now I always have someone to hang out with because they introduced me to their friends and so on.
- sudosteph 7y agoI have to agree. I've noticed that churches remain really essential to some places, especially smaller isolated communities. From my experience, I think the appeal comes from: 1.) Gives people an excuse to dress nicely in public (good for self-esteem if you're into that sort of thing) 2.) Free meals (often delicious and home-cooked), potentially before and after 3.) Singing music together is fun and it doesn't matter if you're bad at it 4.) The preacher will tell the congregation if someone is sick or had a bad thing happen, and then some of the other people will typically express their care to the person and maybe visit them and bring them food. 5.) The preacher typically will tell at least one corny joke or do some weird dramatic thing to get your attention and make a point. It's like weird theater at some places. And of course, organizing volunteer things is pretty solid too. On the less positive side, some people like to use church to show-off and find things to gossip about. So while that behavior may make some feel less lonely, probably causes others to be repulsed away.
- rjegundo 7y agoIf church was not solving a real problem it would not longer exist at scale. Is just not the problem most people thin
- rchaud 7y agoIt also makes money, tax-free. And by quoting scripture, it helps politicians and grifters appear to be above board to some people, without requiring them to make the sacrifices faith asks for. Get rid of those aspects, and religion really will disappear.
- zebraflask 7y agoI would think given the very diverse audience enjoyed by HN, this kind of statement would not be posted. I don't think the poster is trying to behave in a bigoted way, but that could be a very reasonable interpretation.
- DavideNL 7y ago> Folks can say what they want about religion ...and for those who are no believers, perhaps becoming a Pastafarian is a good alternative option : https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Pastafarians https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Pastafarians
- mcrad 7y agoSo True. Unfortunately the media has convinced the masses to adopt political parties as their modern version of religion. Any atheist with half a brain can see how dangerous it is to put all faith and trust in the political class.
- desireco42 7y agohttps://www.amazon.com/Religion-Atheists-Non-believers-Guide-Uses/dp/0307476820/ https://www.amazon.com/Religion-Atheists-Non-believers-Guide... Religion for Atheists: A Non-believer's Guide to the Uses of Religion (my favorite philosopher)
- Balgair 7y agoFor those looking for community without religion, try Unitarian Unversalism. I've personally had a very good experience with it: https://www.uua.org/find https://www.uua.org/find
- jsnk 7y agoI wish cultural Christianity was a thing. I am an atheist who believes that Christianity is an important tradition to keep. Just like Judaism, I wish there was reformed Christianity that allows atheists to participate in their religion without belief in God.
- mattigames 7y agoLets see what data says; top 10 less religious countries are[0]: China, Japan, Estonia, Sweden, Norway, Czech Republic, Hong Kong, Netherlands, Israel, United Kingdom Top 10 most religious countries are[0]: Ethiopia, Malawi, Niger, Sri Lanka, Yemen, Burundi, Djibouti, Mauritania, Somalia, Afghanistan So looking at this -at least by itself- is far from certain that religion plays a large role in maintaining a healthy society; you may be thinking of a specific subset of religions/denominations or perhaps using a different 'measure' for the impact of religion. [0]https://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/maps-and-graphics/most-religious-countries-in-the-world/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/maps-and-graphics/most-re...
- humanrebar 7y agoThere could be a more indirect effect of religious belief on healthy society. Hypothetically social capital could build up over the years and deeply affect hard-to-measure things like trust and fair governance. If that's the case, it could take more than a couple decades for drastic change in beliefs to transform a country.
- xkcd-sucks 7y agoBy any objective population statistic, being a member of the LDS (Mormon) Church is beneficial. People who are gay / enjoy coffee might disagree, but this is merely anecdotal evidence to the contrary.
- mikorym 7y agoIn South Africa there are many beautiful churches from a bygone era. One of the most well known is in Graaff-Reinet. [1] Church played a very dominant role in Protestant communities, together with the other pillars of the family and the school. I think that the cross-over period to more secular belief systems indeed does lose a lot of the community aspect of the church. It is also not clear at all how to fill the void... Sports? Hobbies? Nature? Guns n' Roses concerts? [1] https://www.graaffreinet.co.za/listing/dutch_reformed_church_groot_kerk https://www.graaffreinet.co.za/listing/dutch_reformed_church...