9 ms·
Apple tried to buy Tesla for more than it’s currently worth in 2013, report says
- Analemma_ 8y agoUntil someone from Apple or Tesla confirms this, it should be treated as a rumor and not taken at all seriously. Investment bank analysts are full of shit, and the ones covering Apple doubly so. Remember Gene Munster and the Apple TV set he said was totally, definitely coming any day now... for a decade?
- juskrey 8y ago* until someone from Apple or Tesla denies this
- mikekij 8y agoAs a Tesla optimist, it seems like their biggest constraints are cash and the distraction of quarterly earnings calls with analysts. Apple could use that huge stockpile of cash to allow Tesla to continue playing the long game, without having to worry about their stock price fluctuating every day.
- Shivetya 8y agoWell I would expect Apple's biggest contribution would be better supply chain management, product focus, and UI improvements. Tesla suffers from Musk's lack of focus. There are well past the time someone who is not a product person provide some structure to operate within.
- mft_ 8y agoFrom what I've read, totally agree: they need a strong COO to focus on delivery. A Gwynne Shotwell or --funnily enough-- a Tim Cook of old. (It's odd that Elon presumably sees the benefit of Gwynne at SpaceX yet doesn't replicate the formula at Tesla.)
- tyre 8y agoAnd you would think Elon could still be given free reign, but I suspect he would reject this out of hand because he wants to stay in absolute control. We obviously don’t know everything behind this, but Tesla’s in perpetual turmoil internally and externally. They’ve done incredible things and at the same time put that in jeopardy. Elon has huge upside but can be his own worst enemy at times (get the fuck off of twitter)
- dangero 8y agoApple can't buy Tesla and let Musk have free reign because it will expose them to potential liabilities much larger than their investment in Tesla. Example: -Stock manipulation would now be manipulation of Apple stock. -Autopilot related deaths and quality issues now create lawsuits against Apple's bank account and reputation.
- xkjkls 8y agoTheoretically that depends on the deal. There are ways to have financial ownership without assuming all the liabilities
- dwighttk 8y agoThat's assuming Tesla has something Apple can't get elsewhere with the cash.
- kovek 8y agoWhy would Elon Musk worry about the stock price fluctuating? How is the company affected by the stock price? The only thing I can think of is as follows: When the company needs liquid capital, they sell shares that they already own, and in that case a higher stock price is more beneficial.
- xkjkls 8y agoThey also pay their employees using a large amount of stock. A poorly performing stock means poor morale and more difficulty recruiting.
- xkjkls 8y agoWell, cash and a distraction of earnings calls is a symptom of the real problem, weak demand. The 3 has been cannabalizing the S and X, which before were the major high margin products that sustained the company. If they have to keep raising cash just to keep themselves afloat, there’s never going to be any return for shareholders. It will all get eaten by debt and dilution.
- rockinghigh 8y agoThe comparison is misleading because Tesla had 120M shares outstanding in 2013 versus 170M shares today. $240 per share at the time is equivalent to $169 per share today or $28B in market capitalization. It’s still 15% cheaper than today’s share price.
- earthshot 8y agoYou need to adjust for cash and debt to get the enterprise value. If you do so, you’ll find that Tesla is worth about 50% less than it was.
- gpm 8y agoDo you mean more? Because according to the comment above debt is 11B, and I happen to know that they have ~2B cash on hand, so roughly speaking enterprise value should be 9B larger than market cap right now, and it should have been less than 600M above market cap back then (their old debt value also listed in a comment above).
- atdrummond 8y agoMisread, please ignore.
- TorKlingberg 8y agoThat depends on what you are trying to calculate. If you want the market value of a company it's the market cap, # of shares * share price. If you want the value of the company as a going concern it's market cap + debt - cash.
- Reason077 8y agoEnterprise value is not derived from market cap. Rather, market capitalisation reflects investor’s assessment of the enterprise value. Whether rational or not, this already takes cash and debt positions into account.
- InTheArena 8y agoThis has been openly talked about for a while. It makes all the sense in the world - Apple wants to get into this space, and has the pieces that Tesla is missing - supply chain optimization, good capitalization and strong marketing. Tesla has what Apple is missing - vision, electronics, deep learning experience. I'm still amazed that this hasn't happened yet.
- blantonl 8y agoThat, and Netflix. Apple truly would expand their footprint into the daily life of hundreds of millions of people.
- rb808 8y agoThis makes no sense. Apple makes computers. A car company is completely different, even it if Tesla's have bigger screens than other cars. There is no money in making cars, Apple is worth more than all the other car companies put together.
- frenchie4111 8y agoOr, that's why it makes sense. Apple wanted to move into the car market, and this would be a way to bootstrap that movement.
- josefresco 8y agoIf there is "no money" in making cars, what is the growth path for Apple? Who or what should they acquire?
- sc90 8y agoTransportation?
- ggg2 8y agoit's telling that the transportation market is late for disruption when you have to remind americans (or non-americans that live in the silicon valley culture, as most everyone here) that it is not just about cars...
- Someone 8y agoThere likely is lots of money in health. Almost everybody claims it’s the most important thing to them, the aging population gets more health problems and many of them also get more disposable income (kids left the house, fewer holiday trips due to declining health) That’s probably a big reason for the existence of the Apple Watch and HealthKit.
- gradys 8y agoApply s/car/phone and it was all true in the mid-2000s as well. Maybe they saw an angle you're not.
- S_A_P 8y agoI think that the fact that either Alphabet or Apple could easily buy Tesla in cash is a great reason not to short the stock.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoI encourage short sellers to make the attempt still. It makes things interesting.
- _jal 8y agoI think the fact that it comes with a mercurial CEO with discipline issues subtracts quite a bit from a potential acquirer's price. Think about it - if you were considering buying the firm, what odds would you put on your first board meeting after being all about whatever the hell Musk got up to last week?
- athenot 8y agoIn the case of Apple, Tim Cook has spent quite a while working with Steve Jobs so he's no stranger to collaborating with a loose canon and could probably handle Musk pretty well. Just speculating, of course.
- rchaud 8y agoThe difference is Jobs' obsession was limited to consumer electronics, more or less, and he pushed the company to focus heavily on a very limited range of products. Musk on the other hand will talk about cars one day, then solar energy the next, then the Hyerloop, then landing on Mars and making toy flamethrowers. The fit could not be more wrong. Apple's acquired properties are quietly extinguished and replaced with Apple branding. Musk wouldn't have the temperament to play second fiddle to anybody else.
- cgy1 8y ago>Apple's acquired properties are quietly extinguished and replaced with Apple branding. Musk wouldn't have the temperament to play second fiddle to anybody else. Beats as a brand is still around and producing new products.
- brmgb 8y agoOn the one hand, Apple has a lot of experience in domains where Tesla has been less than great (supply chain, manufacturing) and software is slowly becoming a key differentiator for the automobile industry so I can somewhat see where synergies might exist. On the other hand, automobile is quite far from Apple core business. I know that there is not much growth remaining in Apple key markets but still if I were a shareholder, I'm not sure I would be comfortable with Apple making such a move. I guess we are entering a new golden age for conglomerates.
- NicoJuicy 8y agoI'm not sure if supply chain optimalisation is the same as manufacturing robotics that Tesla needed though
- brmgb 8y agoI'm far from convinced Tesla actually needed so much robotics. Relying on robots so much might actually have been a strategic mistake due to their inexperience. It looks to me like this bet has still to pay off. Nevertheless, Apple knowledge goes a lot further than supply chain optimization. They are actually quite good at manufacturing (both manual assembly and robotics). They know how to design products optimized for large volume production. They know how to work effectively with third parties. They know how to do quality control which is extremely important for a system integrator. Apple is not a pure software company: they already have a manufacturing culture in place inside the company. What they don't have is domain specific knowledge so if they really wanted to enter the transport market, I guess buying Tesla could make sense.
- screye 8y agoAs we keep getting better at operating at scale, logistics will continue economically favoring conglomerates over smaller companies. Amazon is the best example of this, and I don't see why the likes of Apple won't follow suit. Apple seems to be aggressively hiring from top institutes for their self-driving team. So, they might just have decided to go about the whole thing by developing a 1st party product instead.
- 8y ago
- sc90 8y agoDo electric bicycles pose a threat to Tesla (car companies in general)?
- koverda 8y agoNot any more of a threat than regular bicycles pose to regular cars.
- jvagner 8y agoI wish cities would commit to bike-only streets. E-bikes are unbelievably fun ways to get around.
- morkfromork 8y agoPickup trucks are the top selling vehicles in the US. Hard to replace those with bicycles.
- sc90 8y agoNot really, a significant percentage of car trips involve a short distance.
- morkfromork 8y agoDepends on how you define short, how many trips you take per day, terrain, weather and physical ability of the person to actually ride a bike.
- ggg2 8y agowould be interesting to see how much of this is real need for a pickup. there's a marlon brandon(?) movie where he buys the biggest ram truck, just to drive up and down the street every day :) likewise, one could say that california has a need for SUVs, while everyone only drive them under 30mph in a perfectly paved roads under perfect dry weather, alone 90% of the time, and with a single kid the other 10. At this point I think the america Lives on pickup truck production is just a fashion indicator that some car manufacturers love to disseminate to help their stock over japanese makers who are not heavy on pickups.
- Phillipharryt 8y agoThis piece uses Ashlee Vance as a source. Having read and checked on facts in his books, his factchecking is sketchy at best. It's a somewhat believable rumour, but of course take it with a pinch of salt and consider that analysts like making big calls as well (usually backed by "anonymous sources").
- w8vY7ER 8y agoI have enjoyed his writing so far and haven't found reason to question his fact checking yet. Can you offer any example for someone curious about the sketchiness you mentioned?
- Phillipharryt 8y agoMusk himself claims it's rife with errors https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/895834554245709824?lang=en https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/895834554245709824?lang=... and I recall some of his figures about initial tesla production being outrageous. Like body gaps of 40mm being deemed the target. Figures like that made me wonder if anyone had proof-read it because a 4cm gap in a car is enough to fit your hand through
- w8vY7ER 8y agoThanks, this was news to me. Appreciate the insight e: in hindsight your comment about 40mm gaps, as an example, does some particularly crazy and I'm surprised it didn't stand out to me.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- fit2rule 8y agoThis explains all that "iCar" nonsense. I mean, even as a seasoned and dyed Apple fanboix, I can honestly tell you, I don't want Apple to make cars. I want them to make computers.
- ambicapter 8y agoAre you mad that they make phones?
- TomMarius 8y agoThey make pocket computers, actually
- yarrel 8y agoAnd ear computers. They can make computers on wheels as well.
- fit2rule 8y agoI still see Apple making very, very good computers - which integrate with cars (made by others) - a much better scenario than Apple "re-inventing personal transportation". It is an iron fist wrapped in a velvet glove. Never forget how much control is being lost by generations of people now, courtesy of the user-experience candy hit .. User owns their computer, and user owns their data: this is not so great, all things considered, if we look at Apple and their compatriots from an angle. There is still an effort to make open, honest computing platforms. At the moment, immense numbers of eyeballs are focused on their pocket-glass mirror. Honestly, there is something here which must be deconstructed, and it could happen with a new OS/platform ideology where Apple making cars would be an extremely poor future.
- rchiniquy 8y agoThe validity of the comparison aside, if Apple had bought Tesla in 2013, I feel pretty confident Tesla would be worth more now than it is.
- raverbashing 8y agoGiven the push Apple can do to things like battery factories, sensor manufacturers and other things it makes me wonder. This is one of the Apple "secret sauces". Want Gorilla Glass? You get me the latest gen exclusively and I help you build your factory.
- WalterSear 8y agoIt's had such a big effect, it's arguably the secret sauce.
- throwayEngineer 8y agoWhat would they synergize? Apple is known for marketing, which is already Elons speciality. Tesla cars are first revision technology, which means almost starting from scratch anyway. Two companies that live on reputation instead of quality would tarnish both.
- xkjkls 8y agoApple's limitless access to capital would be one. Tesla has really had dial down many of their ambitions because of how expensive it is for them to raise capital.
- Traster 8y agoApple is known for its operations. Tim Cooke was head of ops before he was CEO, imagine Tesla produced the same cars as today, but when it wanted to ship its inventory to Europe it didn't tank an entire quarter of sales because of fuck ups? Or imagine if Tesla had a competent scale-up of manufacturing their Model 3. Those are the things that Apple could help a lot with.
- jraines 8y ago
- magwa101 8y agoTesla is fucked, maybe Toyota buys them?
- bduerst 8y agoThey already turned down VW.
- williesleg 8y agoBut then we wouldn't have the model 3. And the S and X would have a notch.
- objektif 8y agoThis makes sense to me, think about all the car related electronic components Apple can sell once cars start driving themselves. There are lots of opportunities.
- shmerl 8y agoGood thing Apple didn't swallow it.
- buryat 8y agoSaudis tried to buy Tesla for $420 in 2018
- xkjkls 8y agoThere is no evidence that this was ever true.
- skinnymuch 8y agoAny proof? An unsubstantiated tweet doesn’t count.
- erpellan 8y agoThese days, I'd be suggesting Apple buy Jaguar. Both brands have a reputation for design and customer satisfaction, and customers with a certain insensitivity to price. Jaguar are reinventing themselves as a BEV company with the i-Pace. (Other car manufacturers like BMW and Audi are shoe-horning electric motors into their existing platforms, not redesigning from scratch).