9 ms·
What is a reliable way to make money from free articles (other than NY times - style limited articles)? As in, what ad networks can you set up that only use the
by judge2020 8y ago
What is a reliable way to make money from free articles (other than NY times - style limited articles)? As in, what ad networks can you set up that only use the content of the page to target ads? At this point, if you don't use Google Ads (adsense), your advertiser pool drops significantly and you'll likely be making less money overall.
- raverbashing 8y agoyes, but Adsense is a couple of cookies, no? These sites have hundreds and hundreds of cookies
- judge2020 8y agoIt's currently being looked into by the EU but it's very likely even Adsense is in violation of GDPR. Also, haven't looked at every company they list, but maybe they're covering their bases by listing every company part of adchoices? https://youradchoices.com/participating https://youradchoices.com/participating
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoMy understanding is it's common for sites to use a bunch of ad providers, because not all of them will offer up good paying ads on a given page. So you try for the most profitable ad provider, and then another ad provider, and then another one, and then maybe if none of them pan out, you show the Google Ad, which gives you something to fill your ad box. Source: I know a guy who runs a blog who wrote Google+ posts about doing it.
- raverbashing 8y agoI'm not saying Adsense wasn't in violation but I'm just saying that the other ad providers have a lot of cookies
- nothis 8y agoMaybe advertising isn't the future of the web? I know I'm talking hypotheticals, not anything that helps people make money of actual work done online, right now. But I'd be ready to pay for a fairly done flat rate service that gives me access to quality content on a variety of sites for a reasonable price a month. If you do that, companies would not have to track anything after confirming my login, it would no longer be the main revenue stream. Are there any good estimates how much money the internet makes from the ad data of an average person, per month? Like, spread among multiple websites? Is that too crazy an amount to ever expect people to pay?
- manigandham 8y agoThis has been tried countless times and there are dozens of options available. There's no scale to it.
- kortilla 8y agoThere wouldn’t be any scale to adtech either without massive adoption. If adtech collapses as a viable stream, something will quickly take its place.
- manigandham 8y agoIt's either direct or indirect payments. Direct payments haven't scaled so indirect (ads) will continue. This is a human behavior issue. You would need to change the behavior of billions of people before the ads model gets affected.
- alnorth 8y agoIt seems to be working fine for Spotify and Netflix. Is there something special about journalism that means it wouldn't work there?
- manigandham 8y agoIt's barely working for Spotify and Netflix is testing ads. Music and movies are highly repeatable and have production costs that users recognize and value. News and general content is not valued the same so nobody wants to pay for it. The severe dropoff in any paywalled site shows the effect of charging for news.
- ljm 8y agoI’d happily accept ads for things on the internet as long as they were relevant to the topic and non-intrusive. These sites do need to earn some money for the work they do and I can decide if that work is valuable or not by reading their articles or watching their videos. Just make the ad experience sensible instead of throwing shitty dark patterns and other things that interrupt the experience. Let me subscribe to a pure RSS feed or other lightweight experience I can pull into a reader. At least then I’m actually choosing to receive ads. In return it would be nice to have a say in the sheer amount of attention grabbing advertising we’re subjected to in the physical realm. There is no consent there, and this advertising only serves the purpose of businesses selling stuff. Why can’t I charge a cost per view for everything shoved in my face on the way to work, or at the cinema, or on the train, or in any other situation where I’ve already handed over cash? My attention is a scarce resource that holds a lot of value to my friends, family, colleagues, and any other human being in my life. I’d love to paywall access to that. In short though I believe there has to be a fundamental shift from the belief that ads, tracking, and shadow profiles are the path to profit in an increasingly connected world. Something about the relationship needs to change, maybe towards business-2-citizen instead of business-2-consumer.
- Mirioron 8y ago>Why can’t I charge a cost per view for everything shoved in my face on the way to work, or at the cinema, or on the train, or in any other situation where I’ve already handed over cash? Because you don't own whatever is being used to advertise. It's not your decision to make. They can charge you and then show you ads. >In short though I believe there has to be a fundamental shift from the belief that ads, tracking, and shadow profiles are the path to profit in an increasingly connected world. Belief doesn't mean anything. What matters is what pays the bills. If alternatives worked well, then I'm sure we'd have plenty of sites that would already be doing this. You could argue that crowdfunding is one such route, but I don't think that will ever work on a large scale. The amount of money required just isn't there. The reason ad-tech is so common is because people are unwilling to pay any amount of money.
- ericd 8y ago
- globuous 8y agoWhy not just show adds not targeted for a particular user, but rather for the audience targeted by the media outlet in the first place? If the NYT or whatever started advertising for its audience, I wouldn't have shoes ads all over the place as soon as I buy a pair of shoes on amazon. The big lie of adtech is that it can advertise better than conventional methods. Yet I've yet to see a relevant ad online - when I see them in paper magazines and metro stations that don't aggressively target me individually. I'm not against advertising online, I don't like ads because I think they're too good and leverage our vices too much, yet I understand their necessity in the "econo-societal" context we live in. Therefore I am for ads in the metro, TV, magazines, billboards and websites. But I sure as fuck am against individually targeted ads, because even if they worked better I think that'd be going too far, but mostly because they don't work whatsoesver? In my circle of friends I've never heard someone going "yo, I saw this sick ad for [whatever], I'm sold, I'm gonna order one of those". I have however heard some (and myself) say "I saw this concert ad in the metro on my way here, wanna go ?" (The malade imaginaire with Daniel Auteuil ad in the Parisian metro worked on me for instance.) I could go on and on about this, but I've recently switched to dvorak and I'm pretty slow at typing. My thesis is as follows though: use ads on me, but don't follow me everywhere and try to find out what I might buy again. Use conventional pre ad tech means, they work better anyway. P.S. google sponsored links are such a dark pattern. I didn't realize it until I saw a very good friend of mine use google (peer googling if you will). He'd wouldn't even notice the sponsored links and click on them as if they were the first non-paid google link - only to click the back button and the second sponsored link again and again, until finally hitting the first non-paid link and being satisfied with its content. He's an architect and therefore very attentive to details and yet, he'd automatically click on them as we were googling after I repeatably explained him what was going on. I bet you most non techies are this way. P.S.S I haven't even had the time to discuss about the gdpr popups that show iphone style toggles but that are so evily designed that you cannot tell if they are "on" or "off". Or all the sites that check them all by default when they should be off. And all those sites that you just cannot even find where the hell to set these things even after navigating on all the nested links in the popup.
- Mirioron 8y ago>The big lie of adtech is that it can advertise better than conventional methods. Yet I've yet to see a relevant ad online - when I see them in paper magazines and metro stations that don't aggressively target me individually. How often do you see ads online that are in one of the hundreds of languages that you don't speak? How often are these ads for a particular business in a location that's in another country? Without some targeting, many of the ads I get are in languages I do not understand. Sometimes they advertise services that are in another country entirely.
- Veen 8y agoThe same way publications made money for two centuries without tracking and “personalization”, by displaying advertising relevant to the content and the publication’s target audience.
- mochomocha 8y agoThis does not work as well. If you take any machine learning model for ads, "content" related features are way less predictive than "user" related features. ie who you are matters more than what you're currently reading. [Disclosure: I've built a lot of these models in the past]
- Jach 8y agoIt seems to have worked better than well for New York Times: https://digiday.com/media/gumgumtest-new-york-times-gdpr-cut-off-ad-exchanges-europe-ad-revenue/ https://digiday.com/media/gumgumtest-new-york-times-gdpr-cut... Do you think it's not repeatable?
- mochomocha 8y agoIt might be good for supply (publishers) short term, but it's worse for demand (advertisers) and for ads quality since it removes personalization opportunities. An open-market like RTB where offer meets demand is more efficient (except for privacy-minded users which aren't even part of the transaction). It's also worse for supply long-term as it ties them more to Google and FB, or to a non-scalable contract negotiation process mad-men style with a handful of advertisers.
- LaGrange 8y ago> except for privacy-minded users ...that's like saying "high standards of medicine are bad except for hygiene-minded users." The fact that the user has other concerns in their life doesn't change the fact that it's still bad for them.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoDo you mean that advertising won't generate the maximum amount of revenue possible unless it violates users' privacy?
- kasey_junk 8y agoNote that the first RTB complaints were actually about the contextual parts of the specification. They specifically went after the parts that only use website subject data.
- diggan 8y agoAFAIK, Guardian asks visitors for donations, and just recently started turning a profit with this way: https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-48111464 https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-48111464 So, maybe ads are not the answer after all.
- Tsubasachan 8y agoThat is a pretty bad argument. Not everything that makes the most money is good and should be supported. There are other things to consider.
- burtonator 8y agoI hope the ad industry completely implodes of this. Users are still paying for the content just indirectly. It would be FAR better for everyone if people started paying for content again.
- jefftk 8y ago> what ad networks can you set up that only use the content of the page to target ads? With AdSense you can use non-personalized ads: https://support.google.com/admanager/answer/9005435?hl=en https://support.google.com/admanager/answer/9005435?hl=en (Disclosure: I work for Google)
- bcsusnak 8y agoHey there! I'm part of a team that recently founded contextcue.com, a privacy-focused ad network that does exactly what you just described. We only use the content of the page to place ads, and don't track, collect, or store any user data. We're still in the early stages, but would love to get your thoughts if you want to check it out. Let me know if you have any questions!