6 ms·
Tens of billions of wages no longer to be paid out to truckers. Amazon seem a long way on with packers too. That's a lot of wealth transfer that's no longer go
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
Tens of billions of wages no longer to be paid out to truckers. Amazon seem a long way on with packers too.
That's a lot of wealth transfer that's no longer going to happen between companies and poorer people; seems we'll accelerate wealth/income disparity.
- jryle70 8y agoOr a half full view: tens of billions, possibly more, will be paid to the same truckers in their new, more fulfilling and healthier occupation? I don't know which scenario will play out. Neither do you. We'll have to see. Better yet, strive to make my scenario the reality. Complain about automation wouldn't help.
- maximente 8y agocomplaining about automation sure will help, there's even a US presidential candidate polling >1% whose ideas about how the government supports its citizens were greatly inspired by - you guessed it - people losing jobs and not getting them back due to automation. the idea that an individual can somehow strive to change capital capturing massive swathes of business and not sharing those proceeds with those they have sidelined is pretty laudable. i appreciate your optimism but i would consider it more on the unrealistic side, especially given that truck drivers probably aren't gung ho about studying for years to get retrained given most of them don't have college degrees in the first place.
- arcticbull 8y ago> i appreciate your optimism but i would consider it more on the unrealistic side, especially given that truck drivers probably aren't gung ho about studying for years to get retrained given most of them don't have college degrees in the first place. That doesn’t mean we should create or endorse make work projects, jobs that could be faster, cheaper and more efficient when automated. Society has a responsibility to these people, which is why I support both basic income and job retraining programs. It’s the humane way to make progress without fear.
- chpatrick 8y agoWhat I fear is that the new, more fulfilling occupations you describe will go to the next generation of non-truckers, not those who lost their jobs. If you spent your whole life driving trucks and it's what you're good at, can you really transfer to a new occupation that's more fulfilling and well-paid in older age, or will you just be left unemployed or stuck with a worse job? I think more automation is absolutely the future but we need to find some way to take care of the people who are left behind, and not just say "oh they'll get some other job".
- gdubya 8y agosome way to take care of the people left behind.... some kind of Income that was Basic but Universal...
- StanislavPetrov 8y agoWe know how the scenario plays out because we've seen the effects of automation playing out for the last 20 years. These fantasy jobs that people have been talking about since NAFTA never materialized. For working people home, health and general insecurity have skyrocketed along with household debt as wages have stagnated and fallen. We can either deal with reality as it exists or keep spinning ideological fantasies until the situation reaches a breaking point.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoYes, assuming we have a World with infinite resources then your suggestion would be compelling. As we could just manufacture more, and move these people in to other industries, producing ever more stuff for the people higher up the wealth scale. How do you think that's going to play out with energy production becoming problematic due to climate change, with water becoming hard to come by even in some Western regions, with resources like sand (!) growing in short supply. Oh, sure, we'll just buy our way out with our endless resources and our ever increasing consumption. WCGW. The real "half full", ie optimistic, outlook is that we find a way societally to do something like UBI, or spread jobs across more people (3 day week, etc.), or something else, without having to get there through violent revolution or similarly disturbing means. You're right, I don't know _the_ answer, but I do know it's not greater consumption (ie shift truckers in to a job producing something else), unless we first solve energy production in a massively transformative way.
- phreack 8y agoThe way forward seems to be enforcing the distribution at the state level, rather than forbidding automation.
- z3t4 8y agoAutomation, electronics, washing machines, sewing machines etc have been a way out of poverty. human labour will be worth more. And prices of goods will go down, so the poor can buy more.
- mcintyre1994 8y agoYou might not agree with his proposed solution (it's UBI), but Andrew Yang's book 'The war on normal people' is a really good well researched exploration of this issue (and other industries too).
- munk-a 8y agoI think a UBI is sort of inevitable to ensure society transitions peaceably into this new era - this round of automation appears to be falling well short on new industry creation compared to prior iterations. It's something I'd love to see get a wider adoption as otherwise I'm pretty :shrug: on Yang.
- HeadsUpHigh 8y agoAre we really going to have the same conversation every single time something about automation is mentioned. I'm just mindblown how hostile people suddenly became to the very same process that has been enriching our lives since the first industrial revolution.
- ionwake 8y agoYes because we live in a society that currently cannot function without employment
- anticensor 8y ago-cannot +does not It is a deliberate choice by states and elites, not an inability.
- simonh 8y agoThat’s been true since the introduction of the Jaquard Loom.
- ivalm 8y agoHave we previously lived in a society that was more friendly to unemployed? Because automation has been happening for a while, people got displaced from their jobs for a while....
- pbhjpbhj 8y ago>I'm just mindblown how hostile people suddenly became // I welcome automation, I don't welcome the income disparity that goes along with it. Automation needs to serve mankind, not only serve the currently wealthy who can "own the means of automation" to coin a phrase. No longer is the issue owning the means of production, but that the capitalists can owner the tools, and the [robotic] workers. Where does that leave the proletariat (the current workforce)? It leaves them useless to the Capitalists. In Capitalism that which doesn't aid profit becomes valued at zero -- and people can't live on zero, even if that means wealthy people can have their parcels delivered without any human intervention. We can't rely on perpetual growth to get out of it, we're getting to the crunch. What worked before worked because we discovered energy production that seemed limitless, but coal isn't limitless. "But we found oil, surely that's limitless?".
- DINKDINK 8y ago>we'll accelerate wealth/income disparity Do you believe that the wealth/income disparity would decrease if instead of employing one worker to drive a truck, each box was hand carried by 1000 workers? Unless the more cost-efficient delivery companies prevent competitors from entering the (now leaner) delivery market, the result of a decrease in the marginal cost of production is more, better quality, cheaper goods whose price decrease benefits those who are at the margins the most (the group you seem to be wanting to help and who would hurt the most by artificially increasing the cost of delivering goods). The "Curse" of Machinery https://www.stevebaker.info/quick-guides/economics-in-one-lesson-henry-hazlitt/vii-the-curse-of-machinery/ https://www.stevebaker.info/quick-guides/economics-in-one-le... Spread-the-Work Schemes http://www.stevebaker.info/quick-guides/economics-in-one-lesson-henry-hazlitt/viii-spread-the-work-schemes http://www.stevebaker.info/quick-guides/economics-in-one-les...
- JamesBarney 8y agoSure in the long run automation benefits society. But in the short run they can definitely lead to increases in inequality. And yes if you suddenly created huge numbers of unnecessary jobs at the bottom income disparity would decrease.
- m463 8y agoI've wondered if maybe we'll just have 5-day weekends?
- megaremote 8y agoIf you have to go to the extreme to make your argument, maybe you are wrong? Yes, it is disconcerting to remove so many jobs. There needs to be a solution to that.
- manfredo 8y agoWhy is there so much emphasis on wealth disparity when there's substantial evidence that life is significantly getting better for the poor regardless of this disparity? This is just one example off the top of my news queue: https://www.economist.com/united-states/2019/05/18/american-life-is-improving-for-the-lowest-paid https://www.economist.com/united-states/2019/05/18/american-... The phrase "A rising tide lifts all ships" gets routinely mocked, but the data seems to indicate that is is true. While inequality has risen over the past several decades, quality of life even for the poorest quartile has improved.