3 ms·
Not sure I buy the remote-controlled-by-humans idea personally. I mean, to remotely drive a car at 30mph, you either need to emergency-stop any time the contro
by michaelt 8y ago
Not sure I buy the remote-controlled-by-humans idea personally.
I mean, to remotely drive a car at 30mph, you either need to emergency-stop any time the control signal drops out (in which case you'll constantly get rear-ended) or you need a control system so good it can keep going even through signal drop-outs (in which case why do you have the remote control anyway) or you need an immortal data connection that never suffers drop-outs or so much as 100ms of latency (i.e. orders of magnitude better than what we have today).
I mean, you could do "Human remotely controls the vehicle at walking pace" easily enough, as you could stop all you liked without people hitting you. But we'd need lots of changes to the roads to support a mass of vehicles going that slowly.
- snarf21 8y agoSorry, I was not saying remote controlled. I was saying fully autonomous but only from interstate to interstate with specially designed and designated on/off ramps. They would drive highway speeds (except in traffic).
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoHow does the air force manage with remote controlled drones piloted a half a globe away? I guess flying is a bit different as it is much easier to automate than driving, but still.
- black6 8y agoAirspace is much less crowded, much more controlled, and military drones don’t need microsecond response—their missions are largely ISR with the occasional extrajudicial bombing with a lag-time > a few seconds anyway.
- michaelt 8y agoThe Big Sky Theory [1] means (unless you're in the Blue Angels) a plane can almost always keep going straight forward for 20 seconds with no worries. No risks of a child running out or a vehicle 2 seconds in front suddenly braking. This doesn't apply to a vehicle driving a city street. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_sky_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_sky_theory
- marcosdumay 8y agoThe current expected result of children running into a road in front of a truck is for they to die. Roads are a much more controlled environment than city streets.
- emj 8y agoI would say that is something truckdrivers spend a lot of time avoiding, by exprience and professionalism. The same can not be said about driverless tech companies, everyone really want to be first, that makes children and other soft targets losers.
- seanmcdirmid 8y ago> I would say that is something truckdrivers spend a lot of time avoiding, by exprience and professionalism. Then they are doing a bad job about it. https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/large-trucks#Trends https://www.iihs.org/topics/fatality-statistics/detail/large... > The same can not be said about driverless tech companies, everyone really want to be first, that makes children and other soft targets losers. I would guess that it would be pretty hard to do worse than we are already doing.
- emj 8y agoThere are technological solutions that help truck drivers to drive safely but they are actively fought by truck producers. No one is a saint, but I promise you that truck drivers spend alot of their time worrying about you and me. My argument is a variant of "better the devil you know".
- pjc50 8y agoThe car only needs to emergency stop if the "self-driving" has a sudden disengage feature which relies on transferring control to a human in miliseconds. If it's actually "self-driving" and can handle uncertainty in a more reasonable way it's not so much a problem.