4 ms·
You were well equipped to answer that particular question. Do you think the answer would be as straightforward if you substituted your jury on this case?
by Aeolun 8y ago
You were well equipped to answer that particular question.
Do you think the answer would be as straightforward if you substituted your jury on this case?
- MisterBastahrd 8y agoA bunch of intelligent adults with access to data, the facts, and a lot of free time? Yes.
- wutbrodo 8y agoJury selection doesn't filter for intelligence, so your description doesn't seem applicable.
- zamfi 8y agoI think you would be surprised. Jury selection filters for people who vote, have long-term residence in a single location, have jobs that at least modestly allow jury service, and who actually show up to jury duty. To make a sweeping generalization, those things all correlate with intelligence. Anecdotally, the people I've met at jury selection in downtown Oakland, CA are not a representative sample of who you see outside the building.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- raxxorrax 8y agoAnd therefore have an investment in ruling correctly. I think you are correct and the appeal to expert opinion is not convincing. As a non-American, the jury system feels alien. Advantages and disadvantages, I guess.
- klmr 8y agoExcept it clearly didn’t work in this case since the jury reached a conclusion that is fundamentally at odds with the conclusion reached by experts worldwide. I’m baffled by how this is discussed on here as “well, maybe the jury was right”. We know that the jury wasn’t right.
- sgift 8y ago> conclusion reached by experts worldwide. A relevant group of the experts don't agree with the conclusion, namely those working for the IARC/WHO.
- klmr 8y ago… and the IARC monograph on Roundup, in turn, has been dismissed universally by experts as both flawed and misleading. Amongst other things, they arbitrarily excluded high-quality studies that showed no evidence of carcinogenicity, and included at least one study claiming to show an effect but in reality failed to do so (it didn’t show dose dependence, which means the result is not statistically robust but rather a random fluke). The scientific consensus is completely on Monsanto’s side in this debate. Pretending otherwise is simply dishonest, there’s no other word for it.
- sgift 8y agoIf that is the case then it shouldn't be a problem to ask IARC to make a new monograph. That this doesn't happen tells me that the case isn't as simple here as you say.
- rmrfrmrf 8y agoOr maybe the experts are wrong?
- klmr 8y agoYes, of course maybe all the experts are wrong, and the jury of lay people was right. But even if this unlikely case occurred here, do you really want to build legal cases and policy on such a fluke?