21 ms·
U.S. Farmers Are Being Bled by the Tractor Monopoly
- thomasedwards 8y agoSounds like it’s a really great time to be a farmer in the US.
- cmiles74 8y agoI suspect you're being sarcastic and I agree. The US has been a tough place to be a farmer since the 80s. https://www.nytimes.com/1991/10/14/us/farmer-suicide-rate-swells-in-1980-s-study-says.html https://www.nytimes.com/1991/10/14/us/farmer-suicide-rate-sw... https://www.motherjones.com/media/2018/07/the-cdc-just-retracted-its-farmer-suicide-data-that-could-be-terrible-news-for-farmers/ https://www.motherjones.com/media/2018/07/the-cdc-just-retra...
- module0000 8y agoThis is stranger than fiction. I would have laughed 15 years ago if someone suggested DRM and electronic licensing would ever be applied to a tractor.
- EADGBE 8y agoMost wouldn't have even known what these meant.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoWhat I am wondering: Has that changed what you laugh about now? Like, what people warn about our future now? As far as I am concerned, this is exactly what I expected, and I am seriously surprised anyone could be surprised by it. Like, I was not necessarily thinking specifically about tractors 15 years ago, but I think it was just obvious that DRM would be used to gain control over devices that are run by software, and obviously pretty much all devices sooner or later would be run by software, and as such, of course, tractors would be, too, sooner or later.
- ddingus 8y agoGreat question! For me, yes. I do think differently about these warnings. We are in an interesting time. How we resolve these basics are going to impact people and the planet for a very long time. It also impacts what I do. One thing is I am extremely reluctant to depend on things I cannot repair. Grew up rural, and repair was a basic skill in life. I am thankful for it. Has saved me so many times. Right to repair is a major issue, close to my heart.
- freedomben 8y agoCompletely agree. I also wasn't thinking about tractors (or really vehicles for that matter), but in the mid-2000s I was helping build "tamper proof" devices for my employer. Listening to Richard Stallman talk I would think he was crazy. Then I saw how much we raked in providing "support" for the tamper-proof devices when they needed service. It became quickly apparent that the rest of the industry was just a little bit behind. We are headed to a crazy world. Cory Doctorow's message on the War on General Purpose Computing is more relevant than ever. For anyone that hasn't seen his Cory, he's got numerous videos on Youtube. Check out some of his talks at Google.
- wccrawford 8y agoWhen most non-farmers think of tractors, they think of something like a dumbed-down car with a lot of power. It's an engine that drags a tool through a field. The idea that something like that could be locked behind components that can't be fixed or replaced cheaply is astounding to them. I feel like it's the same as asking Henry Ford what he thinks about all the electronics in today's cars. It'd blow his mind.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 8y agoWell, yeah, sure, but I guess I was assuming people who knew what DRM is, not necessarily the general public--if you didn't even know what DRM is, it's not that surprising you probably wouldn't have an idea of how it would be used.
- Someone1234 8y agoThis comment might apply to cars 15 years from now. Tesla is likely the closest to "car as a service" but it has been coming along for a few years across the entire auto industry.
- mrguyorama 8y agoMy understanding is that ford is really really bad for this as well, requiring incredibly expensive computers, software packages, and training to repair even basic things without it pissing off the ECU
- stochastic_monk 8y agoThis is why I will never again own a Ford. (That, and the endless recalls.)
- jacquesm 8y agoAnd the bits falling off the car within the warranty period, that turn out not to be part of the warranty after all. In my case: a transmission brace that broke under light use in under a year on an F150.
- mywittyname 8y agoOr the aluminum hood on my car that has a massive paint defect that isn't covered by the paint warranty because it needs to "rust" through for them to cover it. They added that clause to the warranty agreement knowing that aluminum will never rust, rather than fixing an issue they knew about for over a decade.
- navigatesol 8y agoI just finished up the second of back to back Ford leases this month (2010 F-150, 2014 Fiesta ST) and didn't have a single issue with either car. 8 years, 2 cars, only oil changes, tires and brakes (on the ST). I guess your mileage may vary, literally.
- colechristensen 8y agoYou wouldn't had you been in the market for a tractor 15 years ago. Unfixable black box electronics has been a part of farm machinery for quite a while now.
- jethro_tell 8y agoThe reason people talk about working on older cars/trucks/tractors as easier, isn't because they are to incompetent to work with the electronics, it's because for the most part they are a black box.
- jayesobj 8y agoTractors are behemoths of modern machinery. I have relatives in the tractor industry, as well as relatives who are farming, and this has been coming for a long time. Tractors are ridiculously expensive. I was talking with a relative who sells them, and some of them cost more than pretty nice homes in the city we live in (as in, we live in a large metro area, and they can easily cost more than a very large, attractive home). These things aren't just tilling dirt like you might have in the 20s either, or like you might with a garden in your backyard. There's all sorts of modern planting and harvesting methods, and tractors are sort of the engine that drives a lot of this machinery (which is very large). The technology involved can be complex, and it's often tied to aerial surveillance, soil monitoring etc. The intellectual property problems associated with Deere and other manufacturers go beyond DRM per se. Deere over the last couple of decades has tried to force smaller sellers to abandon other manufacturers. I.e., "as of X date, if you continue to carry equipment from other manufacturers, we will no longer supply you with Deere equipment." This is extraordinarily anticompetitive when you consider that these pieces of equipment are extremely expensive, and that the dealers are geographically very sparse. So, it's hard on the farmers because if the dealer does become Deere-exclusive they might have to travel far to find alternatives, and it's hard on the dealers, because they are forced to put their eggs in one basket even when the buyers might want (or need) choice. I've seen families split apart actually in cases where one part of the family is on the dealer or farmer side, and the other is on the Deere side. Deere really has become anticompetitive in many ways, not just with DRM. If there ever was a case for antitrust enforcement in my opinion, it would probably be with Deere.
- beauzero 8y agoI am for "right to repair" but one thing that has been left out of this narrative/discussion, in this article, and elsewhere is that when making payments there are insurance and/or warranty riders on these contracts when John Deere is providing the financing. They do this because they want the equipment repaired in a manner that meets JD's engineering specs. On the flip side I have seen certified JD mechanics, at a dealership, break off something as simple as the BlueDef/urea tank on a tractor because they didn't know how to fix it, forcing the tractor to remain in the shop while parts were reordered. In return they lent a similar tractor out at no charge because hay was already on the ground and rain was coming. This works well when the dealership is literally 6 miles down the road...not so good when its 60 or 160.
- ZWoz 8y agoSorry for being naive, I am not american. Can you tell, why those farmers aren't buying tractors from other companies? Those news always contain Deere name, I don't see similar critique against say Valtra or Belarus.
- ganoushoreilly 8y agoThey're not readily available in the market.
- uptownJimmy 8y agoIt's been a long time since the bank foreclosed on my boyhood farming days, and I have been as far away from tractor news as possible ever since. Is nobody else making tractors anymore? I remember John Deere tractors being the very cream of the crop: are they still well-made and revered for it? What a weird world. We would have been incredulous to be told that one day we wouldn't be able to repair our tractors without computers. That was back in the TRS-80 era, for reference...
- ip26 8y ago"Tractor" is something of a loaded term, implying simplicity and so on. It sounds like some of the products JD makes today could be more accurately thought of as "Robot Tractors".
- toomuchtodo 8y agoRelated: https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/xykkkd/why-american-farmers-are-hacking-their-tractors-with-ukrainian-firmware https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/xykkkd/why-american-farme... (Why American Farmers Are Hacking Their Tractors With Ukrainian Firmware) https://tractorhacking.github.io/ https://tractorhacking.github.io/
- chicob 8y ago"The project is through California Polytechnic State University’s Capstone I/II class and sponsored by iFixit. Material on this site is protected from DMCA takedown by a DMCA exemption granted by the US Copyright Office." Yes.
- jahlove 8y agoThe Vice News video on this problem is really good.
- VonGuard 8y agoThis is a HUGE problem. If John Deere were to go out of business tomorrow, a huge swath of our world's farmers would be unable to produce anything thanks to tractors turning off and not working properly. Remember that old game you like with online validation for single player mode? Remember how it stopped working when the servers went offline. There's a DMCA fair use exception to allow you to circumvent that DRM thanks to the EFF and the MADE, but there is no such fair use allowance for tractors....
- genericone 8y agoYou would think tractor usability would be of far greater importance compared to game availability!
- toomuchtodo 8y agoSeveral US politicians (Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, former Colorado governor John Hickenlooper) are advocating for federal right to repair legislation for farmers. https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/8xzqmp/bernie-sanders-calls-for-a-national-right-to-repair-law-for-farmers https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/8xzqmp/bernie-sanders-cal... As always, if this matters to you, get involved and vote.
- bsbechtel 8y agoAt one point, there was talk of the industry moving to a pay per hour of horsepower model or something similar where you are basically paying for guaranteed uptime. I don't know if there is still an effort to move towards that or not, but that would change this discussion quite a bit.
- colechristensen 8y agoJust a little supporting fact most people wouldn't be aware of, when you're buying a used tractor the "odometer" you look at isn't in miles but hours which is tracked in the same way.
- Trisell 8y agoOutside of the large corporate farms I think you are going to see an increase in farmers continuing to refurbish older tractors that are pre computers and then begin to retrofit those tractors with third party systems that won’t give them complete vendor lock in. A good example is Welker Farms. They run Big Bud tractors from the 70s refurbish them every decade or so. And have added in gps guidance and other things as 3rd party mods. Also they have a great YouTube channel[1]. 1 https://www.youtube.com/WelkerFarmsInc?uid=tKUW8LJK2Ev8hUy9ZG_PPA https://www.youtube.com/WelkerFarmsInc?uid=tKUW8LJK2Ev8hUy9Z...
- cheeze 8y agoVery cool. Thanks for sharing!
- thrower123 8y agoThat's the thing. This big iron equipment doesn't just quit working and fall apart after a few years. It's expensive enough that you rebuild engines, weld up parts that break, redo seals in the transmission, etc, and keep it going for decades. I've driven Cat D6 bulldozers that were older than I was when I was in college, and they are still going, a decade later. Particularly the stuff that is built for heavy usage has to be used hard, patched together with limited repair facilities in remote places, and handled by inexpert operators.
- yason 8y agoIf you can't fix or tinker with it then it's not yours, and if it isn't yours it's not worth "buying" it but rather renting. Does JD lease their equipment? Or do they hope to? On another take, I can imagine old, repairable tractors going up in value at some point. You can traditionally keep those going for decades.
- Loughla 8y agoFor smaller operations like mine, those older tractors are already valuable. I run Massey's from the 70's and 80's that I can fix on my own as long as I can find parts. For large operations (and the way the entire ag economy is moving is large operations) this doesn't matter. They lease their machinery anyway, so what does it matter if they can't work on them? JD will come to the field to fix it if it breaks down. It's a cost savings for them. This is just another nail in the coffin of rural america/family farms. And before the next person tells me 'most farms are family farms', I need your citations, and I want to see it broken down by family owned corporations v actual family farms.
- ngneer 8y agoInformation asymmetry. I would humbly posit that this is one of the biggest challenges that the information security community has to tackle on the face of the planet, and it is not just a technological one. Farmers are at the mercy of equipment manufacturers, who are centralizing control. A model with distributed control is more robust in the long run, and should be an option for consumers. Are there any competitive open source tractors out there?
- 0x262d 8y agothis was predicted by Lenin in Imperialism: The Highest Stage of Capitalism, a good portion of which is dedicated to the unstoppable gradual rise of monopolies and cartels. more people here should read it.
- JohnFen 8y agoOr, for those who are allergic to Lenin, Adam Smith made pretty much the same point in "The Wealth of Nations".
- hilbert42 8y agoWhether a generation takes Smith's or Marx's line, lessons learned will be forgotten within a generation or two and the arguments start over again. Tragically, this is a part of the human condition and it is not just limited to politics and the economy but also applies to many other fields of human endeavour.
- hippich 8y agoI got a small old grey-market tractor made by Mitsubishi. Most of the wiring is shot, only ignition, sparkplugs and battery-to-starter is working. The rest is destroyed by someone previously. (alternator is probably also dead). And it works awesomely! Just gotta charge the battery once in a while in the garage. That is tractor. What is sold by JD - is semi-authonomous sophisticated machines with equally sophisticated service network, not a tractor :P
- PorterDuff 8y agoI can't think of why this would be unique to farmers, perhaps aside from a push towards autopilot systems. Mining equipment, road building, all of that hyper-specialized stuff for slicing and dicing trees, I would think they all have this issue. Perhaps it's the greater prevalence of owner-operators. I've probably bought the newest car I ever will (which is now 15 years old), so it would be nice to steer clear of the dealer-only craziness and the inevitable spying on you that new vehicles are going to accrue. I can just imagine how ticked I'd be if the tech juggernaut was messing with my income in a bad way.
- analog31 8y agoAn amusing anecdote: At my workplace, the software developers decided that I didn't deserve to have a "seat" of their magnificent development tools. I downloaded a copy of Python. Now my entire work group runs on Python. A couple years later, same story with the embedded systems developers. Now we all develop on Arduino. My side business, manufacturing a hardware gadget, runs entirely from open source tools.
- bricej13 8y agoDisclaimer: My father worked as an engineer for John Deere for 35 years. I interned at John Deere writing code that runs on the tractor controllers. Discussions on this topic always end up one-sided and simplistic. Hopefully I can shed some light on the more nuanced reasoning behind John Deere's position. Having the DRM in place allows Deere to reduce manufacturing expense and increase platform flexibility. There is a very wide array of needs that farmers have based on what they do. Deere allows buyers to customize tractors to their needs for everything from engine horsepower, to wheel count, size, and type, cab quality-of-life, to hydraulic hookups for implements. Some of these changes are just a software change, while others are a software + hardware change. Engine horsepower, for example, can be increased by a software update. Techincally, this is pretty cool. Designing and manufacturing engines is expensive. This allows them to manufacture fewer different engines that can cover a wider variety of use cases. It also allows farmers the flexibility to upgrade their engine horsepower at a future date. If I remember correctly each extra 50hp above the base costs ~10k, so the large configurations subsidize the cost of the base configurations. With that understanding, think of how this can apply to Deere's obligations to the EPA or to warranties. Years ago, farmers found a hack where they could put a resister in-line between the diesel temperature sensor and the ECU and increase their horsepower. The hack spread like wildfire. This made the engines run in a configuration that had not been tested by Deere or approved by the EPA. Who would the EPA go after if it had caused emissions issues? Should Deere honor the warranty in this case of those who did the hack? How would Deere know if someone did the hack, borked the engine, then removed the resistor? Liability is the enemy of automation. Deere has added some automation over the years, allowing the tractors to drive straight down the field without intervention, and executing perfect turns at the push of a button. This is functionality that no companies would let end users change. Much like my dad, a tractor is not a cell phone. Installing a custom rom on a cell phone is one thing, updating the autonomous driving of a 10 ton tractor is quite another. There's got to be some middle ground, but I don't know what it is.
- jacquesm 8y agoAll of the advantages you list could be provided better without DRM from the viewpoint of the farmer, open standards and all that. The three point hitch is what made farm equipment investments a good destination of the money farmers had saved, not DRM.
- dv_dt 8y agoIt's just one case of many in a system where financialization and extraction have taken precedent over companies competing to provide fundamental values to consumers. There isn't enough competition, there isn't enough access or willingness for capital to take risks (how many farmers with deep understaning of the ag market have access to capital to start a rival tractor company?).
- leroy_masochist 8y agoFarmer here - 200 head of grass fed cattle plus hay operation. Just to be clear, the problem described in the article does not affect many (probably most) farmers; it primarily affects large scale grain operations that have harvest combines that use a lot of onboard computers. It's a bit dramatic to frame this as "US farmers are being bled". Guys who grow grain on huge farms in the Midwest are not happy about the implications of the TOS they signed with Deere when they, grownups who can read, bought their tractors a few years ago. There, fixed the headline for you.
- LeifCarrotson 8y agoIs there an alternative where they don't sign an equivalent TOS and still get the same features? Perhaps they have to pay for the privilege? Or is this a unilateral power grab by the manufacturers?
- leroy_masochist 8y agoMidwest grain farmers are super boxed in with regard to what they must sign in order to have access to the latest tractor technology for their specific crop, but that's happening within the context of the technology getting incrementally better year-by-year, i.e., continuously cheaper input costs per unit of crop yield. This is all somewhat par for the course for a highly commoditized industry. Also, check out the comment below from the child of the Deere engineer who makes the point that "liability is the enemy of automation". If you gave farmers the ability to hack their tractors you are opening a bunch of complicated issues.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoWhy do they need the latest tractor technology? Amazingly, people used to survive using tractors without air conditioning. Just slum it a little and use something that was state of the art for 1990. Plenty of Deere competitors can beat that.
- brianwawok 8y ago
- shmerl 8y agoAnother example how DRM is a crooked tool that should be banned.
- loons2 8y agoI'm not a farmer, but I wouldn't even buy a John Deere lawn mower for exactly this reason. The tractor I did buy is a Branson. The engine comes from the same factory that Cummins engines come from (matter of fact, some JD engines come from the Kukje factory) and everything is built with durability in mind. Yes, the dealer is 135 miles away, but since I'm not really depending on the machine to make a living, I can live with that.
- hilbert42 8y agoHow did we ever get into the situation where we cannot repair our own stuff—stuff that we have actually purchased ourselves? The situation that we've now reached where technology is now being locked up and out of sight in large corporations is frankly damn disgraceful and we really need to act and to do something about it ASAP. This new trend is deskilling the workforce and population generally and it's not in the national interest for society to allow this to continue. …And that's just for starters. There was a time early in my career when anyone who purchased any hi-tech equipment would have expected to receive a comprehensive operational manual with the equipment and optionally a proper service manual with a comprehensive description of equipment's operation and procedures to fix it. And of course spare parts would have been available as a matter of course. It was so common that no one would have ever thought it possible not to be able to get maintenance manuals. My introduction to electronics and technology generally was by way of equipment manuals and I learned a great deal from them. Home appliances such as radios and televisions often had the circuit diagrams inside the back of the case at the time of purchase. Mechanics manuals were always available for cars and other vehicles and so on. I recall quintessential examples of this with manuals from companies such as Tektronix whose oscilloscopes manuals were a remarkable sight—they were truly wonderful. For the younger generation who has never experienced what is was actually like to be able to get detailed information from a manufacturer then download this Tektronix oscilloscope 7834 manual dated 1977 from the Internet Archive: https://archive.org/details/tektronix_7834 https://archive.org/details/tektronix_7834. (I actually purchased several of these instruments so I've firsthand knowledge.) Even if you don't understand a word of this manual nevertheless even just a glance at it will show you what we've actually lost as a society by manufacturer's refusing to release information. It's a nonsense when manufacturers claim that they shouldn't have to release proprietary information as it would aid competitors. Clearly, the release of this information by Tektronix never affected its bottom line. In fact, this instrument reigned quite supreme at what it did for years. In fact, hiding circuit information and obfuscating source code has been detrimental for security and other reasons. If Volkswagen had not obfuscated its embedded code then it wouldn’t have faced the multibillion dollar fines that it's had to endure. BTW, IBM provided circuit schematics and BIOS source code for its first PCs—the XT and AT. Oh, how times have changed for the worse.
- 8y ago
- Circuits 8y agoIt must not be that huge of a problem because farmers are continuing to purchase the most up-to-date tractors with all the wing-dings, bells and whistles they can afford. The guidance consoles are not tied into the machine and don't care how old the equipment is, so why again do you need that brand new $200k tractor? Perhaps this will be a wake up call. Stop buying new equipment and fix your already existing, already purchased, old equipment.
- colechristensen 8y agoThe fixable equipment without electronic black boxes is several decades old and increasingly difficult to come by. New farm equipment is financed with loans/leases, trade ins and depreciation in ways that make it a sort of trap that is difficult to escape buying new things all the time.
- Circuits 8y agoNot the first time I have heard that and yet I see thousands of machines in hundreds of machine graveyards where old equipment has been sitting for decades collecting rust spread accost the country side. The same can be said about cars and the people who own the old equipment are basically giving it away if not paying people to take it... The problem, imho, is that people actually don't want to be able to fix their machines themselves because they don't want to spend the time it takes to do it. They want to be able to pay a guy to do it for them and even then they complain about the cost or the hassle involved in making that happen. Today's farmers are not the farmers of 20 years ago. They are the same as everyone else, to busy playing angry-birds to learn how to fix a carburetor.
- jacquesm 8y agoI'll take a 9N in any condition.
- Loughla 8y agoFrom experience - it's not that simple. I run 70's and 80's Masseys. I have to fix them constantly, by myself. The biggest hassle is waiting for parts. The last time I needed a part from an implement or salesman that I couldn't get from a junkyard took 2 weeks for delivery, once they found it. It was 20 days total from breakdown to fix, and all but 12 hours of that was out of my control. So, put yourself on a broken down tractor in harvest season with rain in the forecast for two days from now. That white glove treatment you get with new machinery looks pretty nice when that happens. That being said, I agree that people want to complain more than they want to fix anything. I enjoy working with my hands as a hobby, so I'm odd, I think. Most people just want their machines to work, with no inputs.
- toss1 8y agoBeen long outraged at this kind of lock-in problem, wherever it is found. My first thought on reading this kind of article is "what a great opportunity for a startup". Then, I immediately realize that there are likely no VCs that would fund such a thing. It seems that every (ok, a vast majority) new business models that gets funded either start with or soon add some kin of lock-in even when completely unnecessary. they tout it as a "cloud" feature, but in reality it is just a DRM lockup. The real problem is VCs and founders failing to truly compete on features, and instead trying to compete on network effects and lock-in to build an extractive business model -- just lock 'em in and charge the highest rent/rates you can.
- canada_dry 8y ago> U.S. consumers may be unaware of the farmers’ plight Sadly, the vast majority of the US population only really care about things in their own home/backyard. The concept of awareness at even a national level is lost on most.
- jartelt 8y agoMany farmers in the Midwest are actually millionaires that own large swathes of land. Yes, they work very hard, but they also like to complain a lot despite the fact that many of them are better off than many non-farmers in the Midwest.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoJohn Deere is also buying or investing in automated farming equipment(Blue River Tech being their biggest acquisition) and farm robotics. They now have a Silicon Valley VC/investment arm in San Francisco. A lot of new technologies that are being developed are bought out by the big fish and banished to a dark vault to die to kill competition. Net net..farmer never wins.
- donatj 8y agoThe real problem I see for modestly sized farms's is they are massively underserved by modern tractors. They are over complicated and over priced. Most of the farmers I know still use tractors from the 1950s-1970s as their primary workhorses because they're simple and reliable. No one builds tractors like that anymore, in part due to the shrinking demands and in part due to regulation. Why would I pay $50k+ for a new tractor that does way more than I really need, breaks down often and I can't service when I can get an old but just as useful tractor for $3-5k. The companies that have sprung up to build parts for these ancient tractors is absolutely fascinating. Outside of perhaps some of the larger cast pieces, you can replace almost everything with new parts.
- Loughla 8y ago>The companies that have sprung up to build parts for these ancient tractors is absolutely fascinating. Outside of perhaps some of the larger cast pieces, you can replace almost everything with new parts. There is a literal workforce dedicated to fixing or fabricating these old parts. Find your nearest custom machine shop. One-job shops. They exist to build or fix a million things one time, instead of production machining where they build one thing a million times. These people are mad-geniuses at reverse-engineering and figuring out how to make things based on burnt-out or broken pieces. Source; My father is a master machinist at one of these shops. He has worked on everything from re-building hydraulic cylinders for local guys to one-off parts for prototype cars that we can't discuss the name of to rebuilding structural supports on a bridge.
- mymythisisthis 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uO5EWOFpV1E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uO5EWOFpV1E Matthias explains what makes a good farm tracker.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ltbarcly3 8y agoPlease don't take this comment as "there is nothing wrong" and don't take it as "there's nothing to talk about here". Clearly this is a problem that needs to be discussed and brought to people's attention. This is a response to people taking this article and interpreting it as though there is some injustice being done to farmers and that we need some sort of government intervention: How is it a monopoly? There are like 8 or 9 different major tractor brands to choose from. The word is out on the street (or fields?), and I've seen articles like this for well over 5 years now. There's a simple solution for farmers that don't want the costs (and benefits presumably) of these restrictive deals: don't buy a tractor that has these restrictive terms of service.
- qntty 8y agoThe meaning of monopoly here is that JD has a monopoly on the repair of JD tractors. That is, there cannot be competitors if they require you to use official repair places. It doesn't mean that JD repair centers have a monopoly on the repair of all tractors, or that JD has a monopoly on the market for tractors themselves. It's not meant to imply that it would legally be considered a monopoly.
- ergothus 8y agoI agree that what we are seeing is not really a monopoly. The issue is better defined as "industry realities prevent effective use of voting with their wallets". > There's a simple solution for farmers that don't want the costs (and benefits presumably) of these restrictive deals: don't buy a tractor that has these restrictive terms of service. ...and lose compatibility with a large number of add on equipment and related software. Much like the AAA games industry moving towards micro-transactions, your ability to avoid suppliers that require that is limited and you are the one that ends up losing out. How do we solve these issues? No idea. But expecting farmers (in this case) to take the hit themselves in the hopes that enough of their peers do the same to create a big enough financial incentive for vendors to change their ways is unlikely to succeed.
- ltbarcly3 8y agoI appreciate your points, I just really dislike paternalism, especially when it means treating farmers who are probably pretty savvy and creative like they are helpless. I'm fairly certain that building compatible equipment is totally legally protected in the US. It would seem like a huge opportunity for some people living in farm/manufacturing country to start building adapters or other compatibility mechanisms to use add on equipment across tractor brands if the tractor manufacturers aren't interested in doing it. If Henry Ford could build a car in his garage, I'm sure there are plenty of people out there that could make a combine work with a tractor that doesn't have the right logo on the side.
- eledumb 8y agoForeign import knock off tractors will take care of this problem and then U.S. manufacturers will be crying unfair "foreign competition" and then they will get bailed out, time and time again until they can no longer compete even with the bail out.
- downrightmike 8y agoFarm and ranch families comprise just 2 percent of the U.S. population. https://www.fb.org/newsroom/fast-facts https://www.fb.org/newsroom/fast-facts
- squish78 8y ago... and they keep the other 98% alive
- olivermarks 8y agohttps://www.ft.com/content/ff8abbc2-7302-11e9-bf5c-6eeb837566c5 https://www.ft.com/content/ff8abbc2-7302-11e9-bf5c-6eeb83756... Good Rana Faroohar piece that touches on this: 'concentration of power in agribusiness has been a bigger and certainly a longer-term problem for American farmers than China. As a few companies gained control of key areas of the food supply chain, spending on research and development fell, input costs rose, and margins for individual farms went down. The CAP report also documents small farmers being forced into opaque contracts and held up by ridiculous rules, such as those forbidding them to repair their machinery without permission from John Deere or other large manufacturers'
- smolder 8y agoU.S. Internet users are being bled by the internet monopolies. U.S. Humans are being bled by the health oligopoly. When it comes to industry hurting society, no one who matters cares, and no one who cares matters. "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!"
- PeterCorless 8y agoIt's not a "monopoly," technically. It's an oligopoly. John Deere having 53%; CNH (International Harvester, New Holland) having 35%, AGCO 7%, and miscellaneous players fighting over the last 5%. Article: https://www.farm-equipment.com/articles/15962-manufacturer-consolidation-reshaping-the-farm-equipment-marketplace https://www.farm-equipment.com/articles/15962-manufacturer-c... Image: https://www.farm-equipment.com/ext/resources/images/issues/2018/FE-September-2018/MarketShare.jpg https://www.farm-equipment.com/ext/resources/images/issues/2...
- new-day-rising 8y agoLarge scale grain farms (aka commercial farms - not the historical family farm) typically run combines 24-7 during harvest and use the combines for 1 harvest only. They lease them and don't own them. Smaller operations buy them refurbished...
- snazz 8y agoAs a Minnesotan (but not a farmer), I’m extremely exited to see so much progress with Right-to-Repair legislation (see [0]), especially since it should benefit consumers nation- or even world-wide. If one US state passes the bill, we're unlikely to tech companies create a “Minnesota Edition” device with repair manuals only accessible to Minnesota residents. More likely, compliant businesses will offer this information freely and benefit everyone. [0]: http://www.startribune.com/right-to-repair-bill-appears-headed-for-first-time-to-floor-of-minnesota-house/507485152/ http://www.startribune.com/right-to-repair-bill-appears-head... Also: https://states.repair.org/states/minnesota/ https://states.repair.org/states/minnesota/ and https://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2019/04/24/minnesota-could-be-the-first-state-to-pass-a-right-to-repair-bill/ https://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2019/04/24/minnesota-could-be...
- kwiens 8y agoWe're down to the wire in Minnesota. If you want to see the bill happen, call your reps today. A vote could happen as soon as tomorrow, but only if the noise level is high enough.
- snazz 8y agoLiving in the 3rd congressional district, I’m assuming that I would be contacting [solved and redacted; I realized how closely this tells you of my location]. I haven’t done this before for any issue while living in this state. I also found the full text of the bill, which is very easy to read and a lot shorter than I expected! I see nothing about when the bill might be voted upon, but I’m very hopeful it will get passed. https://www.revisor.mn.gov/bills/text.php?number=HF1138&type=bill&version=1&session=ls91&session_year=2019&session_number=0 https://www.revisor.mn.gov/bills/text.php?number=HF1138&type...
- jmpman 8y agoI worked in another industry with an effective monopoly in a subset of the market. When setting our prices, we evaluated behavioral game theory, and determined that we could claim 60% of the gains produced by our technology innovations without upsetting our customer. As we planned for that financial model, we realized that GMO seeds had a similar ability to extract fractions of their productivity gains. We planned to investigate just what fraction they were extracting, and expected it to be a much higher percentage, as Monsanto doesn’t need to worry about upsetting a single customer, they could extract 90% of the gains, and any farmer who didn’t settle for those remaining 10% would be our competed by their peers. Does anyone know how much GMO seeds cost relative to their standard cousins, and how much the cost of growing each and the productivity of each type? The Tractor companies are simply following the seed companies models.
- JoblessWonder 8y agoThis is just another example of the increasing "___ as a Service" model that is flowing through many, many industries. Manufacturers and service providers are trying to manage their cash flow in a different way by getting people to pay regular ongoing fees instead of larger, one time fees at intermittent intervals.
- Gustomaximus 8y agoWhat I dont understand is why farmers are still being brand loyal to companies like John Deere. There are quality tractor brands from Italy, Germany, Finland, Japan and Korea etc. Would jumping to these brands be a easy fix or is there an issue with dealer networks and part there? Seems to me while getting right to repair rules are still important, farmers of an area should be setting up coops for parts and swapping brands. Is that over-simplifying things?