12 ms·
This sounds like good news. I've read lots of negative stories about the working conditions in Amazon warehouses. It would be great if all the jobs could be aut
by irrational 8y ago
This sounds like good news. I've read lots of negative stories about the working conditions in Amazon warehouses. It would be great if all the jobs could be automated.
- atonse 8y agoHonestly the best proposal I've seen for slowing down such automation is to add a tax on these machines. That'll make the cost-benefit equation less obvious. These machines won't pay for themselves in a year and then be practically free. They'll continue to cost a lot. This kind of tax would help slow the progress of such automation to a speed where society can better adjust. And I say this as someone who absolutely loves all this kind of automation.
- rytor718 8y agoI was going to (very slightly) disagree, but the idea that society is slower than technology is an angle that needs to be stated out loud a lot more. We can't out pace machines and its a fair reason to tax them for the time being. That said, I don't necessarily believe "society is slow to catch up" should be a long term problem. It should be something the government mandates for x years -- so that it has a timeline to get its act together and build society towards the future.
- atonse 8y agoTotally agree, that it would be a temporary measure to add some speed bumps. I first heard this proposal from Bill Gates. Suffice to say he's got a unique view and has probably studied this extensively.
- SamuelAdams 8y ago> It should be something the government mandates for x years -- so that it has a timeline to get its act together and build society towards the future. Be careful what you wish for. Social Security was supposed to be temporary too, but here we are, 50 years later. As Milton Friedman put it: > Nothing is so permanent as a temporary government program.
- myself248 8y agoSo how would you tax my cordless drill? It saves a ton of time versus the old bit-and-brace method. Or does the tax only apply to things that replace new jobs, not old ones?
- atonse 8y agoDid the cordless drill result in tons of jobs vanishing overnight? Or did it slowly happen over many years? Is your cordless drill able to walk over and automatically do the job you would've done, firing you overnight? Since it doesn't do any of those things, seems like it wouldn't necessarily be taxed.
- mruts 8y agoMaybe we should have done that 2000 years ago. Then we wouldn't have the scourge of electricity and the candle maker's union would still be going strong: providing high paying quality jobs to the honest workers of the world.
- ilikehurdles 8y agoThe best proposal is a more accessible social safety net that includes things like free higher education (or technical training) and healthcare. I don't think automation should be slowed, but the US is not equipped to handle the ensuing job displacement. Chop up the foreign invasion and domestic spying budget and reallocate toward uplifting the average worker.
- pennaMan 8y agoWon't they just mass up in the inevitable tax havens?
- liotier 8y ago> It would be great if all the jobs could be automated ... If all the capital could be distributed.
- chrinic83a7 8y ago> ... If all the capital could be distributed. Why? We didn't contribute much yo the development of Amazon's specific machines. Oh, you're saying you are entitled to it?
- cle 8y agoWhat do you think is going to happen with that capital?
- egypturnash 8y agoBezos’ pockets.
- Ajedi32 8y agoAnd from there?
- wlesieutre 8y agoLaunched in to space for Bezos's Scrooge McDuck gold pool on his moon colony. But don't worry, nobody needs to get paid for this. The rockets will be built by robots, and the robots will be built by more robots.
- wlesieutre 8y agoThis may come across as a total joke, so I should clarify. Do I really think Bezos will do this? No. Would I be surprised if he did? Also no.
- onion2k 8y agoIs this where you try to claim trickle down economics works despite the top 20% of people owning more than 80% of the financial assets? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_inequality_in_the_Unite...
- pnongrata 8y agoIt would be great if everyone had good working conditions and decent wages.
- simonh 8y agoI'm sure the people currently doing those jobs must be overjoyed.
- preordained 8y agoFree at last! Free at last! Free to...wait a minute...
- CodeMage 8y agoSure, it's good news, just not for the people you're thinking of. Think about people who work in Amazon warehouses despite those conditions. Why do they do that? Because the alternatives are worse. This just removes these jobs and leaves them to face those alternatives.
- asdfman123 8y agoI think HN's tune would be quite different if someone came up with a technology that eliminated half of all programming jobs. Not quite so many people would be saying, "This is great! I for one look forward to technological advancement." I do think the future should involve more automation, I just think we should be -- I dunno, a little less gleeful about it and think about the people it's impacting.
- xxs 8y ago"eliminated half of all programming jobs" Tools to improve speed of development have existed for ages, twice the speed = twice less developers in a blunt way. (that includes even programming languages) Personally I'd consider it an improvement - if I job can be automated, it should be.
- CodeMage 8y ago> twice the speed = twice less developers in a blunt way Except that's not how that works. Increasing the productivity of a job does not eliminate it. A job is eliminated when it's no longer necessary. Unless you live in a parallel dimension, we're both in the world where there's more and more software development being done every day. Twice the speed results in twice the output, not half the developers.
- ekianjo 8y ago> Increasing the productivity of a job does not eliminate it. Of course it does. Not on an individual level, but if suddenly one employee can do three times more work, there is no need to recruit 2 more full time jobs to address the increasing needs. So on the whole, productivity will destroy jobs, but the good news is that the additional returns will create other jobs in other areas.
- Shivetya 8y agoto be honest I am not sure your going to find warehouse work that isn't demanding. they usually all have metrics by which they are judged but we hear very little of other companies simply because Amazon is big and therefor an easy target. be careful what you wish for, automating manual labor jobs just pushes the value of such labor lower which can further put these people behind. as labor costs rise automation will continue to push people into positions that are not easily automated or the cost doesn't suit them but I doubt the workers will always be better off. unlike industrialization we are not bring people in to do new jobs but instead displacing people this go around. so the real work that needs to be done is to find jobs that we can train people for that have some longevity fully taking into account that many may not be able to train to do them
- toomuchtodo 8y agoWe could also reduce the work week and increase taxes to distribute the gains from automation, instead of relying on the goodwill of billionaires. It seems the current political populism environment is best suited for this outcome.
- bamboozled 8y agoIt's going to be an interesting economic situation when the wealth distribution is so skewed towards less than 1% of the population that no one has any money left to make billionaires, billionaires.
- freewilly1040 8y agoThat seems fine?
- oliwarner 8y agoThat's certainly one way of looking at it but I would worry if your answer to "those workers are being abused!" is always "make them redundant via automation". Amazon's warehouse workers were abused because Amazon, not because those jobs should have been automated. They could have had more break time. They could have had lower targets. Pay them more. Paternity leave. So many things you can do to improve working conditions.
- EugeneOZ 8y ago> Pay them more Why, if Amazon can replace them by robots?
- oliwarner 8y agoThen Amazon eliminates yet another cost that other retailers have to burden, further out-competing them. I have no love for retail —it was my Saturday job growing up— but it does employ a huge pile of people, from warehousing through to the shop floor. As consumers, we bitch and whine about the cost this adds, and the hassle of mooching into a busy town to go and get something... So we sit back and use Amazon instead. This is killing retail and it could also kill off manual warehousing. Retail employment in the UK us 10% of the workforce. So what happens when Amazon replaces them too? Fewer and fewer jobs for unskilled workers. Across the board. Much more desperate people. Much more abuse.
- SpicyLemonZest 8y agoHow does Amazon stack up against other warehousing jobs in those areas?
- sneak 8y agoIn such a way that people choose to work for Amazon instead of those other employers, so Amazon’s jobs must be fairly attractive to them.
- JaimeThompson 8y ago
- mc32 8y agoNo, this is just a subversive form of union busting with more deleterious effects on the workers. As a society we need to find a balance between the firm and the worker. Automating jobs away isn’t always good or always bad. But unilaterally automating workers out and them not getting something in return is bad for the worker.
- welly 8y agoThat's the strangest take on this story I've read. Any pearls of wisdom for all those people who are now going to be made redundant?
- irrational 8y agoI've seen a number of articles on what jobs are least likely to be automated. I'd concentrate on doing whatever is required to get my foot into the door of one of those types of jobs.
- benologist 8y agoThe bad working conditions were superfluously imposed by Bezos, it's not a horrible job without the horrible requirements being added.